Abstract
An explosion-generated-plasma is explored for low and high frequency instabilities by taking into account the drift of all the plasma species together with the dust particles which are charged. The possibility of wave triplet is also discussed based on the solution of dispersion equation and synchronism conditions. High frequency instability (HFI) and low frequency instability (LFI) are found to occur in this system. LFI grows faster with the higher concentration of dust particles, whereas its growth rate goes down if the mass of the dust is higher. The ion and electron temperatures affect its growth in opposite manner and the electron temperature causes this instability to grow. In addition to the instabilities, a simple wave is also observed to propagate, whose velocity is larger for larger wave number, smaller mass of the dust and higher ion temperature.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction
An electromagnetic interference on electronic systems due to high-power microwaves (HPMs) introduces noise or signals into the electronic systems. This could cause a temporary system malfunction and component degradation; even a permanent physical damage is also possible at high levels of irradiation. The HPM sources have been under investigation for several years as potential weapons for a variety of combat, sabotage, and terrorist applications [1–3]. The pulse released by an electromagnetic weapon lasts for an extremely short time, i.e. around 100 picoseconds. Hence, the absorption of this blast of high energy by anything capable of conducting electricity (including nerves and neurons) overwhelms the recipient. As a result, the computers used in data processing systems, communications systems, satellites, industrial controls, displays, military systems, radar, HF, VHF, UHF, and television equipment are all susceptible to the electromagnetic pulses (EMPs).
If we think about the explosion-generated-plasma (EGP), we find that the beams of ions and electrons are a source of free energy which can be transferred to waves. So instabilities can evolve in the nonlinear systems. If conditions are favourable, the resonant interaction of the waves in plasma can lead to nonlinear instabilities, in which all the waves grow faster than exponentially and attain enormously large amplitudes in a finite time or after a finite distance, depending on whether temporal or spatial growth is considered. These instabilities are referred to as explosive instabilities. Such instabilities could be of considerable practical interest, as these seem to offer a mechanism for rapid dissipation of coherent wave energy into thermal motion, and hence may be effective for plasma heating [4–7]. A consistent theory of explosive instability shows that in the three-wave approximation amplitudes of all the waves tend to infinity over a finite time called explosion time. The simplest wave coupling process that can exhibit explosive character is the coupling of three-waves with fixed phases [5, 8, 9]. For a wave triplet, all the three waves grow simultaneously. This phenomenon was first described by Cairns [10] using the kinetic equation which takes into account the interactions of waves with random phases and different signs of energy. Fainshtein and Chernova [11] have investigated the high power electromagnetic radiation from the development of explosive and high-frequency instabilities in a system consisting of a relativistic ion beam and a nonisothermal plasma. Based on an asymptotic method they derived and analyzed truncated equations for the complex mode amplitudes, and showed that the explosion is stabilized by a nonlinear frequency shift, while the high-frequency instability is analogous to the decay of low-frequency modes.
This can be seen that in most of the investigations the researchers have used the Boltzmann distribution of the electrons keeping in mind their mass to be negligible. Moreover, the electrons are employed to make background only. However, we consider the finite mass of the electrons and also take into account the dust particles which are always present in most of such plasma and whose charge may fluctuate due to currents flowing into the dust [12, 13]. In view of a strong nonisothermal plasma, we consider the temperature of electrons (T e) to be much higher than that of the ions (T i), i.e. \( T_{\text{e}} {\gg} T_{\text{i}} \) [14–17]. For the sake of generality, we consider initial drift of all the plasma species and derive the dispersion equation for this system and solve it numerically for investigating the instabilities.
Basic model
The plasma is taken to compose electrons, singly charged ions and negatively charged dust grains of uniform mass and charge. Hence, the quasineutrality condition reads \( n_{{{\text{i}}0}} = n_{{{\text{e}}0}} - \alpha Z_{\text{d}} n_{{{\text{d}}0}} \), where \( n_{{{\text{i}}0}} \), \( n_{{{\text{e}}0}} \) and \( n_{{{\text{d}}0}} \) are the unperturbed number density of the ions, electrons and dust grains, respectively, and Z d is the magnitude of the charge on the dust. The parameter \( \alpha \) represents the nature of charge on the dust, and it is positive (negative) for the positively (negatively) charged dust grains.
Basic equations and dispersion relation
If \( n_{\text{i}} \)(\( n_{\text{e}} \)) is the density of ions (electrons), \( M \)(\( m \)) is the mass of ion (electron) and \( \vec{\upsilon }_{\text{i}} \)(\( \vec{u}_{\text{e}} \)) is the ion (electron) fluid velocity along with their unperturbed values as \( \upsilon_{0} \) and \( u_{0} \) in the x-direction, then one-dimensional continuity equation and momentum equation for the ion, electron and dust fluids can be written as
The system of equations can be closed with the following Poisson’s equation.
