Background

Higher alcohol synthesis from syngas, an economically attractive method for making fuels and chemicals, is of interest due to the enhancement of petroleum price, environmental concerns, and additive for gasoline to increase octane number [1]. There are three different methods for making higher alcohols from syngas: (1) using modified catalysts for synthesis of methanol including Cu-, Zn-, and Cr-based catalysts, (2) using modified catalysts for Fisher-Tropsch synthesis including Fe-, Ni-, and Co-based catalysts, and (3) using promoted molybdenum sulfide catalysts [29]. Among them, molybdenum-based catalysts are more attractive due to their high activity for the water-gas shift reaction [10]. Molybdenum disulfide (MoS2) catalyst mainly produces hydrocarbons, but when it is promoted with alkali metals, it can produce alcohols from syngas [11, 12]. The function of alkali metals is to reduce the hydrogenation ability of alkyl species to form alkanes and increase the sites active for the formation of alcohols [13].

Some investigations have been carried out to study the influence of catalyst physico-chemical properties on higher alcohol synthesis and to have a better understanding of the structure-sensitive effects in higher alcohol synthesis (HAS) catalysis [1416]. A sub-category of the structure-sensitive reactions regards the dependence of both catalytic activity and selectivity on catalytic metal particle size. Microemulsion, a novel technique for catalyst preparation, enables the control of metal particle size with a narrow particle size distribution, regardless of metal content [1720]. Briefly, a microemulsion consists of nanosized water droplets surrounded by an oil phase, which is stabilized by a surfactant [20]. The size of the metal particles formed in water-in-oil (w/o) microemulsions is controlled by changing the micelle size (the water-to-surfactant ratio) [20]. Hayashi et al. found that the activity of a Fe/SiO2 catalyst prepared by microemulsion was higher than that of the catalyst prepared by incipient wetness impregnation with the same metal loading [21]. However, it has been also shown that metal nanoparticles obtained by microemulsion techniques interact strongly with oxygen-carrying ceramic supports (such as Al2O3, SiO2, and TiO2). Such interactions lead to a decrease of the catalyst reduction efficiency [17, 22, 23]. Therefore, oxidic carriers impose serious limitations to the investigation of structure-sensitive effects in catalysis because of the co-existence of incompletely reduced metal phase caused by strong interaction with the oxidic carrier [17, 22, 24]. Specifically, nanoparticles synthesized by microemulsion are known to be more difficult to reduce on oxidic carriers. The control of particle size is another advantage for nanoparticle preparation in microemulsion system. The ratio of water to surfactant is one of the size-determining key parameters [25]. The size of the active metal particles depends on the size of the droplets in the microemulsion. The droplet size will be influenced by the water-to-surfactant ratios. An increase of this ratio at constant concentration of surfactant will increase the average diameter of the droplets. Lisiecki and Pileni reported that the size of Cu nanoparticles prepared in a system consisting of bis(2-ethylhexyl) sulfosuccinate (aerosol-OT) surfactant, cyclohexane, and water increased from 2 to 10 nm as water-to-surfactant ratios changed from 1 to 10 [26].

In our previous works, we used impregnation method to prepare the carbon nanotube-supported MoO3-K2O higher alcohol synthesis catalyst [27, 28]. We showed that CNTs, when used as HA synthesis catalyst support, allow a better metal dispersion and control and minimize the metal-support interactions (formation of mixed compounds). In the present work, we intend to compare the proposed microemulsion technique for MoO3-K2O catalyst preparation with the incipient wetness impregnation method for the control of metal particle size using CNTs as catalyst support. The influences of molybdenum particle size on the catalyst physico-chemical properties, activity, and selectivity were assessed and reported.

Methods

Multiwalled CNTs (purity >95%; characteristics are shown in Table 1) were used as support for the preparation of the catalysts. Prior to catalyst preparation, the support was treated with 30% HNO3 reflux at 120°C overnight, washed with distilled water several times, and dried at 120°C for 6 h.

