Advertisement

Acta Neuropathologica

, Volume 138, Issue 3, pp 389–399 | Cite as

Chronic traumatic encephalopathy is a common co-morbidity, but less frequent primary dementia in former soccer and rugby players

  • Edward B. Lee
  • Kevin Kinch
  • Victoria E. Johnson
  • John Q. Trojanowski
  • Douglas H. Smith
  • William StewartEmail author
Open Access
Original Paper

Abstract

Chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) is reported at high prevalence in selected autopsy case series of former contact sports athletes. Nevertheless, the contribution of CTE pathology to clinical presentation and its interaction with co-morbid neurodegenerative pathologies remain unclear. To address these issues, we performed comprehensive neuropathology assessments on the brains of former athletes with dementia and considered these findings together with detailed clinical histories to derive an integrated clinicopathological diagnosis for each case. Consecutive, autopsy-acquired brains from former soccer and rugby players with dementia were assessed for neurodegenerative pathologies using established and preliminary consensus protocols. Thereafter, next of kin interviews were conducted to obtain detailed accounts of the patient’s clinical presentation and course of disease to inform a final, integrated clinicopathological diagnosis. Neuropathologic change consistent with CTE (CTE-NC) was confirmed in five of seven former soccer and three of four former rugby players’ brains, invariably in combination with mixed, often multiple neurodegenerative pathologies. However, in just three cases was the integrated dementia diagnosis consistent with CTE, the remainder having alternate diagnoses, with the most frequent integrated diagnosis Alzheimer’s disease (AD) (four cases; one as mixed AD and vascular dementia). This consecutive autopsy series identifies neuropathologic change consistent with preliminary diagnostic criteria for CTE (CTE-NC) in a high proportion of former soccer and rugby players dying with dementia. However, in the majority, CTE-NC appears as a co-morbidity rather than the primary, dementia causing pathology. As such, we suggest that while CTE-NC might be common in former athletes with dementia, in many cases its clinical significance remains uncertain.

Keywords

Chronic traumatic encephalopathy Traumatic brain injury Neurodegeneration Dementia Alzheimer’s disease Tau 

Introduction

There is growing concern over the association between exposure to traumatic brain injury (TBI) and increased risk of a variety of neuropsychiatric and neurocognitive outcomes, in particular those linked to a specific neurodegenerative pathology known as chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) [11, 29, 31, 42, 50]. First recognized in the early part of the twentieth century as the punch drunk syndrome of boxers [24], it was not until descriptions of CTE in autopsy studies of non-boxer athletes that the lifelong consequences of exposure to TBI attracted widespread attention [27, 36]. Nevertheless, despite this increased attention, there remain comparatively few accounts of the neuropathology of late survival from TBI [43]. As such, reflecting the relative paucity of cases described, consensus criteria for the neuropathological assessment of CTE remain preliminary [26] and the associated clinical consequences of this pathology remain unclear [48, 50].

In his report on the punch drunk syndrome, Harrison Martland provided the first, formal account of the chronic motor and neuropsychiatric consequences of exposure to repetitive mild TBI [24]. Thereafter, autopsy studies on single cases and small case series described the neuropathology of dementia pugilistica (DP) as an apparently distinctive, perivascular deposition of hyperphosphorylated tau, in the form of neurofibrillary tangles [3, 4, 11, 12]. In addition, widespread amyloid-β (Aβ) plaques were reported in a majority [11, 40]. However, although isolated studies in non-boxer individuals exposed to repetitive TBI were reported [6, 12], to the end of the twentieth century accounts of DP largely were restricted to observations in former boxers.

More recently, the pathology of DP, now termed CTE, has been documented in growing numbers of non-boxer athletes; the overwhelming majority from autopsy studies in former American footballers [28, 31], in addition to isolated descriptions of former athletes from a wide and growing range of sports [1, 9, 10, 22, 25, 37, 47], former military personnel [8, 38] and individuals exposed to a single moderate or severe TBI [15, 51]. Notably, many of these contemporary studies often describe more limited and localized pathology than historical case series of DP, with perhaps more attention on neuropsychiatric than cognitive symptomatology [42, 46]. Further, recent reporting largely focuses on tau pathologies in CTE over the constellation of non-tau proteinopathies that develop in late survivors from TBI. Reflecting this, preliminary consensus criteria for the neuropathological identification of CTE define the disease solely on the pattern and distribution of tau [26]. Finally, many reports often do not consider the clinical consequences of CTE pathology, particularly in patients with dementia where multiple neurodegenerative pathologies may co-exist.

There is, therefore, a continuing need to understand the complex neuropathology of late survival from exposure to TBI and its interaction with wider neurodegenerative pathologies. Herein, we report experience from a single institution on the neuropathological assessment of the largest series to date of former soccer (Association football) and rugby union (hereafter ‘rugby’) players with histories of dementia. Specifically, applying established and preliminary consensus criteria for neuropathological assessment of a range of neurodegenerative diseases, together with detailed review of the clinical histories, we provide insight into the integrated clinicopathological diagnoses of dementia in a cohort of former athletes exposed to repetitive head impacts and mild TBI. Our observations suggest that CTE neuropathologic change (CTE-NC) is present in a high proportion of former soccer and rugby players with dementia. However, considered together, the clinical features and neuropathologies support an integrated clinicopathologic diagnosis of CTE dementia (CTE-D) in only a small proportion of these cases.

