Abstract
In 1936, the arrival of the young theoretical physicist Giovanni Gentile Jr. at the Institute of Physics of Milan University directed by Giovanni Polvani, opened novel horizons both in terms of the choice of research topics in the field of modern physics and of modernization of teaching. Gentile’s solid education at the Pisan school of physics and mathematics in the 1920s and his relationships with Fermi’s school in Rome and later with the great German school of theoretical physics through Schrödinger, London, Heisenberg and Sommerfeld, as well as his special friendship with Ettore Majorana, became the premises on which to build a stimulating research environment with the consequent formation of a new generation of theorists in contact with the international scientific community. The unique partnership between Polvani and Gentile, rooted in a deep human, cultural and scientific affinity, immediately resulted in an effective revitalizing impulse both for the Milan Institute of Physics and for Gentile Jr.’s personal research path. Despite his brief passage in Milan—barely five years before his premature death in 1942—Gentile planted a few seeds of renewal that flourished after the war, contributing to the rebirth and revival of Italian physics almost destroyed by Mussolini’s racial laws and the dramatic consequences of the war.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Notes
- 1.
- 2.
Both Majorana and Gentile had in their personal libraries the first editions of the books by Hermann Weyl (Gruppentheorie und Quantenmechanik, 1928) and Eugene Wigner (Gruppentheorie und ihre Anwendung auf die Quantenmechanik der Atomspektren, 1931) as well as Luigi Bianchi’s Lessons on the theory of finite continuous groups of transformations, Andreas Speiser’s Theorie der Gruppen von Endlicher Ordnung and Bartel van der Waerden’s Die Gruppentheoretische Metode in der Quantenmechanik. Majorana’s investigations on group theory are largely present in his personal papers, preserved in his personal papers at Domus Galilaeana in Pisa. On Majorana and Gentile’s interest in group theory see [16]. See also [17] for the onset of group theory in the new quantum mechanics.
- 3.
As mentioned in Majorana’s letter to Gentile of 22 December 1929 (G. G. Jr. Papers, Physics Department, Sapienza University, Rome, Box 1) a copy of his dissertation was requested by Johann Kudar, then in Berlin: “As soon as I will have confirmation of your new address, I will send you some of the well-known works of Fermi, as well as, for necessary deference to the desire expressed by the illustrious Kudar, the only copy in my possession of my dissertation.” And actually, starting from January 1929, Kudar published a series of articles discussing the connection between quantum mechanics and radioactive decay, topics that were very close to Majorana’s dissertation. A copy of Majorana’s dissertation can be found in Gentile’s papers, Box 7.
- 4.
The last published work during his stay in Pisa is Sopra la teoria della Rimanenza e della curva di Magnetizzazione, submitted in December 1933, but of course it was related to research work arising from Heisenberg’s deep interest in ferromagnetism [22].
- 5.
- 6.
Curriculum Vitae, G. G. Jr. Papers, Physics Department, Sapienza University, Rome, Box 1.
- 7.
In this regard, see also [27]. Gentile’s deep interest and involvement in reflecting on the epistemological and scientific implications raised by the theories that had profoundly revolutionized physics from the beginning of the twentieth century, were discussed by Maiocchi in the biographical entry dedicated to Gentile [7].
- 8.
In the hapter on magnetic moments and vector model of the atom, Gentile introduces the fundamental concepts of reducible and irreducible representations of a group, concepts which are then used for the determination of the group representations of rotations and infinitesimal rotations and the selection rules for spectral emission. At that time no theoretical physics course included this kind of teaching.
- 9.
G. G. Jr. Papers, Physics Department, Sapienza University, Rome, Box 1.
- 10.
From the text of the speech given by Polvani for the inauguration of the new seat of the Institute of Physics on 10 February 1964 [30, p. 38].
- 11.
Gentile to Vincenza Bartalini, 2 and 22 February 1938. All excerpts from the letters to Nani, still kept by the family, are reproduced with kind permission of Alessandra Gentile.