In the above equations, the subscripts x and t denote the respective differentiation. The densities are normalized by a background density \( n_{0} \), potential \( \phi \) by \( T_{\text{e}} /{\text{e}} \), time t by the inverse of frequency \( \omega_{pi} = \sqrt {{\text{e}}^{2} n_{0} /\varepsilon_{0} M} \), velocities \( \upsilon_{\text{i}}, u_{\text{i}}, \upsilon_{\text{d}} \) by the ion acoustic speed C s = \( \sqrt {T_{\text{e}} /M} \) and length x by the Debye length \( \lambda_{\text{De}} = \sqrt {\varepsilon_{0} T_{\text{e}} /{\text{e}}^{2} n_{0} } \).
The solution of the above equations is obtained for the variation of perturbed quantities as \( \psi_{1} \)~\( \exp (i\omega t - ikx) \) together with \( \psi_{1} \equiv n_{{{\text{i}}1}} ,n_{{{\text{e}}1}} ,n_{{{\text{d}}1}} ,\vec{\upsilon }_{{{\text{i}}1}} ,\vec{u}_{{{\text{e}}1}} , {\phi }_{1}, \vec{\upsilon }_{{{\text{d}}1}} \). Here \( \omega \) is the frequency of oscillations and \( k \) is the wave number. Hence, the following expressions for the perturbed densities are obtained from the basic fluid equations.
The use of these expressions in the Poisson’s Eq. (7) yields
After simplifying the above equation, we get the following dispersion equation
Here
together with
Results and discussion
The dispersion Eq. (12) carries a term \( \alpha^{2} \), it means the same results are expected for the cases of positively charged dust grains and negatively charged dust grains. We numerically solve Eq. (12) by giving typical values to various parameters in view of the plasma generated in an explosion. Hence, \( k = 0.5 \), \( \upsilon_{{{\text{d}}0}} = 0.002 \), \( n_{{{\text{i}}0}} = 1.1 \), \( M = 23.38 \times 10^{ - 27} \) kg, \( m_{\text{d}} = 10^{ - 20} \) kg, \( u_{0} = 0.4 \), \( \upsilon_{0} = 0.04 \), \( n_{{{\text{nd}}0}} = 0.001 \), \( Z_{\text{d}} = 100 \), \( T_{\text{i}} = 1 \) eV and \( T_{\text{e}} = 10 \) eV [18–22]. Our numerical calculations show that two types of instabilities occur in the plasma if we consider the role of dust mass, which is present in the said plasma. The growth rates of these instabilities are found to be influenced by density and mass of the dust grains. For the parameters within this range, we observe that there are two roots that satisfy the condition for unstable growth of the disturbances. However, in some cases more roots are found, but their growth is too low, showing that these roots are very small perturbations in the system. We solve Eq. (12) for the complex root of \( \omega \left( {\equiv \omega_{\text{R}} - i\gamma } \right) \) and plot the normalized growth rate \( \gamma \) in Figs. 1, 2, 3, 4. Since the normalization is done with respect to ion plasma frequency, the growth rate \( \gamma < 1 \) is called to correspond to lower growth rate instability (LFI) whereas the growth rate \( \gamma > 1 \) to higher growth rate instability (HFI).
Variation of growth rates with normalized wave number, when \( \upsilon_{{{\text{d}}0}} = 0.002 \), \( n_{{{\text{i}}0}} = 1.1 \), \( M = 23.38 \times 10^{ - 27} \) kg, \( m_{\text{d}} = 10^{ - 20} \) kg, \( u_{0} = 0.4 \), \( \upsilon_{0} = 0.04 \), and \( n_{{{\text{nd}}0}} = 0.001 \), \( Z_{\text{d}} = 100 \), \( T_{\text{i}} = 1 \) eV and \( T_{\text{e}} = 10 \) eV
Variation of propagating and real frequencies with normalized wave number (dashed line) when the other parameters are the same as in Fig. 1. The solid line (dotted line) corresponds to \( \omega_{{{\text{R}}1}} \)(\( \omega_{{{\text{R}}2}} \))
Variation of growth rate \( \gamma_{1} \) with dust density, when \( k = 0.5 \) and the other parameters are the same as in Fig. 1
Variation of growth rate \( \gamma_{1} \) and propagating frequency with dust mass, when \( k = 0.5 \) and the other parameters are the same as in Fig. 1
Figure 1 shows the variation of growth rates of the instabilities with wave number. Here \( \gamma_{2} \) corresponds to the higher growth rate instability (called HFI) and \( \gamma_{1} \) corresponds to the lower growth rate instability (LFI). Both the growth rates \( \gamma_{1} \) (solid line) and \( \gamma_{2} \) (dashed line) behave similarly and these go higher for the longer values of \( k \).