Table 1 Textural properties of the fresh and purified carbon nanotubes

For the preparation of the first catalyst, molybdenum and potassium particles were synthesized in a reverse microemulsion using a nonionic surfactant Triton X-100 and n-hexanol as the oil phase. The concentrations of molybdenum and potassium were adjusted using aqueous solutions of (NH4)6Mo7O24·4H2O, (Merck, Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA) and K2CO3 as 15 wt.% molybdenum and 8 wt.% potassium. The water-to-surfactant molar ratio (w/s) was selected as 2. After 15 min of vigorous stirring, a microemulsion was obtained. Hydrazine was added to develop nanoparticle formation in the core of the micelles by reducing the metal oxides. Then, the purified carbon nanotubes were added under stirring. Afterward, tetrahydrofurane was added dropwise (1 ml/min). The mixture was left to mature and settle slowly overnight and then decanted. The sample was filtered and washed several times with ethanol. Next, the catalyst was dried at 120°C and calcined under argon flow at 450°C for 3 h and slowly exposed to an oxygen atmosphere during the cooling step. The catalyst prepared by this procedure was signified as C1.

The second catalyst, with the same metal loadings, was prepared by the incipient wetness impregnation method using aqueous solutions of (NH4)6Mo7O24·4H2O and K2CO3. After the impregnation step, the catalyst was dried at 120°C and calcined at 450°C under argon flow for 3 h and slowly exposed to an oxygen atmosphere during the cooling step. The catalyst prepared by this procedure was signified as C2.

ICP-OES

The metal loadings of the fresh and purified supports and the calcined catalysts were performed using Varian VISTA-MPX inductively coupled plasma-optical emission spectrometry (ICP-OES) instrument (Varian, Palo Alto, CA, USA).

BET surface area measurements/BJH pore size distributions

Surface area, pore volume, and pore average diameter of the supports and calcined catalysts were measured using an ASAP-2010 V2 Micrometrics system (Micrometric Instrument Co., Cleveland, OH, USA). The samples were degassed at 200°C for 4 h under 50-mTorr vacuums, and their Brunauer-Emmett-Teller (BET) area, pore volume, and pore diameter were determined.

X-ray diffraction

The phases and particle sizes of the crystals present in the calcined, reduced, and sulfide catalysts were analyzed by X-ray diffraction (XRD) using a Philips Analytical X-ray diffractometer (X’Pert MPD, X’Pert, PANalytical B.V., Almelo, The Netherlands) with monochromatized Co/Kα radiation, 2θ angles from 20° to 80°. The Debye-Scherer formula (d = 0.9λ / β cosθ, where β is the full width at half maximum; λ, the wavelength of X-ray; and 0.9, a constant) was applied to MoO3 peaks at 2θ = 43.3° (the most intense peak for MoO3), in order to calculate the average particle sizes.

Transmission electron microscopy

The morphology of the support and catalysts was studied by transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Sample specimens for TEM studies were prepared by ultrasonic dispersion of the catalysts in ethanol, and the suspensions were dropped onto a carbon-coated copper grid. TEM investigations were carried out using a Philips CM20 (100 kV) transmission electron microscope equipped with a NARON energy-dispersive spectrometer with a germanium detector.

Temperature-programmed reduction

The H2 temperature-programmed reduction (TPR) profiles of the catalysts were performed in order to study the reducibility of the metal species in the catalysts. The calcined catalyst sample (0.05 g) was first purged in a flow of helium at 140°C to remove traces of water and gases that exist in the catalyst, and then cooled to 40°C. Then, the TPR of each sample was performed using 5% H2 in argon stream at a flow rate of 40 ml/min at atmospheric pressure using Micromeritics TPD-TPR 2900 analyzer (Norcross, GA, USA) equipped with a thermal conductivity detector (TCD), heating at a linearly programmed rate of 10°C/min up to 850°C.