- 12.
He was helped by his student Piera Pinto, who would later marry her fellow student Carlo Salvetti.
- 13.
C. Salvetti, interview by L. Bonolis, Rome, 18 July 2002.
- 14.
C. Salvetti, interview by L. Bonolis, Rome, 18 July 2002.
- 15.
Due to his early death in March 1942, when the first volume of Questioni di Fisica was nearly ready, Gentile was unfortunately unable to complete his project himself and the first volume was published by Sansoni after the war, edited by Bernardini and Polvani [33]. For this collection of essays Gentile had secured the collaboration of leading Italian physicists. Related papers and correspondence are in G. G. Jr. Papers, Physics Department, Sapienza University, Rome, Box 1.
- 16.
Gentile helped Polvani to write an historical essay on the Italian contribution to physics during the years 1839–1939 [34]. See also, for example an unpublished manuscript on the evolution of the energy concept in its different aspects written with Vanna Tongiorgi, who later married Cocconi and was his collaborator in cosmic-ray studies (G. G. Jr. Papers, Physics Department, Sapienza University, Rome, Box 4).
- 17.
G. G. Jr. Papers, Physics Department, Sapienza University, Rome, Box 1.
- 18.
Gentile had been also asked at the time to write Sommerfeld’s biographical entry for the Enciclopedia Italiana (G. G. Jr. Papers, Physics Department, Sapienza University, Rome, Box 1).
- 19.
Giovanni Polvani, who had this article reprinted in Il Nuovo Cimento after the author’s death [36], paid great attention to it in his account of Gentile’s scientific career.
- 20.
Brief undated note (Giovanni Gentile Foundation for Philosophical Studies, Archive, Sapienza University, Rome).
- 21.
Majorana to Gentile, 25 August 1937 (G. G. Jr. Papers, Physics Department, Sapienza University, Rome, Box 1).
- 22.
Giovanni Gentile Foundation for Philosophical Studies, Archive, Sapienza University, Rome.
- 23.
For details on the competition see [37].
- 24.
Such personal correspondence is kept by the family.
- 25.
- 26.
For a wide discussion on such issues see Galison’s article [42].
- 27.
G. G. Jr. Papers, Physics Department, Sapienza University, Rome, Box 1.
- 28.
Gentile to Nani, 22 February and 3rd March 1938 (family papers).
- 29.
Majorana to Gentile, 2 March 1938 (G. G. Jr. Papers, Physics Department, Sapienza University, Rome, Box 1).
- 30.
G. G. Jr. Papers, Physics Department, Sapienza University, Rome, Box 1.
- 31.
Gentile to Nani, 18–19 November and 1st December (family papers).
- 32.
C. Salvetti, interview by L. Bonolis, Rome, 18 July 2002.
- 33.
See for example Elisa Bonauguri’s dissertation on the vector model of the atom, discussing the properties of the group of rotations as an expression of the spherical symmetry of the electron cloud, part of which was published in 1939 [44]. See also Gentile’s article on the same topic [45]. After Gentile’s death, in order to honor the memory of her teacher and his inspiring guide, Teresa Magri Materossi published part of her dissertation discussed in 1941 with the title The problems of Lecher wires or propagation of electromagnetic waves along parallel wires, in a special issue of Il Nuovo Cimento dedicated to Gentile [46].
- 34.
- 35.
The title was Il metodo dell’amplificatore proporzionale a lampada per lo studio delle particelle elementari. I am grateful to Leonardo Gariboldi for providing the exact title of Salvetti’s thesis.
- 36.
After the discovery of nuclear fission announced at the beginning of 1939, a main topic of the utmost interest among physicists became the neutron cross section, which was directly involved in the mechanism of the nuclear chain reaction. In this regard, Gentile’s student Carlo Borghi wrote a dissertation completed in 1940 on the neutron cross section and Compton effect, which resulted in a work published in the issue of Nuovo Cimento including articles honoring Gentile’s memory [49]. Borghi would be in charge of the Calculus of Probability course after Gentile’s death.
