Abstract
The band structure in a kagome lattice can naturally exhibit flat band, Dirac cones, and van Hove singularity, enabling rich interplays between correlation and topology. However, the flat band is rarely detected just at the Fermi level in kagome materials, which would be crucial to realize emergent flat band physics. Here, combining angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy, transport measurements and first-principles calculation, we observe a striking Fermi-level flat band in paramagnetic YCr6Ge6 as a typical signature of electronic kagome lattice. We explicitly unveil that orbital character plays an essential role to realize electronic kagome lattice in crystals with transition-metal kagome layers. We further engineer this material with magnetic rare earth elements to break the time-reversal symmetry of the Fermi-level kagome flat band. Our work establishes a Fermi-level flat band in a kagome magnet as an exciting quantum platform.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
1 Introduction
Due to the unique triangular-based corner sharing geometry, the kagome lattice (Fig. 1a) provides an exciting platform [1] for the realization of a series of unconventional quantum phases, including spin liquids [2], noncolinear magnetism [3], Chern energy gap [4], and unconventional charge ordering [5]. Particularly, the destructive quantum interference in the kagome lattice can lead to a flat band [6], which are proposed to host many emergent physics, such as the potential realization of high temperature fractional quantum Hall effect when a combination of spin-orbital coupling, time-reversal symmetry breaking and partial electron filling of the flat band is considered [7]. Along this direction, flat bands in several kagome materials have been successfully identified [8–17]. However, in those materials, the flat band is fairly far away from the Fermi level (usually on the order of 100 meV away from Fermi level), limiting its potential for further fundamental research and its application value in quantum devices.
In this paper, using angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES), we report the direct observations of typical kagome band structure with a Fermi-level flat band in paramagnet YCr6Ge6 (Fig. 1a), consisting with previous transport and first-principle calculation results [18]. We unveil that orbital character plays an important role in formation of flat band in kagome materials, with band flatness decomposed for \(d_{x^{2} - y^{2}} / d_{xy}\) states. We further introduce ferromagnetism in the system by substitution Y with magnetic Gd, in which the Fermi-level flat band is preserved. Beside of systems with transition metals V [5, 16, 17, 19], Mn [3, 4, 15, 20–23], Fe [8, 10, 24, 25] and Co [9, 11–14, 26–28] kagome planes, Cr-based kagome magnet (Y,Gd)Cr6Ge6 provides a good platform to study the intrinsic properties of Fermi-level flat band, and its interplay with spin-orbit coupling (SOC) and time reversal symmetry breaking.
2 Results
2.1 Fermi-level flat band in YCr6Ge6
Firstly, we map the in-plane band structure with \(h\nu = 55\) eV, corresponding to the \(k_{z} = 0\) plane in the bulk Brillouin zone (BZ) (Fig. 1b). The Fermi surface (FS) consists of a big pocket (named as α) centered at the Γ point, and a hot spot (labeled as β) at the K point (Fig. 1c). The α band crosses Fermi energy (\(E_{F}\)) along the Γ-M (Fig. 1d) and Γ-K (Fig. 1e) directions, with Fermi momentum indicated by arrows. Interestingly, additional flat band, named as γ, is clearly observed near \(E_{F}\). We note spectra weight of the α and flat γ bands in the first BZ are much less intense than that from higher BZs (Fig. 1c-e), due to the matrix element effect of photoemission. To eliminate the strong intensity variation and focus on the band dispersion, we plot the experimental results along the Γ-M direction in the 2nd BZ, with the ARPES intensity and energy distribution curve (EDC) plotted in Fig. 1f and h, respectively. The flat band γ clearly appears with peaks near \(E_{F}\) in EDC plot along the Γ-M direction between two 2nd Γ points. Similarly, the flat band γ is explicitly observed near \(E_{F}\) along the Γ-K-M direction in higher BZs as seen from results shown in Fig. 1g and i. In addition to the high-symmetry directions, the γ band shows no dispersion at \(E_{F}\) in whole the \(k_{z} = 0\) plane (see Additional file 1 Fig. S3), indicating an electronic kagome lattice origin of the Fermi-level flat band γ.