Methods

Ethical approval and recruitment

Ethical approval for all procedures in this study was provided by: the University of Glasgow Medical Veterinary and Life Sciences College Ethics Committee (reference number 200160147); the West of Scotland Research Ethics Committee (project ID 225271); and the Greater Glasgow and Clyde Biorepository (Application number 340). In each case, written authorization for a hospital diagnostic autopsy and donation of brain tissue to the Glasgow TBI Archive for use in research was obtained from the next of kin. Nevertheless, to preserve patient confidentiality, specific details of individual cases are presented as summarized data, with age at disease onset and death presented in decades. Consecutive research brain donations spanning the period 2014–2018 were included: one case each from years 2014, 2015 and 2016; two from 2017; and six from 2018. No potential donors notified to the Archive over the period of accrual were excluded.

Neuropathological evaluation

At the time of autopsy, whole brains were immersion fixed in 10% formal saline for a minimum of 2 weeks, following which intact brains, where available, were transported to Glasgow for dissection and processing. For Case 1, only tissue blocks from target areas were available for review. Case 7 had been partially dissected prior to transport, but the complete specimen remained available for assessment. Following fixation, all brains were dissected, examined macroscopically and processed to paraffin using standard laboratory techniques. Tissue blocks for histopathological evaluation were sampled in line with standardized protocols for assessment of neurodegenerative disease. Specifically, sampled tissue blocks were sufficient to fulfill the minimum sampling recommended by the preliminary consensus criteria for CTE [26].

From all tissue blocks, 8 μm sections were prepared and stained for Hematoxylin and eosin using standard laboratory techniques. In addition, in line with consensus protocols, sections from selected blocks were stained for: hyperphosphorylated tau (PHF-1; 1:1000; Dr P Davis), Aβ (6f3d; 1:75; Dako), phosphorylated TDP-43 (1D3; 1:500; Millipore), alpha-synuclein (KM51; 1:200; Leica) and, where indicated, 3-repeat (8E6/C11; 1:3000; Millipore) and 4-repeat tau (1E1/A6; 1:400; Millipore). Thereafter, stained sections were independently reviewed by two neuropathologists (KK, WS), blind to clinical history, and a consensus reached on the nature, extent and distribution of pathologies using established criteria for neuropathological assessment of neurodegenerative disease. Specifically, preliminary NINDS consensus diagnostic criteria were employed for assessment of CTE pathology [26], with CTE neuropathologic change (CTE-NC) confirmed where hyperphosphorylated tau was present in neurons, astrocytes and cell processes around small vessels in an irregular pattern and at the depths of cortical sulci. Further, although consensus staging criteria for CTE do not exist, where present, extent and distribution of CTE-NC were dichotomized as ‘low’ or ‘high’, corresponding to stages I/II or III/IV, respectively, of a widely used protocol [28].

Verbal autopsy

Following completion of the neuropathology evaluation, face-to-face or telephone discussions (where face-to-face meeting was not practical) between the lead investigator (WS) and the next of kin were arranged. These comprised open ended, semi-structured interviews documenting a narrative account of the patient’s clinical course, dementia diagnosis in life and management in the final illness. In addition, details were gathered on lifelong health (including exposure to TBI), history of participation in sport (including combat sports), medications, drug and alcohol exposure, family history and history of employment. At the culmination of this verbal autopsy, the comprehensive clinical information obtained was considered in context of the neuropathological features and a layered, diagnostic autopsy opinion provided, encompassing the final integrated diagnosis of dementia (clinicopathological diagnosis of dementia subtype) [21].

Statistics

Summary statistics and between-group differences were calculated using Minitab (Version 18.1, Minitab Inc.), with between-group differences assessed using the two-sample t-, Mann–Whitney or Kruskal–Wallis tests as appropriate.

Results

Demographic and background information

Eleven brain donations from former athletes with a history of dementia were received over the period of study (seven soccer; four rugby). Average age at onset of dementia was 60 ± 8.6 years (range 48–75), with no difference in age of onset between former soccer (59.7 ± 8.1 years) or rugby (60.5 ± 10.8 years; p = 0.906) players, and similar disease durations (soccer 9.4 ± 4.5 years; rugby 11.2 ± 6.8 years; p = 0.657). Mixed playing positions were reported, with years of active participation in their sport estimated at 23.8 ± 8.4 years (range 11–35 years; rugby 28.8 ± 6.5 years vs soccer 21 ± 8.5 years; p = 0.156). In five subjects, a history of previous TBI with brief loss of consciousness was reported; none required hospital admission and all would be compatible with ‘mild’ TBI/concussion. Full demographic information, including details of sports career and post-mortem intervals, is provided in Table 1.
Table 1

Cohort demographic information

Case no

Sex

Sport

Position

Other contact sports

Estimated years in sport

History of TBI with LOC

Family history NDD

PMI (days)

1

M

Soccer

Forward

No

18

NA

Nil

NA

2

M

Soccer

Defense

No

20

Yes

Nil

11

3

M

Soccer

Defense

No

35

Yes

Nil

4

4

M

Soccer

Defense

No

30

No

Mother and brother ‘dementia’