- 37.
G. Salvini, interview by L. Bonolis, Rome, 25 November 2004, 6 February 2005.
- 38.
- 39.
- 40.
Brillouin’s article was later cited by Gentile [64, p. 493], who criticized Brillouin’s method as not proper to treat the case of an intermediate statistics.
- 41.
- 42.
Manuscript given to the author by the late Carlo Salvetti in 2002.
- 43.
“Most illustrious Professor, I would like to report some results that I have reached after some considerations on the intermediate quantum statistics with the prayer for your judgment.” Caldirola to Gentile, 18 July 1941 (G. G. Jr. Papers, Physics Department, Sapienza University, Rome, Box 1).
- 44.
- 45.
- 46.
Caldirola revisited the subject of intermediate statistics in 1975, in a review article on the exclusion principle in which he recalled the debate that flourished at the time in the Milanese school and discussed its subsequent evolution and possible applications to modern physics [76].
- 47.
Antonio Borsellino, at the time working at Politecnico in Milan, demonstrated the incompatibility of Gentile’s statistics with quantum field theory [85].
- 48.
See [86] and references therein.
- 49.
Gentile to Sommerfeld, correspondence between 1st February and 3rd March 1942 (G. G. Jr. Papers, Physics Department, Sapienza University, Rome, Box 1).
References
Fermi E (1934) Versuch einer Theorie der \(\beta \)-Strahlen I. Zeitschrift für Physik 88(3–4):161–177
Guerra F, Robotti N (2018) The lost notebook of Enrico Fermi. The true story of the discovery of neutron-induced radioactivity. Springer, Cham
Polvani G (1943) Giovanni Gentile junior. Il Nuovo Cimento 1(3):155–160
Pompeo Faracovi O (2007) Appunti su Enriques, Giovanni Gentile Jr. e la storia delle scienze. In: Pogliano C (ed) Scienze e storia nell’Italia del Novecento. Plus - Pisa University Press, Pisa, pp 99–114
Schrödinger E (1926) An undulatory theory of the mechanics of atoms and molecules. Phys Rev 28(6):1049–1070
Turi G (2019) Il nome del padre: Giovanni Gentile Jr. Giornale Critico della Filosofia Italiana XV(III):664–687
Maiocchi R (2000) Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani, vol 53. Istituto dell’Enciclopedia Italiana, Roma, pp 214–215
Gentile G Jr (1928) Sulla teoria dei satelliti di Rutherford. Rendiconti Reale Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei – Classe di Scienze VII(IV):346–349
Chadwick J (1932) Possible existence of a neutron. Nature 129(3252):312–312
Alunni C (2013) Ettore Majorana et la Philosophie. Entre Affinités Électives et Conjectures Philosophiques. Revue de Synthèse 134:53–73
Gentile G Jr (1928) Sui termini accentati del Calcio. Rendiconti Reale Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei – Classe di Scienze VII(II):911–915
Gentile G Jr, Majorana E (1928) Sullo sdoppiamento dei termini Röntgen e ottici a causa dell’elettrone rotante e sulle intensità delle righe del cesio. Rendiconti Reale Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei – Classe di Scienze VIII(V–VI):229–233
Majorana E (1932) Teoria relativistica di particelle con momento intrinseco arbitrario. Il Nuovo Cimento 9(10):335–344
Gentile G Jr (1939) Sulla rappresentazione del gruppo di Lorentz e sulla teoria di Dirac dell’elettrone. Il Nuovo Cimento 16(4):181–190
