Abstract
Ethical consumption is on the rise, however little is known about the degree and the implications of the sometime conflicting sets of values held by the broad category of consumers who report consuming ethically. This paper explores convergence and divergence of ethical consumption values through a study of organic, fair trade, and local food consumers in Colorado. Using survey and focus group results, we first examine demographic and attitudinal correlates of ethical consumption. We then report evidence that while many organic, fair trade, and local food consumers converge around similar values, some Colorado consumers support only local food, while opposing the consumption of organic and fair trade products. Next, we investigate how ethical consumers who converge and diverge frame their commitment to consuming ethically. The discussion and conclusion suggest that community development planners of projects that focus on ethical consumption will need to successfully traverse issues stemming from convergence and divergence to enjoy long-term sustained success.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
A reviewer pointed out that reflexive consumption is similar to Kneafsey et al.’s (2008: 42) conceptualization of “ethics of care,” where many consumers report taking concern for others into account when making purchasing decisions, however many of them do not report being ethical or political consumers.
We recognize that there are other additional themes/rationales for purchasing organic, fair trade and local food, however we chose to focus on environmental, social, political, and location because they seem to be the most common in the literature.
Author 2 has been an active member of the planning process since 2008. Author 1 participated for a period in 2009. The study described in this article was initiated prior to our involvement in the Community Marketplace project, and remained independent of the planning discussions throughout.
The sample was purchased from Survey Sampling International. We purchased a sample of 1,000 Colorado residents, 18 years old and over from a sampling frame of all Colorado residents 18 years old and over. However, after the initial mailing, we discovered that 97 addresses where unusable (undeliverable or the respondent had changed residences), resulting in a usable sample of 903 respondents. We mailed a copy of the survey and a cover letter explaining the survey, after a week and a half, we mailed a reminder postcard, then after another week, we mailed a second copy of the survey and cover letter.
Some scholars advocate that focus groups have between 6 and 12 respondents (Morgan 1997; Stewart et al. 2007) in order to obtain the best results, however Peek and Fothergill (2009: 37) note that smaller groups, between 3 and 5 participants, often run smoother than larger groups, and can work better for reasons such as time constraints and covering all the desired material. We chose to follow this model and keep our focus groups under 10 people. We had groups of 3, 5, 7 and 8 participants.
All statistical analysis was performed with Stata 11.2.
We also created the scale by standardizing both variables through Z-score transformations and adding the Z-scores. The results were very similar so we use the additive scale for simplicity.
We place the value of “6” in the low category because when the correlations are done with the “6” category alone, the results are closer to the low category.
We use the terms “attitude/attitudinal” to refer to all of the socio-political scale variables, even if the question asks about a behavior, such as frequency of recycling. We recognize that the well documented attitude-behavior gap in consumption studies (Vermeir and Verbeke 2006) positively biases our results. The majority of the socio-political statements refer to attitudes, however even when they ask about a behavior, we have not truly measured whether they have engaged in that behavior, we have only asked them about it, so we choose to refer to them as attitudes.
The focus group respondents had a mean income of $51,000, were approximately two-thirds female, had an age range of 20-58, and the majority indicated that they had attended at least some college.
We realize that the labels “Global Localists” and “Food Patriots” apply most directly to our specific case of organic, fair trade and local food. But we believe that similar dichotomies that exhibit divergence also exist and therefore the convergence/divergence debate and its implications are applicable in other similar situations, but where the conflicting ethical values and products may be different.
References
Allen, P. (2004). Together at the table: Sustainability and sustenance in the American agrifood system. University Park, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press.
Alter-Eco (2008) Alter-Eco fair trade study: A survey of existing and potential fair trade customers. Alter-Eco America, October 2008.
Arvola, A., Vasallo, M., Dean, M., Lampila, P., Saba, A., Lähteenmäki, L., et al. (2008). Predicting intentions to purchase organic food. The role of affective and moral attitudes in the theory of planned behaviour. Appetite, 50, 443–454.
Baker, L. E. (2004). Tending cultural landscapes and food citizenship in Toronto’s community gardens. Geographical Review, 94, 305–325.