3

5

M

Soccer

Forward

No

18

No

Nil

1

6

M

Soccer

Defense

Rugby

15

No

Nil

3

7

M

Soccer

Defense

No

11

No

Mother PD

3

8

M

Rugby

Back

No

20

Yes

Nil

0.5

9

M

Rugby

Forward

No

35

Yes

Brother AD

2

10

M

Rugby

Forward

No

32

Yes

Nil

2

11

M

Rugby

Forward

Soccer

28

No

Nil

6

AD Alzheimer’s disease, LOC loss of consciousness for less than 30 min, NDD neurodegenerative disease, PD Parkinson’s disease, PMI post-mortem interval, TBI traumatic brain injury

Neuropathology

Macroscopic appearances

Neuropathological evaluation revealed intact, fixed brain weights typically low (soccer 1225 ± 118 g; rugby 1224 ± 120 g; p = 0.989), with associated atrophy of frontal and temporal lobes (Fig. 1a) and hydrocephalus ex vacuo. In addition, moderate atrophy of the heads of the caudate nuclei was noted in Case 11. Septum pellucidum abnormalities were present in five cases, as fenestrated (Fig. 1b) or cavum septum or as mixed fenestrated and cavum (Table 2). Evidence of old, focal ischemic pathology as cavitated infarcts was noted in four cases. However, no focal pathology consistent with previous traumatic brain injury was present; specifically, no healed contusions were identified.
Fig. 1

Representative macroscopic and histologic images from Case 8, a former rugby union player who first presented in his 50 s with a change in behavior marked by increasing levels of frustration and agitation associated with aggressive outbursts. In the following years, these behavioral and personality symptoms progressed, with cognitive disturbance evolving late in the course of disease. The patient died in his 70 s, 18 years after first presentation. On examination of the whole brain, there is gyral atrophy with associated sulcal thinning, most evident in frontal lobes (a). Sectioning the brain in the coronal plain through the mammillary bodies reveals ventriculomegally, consistent with the atrophy noted externally, in addition to fenestration of the septum pellucidum (b; white arrow). Staining sections for hyperphosphorylated tau (p-tau; PHF1) reveal widespread cortical immunoreactivity, within which are multiple patches of increased staining density towards the depths of cortical sulci (c), which on higher power are seen to coincide with neuronal and astroglial immunoreactive profiles clustered around small blood vessels (d; black arrows). In addition to widespread p-tau pathology, numerous Aβ plaques are present (e; 6f3d). The final integrated dementia diagnosis was CTE-D

Table 2

Neuropathological observations

Case no

Sport

Septum

CTE-NC

ADNC

CAA

TDP-43

Other ND pathology

Clinical diagnosis

Integrated CPC diagnosis

A

B

C

1

Soccer

F + C

High

1

2

0

4

CVD

AD

CTE

2

Soccer

C

High

0

2

0

0

5

CVD; PART

AD

VaD

3

Soccer

F

High

2

3

3

2.25

DLB

AD

DLB

4

Soccer

NA

High

3

3

2

0

4

CVD; ARTAG

Mixed AD/VaD

CTE

5

Soccer

C

Low

3

3

2

3.5

3

CVD; DLB; ARTAG

Mixed AD/VaD

AD

6

Soccer

Intact

No

3

3

3

4

ARTAG

‘early onset dementia’

AD

7

Soccer

Intact

No

0

0

0

0

4

PSP

AD

PSP

8

Rugby

F

High

3

3

2

3

5

ARTAG

VaD

CTE

9

Rugby

F

Low

3

3

3

4

4

CVD; ARTAG

AD

AD

10

Rugby

Intact

Low

2

3

3

0.25

3

CVD

AD

Mixed AD/VaD

11

Rugby

Intact

No

0

0

0

0

CBD

CTE

CBD

AD Alzheimer’s disease, ADNC Alzheimer’s disease neuropathologic changes, ARTAG aging-related tau astrogliopathy, C cavum, CAA cerebral amyloid angiopathy [35]; CBD corticobasal degeneration,CPC clinicopathological correlation, CTE-NC chronic traumatic encephalopathy neuropathologic change, CVD chronic cerebrovascular disease, DLB dementia with Lewy bodies, F fenestrated, NA not assessed, ND neurodegenerative disease, PART primary age-related tauopathy, PSP progressive supranuclear palsy, TDP-43 abnormally phosphorylated TDP-43 pathology [16], VaD vascular dementia

Microscopic appearances

Histological examination revealed a variety of neuropathologies, including those fulfilling criteria for multiple neurodegenerative pathologies (Table 2). Evidence of old ischemic injuries was confirmed in Cases 2, 4, 5, 9 and 10 as variably sized foci of architectural disturbance with neuronal loss and astrocytic gliosis, occasionally with cystic degeneration and an established glial limitans. Bilateral hippocampal sclerosis was also present in Case 2. Marked substantia nigra pigment incontinence, neuronal loss and astrocytic gliosis were noted in Cases 3, 7 and 11, and occasional remaining neurons containing either classical Lewy bodies (Case 3) or globose tangles (Cases 7 and 11).

