Abstract
The view that clinical research is always less “scientific”, and therefore less valuable than biomedical research, reflects considerable prejudice. The fact that the clinician who takes care of patients cannot devote all his professional life to research is not, in itself, valid grounds for depreciating the quality of clinical science. Such value judgments based on any epistemiological model (1–4), are only valid and fair when the work of full-time investigators in clinical disciplines is compared with that of full-time basic research scientists.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
References
Lakatos I, Musgrave A, Editors. Criticism and the growth of knowledge. Cambridge-London-New York: Cambridge University Press, 1975: 1–282.
Stachowiak H. Medizin als handlungswissenschaft. In Gross R, editor. Modelle und realitaten in der medizin, schattauer verlag. Stuttgard-New York: 1983: 7–22.
Stegmuller W. Theoriendynamik. Normale wissenschaft und wissenschaftliche revolutionen. Methodologie der forschungsprogramme oder epistemologische anarchie? In Probleme und resultate der wissenschaftstheorie und analytischen philosophie. Band II. Theorie und Erfahrung. Berlin-Heidelberg-New York: Springer Verlag, 1973: 153–327.
Feyerabend PK. Wie wird man ein braver empirist? Ein aufruf zur toleranz in der erkenntnistheorie (how to be a good empiricist—a plea for tolerance in matters epidemiological). In Kruger L, editor. Erkenntnis-Probleme der Naturwissenschaften, Kiepenheuer—Witsch. Koln-Berlin: 1970: 302–335.
Lorenz W, Hamelmann H, Troidl H. Marburg experiment on surgical research: a five-year experience on the cooperation between clinical and theoretical surgeons. Klin Wschr 1976; 54: 927–936.
Lorenz W, Roher HD. Fifteen years of the Marburg Experiment on surgical research. Part I: change from experimental to theoretical surgery. Theor Surg 1986; 1: 21–31.
Lorenz W. The progress of surgical science. Lancet II. 1983: 1017–1017.
Lorenz W, Roher HD. Entwicklung wissenschaftlicher Aussagen. In Schreiber HW, Carstensen G, editors. Chirurgie im Wandel der Zeit 1945–1983. Berlin-Heidelberg: Springer Verlag, 1983: 28–35.
Rohde H, Troidl H, Lorenz W. Systematic follow-up: a concept for evaluation of operative results in duodenal ulcer patients. Klin Wschr 1977; 55: 925–932.
Troidl H, Lorenz W, Rohde H, Fischer M, Ves-tweber KH, Hamelmann H. Trends in der Chirurgie des chronischen ulces duodeni: eine prospektive kontrollierte aber noch immer nicht randomisierte Studie. Chirurg 1979; 50: 285–290.
Lorenz W, Ohmann CH. Methodische Formen klinischer Studien in der Chirurgie: indikation und bewertung. Chirurg 1983; 54: 189–195.
Allgower M. Interdisziplinare Zusammenarbeit in der Chirurgie. Ther Umsch 1972; 29: 645.
Lorenz W. Attitudes to controlled clinical trials. Lancet I 1982: 1460–1461.
Lorenz W, Doenicke A, Meyer R, et al. An improved method for the determination of histamine release in man: its application in studies with propanidid and thiopentone. Europ J Pharmacol 1972; 19: 180–190.
Lorenz W, Benesch L, Barth H, et al. Fluoro-metric assay of histamine in tissues and body fluids: choice of the purification procedure and identification in the nanogram range. Z Analyt Chem 1970; 252: 94–98.
Doenicke A, Lorenz W. Histaminfreisetzung und anaphylaktische reaktionen bei narkosen. Biochemische und Klinische Aspekte. Anaesthesist 1970; 19: 413–417.
Lorenz W, Reimann H-J, Barth H, et al. A sensitive and specific method for the determination of histamine in human whole blood and plasma. Hoppe-Seyler’s Z Physiol Chem 1972; 353: 911–920.
Beaven MA, WoldeMussie E. Histamine in body fluids: its measurement in different clinical states. NER Allergy Proc 1984; 5: 300–310.
Moss J, Rosow CE, Savarese JJ, Philbin DM, Kniffen KJ. Role of histamine in the hypotensive action of d-tubocurarine in humans. Anesthesiology 1981; 55: 19–25.
Moss J, Rosow CE. Histamine release by narcotics and muscle relaxants in human. Anesthesiology 1983; 59: 330–338.
Lorenz W, Doenicke A, Meyer R, et al. Histamine release in man by propanidid and thiopentone: pharmacological effects and clinical consequences. Brit J Anaesth 1972; 44: 355–369.
Doenicke A, Lorenz W, Beigi R, et al. Histamine release after intravenous application of short-acting hypnotics: a comparison of etomidate, althesin (CT 1341) and Propanidid. Brit J Anaesth 1973; 45: 1097–1104.
Lorenz W, Roher HD, Doenicke A, Ohmann CH. Histamine release in anaesthesia and surgery: a new method to evaluate its clinical significance with several types of causal relationship. Clin an-aesthesiol 1984; 2: 403–426.
Lorenz W, Seidel W, Doenicke A, et al. Elevated plasma histamine concentrations in surgery: causes and clinical significance. Klin Wschr 1974; 52: 419–425.
Watkins J. Etomidate: An “immunologically safe” anaesthetic agent. Anaesthesia 1983; 38: 34–38.
Troidl H, Lorenz W, Barth H, et al. Augmentation of pentagastrin stimulated gastric secretion in the Heidenhain pouch dog by amodiaquine: inhibition of histamine methyltransferase in vivo? Agents Actions 1973; 3: 157–167.