Baker, S., Thosmpson, K. E., Engelken, J., & Huntley, K. (2004). Mapping the values driving organic food choice. Germany vs. the UK. European Journal of Marketing, 38, 995–1012.
Bellows, A. C., Alcaraz, V. G., & Hallman, W. K. (2010). Gender and food, a study of attitudes in the USA towards organic, local U.S. grown, and GM-free foods. Appetite, 55, 540–550.
Benford, R. D. (1997). An insider’s critique of the social movement framing perspective. Sociological Inquiry, 67, 409–430.
Berry, H., & McEachern, M. G. (2005). Informing ethical consumers. In R. Harrison, T. Newholm, & D. Shaw (Eds.), The ethical consumer (pp. 11–24). London: Sage.
Blue, G. (2009). On the politics and possibilities of locavores: Situating food sovereignty in the turn from government to governance. Politics and Culture, 9, 68–79.
Boston Consulting Group. (2009). Appeal of green products growing despite recession. http://www.wbcsd.org/plugins/DocSearch/details.asp?type=DocDet&Objectld=MzMxMDM. Accessed 15 November 2010.
Botonaki, A., Polymeros, K., Tsakiridou, E., & Mattas, K. (2006). The role of food quality certification on consumers’ food choices. British Food Journal, 108, 77–90.
Bougherara, D., Grolleau, G., & Mzoughi, N. (2008). Buy local, pollute less. What drives households to join a community supported farm? Ecological Economics, 68(5), 1488–1495.
Bourdieu, P. (1984). Distinction: A social critique of the judgment of taste. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Briz, T., & Ward, R. W. (2009). Consumer awareness of organic products in Spain: An application of multinomial logit models. Food Policy, 34, 295–304.
Buck, D., Getz, C., & Guthman, J. (1997). From farm to table: The organic vegetable commodity chain of northern California. Sociologia Ruralis, 37, 3–20.
Carroll, W. K., & Ratner, R. S. (1996). Master frames and counter-hegemony: political sensibilities in contemporary social movements. Canadian Review of Social Anthropology, 33, 407–435.
Cerulo, K. A. (1997). Identity construction: New issues, new directions. Annual Review of Sociology, 23, 385–409.
Cherrier, H. (2007). Ethical consumption practices: Co-production of self-expression and social recognition. Journal of Consumer Behavior, 6, 321–335.
Coff, C. (2006). The taste for ethics: An ethic of food consumption. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer.
Coombes, B., & Campbell, H. (1998). Dependent reproduction of alternative modes of agriculture: Organic farming in New Zealand. Sociologia Ruralis, 38, 127–145.
DDA (Downtown Development Authority). (2008). Fort Collins Community Marketplace Concept Report. Downtown Development Authority, Ft. Collins, CO, October 2008.
DDA (Downtown Development Authority). (2010). Fort Collins Community Marketplace Feasiblity Study. Downtown Development Authority, Ft. Collins, CO, October 25, 2010.
de Ferran, F., & Grunert, K. G. (2007). French fair trade coffee buyers’ purchasing motives: An exploratory study using means-end chains analysis. Food Quality and Preference, 18, 218–229.
De Pelsmacker, P., Driesen, L., & Rayp, G. (2005). Do consumers care about ethics? Willingness to pay for fair-trade coffee. The Journal of Consumer Affairs, 39, 363–385.
DeLind, L. B. (2011). Are local food and the local food movement taking us where we want to go? Or are we hitching our wagons to the wrong stars? Agriculture and Human Values, 28, 273–283.
Dettmann, R. L. & Dimitri, C. (2007). Organic consumers: A demographic portrayal of organic vegetable consumption within the United States. Paper presented at the EAAE International Marketing and International Trade of Quality Food Products Meeting. Bologna, Italy, March 8–10.
Dimitri, C. & Greene. C. (2002). Recent growth patterns in the U.S. organic foods market. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Economics Research Service, Market and Trade Econoimcs Division and Resource Economics Division. Agriculture Information Bulletin, 777.
Doran, C. J. (2009). The role of personal values in fair trade consumption. Journal of Business Ethics, 84, 549–563.