Hyperphosphorylated tau

All 11 brains showed abnormal hyperphosphorylated tau (p-tau) pathology, consistent with several distinct tauopathies [17]. In eight cases (five soccer, three rugby), p-tau was present in a patchy distribution towards the depths of cortical sulci as neurofibrillary tangles, neurites and thorn-shaped astrocytes clustered around cortical vessels, fulfilling the preliminary consensus neuropathological criteria for the recognition of CTE (Figs. 1c, d, 2a, b) [26]. Notably, patients in whom CTE neuropathological change (CTE-NC) was present were generally older at disease onset (median 63.5 years vs 50 years; p = 0.019; Mann–Whitney) and at death (74.5 years vs 59 years; p = 0.041) than patients without CTE-NC. There was no difference in disease duration between cases with or without CTE-NC (10.5 years vs 8.7 years; p = 0.610).
Fig. 2

Representative images from Case 3, a former soccer player who first came to attention in his 60 s with mild cognitive impairment. There followed a steady progression in these symptoms, with exacerbations in the post-operative period, and with the development of visual hallucinations and motor signs leading to a clinical suspicion of Parkinson’s disease, or related disorder. After an 8-year course, the patient died in his 70 s. Staining for p-tau reveals patches of neuronal and astroglial immunoreactivity at the depths of cortical sulci (a), which on higher power are clustered around small cortical vessels (b; PHF1). Frequent Aβ plaques are also present (c; 6f3d). In addition, staining for alpha-synuclein reveals extensive cortical staining (d), with numerous cortical Lewy bodies present (e; black arrows). Sections of the midbrain also reveal scattered classical Lewy bodies (f; white arrow) within remaining pigmented neurons of the substantia nigra. Given the stereotypical clinical presentation and associated neuropathological features, an integrated diagnosis of dementia with Lewy bodies was made, with co-morbid CTE-NC noted

In addition to CTE-NC, neurofibrillary tangle pathology in wider distribution was present in six former soccer and three former rugby players, consistent with AD Braak stage III to VI pathology [2]. In the remaining two cases, p-tau pathologies appeared as 4R tau-positive, 3R tau-negative, neuronal cytoplasmic inclusions, neurites, coiled bodies, and tufted astrocytes, or as astrocytic plaques, ballooned cells, and pre-tangles, consistent with pathologic diagnoses of progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP) [23] or corticobasal degeneration (CBD), respectively [5]. Finally, subcortical, periventricular, subpial or peri-infarct p-tau immunoreactive, and thorn-shaped astrocytes were present in five cases, typical of aging-related tau astrogliopathy (ARTAG) [19, 20].

Amyloid-β

Screening for amyloid-β (Aβ) pathologies revealed abnormalities in eight cases (five soccer, three rugby). In seven examples, these appeared as moderate to frequent, mixed diffuse and neuritic plaques (CERAD B or C) [32], typically in wide distribution (Thal phase 4 or 5) (Figs. 1e, 2c) [49], while in one case more localized (Thal phase 2) diffuse plaques were identified. In addition, cerebral amyloid angiopathy (CAA) was present in seven Aβ plaque-positive cases, typically of high severity by routinely employed histological assessment protocols [35].

TDP-43

Staining for phosphorylated TDP-43 revealed scattered neuronal cytoplasmic inclusions and neurites in seven brains, consistent with stage 3, 4 or 5 TDP-43 pathology [16]. This included Case 2, in which there was noted bilateral hippocampal sclerosis, supporting a pathological diagnosis of hippocampal sclerosis of aging [34]. The remaining cases were negative for TDP-43.

Alpha-synuclein

Alpha-synuclein-positive profiles were present in just two brains. In Case 3, abundant synuclein-immunoreactive neurites and neuronal cytoplasmic inclusions consistent with cortical Lewy bodies were present, supporting a neuropathologic diagnosis of diffuse neocortical pattern of Lewy body disease (Fig. 2d–f) [30, 39]. Case 5 exhibited classical Lewy bodies, with sparse synuclein-positive neurites and neurons in the cingulate gyrus, medial temporal lobe and amygdala supporting a diagnosis of limbic/transitional pattern Lewy body disease [30].

Summary of neuropathologies

Thus, multiple, mixed neurodegenerative pathologies were typical in these former soccer and rugby players with dementia. In some form, p-tau pathologies were identified in all cases. Thereafter, Aβ pathologies were present in 73%, TDP-43 in 64%, vascular pathology in 55% and alpha-synuclein in 18%. Deposition of p-tau in a pattern and distribution fulfilling preliminary neuropathological criteria for CTE was present in eight cases, all but one of which also showed mixed p-tau and Aβ pathologies in keeping with Alzheimer’s disease neuropathologic changes (ADNC), with seven cases in total showing ‘high/intermediate’ ADNC and a single case with ‘low’ ADNC [33]. In addition to plaque pathology, widespread CAA was present in seven brains, five of which showed features of macro- and/or micro-vascular ischemic pathology. A further two cases had evidence of ischemic pathology in the absence of CAA. All five cases with abnormalities in the septum pellucidum had co-existent CTE neuropathology.