Gentile G Jr (1940) Sulle equazioni d’onda relativistiche di Dirac per particelle con momento intrinseco qualsiasi. Il Nuovo Cimento 17(1):5–12
Bonolis L (2004) Giovanni Gentile e Ettore Majorana. La comparsa della teoria dei gruppi nella fisica teorica italiana. In: Robotti N, Paoletti A, Leone M, Tucci P (eds) Atti del XII Congresso Nazionale di Storia della Fisica e dell’Astronomia (Genova-Chiavari - 6/8 June 2002). Istituto Italiano di Studi Filosofici, Napoli, pp 117–235
Bonolis L (2004) From the rise of the group concept to the stormy onset of group theory in the new quantum mechanics. A saga of the invariant characterization of physical objects, events and theories. La Rivista del Nuovo Cimento 27(4–5):1–110
Gentile G Jr (1930) Wechselwirkung zwischen einem H- und einem He- Atom und zwischen zwei He-Atomen. Zeitschrift für Physik 63(11–12):795–802
Heitler W, London F (1927) Wechselwirkung neutraler Atome und homöopolare Bindung nach der Quantenmechanik. Zeitschrift für Physik 44(6–7):455–472
Bloch F, Gentile G Jr (1931) Zur Anisotropie der Magnetisierung ferromagnetischer Einkristalle. Zeitschrift für Physik 70(5–6):395–408
Bloch F (1976) Heisenberg and the early days of quantum mechanics. Phys Today 9(12):23–27
Gentile G Jr (1934) Sopra la Teoria della Rimanenza e della Curva di Magnetizzazione. Il Nuovo Cimento 11(1):20–33
Majorana E (1937) Teoria simmetrica dell’elettrone e del positrone. Il Nuovo Cimento 14(4):171–184
Guerra F, Robotti N (2008) Ettore Majorana. Aspects of his scientific and academic activity. Scuola Normale Superiore, Pisa
De Gregorio A, Esposito S (2008) Enrico Fermi e Ettore Majorana: I corsi di Fisica Teorica. Atti del XXV Congresso Nazionale di Storia della Fisica e dell’Astronomia, Milano, 10–12 novembre 2005. SISFA, Milano, pp C07.1–C07.5
Gentile G Jr (1937) Questioni Classiche di Fisica. Sansoni, Firenze
Gentile G Jr (1936) Motivi speculativi nella fisica moderna. Atti Società Italiana per il Progresso delle Scienze, Roma, pp 3–6
Gentile G Jr (1934) Lezioni di Meccanica Quantistica, Anno Accademico 1933–1934. Ufficio dispense dell’ Università di Pisa
Gentile G Jr (1937) Fisica Nucleare. Casa Edizioni Roma, Roma
Belloni L (1988) Giovanni Polvani e l’Istituto di Milano. Il Nuovo Saggiatore 4:35–49
Amaldi E (1942) Giovanni Gentile junior. Vita Universitaria, 2–2
Enriques F (1924–1927) Questioni riguardanti le matematiche elementari. Zanichelli, Bologna
Bernardini G, Polvani G (eds) (1947) Questioni di Fisica. Sansoni, Firenze
Polvani G (1939) Il contributo italiano al progresso della fisica, negli ultimi cento anni. In: Un secolo di progresso scientifico italiano: 1839–1939. Società Italiana per il Progresso delle Scienze, Roma
Gentile G Jr (1937) Per la teoria degli effetti polarizzanti delle fenditure. Diffrazione della luce da due cilindri paralleli e indefiniti. Sansoni, Firenze
Gentile G Jr (1943) Per la teoria degli effetti polarizzanti delle fenditure. Diffrazione della luce da due cilindri paralleli e indefiniti. Il Nuovo Cimento 1(3):161–175
Simoncelli P (2006) Tra scienza e lettere. Giovannino Gentile (e Cantimori e Majorana). Le Lettere, Firenze
Gentile G Jr (1938) Sui limiti dell’elettrodinamica ed i nuovi risultati sperimentali sulla radiazione cosmica. Rendiconti Seminario Matematico e Fisico di Milano XII:113–135