Besides flat band, YCr6Ge6 shows complete hallmarks of electronic kagome lattice including Dirac dispersions and saddle points. Figure 2a shows band structure evolution in the \(k_{z} = 0\) plane. From \(E_{F}\) (Fig. 1c) to higher \(E_{B}\) (Fig. 2a-I), the hole-like α pocket at the Γ points also becomes bigger and the β band at K point evolves from a single hot spot to a circular pocket. Further to higher \(E_{B}\) (Fig. 2a-II), the α and β pockets further expand and touch each other at \(T_{\alpha -\beta }\) point along the Γ-K direction at \(E_{B} \sim 0.26\) eV. Then the α and β pockets become even bigger at higher \(E_{B}\), and the two α bands touch each other at the saddle point \(S_{\alpha}\) along the Γ-M direction at \(E_{B} \sim \) 0.4 eV (Fig. 2a-III). At \(E_{B}\) higher than the \(S_{\alpha}\) point, the α band evolves from big hole-like pockets around different Γ points to small electron-like pockets around the K point. Then two β bands touch each other at the saddle point \(S_{\beta}\) along the M-K direction at \(E_{B} = 0.5\) eV (Fig. 2a-IV). The β band evolves from six small hole-like pockets at different K points to single big electron-like pockets centered at the Γ point as \(E_{B} > 0.5\) eV, that becomes smaller and moves towards to the center of BZ with higher \(E_{B}\), as seen from Fig. 2a-IV-VI. Furthermore, the electron-like α pocket at the K point shrinks into a single point \(D_{\alpha}\) at \(E_{B} \sim 0.6\) eV (Fig. 2a-V), and become a hole-like pockets at higher \(E_{B}\) (Fig. 2a-VI). The touching point \(T_{\alpha -\beta }\), Dirac point \(D_{\alpha}\) and saddle points \(S_{\alpha}\) and \(S_{\beta}\) are clearly resolved in the intensity and curvature plots along the Γ-K-M and Γ-M directions in Fig. 2b-e. The effective masses \(m^{*}\) of the α and β bands change the sign along the Γ-K-M and Γ-M directions at the \(S_{\alpha}\) and \(S_{\beta}\) points, respectively.
2.2 Orbit-selectivity in formation of flat band
Our photon energy dependent ARPES measurements in Fig. 3b further indicate that inter-kagome-layers interaction is non-negligible in YCr6Ge6. The periodical variation along the \(k_{z}\) direction is a direct evidence of the bulk electronic states origins for the ARPES signals. We note that the periodicity along \(k_{z}\) is of \(4\pi/c\), as twice as that in the bulk BZ along the \(k_{z}\) direction (\(2\pi/c\)), because the two Cr kagome lattice in the unite cell are crystalline equivalence (Fig. 1a). Along the out of plane direction Γ-A-Γ (Fig. 3c), ARPES intensity near \(E_{F}\) only appears near the Γ point, corresponding to the flat band γ closed to \(E_{F}\) in the \(k_{z} = 0\) plane. The photon energy dependent ARPES results demonstrate a planar flat band nature of γ, which is nondispersive feature in the \(k_{z} = 0\) plane, indeed dispersive along the \(k_{z}\) direction.
Our first-principal calculations projected on Cr-\(3 d_{z^{2}}\) orbit (Fig. 3d) show a good agreement with the observed α and γ bands (Fig. 3a). Our calculations further suggest that the observed β band corresponds the lower branches of the Dirac dispersion for the \(\text{Cr-}3d_{x^{2} - y^{2}}\) and \(3d_{xy}\) states (Fig. 3g). As seen from the insets of Fig. 3d and g, SOC opens gaps around 10 and 30 meV for the Dirac points at the K point for the \(d_{z^{2}}\) and \(d_{x^{2} - y^{2}} / d_{xy}\) states, respectively. We note that a renormalization fact of 1.6 is needed for the calculation results to fit the overall features of experimental results (Additional file 1 Fig. S4), indicating a moderate electronic correlation effect in YCr6Ge6.