Integrated clinicopathological diagnosis

Following neuropathological evaluation, verbal autopsy interviews with the donor’s next of kin, supplemented by clinical case records’ review, where available, provided comprehensive accounts of the clinical presentation and disease course (summarized in Table 3), which informed a final, integrated clinicopathological diagnosis of dementia subtype for each case. The most frequent integrated diagnosis was Alzheimer’s disease (AD; four cases; one as mixed AD and vascular dementia), followed by three cases with dementia compatible with CTE (CTE-D). Of the remaining cases, these included one case each of vascular dementia, dementia with Lewy bodies, PSP and CBD. Thus, within this cohort, three broad diagnostic categories might be proposed, distinguished by the presence of CTE-NC and its association with dementia diagnosis. These consist of: (1) patients with dementia but no evidence of CTE-NC (n = 3; median age onset 50 years); (2) patients with an integrated diagnosis of CTE-D (n = 3; median 55 years); and (3) patients with CTE-NC as co-morbidity in context of an alternate integrated diagnosis (n = 5; median 66 years; p = 0·024; Kruskal–Wallis).
Table 3

Major clinical symptoms reported

Case no

Age symptom onset

Age at death

Disease duration (years)

Major symptoms at presentation and over disease course

1

50 s

50 s

5

Behavioral change and personality change (impulsivity) at onset; progression to cognitive impairment (memory) late in disease

2

60 s

60 s

7

Mild, but evolving cognitive impairment (memory) at onset; acute stroke with cognitive deterioration later in disease and stepwise deterioration thereafter

3

60 s

70 s

8

Cognitive impairment (problem solving) at onset; acute deterioration post-operatively; Parkinsonism and visual hallucinations late in course

4

60 s

70 s

10

Behavioral change with aggression and cognitive impairment (memory) at onset; Reduced mobility late in disease

5

60 s

80 s

16

Loss of confidence associated with cognitive impairment (spatial awareness) at onset; progressing memory impairment; sleep and behavioral disturbance late in course

6

50 s

50 s

6

Cognitive impairment (memory; conceptual) at onset; behavioral change later as mild disinhibition

7

50 s

60 s

13

Behavioral change at onset; progressing to memory decline and motor symptoms

8

50 s

70 s

18

Behavioral and personality change (short tempered; irritable; loss of confidence); memory impairment late in disease

9

60 s

70 s

16

Cognitive impairment (memory) at onset; gradual decline with evolving cognitive symptoms thereafter; not behavioral symptoms

10

70 s

70 s

4

Cognitive impairment post diagnosed lacunar infarct at onset; decline thereafter

11

50 s

50 s

7

Behavioral change (becoming introverted) and mild cognitive (memory) symptoms at onset; motor symptoms (shuffling gait) and speech loss with progression

Discussion

Herein, we present observations on neurodegenerative pathologies and their relationship to the final integrated, clinicopathological dementia diagnosis in a consecutive series of 11 brain donations from former soccer and rugby union players with dementia. In addition to ubiquitous tau pathologies, our cases invariably showed mixed, often multiple, co-existent neurodegenerative pathologies, including frequent Aβ pathologies as amyloid plaques and cerebral amyloid angiopathy. Further, although the pathognomonic neuropathology of CTE described within preliminary consensus criteria was present in a high proportion of brains in this series, in only three would CTE be regarded as the primary integrated dementia diagnosis following comprehensive review of the clinical histories and neuropathologies. In the remaining five cases with CTE neuropathologic change (CTE-NC), this appeared as co-morbid pathology in the setting of an alternative integrated dementia diagnosis. Thus, in context of dementia arising in athletes exposed to repetitive mild traumatic brain injury, three distinct clinicopathological groupings are suggested by this series defined by the presence of CTE-NC and its relationship to the final integrated dementia diagnosis. These observations support the need for comprehensive neuropathological evaluation and reporting in individuals exposed to TBI, with distinction between the autopsy finding of CTE-NC and the putative clinical consequences of this pathology, including CTE dementia (CTE-D).

Notably, mixed neurodegenerative pathologies were present in nine of our series, even in relatively younger aged patients. Mixed pathologies increasingly are recognized in studies of neurodegenerative disease [18, 41, 44], with prevalence estimates ranging up to 80% of dementias at autopsy and directly correlated with age [41]. In contrast to our experience, previous series report mixed neurodegenerative pathologies in just 45% of former athletes [31]. In this respect, mixed pathologies appear more frequent in our patients than in similar studies in former athletes, perhaps reflecting an older patient cohort. Conceivably, such mixed neurodegenerative pathologies might contribute to clinically ‘atypical’ presentations, leading to challenges in establishing accurate clinical diagnoses. There is undoubtedly a need for continued autopsy brain examination in individuals surviving TBI, with accurate and comprehensive documentation of the full spectrum of pathologies encountered in each examination.

Reporting in CTE largely focuses on p-tau pathologies. Indeed, preliminary consensus criteria define pathognomonic CTE neuropathology solely by the pattern and distribution of p-tau [26]. While pathognomonic p-tau pathologies were common in our current series, Aβ pathology as plaque and/or CAA was as frequent and present in all but one case with CTE-NC. In contrast, studies on former American footballers with CTE document Aβ pathology in just 61% [45]. However, incidence of dementia was reported higher in those older American footballers in which there were high burdens of CTE and Aβ. In this context, our data support these observations and might suggest that few post-TBI dementias arise in context of a pure tauopathy (pure CTE-NC), the majority arising in context of mixed proteinopathies, including frequent Aβ pathologies. As such, dementia-associated neurodegenerative pathology in former athletes might be more reminiscent of AD.