Doran, C. J. (2010). Fair trade consumption: In support of the out-group. Journal of Business Ethics, 95, 527–541.
Doran, C. J., & Natale, S. M. (2011). (Empatheia) and caritas: The role of religion in fair trade consumption. Journal of Business Ethics, 93, 1–15.
DuPuis, E. M. (2000). Not in my body: rBGH and the rise of organic milk. Agriculture and Human Values, 17, 285–295.
DuPuis, E. M., & Goodman, D. (2005). Should we go “home” to eat?: Toward a reflexive politics of localism. Journal of Rural Studies, 21, 359–371.
Ecolabel Index. (2011). Ecolabels. http://www.ecolabelindex.com/ecolabels/ Assessed 22 April 2011.
Elgin, D. (2009). Voluntary simplicity: Toward a way of life that is outwardly simple. New York, NY: Harper Collins Press.
FLO (Fairtrade Labelling Organizations International). (2009). Products. http://www.fairtrade.net/products.html. Accessed 15 November 2010.
French, S., & Rogers, G. (2007). Understanding the LOHAS consumer: The rise of ethical consumerism. Harleysville, PA: The LOHAS Journal, National Marketing Institute.
Fridell, M., Hudson, I., & Hudson, M. (2008). With friends like these: The corporate response to fair trade coffee. Review of Radical Political Economics, 40, 8–34.
FTF (Fair Trade Federation). (2008). Interim report of fair trade trends. http://www.fairtradefederation.org/ht/d/sp/a/GetDocumentAction/i/6944. Accessed 15 November 2010.
FTF (Fair Trade Federation). (2009). Report on trends in the North American fair trade market. Washington, D. C: Fair Trade Federation.
Gilg, A. W., & Battershill, M. (1998). Quality farm food in Europe: A possible alternative to the industrialized food market and to current agri-environment policies. Food Policy, 23, 25–40.
Grankvist, G., & Biel, A. (2001). The importance of beliefs and purchase criteria in the choice of eco-labeled food products. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 21, 405–410.
Grunert, S. C., & Juhl, H. J. (1995). Values, environmental attitudes, and buying of organic foods. Journal of Economic Psychology, 16, 39–62.
Guthman, J. (2003). Fast food/organic food: Reflexive tastes and the making of ‘yuppie chow’. Social & Cultural Geography, 4, 45–58.
Guthman, J. (2004). Agrarian dreams: The paradox of organic farming in California. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Harrison, R., Newholm, T., & Shaw, D. (2005). The ethical consumer. London: Sage.
Hartman Group. (2008). The many faces of organic 2008. Bellevue, WA: Hartman Group.
Hartman Group. (2009). Sustainability: The rise of consumer responsibility. Bellevue, WA: Hartman Group.
Hinrichs, C. C. (2000). Embeddedness and local food systems: Notes on two types of direct agricultural market. Journal of Rural Studies, 16, 295–303.
Hinrichs, C. C. (2003). The practice and politics of food system localization. Journal of Rural Studies, 19, 33–45.
Hinrichs, C. C., & Allen, P. (2008). Selective patronage and social justice: Local food consumer campaigns in historical context. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 21, 329–352.
Hodson, R. (1999). Analyzing documentary accounts. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Honkanen, P., Verplanken, B., & Olsen, S. O. (2006). Ethical values and motives driving organic food choice. Journal of Consumer Behavior, 5, 420–430.
Huang, C. L. (1996). Consumer preferences and attitudes toward organically grown produce. European Review of Agricultural Economics, 23, 331–342.
Hughner, R. S., McDonagh, P., Prothero, A., Schultz, C. J., I. I., & Stanton, J. (2007). Who are organic food consumers? A compilation and review of why people purchase organic food. Journal of Consumer Behavior, 6, 94–110.
Hunt, S. A., Benford, R. D., & Snow, D. (1994). Identity fields: Framing processes and the social construction of movement identifies. In H. Larana, H. Johnston, & J. Gusfield (Eds.), New social movements: From ideology to identity. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
Kearney, A. T. (2009). Green winners: The performance of sustainability-focused companies during the financial crisis. http://atkearney.com/shared_res/pdf/Green_Winners.pdf. Accessed 15 November 2010.