The unique behavior of the planar Fermi-level flat band γ is related to the intrinsic orbital character for the layered kagome lattice. As seen from Fig. 3e, intra-kagome-plane hopping process of the \(d_{z^{2}}\) electrons is dominated by \(t_{1}\) and other in-plane hopping terms (\(t_{2}\) and \(t_{3}\)) are negligibly weak. Therefore, both the \(d_{z^{2}}\) bands in the \(k_{z} = 0\) plane (Fig. 3a and d) show a typical 2D electronic kagome lattice with Fermi-level flat band, von Hove singularity and Dirac dispersion. The hopping of \(d_{z^{2}}\) electrons between the adjacent kagome planes (\(t_{4}\) and \(t_{5}\) in Fig. 3f) are considerable, as intermediated by the spacing layers (Fig. 1a). The inter layer hoping terms lead to promising \(k_{z}\) dispersion of the planar Fermi-level flat band. The abnormal transport anisotropy in YCr6Ge6 ([18] and Additional file 1 Fig. S7), with the in-plane resistivity more than twice larger than the out-of-plane one, provides transport signatures of the planar flat band. The planar Fermi-level flat band also leads to a peak in density of states (DOS) at \(E_{F}\) (Fig. 3j). The relatively big Sommerfeld coefficient (80.5 mJ K−2 mol−1) experimentally determined by heat capacity measurements serves as another transport property supporting the planar flat band.
Distinct from the \(d_{z^{2}}\) electrons, the inter-layer interaction of \(d_{x^{2} - y^{2}}\) and \(d_{xy}\) orbits are expected to be weak (Fig. 3i), which results in less dispersive feature along the Γ-A direction (Fig. 3g). In the meantime, the \(d_{x^{2} - y^{2}}\) and \(d_{xy}\) orbits lay in the kagome plane and can induce additional in-plane hopping between the second and third nearest-neighbour sites (Fig. 3h), respectively. The additional terms \(t_{2}\) and \(t_{3}\) terms destroy the flatness of the \(d_{x^{2} - y^{2}}\) and \(d_{xy}\) orbits locating at about 0.7 eV above \(E_{F}\).
2.3 Ferromagnetism and Fermi-level flat band in GdCr6Ge6
We further systematically engineer this kagome metal with magnetic rare earth element Gd to break time-reversal symmetry of the Fermi-level flat band. The temperature dependent magnetic susceptibility measurements on GdCr6Ge6 reveals the emergence of ferromagnetic ordering below a Curie temperature \(T_{C} \sim 11.2\) K, which is consistent to the Weiss temperature \(\theta _{\mathrm{CW}} \sim 11.5\) K extracted from the data of paramagnetic phase (Fig. 4a). The magnetization M shows saturation and hysteresis below \(T_{C}\) (Fig. 4b), further confirmed the ferromagnetism. Since Gd 4f shell is half filled, there is a large local moment in Gd. Therefore, the ferromagnetism could mainly arise from the localized 4f electrons in Gd, which is away from Fermi-level. The core-level spectra of YCr6Ge6 and GdCr6Ge6 are shown in Fig. 4c, with Gd-4f peaks at \(E_{B} \sim 8\) eV and Y-3d one at \(E_{B} \sim 155\) eV, respectively. The band structure of GdCr6Ge6 (Fig. 4d) is very similar as that of YCr6Ge6 (Fig. 2d), with the Fermi-level flat band preserved in GdCr6Ge6 above \(T_{C}\). Time reversal symmetry breaking and SOC are expected to split the spin degeneracy of the flat band γ and separate it from the α band by opening a gap at the Γ point, which can induce a topological Chern band in ferromagnetic phase of GdCr6Ge6. In future, we hope to further resolve the magnetic splitting of the flat band through high resolution and ultra-low temperature ARPES, and explore the tantalizing unusual anomalous transverse transports as well as the quantization properties of the magnetic flat band [7, 29]. For partially substituted compounds, the susceptibilities and ARPES results also present similar magnetic properties and the Fermi-level flat band in electronic structure, as shown in Fig. S8 of Additional file 1.