Since the first description of CTE in a former American football player [36], there has been a proliferation in autopsy series reporting its presence in individuals surviving a spectrum of TBI exposures (for review, see Hay et al. [11]). Nevertheless, the published case experience in CTE remains low [43], with reports typically documenting CTE pathology, but including little interpretation of its clinical implications. By example, an autopsy series documenting 110 of 111 former National Football League (NFL) American footballers with CTE pathology offered no insights into final integrated clinicopathological diagnoses [31]. Similarly, no opinion on final, integrated clinicopathological diagnoses after neuropathological evaluation was provided in a study of six former soccer players with dementia, four of whom had CTE neuropathology [22]. We identified CTE-NC in eight of our 11 former athletes with dementia. However, in just three of these cases was the integrated, primary dementia diagnosis consistent with CTE dementia (CTE-D) after consideration of the comprehensive clinical information. As such, while CTE-NC is a common pathology in former contact sports athletes with dementia, CTE-D appears a less common primary dementia diagnosis.

In this series of former soccer and rugby players with dementia, CTE-NC was present in 73% of cases. Adding this experience to observations in previous, isolated case reports in rugby and soccer, where sought, autopsy confirmed CTE pathology is reported in 75% of former athletes from these sports: 13/18 (seven from this study) soccer [1, 6, 9, 10, 22, 25] and 5/6 (four from this study) rugby [25, 45]. Elsewhere, CTE neuropathology has been reported ranging from 50% (7/14) of former boxers [7] to 99% (110/111) of former NFL footballers examined [31]. Although such studies are subject to numerous biases and limitations, rendering them uninformative regarding true disease prevalence, the apparent variation in reported prevalence of CTE neuropathology between these autopsy series might suggest between sports’ differences in risk and/or variability in methodologies of specimen accrual and neuropathology assessment between laboratories.

In summary, our observations suggest that while CTE-NC may be a common pathology in former soccer and rugby players with dementia, CTE dementia appears a less common primary dementia diagnosis. Current criteria for AD distinguish neurodegenerative pathologies, defined as AD neuropathologic changes (ADNC) [13, 33], from the clinical syndrome of dementia of Alzheimer’s disease type [14]. Reflecting this approach, we propose that there should be a similar distinction between CTE neuropathologic change and the clinical consequences of this pathology, including CTE dementia. As experience grows, CTE-NC conceivably might echo experience in AD, where the neuropathologic change can represent incidental pathology without clinical effect, or the major pathology driving clinical dementia phenotypes, or a co-morbid pathology within mixed neurodegenerative disease. In other words, in the absence of clinical correlation, CTE neuropathologic change should perhaps be regarded as a pattern of pathology, rather than diagnostic of a specific disease.

Notes

Acknowledgements

This work is supported by funding from: the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke of the National Institutes of Health under award numbers R01NS092398, R01NS094003 and R01NS038104; The Football Association and Professional Footballers Association (WS); and an NHS Research Scotland Career Researcher Fellowship (WS).

Author contributions

WS and KK reviewed the pathology in each case and generated the original observations and dataset; WS provided a first draft of the manuscript and collated comments into a final submission draft. All other authors contributed to discussions on data analysis and interpretation and provided edits and comments on manuscript drafts.

Compliance with ethical standards

Conflict of interest

The authors declare no competing interests.