Seidel W, Troidl H, Lorenz W, et al. Eine prospektive, kontrollierte Studie zur selektiven va-gotomie beim chronischen duodenalulkus: fru-hergebnisse mit einer standardisierten operationsauswahl u. operationstechnik. Klin Wschr 1973; 51: 477–486.
Rohde H, Lorenz W, Troidl H, Reimann H-J, Hafner G, Weber D. Histamine and peptic ulcer: influence of sample-taking on the precision and accuracy of fluorometric histamine assay in biopsies of human gastric mucosa. Agents Actions 1980; 10: 175–185.
Troidl H, Lorenz W, Rohde H, Hafner G, Ron-zheimer M. Histamine and peptic ulcer: a prospective study of mucosal histamine concentrations in duodenal ulcer patients and in control subjects suffering from various gastrointestinal diseases. Klin Wschr 1976; 54: 947–956.
Barth H, Troidl H, Lorenz W, Rohde H, Glass R. Histamine and peptic ulcer disease: histamine methyltransferase activity in gastric mucosa of control subjects and duodenal ulcer patients before and after surgical treatment. Agents Actions 1977; 7: 75–79.
Troidl H, Rohde H, Lorenz W, Hafner G, Hamelmann H. Effect of selective gastric vagotomy on histamine concentration in gastric mucosa of patients with duodenal ulcer. Brit J Surg 1978; 65: 101–16.
Man WK, Saunders JH, Ingoldby C, Spencer J. Effect of selective gastric vagotomy on histamine concentration in gastric mucosa of control subjects and duodenal ulcer patients before and after surgical treatment. Agents Actions 1977; 7: 75–79.
Lorenz W, Thon K, Barth H, Neugebauer E, Reimann H-J, Kuschej. Metabolism and function of gastric histamine in health and disease. J Clin Gastroenterol 1983; 5 (suppl. l): 37–56.
Hansen JH, Knigge U. Failure of proximal gastric vagotomy for duodenal ulcer resistant to Cimetidine. Lancet 1984; 11: 84–86.
Lorenz W, Thon K, Ohmann CH, Roher HD. Symptomloses und kompliziertes ulcus pepticum als extreme erscheinungsformen der ulcuskran-kheit: konsequenzen fur die wähl zwischen konservativer und chirurgischer therapie. Langen-becks Arch. Chir 1985; 366: 69–79.
Messmer K, Lorenz W, Haendle H, Klovekorn WP, Hutzel M. Acute hypotension and histamine liberation following rapid infusion of plasma substitutes in dogs. Europ Surg Res 1969; 1: 188–189.
Goth A. Histamine release by drugs and chemicals. In Histamine and antihistamines, International Encyclopedia of Pharmacology and Therapeutics, vol 1, Oxford-New York-Toronto- Sydney-Braunschweig: Pergamon Press, 1973: 25–43.
Keller R. A study of the mastocytolytic effects of polycations in the presence of certain plasma substitutes. Bibl Haemat 1969; 33: 126–130.
Messmer K, Lorenz W, Sunder-Plassmann L, Kloevekorn WP, Hutzel M. Histamine release as cause of acute hypotension following rapid colloid infusion. Naunyn-Schmiedebergs Arch. Pharmak 1970; 267: 433–445.
Lorenz W, Doenicke A, Messmer K, et al. Histamine release in human subjects by modified gelatin (Haemaccel (R)) and dextran: an explanation for anaphylactoid reactions observed under clinical conditions? Brit J Anaesth 1976; 48: 151–165.
Lorenz W, Doenicke A, Schöning B, Karges H, Schmal A. Incidence and mechanisms of adverse reactions to polypeptides in man and dog. In Hennessen W, editor. Joint WHO/IABS symposium on the standardization of albumin, plasma substitutes and plasmapheresis, Geneva 1980. Develop. Biol. Standard. 48. Karger Verlag 1981: 207–234.
Williams JG, Riley TRD, Moody RA. Resuscitation experience in the Falkland Islands Campaign. Brit Med J 1983; 286: 775–777.
Bennet JR, Dykes PW. Ulcerative disease of the stomach and the duodenum. In Dykes PW, Keighly MRB, editors. Gastrointestinal Haemorrhage, John Wright, Bristol. 1981: 155–165.
DeDombal FT, Morgan AG, Staniland JR, Ohmann C. Clinical features computer analysis. In Dykes PW, Keighley MRB, editors. Gastrointestinal haemorrhage, John Wright Bristol. 1981: 155–165.
Thon K, Ohmann CH, Stoltzing H, Lorenz W. Medical decision making in upper gastrointestinal bleeding: the impact of clinical criteria for the diagnosis of recurrent haemorrhage. Theor Sur 1986; 1: 32–39.
Ohmann CH, Thon K, Stoltzing H, Lorenz W. Medical decision making for monitoring patients with upper gastrointestinal bleeding. In van Bem-mel JH, Gremy F, Zvarova J, editors. Medical decision making: Diagnostic strategies and experts systems. North-Holland: Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., 1985: 136–139.
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 1986 Springer-Verlag New York Inc.
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Lorenz, W., Troidl, H. (1986). The Marburg Experiment. In: Troidl, H., Spitzer, W.O., McPeek, B., Mulder, D.S., McKneally, M.F. (eds) Principles and Practice of Research. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-96942-3_15
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-96942-3_15
Publisher Name: Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg
Print ISBN: 978-3-642-96944-7
Online ISBN: 978-3-642-96942-3
eBook Packages: Springer Book Archive