3 Conclusion and discussion
We directly observed a Fermi-level flat band from Cr-\(d_{z^{2}}\) electrons in paramagnetic YCr6Ge6 and normal state of ferromagnetic GdCr6Ge6, together with other signatures of typical kagome lattice band structure e.g. von Hove singularity and Dirac dispersions. The Fermi-level flat band can explain the abnormal behaviours in transport measurements. Our results demonstrate that orbital character plays an essential role for realization of flat band in transition metal kagome layers. Topological Chern band are expected in the ferromagnetic state of GdCr6Ge6. The Cr-based kagome magnets (Y,Gd)Cr6Ge6 provide a novel platform for investigating Fermi-level flat band, and its interplay with time-reversal symmetry breaking and SOC.
4 Method
High-quality (Y,Gd)Cr6Ge6 single crystals were grown by the flux method using tin as a flux. The starting elements mixture was heated to 1100°C over 8 h, kept at 1100°C for 10 h and then slowly cooled to 600°C at the rate of 3°C/h, and finally decanted in a centrifuge. ARPES measurements were performed on the “surface and interface” beamline of the Swiss Light Source and “Dreamline” beamline of the Shanghai Synchrotron Radiation Facility, with an overall energy resolution of the order of 20 meV, angular resolution of 0.1°, at \(T= 20\) K. The electronic structure of YCr6Ge6 was calculated based on the density functional theory and the local density approximation for the exchange correlation potential, as implemented in the plane-wave pseudopotential based Vienna ab initio simulation package. The wave functions were expanded in plane waves with a cutoff energy of 470 eV and Monkhorst–Pack k points were 9 × 9 × 5. The residual forces are less than 0.01 eV/Å and SOC is included by using the second-order variational procedure.
Availability of data and materials
The data and materials that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
References
Syôzi I (1951) Statistics of kagomé lattice. Prog Theor Phys 6:306–308
Broholm C, Cava RJ, Kivelson SA, Nocera DG, Norman MR, Senthil T (2020) Quantum spin liquids. Science 367:0668
Tomiyoshi S, Yamaguchi Y (1982) Magnetic structure and weak ferromagnetism of Mn3Sn studied by polarized neutron diffraction. J Phys Soc Jpn 51:2478–2486
Yin JX, Ma W, Cochran TA, Xu X, Zhang SS, Tien HJ, Shumiya N, Cheng G, Jiang K, Lian B, Song Z, Chang G, Belopolski I, Multer D, Litskevich M, Cheng ZJ, Yang XP, Swidler B, Zhou H, Lin H, Neupert T, Wang Z, Yao N, Chang TR, Jia S, Hasan MZ (2020) Quantum-limit Chern topological magnetism in TbMn6Sn6. Nature 583:533–536
Neupert T, Denner MM, Yin JX, Thomale R, Hasan MZ (2022) Charge order and superconductivity in kagome materials. Nat Phys 18:137–143
Mielke A (1991) Ferromagnetic ground states for the Hubbard model on line graphs. J Phys A, Math Gen 24:L73
Tang E, Mei JW, Wen XG (2011) High-temperature fractional quantum Hall states. Phys Rev Lett 106:236802
Lin Z, Choi JH, Zhang Q, Qin W, Yi S, Wang P, Li L, Wang Y, Zhang H, Sun Z, Wei L, Zhang S, Guo T, Lu Q, Cho JH, Zeng C, Zhang Z (2018) Flatbands and emergent ferromagnetic ordering in Fe3Sn2 kagome. Phys Rev Lett 121:96401