References

  1. 1.
    Bieniek KF, Ross OA, Cormier KA, Walton RL, Soto-Ortolaza A, Johnston AE et al (2015) Chronic traumatic encephalopathy pathology in a neurodegenerative disorders brain bank. Acta Neuropathol 130:877–889CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  2. 2.
    Braak H, Braak E (1995) Staging of Alzheimer’s disease-related neurofibrillary changes. Neurobiol Aging 16:271–278CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  3. 3.
    Brandenburg W, Hallervorden J (1954) Dementia pugilistica with anatomical findings [German]. Virchows Arch Pathol Anat Physiol Klin Med 325:680–709CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  4. 4.
    Corsellis JA, Bruton CJ, Freeman- Browne D (1973) The aftermath of boxing. Psychol Med 3:270–303CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  5. 5.
    Dickson DW, Bergeron C, Chin SS, Duyckaerts C, Horoupian D, Ikeda K et al (2002) Office of rare diseases neuropathologic criteria for corticobasal degeneration. J Neuropathol Exp Neurol 61:935–946CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. 6.
    Geddes JF, Vowles GH, Nicoll JA, Revesz T (1999) Neuronal cytoskeletal changes are an early consequence of repetitive head injury. Acta Neuropathol 98:171–178CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  7. 7.
    Goldfinger MH, Ling H, Tilley BS, Liu AKL, Davey K, Holton JL, Revesz T, Gentleman SM (2018) The aftermath of boxing revisited: identifying chronic traumatic encephalopathy pathology in the original Corsellis boxer series. Acta Neuropahtolgica 136:973–974CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. 8.
    Goldstein LE, Fisher AM, Tagge CA, Zhang XL, Velisek L, Sullivan JA et al (2012) Chronic traumatic encephalopathy in blast-exposed military veterans and a blast neurotrauma mouse model. Sci Transl Med 4:134ra160Google Scholar
  9. 9.
    Grinberg LT, Anghinah R, Nascimento CF, Amaro E, Leite RP, Martin MGM et al (2016) Chronic traumatic encephalopathy presenting as Alzheimer’s disease in a retired soccer player. J Alzheimers Dis 54:169–174CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  10. 10.
    Hales C, Neill S, Gearing M, Cooper D, Glass J, Lah J (2014) Late-stage CTE pathology in a retired soccer player with dementia. Neurology 83:2307–2309CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  11. 11.
    Hay J, Johnson VE, Smith DH, Stewart W (2016) Chronic traumatic encephalopathy: the neuropathological legacy of traumatic brain injury. Ann Rev Pathol 11:21–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. 12.
    Hof PR, Knabe R, Bovier P, Bouras C (1991) Neuropathological observations in a case of autism presenting with self-injury behavior. Acta Neuropathol 82:321–326CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  13. 13.
    Hyman BT, Phelps CH, Beach TG, Bigio EH, Cairns NJ, Carrillo MC et al (2012) National Institute on Aging-Alzheimer’s Association guidelines for the neuropathologic assessment of Alzheimer’s disease. Alzheimers Dement 8:1–13CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  14. 14.
    Jack CR Jr, Albert MS, Knopman DS, McKhann GM, Sperling RA, Carrillo MC, Thies B, Phelps CH (2011) Introduction to the recommendations from the National Institute on Aging-Alzheimer’s Association workgroups on diagnostic guidelines for Alzheimer’s disease. Alzheimers Dement 7:257–262CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  15. 15.
    Johnson VE, Stewart W, Smith DH (2012) Widespread tau and amyloid-beta pathology many years after a single traumatic brain injury in humans. Brain Pathol 22:142–149CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. 16.
    Josephs KA, Murray ME, Whitwell JL, Tosakulwong N, Weigand SD, Petrucelli L, Liesinger AM, Petersen RC, Parisi JE, Dickson DW (2016) Updated TDP-43 in Alzheimer’s disease staging scheme. Acta Neuropathol 131:571–585CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  17. 17.
    Kovacs GG (2015) Neuropathology of tauopathies: principles and practice. Neuropathol Appl Neurobiol 41:3–23CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  18. 18.
    Kovacs GG, Alafuzoff I, Al-Sarraj S, Arzberger T, Bogdanovic N, Capellari S et al (2008) Mixed brain pathologies in dementia: the BrainNet Europe Consortium experience. Dement Geriatr Cogn Disord 26:343–350CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  19. 19.
    Kovacs GG, Ferrer I, Grinberg LT, Alafuzoff I, Attems J, Budka H et al (2016) Aging-related tau astrogliopathy (ARTAG): harmonized evaluation strategy. Acta Neuropathol 131:87–102CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  20. 20.
    Kovacs GG, Xie SX, Lee EB, Robinson JL, Casell C, Irwin DJ et al (2017) Multisite assessment of aging-related tau astrogliopathy (ARTAG). J Neuropathol Exp Neurol 76:605–619CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  21. 21.
    Lee EB (2018) Integrated neurodegenerative disease autopsy diagnosis. Acta Neuropathol 135:643–646CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  22. 22.
    Ling H, Morris HR, Neal JW, Lees AJ, Hardy J, Holton JL, Revesz T, Williams DDR (2017) Mixed pathologies including chronic traumatic encephalopathy account for dementia in retired association football (soccer) players. Acta Neuropathol 133:337–352CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  23. 23.
    Litvan I, Haum JJ, Bartko JJ, Lantos PL, Daniel SE, Horoupian DS et al (1996) Validity and reliability of the preliminary NINDS neuropathologic criteria for progressive supra-nuclear palsy and related disorders. J Neuropathol Exp Neurol 55:97–105CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. 24.
    Martland H (1928) Punch drunk. JAMA 91:1103–1107CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. 25.
    McKee AC, Daneshvar DH, Alvarez VE, Stein TD (2014) The neuropathology of sport. Acta Neuropathol 127:29–51CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  26. 26.
    McKee AC, Cairns NJ, Dickson DW, Folkerth RD, Keene CD, Litvan I et al (2016) The first NINDS/NIBIB consensus meeting to define neuropathological criteria for the diagnosis of chronic traumatic encephalopathy. Acta Neuropathol 131:75–86CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  27. 27.
    McKee AC, Cantu RC, Nowinski CJ, Hedley-Whyte ET, Gavett BE, Budson AE et al (2009) Chronic traumatic encephalopathy in athletes: progressive tauopathy after repetitive head injury. J Neuropathol Exp Neurol 68:709–735CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  28. 28.