Hydrogen chemisorption

The amount of chemisorbed hydrogen was measured using the Micromeritics TPD-TPR 2900 analyzer system. The calcined catalyst (0.2 g) was first purged in a flow of argon at 140°C to remove traces of water. The temperature was then raised to 500°C at a linearly programmed rate of 10°C/min, and the catalyst was reduced for 12 h under hydrogen flow and then cooled to 40°C. Then, the flow of hydrogen was switched to argon for 30 min in order to remove the weakly adsorbed hydrogen. Afterwards, the temperature-programmed desorption (TPD) of the samples was performed by increasing the temperature of the samples, with a ramp rate of 40°C/min, to a maximum of 500°C under the argon flow. The temperature-programmed desorption spectrum was used to determine the molybdenum dispersion and its average crystallite size.

Results and discussion

Characterization overview

Textural properties of the fresh and purified carbon nanotubes are given in Table 1. The data indicate that in the case of acid-washed support, surface area, total pore volume, and average internal diameter of nanotubes increased significantly which will result in better dispersion of metal as well as enhancement of the catalyst activity. Table 1 also shows the Fe content for the untreated fresh CNTs and acid-treated CNTs (determined by ICP). As shown, the amount of encapsulated metals in the fresh CNTs was 0.6 wt.% which decreased to zero after acid treatment.

Results of surface area measurements for the calcined C1 and C2 catalysts are given in Table 2. These results show that the BET surface area of the C1 is 157 m2/g. However, the BET surface area for the C2 catalyst is somewhat lower (136 m2/g), which indicates some more pore blockage by metal oxide clusters in the catalyst prepared by incipient wetness impregnation method than the catalyst prepared by microemulsion method.

Table 2 Textural properties of the catalysts

The elemental compositions of the calcined catalysts measured by ICP are given in Table 3. The measured contents of the prepared catalysts are found to be slightly lower compared to the targeted values. The discrepancies may be due to the dilution of Mo because of the hygroscopic nature of the Mo precursor.

Table 3 Chemical composition of the catalysts

Figure 1 presents the TEM image of the purified support. As shown, the treated support is comprised of an interwoven matrix of multiwalled CNTs. TEM images of C1 catalyst made by the microemulsion preparation route is shown in Figure 2. As shown, the very small particles are dispersed mostly inside the tubes and on the outer surface of the CNT walls. In the case of C1 catalyst, the size of particles located inside the nanotubes and the size of particles located outside the nanotubes are within the range of 1 to 5 nm and 1 to 7 nm, respectively. The TEM image of C2 catalyst prepared by impregnation method is shown in Figure 3. This figure shows that the particles are distributed both inside and outside of the nanotube walls. The size of the particles located inside the nanotubes are in the range of 3 to 9 nm. However, particles located outside the nanotubes have grown to about 16 nm. Indeed, the narrow inner diameter of the CNT channels (8 to 12 nm) restricted the insertion of particles in sizes close to the channel diameter (10 nm).

Figure 1
figure 1

TEM image of purified CNTs. Arrows show open caps.

Figure 2
figure 2

TEM image of the catalyst prepared by microemulsion method. Arrows show metal particles.

Figure 3
figure 3

TEM image of the catalyst prepared by impregnation method. Arrows show metal particles.

Figure 4 depicts the size distribution of the particles for C1 and C2 catalysts, which is determined using the population of the total particles of the catalyst based on the data taken from five TEM pictures. According to this figure, the average particle size for the C1 and C2 catalysts are 4.8 and 7 nm, respectively. It should be noted that using impregnation method to make the catalysts, there is no any factor to control the particle size and metal particles disperse randomly in outer and inner surfaces of the CNTs. However, using microemulsion method, the size of particles is related to the size of water droplets and the water/surfactant ratios. By controlling these parameters, it is possible to direct the size of metal particles.

Figure 4
figure 4

Particle size distribution for C 1 and C 2 catalysts.