Yin JX, Zhang SS, Chang G, Wang Q, Tsirkin SS, Guguchia Z, Lian B, Zhou H, Jiang K, Belopolski I, Shumiya N, Multer D, Litskevich M, Cochran TA, Lin H, Wang Z, Neupert T, Jia S, Lei H, Hasan MZ (2019) Negative flat band magnetism in a spin–orbit-coupled correlated kagome magnet. Nat Phys 15:443–448
Kang M, Ye L, Fang S, You JS, Levitan A, Han M, Facio JI, Jozwiak C, Bostwick A, Rotenberg E, Chan MK, McDonald RD, Graf D, Kaznatcheev K, Vescovo E, Bell DC, von Kaxiras E, den Brink J, Richter M, Ghimire MP, Checkelsky JG, Comin R (2020) Dirac fermions and flat bands in the ideal kagome metal FeSn. Nat Mater 19:163–169
Liu Z, Li M, Wang Q, Wang G, Wen C, Jiang K, Lu X, Yan S, Huang Y, Shen D, Yin JX, Wang Z, Yin Z, Lei H, Wang S (2020) Orbital-selective Dirac fermions and extremely flat bands in frustrated kagome-lattice metal CoSn. Nat Commun 11:4002
Yin JX, Shumiya N, Mardanya S, Wang Q, Zhang SS, Tien HJ, Multer D, Jiang Y, Cheng G, Yao N, Wu S, Wu D, Deng L, Ye Z, He R, Chang G, Liu Z, Jiang K, Wang Z, Neupert T, Agarwal A, Chang TR, Chu CW, Lei H, Hasan MZ (2020) Fermion–boson many-body interplay in a frustrated kagome paramagnet. Nat Commun 11:4003
Kang M, Fang S, Ye L, Po HC, Denlinger J, Jozwiak C, Bostwick A, Rotenberg E, Kaxiras E, Checkelsky JG, Comin R (2020) Topological flat bands in frustrated kagome lattice CoSn. Nat Commun 11:4004
Meier WR, Du MH, Okamoto S, Mohanta N, May AF, McGuire MA, Bridges CA, Samolyuk GD, Sales BC (2020) Flat bands in the CoSn-type compounds. Phys Rev B 102:075148
Li M, Wang Q, Wang G, Yuan Z, Song W, Lou R, Liu Z, Huang Y, Liu Z, Lei H, Yin Z, Wang S (2021) Dirac cone, flat band and saddle point in kagome magnet YMn6Sn6. Nat Commun 12:3129
Hu Y, Teicher SML, Ortiz BR, Luo Y, Peng S, Huai L, Ma J, Plumb NC, Wilson SD, He J, Shi M (2022) Topological surface states and flat bands in the kagome superconductor CsV3Sb5. Sci Bull 67:495–500
Peng S, Han Y, Pokharel G, Shen J, Li Z, Hashimoto M, Lu D, Ortiz BR, Luo Y, Li H, Guo M, Wang B, Cui S, Sun Z, Qiao Z, Wilson SD, He J (2021) Realizing kagome band structure in two-dimensional kagome surface states of RV6Sn6 (R = Gd, Ho). Phys Rev Lett 127:266401
Ishii Y, Harima H, Okamoto Y, Yamaura JI, Hiroi Z (2013) YCr6Ge6 as a candidate compound for a kagome metal. J Phys Soc Jpn 82:023705
Ortiz BR, Gomes LC, Morey JR, Winiarski M, Bordelon M, Mangum JS, Oswald IWH, Rodriguez-Rivera JA, Neilson JR, Wilson SD, Ertekin E, McQueen TM, Toberer ES (2019) New kagome prototype materials: discovery of KV3Sb5, RbV3Sb5, and CsV3Sb5. Phys Rev Mater 3:094407
Nakatsuji S, Kiyohara N, Higo T (2015) Large anomalous Hall effect in a non-collinear antiferromagnet at room temperature. Nature 527:212–215
Nayak AK, Fischer JE, Sun Y, Yan B, Karel J, Komarek AC, Shekhar C, Kumar N, Schnelle W, Kübler J, Felser C, Parkin SSP (2016) Large anomalous Hall effect driven by a nonvanishing Berry curvature in the noncolinear antiferromagnet Mn3Ge. Sci Adv 2:e1501870