    McKee AC, Stein TD, Nowinski CJ, Stein TD, Alvarez VE, Daneshvar DH et al (2012) The spectrum of disease in chronic traumatic encephalopathy. Brain 136:43–64CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  29. 29.
    McKee AC, Stein TD, Nowinski CJ, Stern RA, Deneshvar DH, Alvarez VE et al (2012) The spectrum of disease in chronic traumatic encephalopathy. Brain 136:43–64CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  30. 30.
    McKeith IG, Boeve BF, Dickson DW, Halliday G, Taylor JP, Weintraub D et al (2017) Diagnosis and management of dementia with Lewy bodies: fourth consensus report of the DLB consortium. Neurology 89:88–100CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  31. 31.
    Mez J, Daneshvar DH, Kiernan PT, Abdolmohammadi B, Alvarez VE, Huber BR et al (2017) Clinicopathological evaluation of chronic traumatic encephalopathy in players of American football. JAMA 318:360–370CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  32. 32.
    Mirra SS, Heyman A, McKeel D, Sumi SM, Crain BJ, Brownlee LM et al (1991) The consortium to establish a registry for Alzheimer’s disease (CERAD). Part II. Standardization of the neuropathologic assessment of Alzheimer’s disease. Neurology 41:479–486CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. 33.
    Montine TJ, Phelps CH, Beach TG, Bogio EH, Cairns NJ, Dickson SW et al (2012) National Institute on Aging and Alzheimer’s guidelines for the neuropathologic assessment of Alzheimer’s disease: a practical approach. Acta Neuropathol 123:1–11CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  34. 34.
    Nag S, Yu L, Capuano AW, Wilson RS, Leurgans SE, Bennett Da, Schneider JA (2015) Hippocampal sclerosis and TDP-43 pathology in aging and Alzheimer’s disease. Ann Neurol 77:942–952CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  35. 35.
    Olichney JM, Hansen LA, Hofstetter CR, Grundman M, Katzman R, Thal LJ (1995) Cerebral infarction in Alzheimer’s disease is associated with severe amyloid angiopathy and hypertension. Arch Neurol 52:702–708CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  36. 36.
    Omalu BI, DeKosky ST, Minster RL, Kamboh MI, Hamilton RL, Wecht CH (2005) Chronic traumatic encephalopathy in a National Football League player. Neurosurgery 57:128–134CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  37. 37.
    Omalu BI, Fitzsimmons RP, Hammers J, Bailes J (2010) Chronic traumatic encephalopathy in a professional American wrestler. J Forensic Nurs 6:130–136CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  38. 38.
    Omalu B, Hammers JL, Bailes J, Hamilton RL, Kamboch MI, Webster G, Fitzsimmons RP (2011) Chronic traumatic encephalopathy in an Iraqi war veteran with posttraumatic stress disorder who committed suicide. Neurosurg Focus 31:E3CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  39. 39.
    Outeiro TF, Koss DJ, Erskine D, Walker L, Kurzawa-Akanabi M, Burn D et al (2019) Dementia with Lewy bodies: an update and outlook. Mol Neurodegener 14:5.  https://doi.org/10.1186/s13024-019-0306-8 CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  40. 40.
    Roberts GW, Allsop D, Bruton C (1990) The occult aftermath of boxing. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 53:373–378CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  41. 41.
    Robinson J, Lee EB, Xie SX, Rennert L, Suh E, Bredenberg C et al (2018) Neurodegenerative disease concomitant proteinopathies are prevalent, age-related and APOE4- associated. Brain 141:2181–2193CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  42. 42.
    Smith DH, Johnson VE, Stewart W (2013) Chronic neuropathologies of single and repetitive TBI: substrates of dementia? Nat Rev Neurol 9:211–221CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  43. 43.
    Smith DH, Johnson VE, Trojanowski JQ, Stewart W (2019) Chronic traumatic encephalopathy—confusion and controversies. Nat Rev Neurol 15:179–183CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  44. 44.
    Spires-Jones TL, Attems J, Thal DR (2017) Interactions of neuropathological proteins in neurodegenerative diseases. Acta Neuropathol 134:187–205CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  45. 45.
    Stein TD, Montenigro PH, Alvarez VE, Xia W, Crary JF, Tripodis Y et al (2015) Beta-amyloid deposition in chronic traumatic encephalopathy. Acta Neuropathol 130:21–34CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  46. 46.
    Stern RA, Daneshvar DH, Baugh CM, Seichepine DR, Montenigro PH, Riley DO et al (2013) Clinical presentation of chronic traumatic encephalopathy. Neurology 2:1122–1129CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. 47.
    Stewart W, McNamara PH, Lawlor B, Hutchinson S, Farrell M (2016) Chronic traumatic encephalopathy: a potential late and under recognized consequence of rugby union? QJM 109:11–15CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  48. 48.
    Stewart W, Allinson K, Al-Sarraj S, Bachmeier C, Barlow K, Belli A (2019) Primum non nocere: a call for balance when reporting on CTE. Lancet Neurol 18:231–233CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  49. 49.
    Thal DR, Rub U, Orantes M, Braak H (2002) Phases of Aβ-deposition in the human brain and its relevance for the development of AD. Neurology 58:1791–1800CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. 50.
    Wilson L, Stewart W, Dams-OConnor K, Diaz-Arrastia R, Horton L, Menon DK, Polinder S (2017) The chronic and evolving neurological consequences of traumatic brain injury. Lancet Neurol 16:813–825CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  51. 51.
    Zanier ER, Bertani I, Sammali E, Pischiutta F, Chiaravalloti MA, Vegliane G et al (2018) Induction of a transmissible tau pathology by traumatic brain injury. Brain 141:2685–2699PubMedGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2019

Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Translational Neuropathology Research LaboratoryUniversity of PennsylvaniaPhiladelphiaUSA
  2. 2.Department of NeuropathologyQueen Elizabeth University HospitalGlasgowUK
  3. 3.Department of Neurosurgery, Penn Center for Brain Injury and Repair, Perelman School of MedicineUniversity of PennsylvaniaPhiladelphiaUSA
  4. 4.Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, Center for Neurodegenerative Disease Research, Institute on Aging, Perelman School of MedicineUniversity of PennsylvaniaPhiladelphiaUSA
  5. 5.Institute of Neuroscience and PsychologyUniversity of GlasgowGlasgowUK

Personalised recommendations