To determine the crystalline phases, XRD experiments of the calcined catalysts were performed. Figure 5 presents the XRD spectrum of the catalysts with different preparation methods. To detect the phases, we used JCPDS chemical spectra data bank. As shown in this figure, using microemulsion technique decreases the intensity of the peaks corresponding to MoO3 (peaks at 2θ values of 43.3, 63.2, and 71.9), indicating the smaller particle sizes of MoO3 in the case of C1 catalyst. Table 3 shows the average sizes of MoO3 particles calculated from the XRD patterns, using the Debye-Scherer formula at 2θ value of 43.3. As can be seen, using microemulsion technique decreases the average crystal diameter of MoO3 from 7.4 to 5.1 nm. Also, the XRD of both catalyst peaks at 2θ values of 25.8, 31.3, 40.4, and 46.3 can correspond to the crystalline structure of K-Mo-O mixed oxide species (K2Mo2O7, K2MoO4, K2Mo7O20, KMo4O6, and K0.33MoO3) [2431]. In the case of C1 catalyst, the corresponding K-Mo-O peaks appeared more significantly. This implies that using microemulsion technique, which significantly decreases the MoO3 particle sizes, the chemical interactions between K-Mo-O species increase, enhancing the conditions for the formation of alcohols [2431].

Figure 5
figure 5

XRD patterns of the calcined catalysts with different preparation methods.

TPR tests were performed to determine the reducibility of the calcined catalysts. The TPR spectra of the calcined C1 and C2 catalysts are shown in Figure 6. In the case of the catalyst prepared by impregnation method (C2), the low temperature peak (510°C) is typically assigned to the reduction of Mo6+ to Mo4+. The second broad peak is generally assigned to the second reduction step, which is mainly the reduction of Mo4+ to metallic Mo0[2431]. According to Figure 6, the deposition of Mo nanoparticles synthesized by microemulsion method on the CNTs shift the reduction of the Mo6+ to Mo4+ (first peak) to a lower temperature compared to the catalyst prepared by impregnation method, indicating higher reducibility of the uniform particles. According to the TEM picture of the catalyst prepared by microemulsion technique, a good number of the small particles are located inside the tubes, which in turn lead to a better interaction with the intern electron-deficient walls of the CNTs and favor the reduction of molybdenum. The tubular morphology of the graphene layers make CNTs different compared to other carbonaceous supports. The deviation of the graphene layers from planarity causes p electron density to shift from the concave inner surface to the convex outer surface, leading to an interior electron-deficient surface and an exterior electron-enriched surface. Thus, the exterior surfaces of the CNTs are electron rich, whereas the interior ones are electron deficient, which could influence metal and metal oxide particles in contact with either surface. It can be concluded that particles located inside the carbon nanotubes are more susceptible for reduction than the particles located on the outside surfaces [2431].

Figure 6
figure 6

TPR profiles for the catalysts with different preparation methods.

In addition, it should be noted that using microemulsion method and decreasing the particle sizes promote the formation of Mo-K mixed oxide species (as shown by XRD) that are reducible at lower temperatures. In accordance with the first TPR peak, the second peak temperature for the catalyst prepared by microemulsion method shifted to lower temperatures. The degree of catalyst reduction which is proportional to the areas of the corresponding peaks indicates that using micoemulsion technique resulted in a significant improvement in the reducibility of the catalyst (37% enhancement). In addition to the above-mentioned explanations, this can be due to the significant pore blockage for catalyst prepared by impregnation method.

The results of hydrogen chemisorption tests are given in Table 4. As shown, using microemulsion considerably increased the hydrogen uptake and percentage of dispersion. The particle diameter decreased, which is in agreement with the results of XRD and TEM tests. Higher dispersion and smaller molybdenum cluster sizes in the case of C1 catalyst will increase the number of sites available for CO conversion and alcohol formation reaction rates.

Table 4 H 2 chemisorption results for the catalysts

Activity and product selectivity results

Synthesis of higher alcohols was carried out after the reduction and sulfidation of catalysts in a fixed bed reactor at 320°C, 70 bars, gas hourly space velocity of 3.6 nLit/g cat./h, and H2/CO = 2. The liquid products were collected at 0°C, and the exit gas was analyzed to measure the CO conversion. The analysis of liquid products indicates that methanol and ethanol are the major products with small amounts of propanol, butanol, and other higher alcohols. The analysis of exit gas indicates that methane is the major component apart from CO, H2, and CO2.