Gentile G Jr (1939) Sui limiti dell’Elettrodinamica e i nuovi risultati sperimentali sulla radiazione cosmica. Il Nuovo Cimento 16(3):113–135
Gentile G Jr (1939) Il mesotrone. Scientia 66:165–174
Jordan P (1940) La fisica nel secolo XX. Sansoni, Firenze
Galison P (1983) The discovery of the Muon and the failed revolution against quantum electrodynamics. Centaurus 26:262–316
Alvarez L (1972) Recent Developments in Particle Physics. In: Nobel Lectures, Physics 1963–1970. Elsevier Publishing Company, Amsterdam, pp 241–290
Bonauguri E (1939) Il modello vettoriale dell’atomo e il gruppo delle rotazioni. Il Nuovo Cimento 16(4):202–224
Gentile G Jr (1941) Per la teoria del modello vettoriale dell’atomo. Rendiconti del Reale Istituto Lombardo - Classe di Scienze 74:30–36
Magri Materossi T (1943) Il problema dei fili di Lecher. Il Nuovo Cimento 1(3):190–204
Somenzi V (1940) Sopra l’interazione elettrodinamica di due elettroni e la teoria di Welker della superconduttività. La Ricerca Scientifica 11:656–658
Somenzi V (1941) Interazione elettrodinamica di due elettroni e teoria di Welker della superconduttività. Il Nuovo Cimento 18(5):223–234
Borghi C (1943) Sulla sezione d’urto del neutrone in effetto Compton. Il Nuovo Cimento 1(3):176–189
Kerst DW (1940) Acceleration of electrons by magnetic induction. Phys Rev 58(9):841–841
Kerst DW (1941) The acceleration of electrons by magnetic induction. Phys Rev 60(1):47–53
Kerst DW, Serber R (1941) Electronic orbits in the induction accelerator. Phys Rev 60(1):53–58
Bonolis L, Melchionni MG (eds) (2003) Fisici italiani del tempo presente. Storia di vita e di pensiero. Marsilio, Venezia, pp 365–447
Bonolis L (ed) (2008) Maestri e allievi nella fisica italiana del Novecento. La Goliardica Pavese, Pavia, pp 95–142
Bonolis L, Pancheri G (2011) Bruno Touschek: particle physicist and father of the e\(^{+}\)e\(^{-}\) collider. Eur Phys J H 36(1):1–61
Gentile G Jr (1941) Le statistiche intermedie e le proprietà dell’elio liquido. Rendiconti Seminario Matematico e Fisico di Milano XV:96–114
Gentile G Jr (1941) Osservazione sopra le statistiche intermedie. Rendiconti del Reale Istituto Lombardo - Classe di Scienze 74:133–137
Polvani G (1927) L’introduzione della ipotesi dei quanta nella fisica. Il Nuovo Cimento 3(1–2):LXXXIII–LXXXIV
Polvani G (1928) Alcune Immediate Conseguenze Termodinamiche della Quantizzazione del Gas Ideale Monoatomico. Il Nuovo Cimento 5(1):256–264
Polvani G (1928) La nuova teoria quantistica del gas ideale monoatomico e la legge di Avogadro. Il Nuovo Cimento 5(1):307–309
Polvani G (1936) Il Diavolo e la Termodinamica. Rendiconti del Seminario Matematico e Fisico di Milano X 1:221–254
Polvani G (1929) La Radiazione Nera Considerata come un Vapore Saturo di Fotoni. Il Nuovo Cimento 6(1):186–200
Brillouin L (1927) Comparaison des différentes statistiques appliquées aux problèmes de quanta. Annales de Physique 10(7):315–331
Gentile G Jr (1940) Osservazioni sopra le statistiche intermedie. Il Nuovo Cimento 17(10):493–497
Salvetti C (1970) Commemorazione del M.E. Giovanni Polvani. Rendiconti dell’Istituto Lombardo di Scienze e Lettere 104:113–124
Caldirola P (1941) Osservazioni sulle statistiche intermedie. La Ricerca Scientifica 12:1020–1028
Penco MA (2000) Le statistiche intermedie di G. Gentile Jr. In: Tucci P (ed) Atti del XIX Congresso Nazionale di Storia della Fisica e dell’Astronomia Centro Volta, Como, 28–29 Maggio 1999. SISFA, pp 275–285