Figure 2 shows that the higher rate instability is a constant velocity wave. However, the lower growth rate instability (the graph marked with \( \omega_{{{\text{R}}2}} \)) is found to show wave number dependence behaviour. This becomes a constant frequency wave at the larger value of wave number. In addition to the two types of instabilities, this Figure shows that there exists a propagating mode also, whose velocity remains a constant.
Lower growth rate instability (LFI) is found to be influenced by the presence of dust grains. For example, Fig. 3 show that the growth rate \( \gamma_{1} \) is increased when the dust grains in larger number are present. This is due to the negative charge on the dust, which provides larger restoring force to the oscillations of the species because of which the growth is enhanced. However, the mass of dust particles shows opposite effect on the growth rate \( \gamma_{1} \), as expected. Similar effect of dust particles mass is observed on the frequency and hence, on the speed of propagating mode (please see the graph marked with \( \omega_{\text{PR}} \) in Fig. 4).
The effect of ion and electron temperatures on the growth rate \( \gamma_{1} \) is shown in Figs. 5 and 6, respectively. The ion temperature is found to reduce the growth of lower growth rate instability (LFI), whereas the electron temperature enhances the growth rate \( \gamma_{1} \). However, the growth tries to saturate at larger value of electron temperature. Similar effect of electron temperature on the growth rate of dissipative instability has been observed by Keidar and Beilis [23]. The higher growth rate for the case of higher electron temperature can be explained based on the probability of the collisions. On the other hand, the propagating mode (marked with \( \omega_{\text{PR}} \)) behaves oppositely with the ion and electron temperatures. The frequency \( \omega_{\text{PR}} \) and hence, the speed of this wave is found to reduce with the electron temperature and to enhance with the ion temperature (Fig. 6).
Dependence of growth rate \( \gamma_{1} \) on ion temperature, when \( k = 0.5 \) and the other parameters are the same as in Fig. 1
Weak dependence of growth rate \( \gamma_{1} \) and frequency of propagating mode on electron temperature, when \( k = 0.5 \) and the other parameters are the same as in Fig. 1
Wave triplet analysis
Now we discuss the possibility of wave triplet in EGP having dust grains. For this, we reproduce Eq. (12) in the following form
This equation shall yield three waves (triplet) if the coefficients b3 and b4 together with the term in curly bracket vanishes. It means
By solving these equations, we can get the following expression for the drift velocity of the dust grains.
This expression shows the dependence of the drift velocity on the densities, masses, temperatures and initial velocities of ions and electrons in addition to the mass of dust grains and wave number k.
Along with the use of this expression, Eq. (13) yields \( \frac{{mm_{\text{d}} }}{{M^{2} }}\omega^{3} - a_{14} \omega^{2} + \omega b_{1} + b_{2} = 0 \), which can be reformulated as
Here
Every cubic equation with real coefficients has at least one solution \( \omega \) among the real numbers. This is a consequence of the intermediate value theorem. We can distinguish several possible cases using the discriminant
Since we are interested in propagating waves, three distinct real roots of Eq. (14), \( \Delta \) should be positive.
Further, we assume these roots as \( \alpha \), \( \beta \) and \( \gamma \). Hence
The roots of the above equation would satisfy
For the occurrence of triplets, the roots \( \alpha \), \( \beta \) and \( \gamma \) should additionally meet the following condition
Finally, we obtain
\( \beta = \omega_{2} \equiv - \frac{{a^{2} + \sqrt {a^{4} - 32da} }}{4a} \). The following condition is also required to be satisfied
The coefficients a, b and d show their dependence on the wave number k through the drift velocity \( \upsilon_{{{\text{d}}0}} \) and other coefficients such as \( a_{0} \), \( b_{1} \) and \( b_{2} \). Hence, it would be possible to achieve conditions for synchronism, i.e. \( k_{3} = k_{1} + k_{2} \) and \( \omega_{1} = \omega_{2} + \omega_{3} \) (which we have written as \( \gamma = \alpha + \beta \)) in the present explosion-generated-plasma. It means this plasma would support the excitation of wave triplet. This is also supported by Fig. 7, which is plotted based on the dispersion Eq. (12) and shows that a wave with negative energy is possible and the conditions for synchronism can be fulfilled [4, 15, 16, 23].
Dispersion curves corresponding to Eq. (12)
Conclusions
In an EGP, dispersion relation was derived and solved numerically to investigate the evolved instabilities under the effect of initial drifts of ions, electrons and charged dust particles. Two types of instabilities, naming LFI and HFI, were found in the said plasma in addition to a constant velocity propagating mode. The phase velocity of the mode and the growth rate of the LFI were observed to be reduced for higher mass of the dust particles. Only the LFI showed the dependence on the ion and electron temperatures. These results are based on the fixed charge on the dust grains. However, we can estimate the consequences of dust charge fluctuations based on the nonlinear property of the plasma. This has been seen that the system becomes more nonlinear when the charge on the dust grains fluctuates. Since nonlinearity generally enhances the wave amplitude [12], higher amplitude instabilities are expected in the EGP if the charge on the dust grain is observed to fluctuate.