Figure 7 presents the percentage of CO and H2 conversions and different product selectivities during 24 h of continuous synthesis for C1 and C2 catalysts. As shown in this figure, for both catalysts, alcohols have the highest product selectivity. It has been suggested that sulfidation of the mixed oxides present in the calcined form of the catalysts and formation of the Mo-K-S species are responsible for the alcohol formation via following CO insertion mechanism [2831].

CO + 2 H 2 CH 3 OH
(1)
CH 3 OH + H 2 CH 4 + H 2 O
(2)
CH 3 OH + CO + 2 H 2 C 2 H 5 OH + H 2 O
(3)
C 2 H 5 OH + CO + 2 H 2 C 3 H 7 OH + H 2 O
(4)
CO + H 2 O CO 2 + H 2
(5)
Figure 7
figure 7

Percentage of CO and H 2 conversions and different product selectivities for C 1 and C 2 catalysts.

In this mechanism, adsorption of CO and hydrogen takes place at different sites to from intermediate surface species. These surface species propagate chain growth through hydrogenation, followed by insertion of molecularly adsorbed CO species to form different long-chain intermediates. The direct hydrogenation of these intermediate hydrocarbon species leads to the formation of hydrocarbon, methanol, and higher alcohols.

Figure 7 shows that using microemulsion technique for the preparation of Mo-K/CNT catalyst increases the CO and H2 conversions significantly. The percentage of CO conversion and the percentage of H2 conversion increased from 27.7% to 43.8% (about 58.1% enhancement) and 23.9% to 37.6% (about 57.3% enhancement), respectively. The increase in the percentage of CO and H2 conversions upon using microemulsion technique can be due to the increase in Mo dispersion (confirmed by XRD, TEM, and H2 chemisorption tests) and the enhancement in reduction of Mo6+ to Mo4+ and Mo4+ to metallic Mo0 (confirmed by TPR tests). Increasing dispersion, increases the number of active sites available for reaction, thus increases the activity of the catalyst [2431].

Interestingly, Figure 7 also shows that using microemulsion technique for the preparation of Mo-K/CNT catalyst increases the selectivity of total alcohols and decreases the selectivity of hydrocarbons significantly. The total alcohol selectivity increased by 35.58%, whereas the selectivity of hydrocarbons decreased by 24.22%. Different causes can explain the significant enhancement in the selectivity of the C1 catalyst. As shown by XRD tests, using microemulsion technique increased the chemical interactions between K-Mo-O species (the intensity of the peaks corresponding to Mo-K-O mixed oxides increased, i.e., K2Mo2O7, K2MoO4, K2Mo7O20, KMo4O6, and K0.33MoO3). These mixed oxides will convert to Mo-K-S species like K2MoS4 during catalyst reduction and sulfidation processes. The XRD patterns of the reduced and sulfurized C1 catalyst are shown in Figure 8. As shown in Figure 8, the various diffraction peaks observed in the XRD patterns of oxide samples are completely removed after sulfidation, and the new diffraction peaks with less diffraction intensity representing different sulfide species appeared. This confirmed that newly formed active phases during the sulfidation step are well dispersed on the support. The reflections of MoS2 crystallites are observed at 2θ values of 17.6°, 38.4°, 44.4°, and 67.9°. The peaks at 2θ values of 15.6°, 28.7° and 61.6° are due to the characteristic reflections of the K-Mo-S species, which represent KMo3S3.

Figure 8
figure 8

XRD patterns of the reduced and sulfurized C 1 catalyst.

Formation of these species can boost the conditions suitable for the formation of alcohols [24]. In addition, the decrease in the selectivity of hydrocarbons can be due to the decreased availability of hydrogenation active centers, i.e. MoS2 species as also confirmed by XRD results (the intensity of peaks corresponding to MoO3 decreased in the case of C1 catalyst).