Kuroda K, Tomita T, Suzuki MT, Bareille C, Nugroho AA, Goswami P, Ochi M, Ikhlas M, Nakayama M, Akebi S, Noguchi R, Ishii R, Inami N, Ono K, Kumigashira H, Varykhalov A, Muro T, Koretsune T, Arita R, Shin S, Kondo T, Nakatsuji S (2017) Evidence for magnetic Weyl fermions in a correlated metal. Nat Mater 16:1090–1095
Liu ZQ, Chen H, Wang JM, Liu JH, Wang K, Feng ZX, Yan H, Wang XR, Jiang CB, Coey JMD, MacDonald AH (2018) Electrical switching of the topological anomalous Hall effect in a non-collinear antiferromagnet above room temperature. Nat Electron 1:172–177
Wang Q, Sun S, Zhang X, Pang F, Lei H (2016) Anomalous Hall effect in a ferromagnetic Fe3Sn2 single crystal with a geometrically frustrated Fe bilayer kagome lattice. Phys Rev B 94:075135
Ye L, Kang M, Liu J, von Cube F, Wicker CR, Suzuki T, Jozwiak C, Bostwick A, Rotenberg E, Bell DC, Fu L, Comin R, Checkelsky JG (2018) Massive Dirac fermions in a ferromagnetic kagome metal. Nature 555:638–642
Yin JX, Zhang SS, Li H, Jiang K, Chang G, Zhang B, Lian B, Xiang C, Belopolski I, Zheng H, Cochran TA, Xu SY, Bian G, Liu K, Chang TR, Lin H, Lu ZY, Wang Z, Jia S, Wang W, Hasan MZ (2018) Giant and anisotropic many-body spin–orbit tunability in a strongly correlated kagome magnet. Nature 562:91–95
Liu E, Sun Y, Kumar N, Muechler L, Sun A, Jiao L, Yang SY, Liu D, Liang A, Xu Q, Kroder J, Süß V, Borrmann H, Shekhar C, Wang Z, Xi C, Wang W, Schnelle W, Wirth S, Chen Y, Goennenwein STB, Felser C (2018) Giant anomalous Hall effect in a ferromagnetic kagome-lattice semimetal. Nat Phys 14:1125–1131
Wang Q, Xu Y, Lou R, Liu Z, Li M, Huang Y, Shen D, Weng H, Wang S, Lei H (2018) Large intrinsic anomalous Hall effect in half-metallic ferromagnet Co3Sn2S2 with magnetic Weyl fermions. Nat Commun 9:3681
Rhim JW, Kim K, Yang BJ (2020) Quantum distance and anomalous Landau levels of flat bands. Nature 584:59–63
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the Ministry of Science and Technology of China (Grants No. 2018YFA0307000, and No. 2018FYA0305800) and the Innovation Program for Quantum Science and Technology (No. 2021ZD0302802), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grants No. U2032128, and No. 11874047), the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (Grant No. 2042021kf0210).
Funding
Open Access funding provided by Shanghai Jiao Tong University.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
NX and YX supervise the project. TY, QW, and NX did the ARPES experiments with the help of NP, MR, JY, ZC, YH and MS. JS, ZD, YW, JT, GW, GW, ZS and YX grow the materials and performed transport measurements. ZW and RY did calculations. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Corresponding authors
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
T.Y. Yang and Q. Wan contributed equally to this work.
Supplementary Information
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Yang, T.Y., Wan, Q., Song, J.P. et al. Fermi-level flat band in a kagome magnet. Quantum Front 1, 14 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s44214-022-00017-7
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s44214-022-00017-7