References
Giri, D.V., Tesche, F.M.: Classification of intentional electromagnetic environments. IEEE Trans. Electromagn. Compat. 46, 323 (2004)
Efanov, V.: Gigawatt all solid state nano- and pico-second pulse generators for radar applications. In: Proceedings of 14th IEEE International Pulsed Power Conf., Dallas, TX (2003)
Staines, G.: Compact sources for tactical RF weapon applications (Diehl). In: Proceedings AMEREM, Annapolis, MD (2002)
Aamodt, R.E., Sloan, M.L.: Nonlinear interactions of positive and negative energy waves. Phys. Fluids 11, 2218 (1968)
Wilhelmson, H.: On the explosive instabilities of waves in plasmas with special regard to dissipation and phase effects. Phys. Scr. 7, 209 (1973)
Malik, H.K., Singh, S.: Resistive instability in a Hall plasma discharge under ionization effect. Phys. Plasmas 20, 052115 (2013)
Singh, S., Malik, H.K.: Nishida.Y.: High frequency electromagnetic resistive instability in a Hall thruster under the effect of ionization. Phys. Plasmas 20, 102109 (2013)
Wilhelmson, H., Weiland, J.: Coherent non-linear interaction of waves in plasmas. Pergamon Press, Oxford and New York (1977)
Wilhelmson, H., Stenflo, I., Engelmann, F.: Explosive instabilities in the well defined phase description. J. Math. Phys. 11, 1738 (1970)
Cairns, R.A.: The role of negative energy waves in some instabilities of parallel flows. J. Fluid Meek 92, 1 (1979)
Fainshtein, S.M., Chernova, E.A.: Generation of high-power electromagnetic radiation from the development of explosive and high-frequency instabilities in a system consisting of a relativistic ion beam and a nonisothermal plasma. JETP 84, 442 (1996)
Tomar, R., Malik, H.K., Dahiya, R.P.: Reflection of ion acoustic solitary waves in a dusty plasma with variable charge dust. J. Theor. Appl. Phys. 8, 126 (2014)
Malik, R., Malik, H.K.: Compressive solitons in a moving e-p plasma under the effect of dust grains and an external magnetic field. J. Theor. Appl. Phys. 7, 65 (2013)
Landau, L.D., Lifshits, E.M.: Fluid Mechanics. Addison-Wesley, New York (1959)
Coppi, B., Rosenbluth, M.N., Sudan, R.N.: Nonlinear interactions of positive and negative energy modes in rarefied plasmas(I). Ann. Phys. 55, 207 (1969)
Moiseev, S.S., Oraevsky, V.N., Pungin, V.G.: Nonlinear instabilities in plasmas and hydrodynamics. Taylor & Francis (1999)
Fainshtein, S.M.: On the possibility of generation of high-power low-frequency radiation as a result of evolution of explosive instability in the flow–nonisothermal plasma system. Radiophys. Quantum Electron J. 54, 193 (2011)
Luo, Q.-Z., D’Angelo, N., Merlino, R.L.: Experimental study of shock formation in a dusty plasma. Phys. Plasmas 6, 3455 (1999)
Merlino, R.L., Barkan, A., Thompson, C., D’Angelo, N.: Laboratory studies of waves and instabilities in dusty plasmas. Phys. Plasmas 5, 1607 (1998)
Shukla, P.K., Mamun, A.A.: Dust-acoustic shocks in a strongly coupled dusty plasma. IEEE Trans. Plasma Sci. 29, 221 (2001)
Nejoh, Y.N.: Double layers, spiky solitary waves, and explosive modes of relativistic ion acoustic waves propagating in a plasma. Phys. Fluids B 4, 2830 (1992)
Esipchuk, Y.V., Tilinin, G.N.: Drift instability in a Hall-current plasma accelerator. Sov. Phys. Tech. Phys. 21, 417 (1976)
Keidar, M., Beilis, I.I.: Electron transport phenomena in plasma devices with E × B Drift. IEEE Trans. Plasma Sci. 34, 804 (2006)
Acknowledgement
The author HKM would like to thank CSIR, Government of India, for the financial support.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License which permits any use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and the source are credited.
About this article
Cite this article
Malik, O.P., Singh, S., Malik, H.K. et al. Low and high frequency instabilities in an explosion-generated-plasma and possibility of wave triplet. J Theor Appl Phys 9, 75–80 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40094-014-0162-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40094-014-0162-4