Figure 9 shows the selectivity trends of individual alcohols for C1 and C2 catalysts. As shown, using microemulsion method for the preparation of Mo-K/CNT catalyst dramatically decreases the methanol selectivity and increases ethanol and other higher alcohol selectivities. Using microemulsion technique, the methanol selectivity decreased from 19.4% to 14.7%. At the same time, the higher alcohol selectivity (C2  +OH) increased from 25.9% to 46.7%. In an interesting research, Parmon [32] showed that a decrease in the particle size of the catalyst active phase increases the standard chemical potentials of the components and affects appreciably the adsorption equilibrium. In the case of C1 catalyst prepared by microemulsion method, the decrease in Mo particle sizes increases the adsorption of CO and decreases the adsorption of H2. Decreasing the amount of H2 on the catalyst surface can suppress the formation of methane via reaction 2. Also, increasing the partial pressure of CO on the catalyst surface will express the reactions 3 and 4 which in turn increase the selectivity of ethanol and the selectivity of higher alcohols. Also, the reason may be explained from the XRD and TPD characterizations. It is clear from XRD and TPD that the C2 catalyst showed larger MoO3 particle size. MoO3 will change to MoS2 during catalyst reduction and calcination, which is responsible for poor activity of this catalyst towards the formation of higher alcohols.

Figure 9
figure 9

The selectivity trends of individual alcohols for C 1 and C 2 catalysts.

Experimental

Reaction setup and experimental procedure

Higher alcohol synthesis has been performed in a tubular downflow, fixed-bed reactor system. The reactor was made up of Inconel tube of 450-mm length and 22-mm inside diameter. The reactor temperature was controlled via a PID temperature controller. Brooks 5850 mass flow controllers (Hatfield, PA, USA) were used to add H2 and CO at the desired rate to the reactor. The reactor was packed with 0.5 g of catalyst diluted with 90-mesh-size silicon carbide and housed in a melton salt bath controlled by a temperature controller. The reactor was pressurized to 30 bars with He, and the reduction as well as the sulfurization was carried out for 6 h at 450°C at a heating rate of 2°C/min using a gas mixture containing 5 mol% H2S in H2 and a flow rate of 50 ml/min. The temperature was then lowered to the reaction temperature, and the system was then pressurized to the reaction condition. The feed gas mixture (H2/CO ratio of 2) was passed through mass flow controllers, and the HAS reaction was carried out at steady state under the reaction conditions of 320°C, 70 bars, and gas hourly space velocity of 3.6 nLit/g cat./h over a period of 24 h. The product gas was cooled to 0°C and separated into gas and liquid phases at the reaction pressure. The CO, CO2, and other gaseous products were monitored with time intervals of 1 h. The products were collected after completion of the run and analyzed by means of three gas chromatographs, a Shimadzu 4C gas chromatograph (Nakagyo-ku, Kyoto, Japan) equipped with two subsequent connected packed columns: Porapak Q and Molecular Sieve 5 Å, and a TCD with argon which was used as a carrier gas for hydrogen analysis. A Varian CP 3800 with a chromosorb column and a TCD were used for CO, CO2, CH4, and other non-condensable gases. A Varian CP 3800 with a Petrocol Tm DH100 fused silica capillary column and a flame ionization detector were used for liquid products so that a complete product distribution could be provided.

Conclusions

Carbon nanotube-supported alkalized MoS2 nanocatalysts prepared by microemulsion and impregnation methods are used to produce higher alcohols from synthesis gas. Using microemulsion technique decreased the average MoO3 particle sizes from 7 to 4.8 nm, increased the percentage of dispersion from 51 to 59, and increased the percentage of reduction by 37%. In addition, the chemical interactions between K-Mo-O species, enhancing the conditions for the formation of alcohols, are increased. Selectivity and activity were found to be dependent on the catalyst preparation method. Using microemulsion technique increased the percentage of CO conversion from 27.7% to 43.8%. The CNT-supported MoO3-K2O nanocatalyst synthesized by microemulsion technique decreased the hydrocarbon selectivity from 32.4% to 24.5% and increased the alcohol selectivity from 45.3% to 61.4%. Finally, using microemulsion method for the preparation of Mo-K/CNT nanocatalyst severely decreased the methanol selectivity and increased ethanol and other higher alcohol selectivities.