Rossi A (2001) Un contributo al dibattito sui fondamenti della meccanica quantistica: le statistiche intermedie di Giovanni Gentile Jr. Atti del XXI Congresso Nazionale di Storia della Fisica e dell’Astronomia. SISFA, Milano, pp 316–324
Torri D (2013) Giovanni Gentile Junior e le statistiche gentiliane. Dissertation, Università degli Studi di Milano
Balibar S, The discovery of superfluidity. arXiv:physics/0611119 [physics.hist-ph]
Gentile G Jr (1941) Sopra il fenomeno della condensazione del gas di Bose Einstein. La Ricerca Scientifica 3:341–346
Sommerfeld A (1943) Zum Gedächtnis an Giovanni Gentile jun’’. Il Nuovo Cimento 1(3):151–154
Caldirola P (1943) Su alcune proprietà fisiche dell’He II. Il Nuovo Cimento 1(3):205–216
Caldirola P (1944) Sulla distribuzione statistica di un gas quantistico di particelle ad autofunzioni simmetriche Rendiconti del Reale Istituto Lombardo - Classe di Scienze 77:193–200
Caldirola P (1946) Le leggi fondamentali della meccanica statistica classica e quantistica. Rivista del Nuovo Cimento 2:25–47
Caldirola P (1975) Evoluzione storica del principio di esclusione nella fisica. Scientia 110:51–67
Salvetti C (1941) Ricerche sulla conducibilità termica e sulla viscosità nelle statistiche di Gentile e loro possibili applicazioni all’He II. La Ricerca Scientifica 12:894–899
Salvetti C (1942) Sopra i fenomeni di trasporto nelle statistiche gentiliane. I. Atti della Reale Accademia d’Italia. Memorie della classe di Scienze Fisiche, Matematiche e Naturali XIII:651–678
Sommerfeld A (1942) Die Quantenstatistik und das Problem des Heliums II. Berichte der Deutschen Chemischen Gesellschaft 75(12):1988–1996
Wergeland H (1944) Bose-Einstein Condensation and the New Statistics of G. Gentile. Det Kongelige Norske Videns Selskab 17(13):51–54
Wergeland H (1944) Bose-Einstein condensation and the new statistics of G. Gentile II. Det Kongelige Norske Videns Selskab 17(15):63–66
Wergeland H (1969) On the \(<<\)intermediary\(>>\) statistics of G. Gentile. Det Kongelige Norske Videns Selskab 42:22–24
Wergeland H (1976) On unifying formulae in quantum statistics. Physica Norvegica 8:207–211
Schubert G (1946) Zur Bose-Statistik. Zeitschrift für Naturforschung A 1(3):113–120
Borsellino A (1947) Sulle ipotesi poste a fondamento delle statistiche intermedie. Il Nuovo Cimento 4(1–2):52–62
Cattani M (2007) Quantum statistics: the indistinguishability principle and the permutation group theory. Revista Brasileira de Ensino de Fisica 29(3):405–414
Gentile G Jr (1942) Le statistiche intermedie e le proprietà dell’elio liquido. Il Nuovo Cimento 19(4):109–125
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2022 The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer Nature Switzerland AG
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Bonolis, L. (2022). Giovanni Gentile Junior. Physics as an Intellectual and Spiritual Adventure. In: The Milan Institute of Physics. History of Physics. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-99516-4_4
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-99516-4_4
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-030-99515-7
Online ISBN: 978-3-030-99516-4
eBook Packages: Physics and AstronomyPhysics and Astronomy (R0)