Klonsky, K. & Greene, C. (2005). Widespread adoption of organic agriculture in the U.S.: Are market-driven policies enough? Paper presented at AAEA Annual Meeting, Providence, RI, July 24–27.
Kneafsey, M., Cox, R., Holloway, L., Dowler, E., Venn, L., & Tuomainen, H. (2008). Reconnecting consumers, producers and food: Exploring alternatives. Oxford and New York: Berg.
Kortbeck-Olenen, R. (2002). The United States market for organic food and beverages. Geneva: International Trade Center.
LaTrobe, H. L., & Acott, T. G. (2000). Localising the global food system. International Journal of Sustainable Development and World Ecology, 7, 309–320.
Lea, E., & Worsley, T. (2005). Australians’ organic food beliefs, demographics and values. British Food Journal, 107(11), 855–869.
Littrell, M. A., Ma, Y. J., & Halepete, J. (2005). Generation X, baby boomers, and swing: Marketing fair trade apparel. Journal of Fashion Marketing and Management, 9, 407–419.
Lockie, S., Lyons, K., Lawrence, G., & Grice, J. (2004). Choosing organics: A path analysis of factors underlying the selection of organic food among Australian consumers. Appetite, 43, 135–146.
LOHAS. (2009). LOHAS: What is it? http://www.lohas.com/. Accessed 15 November 2010.
Long, J. S. (1997). Regression models for categorical and limited dependent variables. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Long, M. A., Berry, K. J., & Mielke, P. W., Jr. (2009). The tetrachoric correlation coefficient: A permutation alternative. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 69, 429–437.
Loureiro, M. L., & Hine, S. (2002). Discovering niche markets. A comparison of consumer willingness to pay for local (Colorado grown), organic, and GMO-free products. Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics, 34, 447–487.
Low, W., & Davenport, E. (2005a). Has the medium (roast) become the message?: The ethics of marketing fair trade in the mainstream. International Marketing Review, 22, 494–511.
Low, W., & Davenport, E. (2005b). Postcards for the edge: Maintaining the ‘alternative’ character of fair trade. Sustainable Development, 13, 143–153.
Lyson, T. A. (2004). Civic agriculture: Reconnecting farm, food and community. University Park, PA: Penn State University Press.
Micheletti, M. (2003). Political virtue and shopping: Individuals, consumerism, and collective action. New York: Macmillan.
Micheletti, M., & Stolle, D. (2008). Fashioning social justice through political consumerism, capitalism and the internet. Cultural Studies, 22, 749–769.
Morgan, D. L. (1997). Focus groups as qualitative research. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Murray, D. L., & Raynolds, L. T. (2007). Globalization and its antinomies: Negotiating a fair trade movement. In L. T. Raynolds, D. L. Murray, & J. Wilkinson (Eds.), Fair trade: The challenges of transforming globalization. London and New York: Routledge Press.
Nablan, G. (2002). Coming home to eat: The pleasures and politics of local foods. New York: Norton.
Newholm, T., & Shaw, D. (2007). Studying the ethical consumer: A review of research. Journal of Consumer Behavior, 6, 253–270.
Nicholls, A. (2002). Strategic options in fair trade retailing. International Journal of Retail and Distribution Management, 20(1), 6–17.
OTA (Organic Trade Association). (2011). Industry statistics and projected growth. http://www.ota.com/organic/mt/business.html Assessed 20 January 2012.
Oyango, B. M., Hallman, W. K., & Bellows, A. C. (2007). Purchasing organic food in US food systems: A study of attitudes and practice. British Food Journal, 109, 339–411.
Padel, S., & Foster, C. (2005). Exploring the gap between attitudes and behaviour. Understanding why consumers buy or do not buy organic food. British Food Journal, 107, 606–625.
Peek, L., & Fothergill, A. (2009). Using focus groups: Lessons from studying daycare centers, 9/11, and Hurricane Katrina. Qualitative Sociology, 9, 31–59.
Raynolds, L. T. (2000). Re-embedding global agriculture: The international organic and fair trade movements. Agriculture and Human Values, 17, 297–309.
Raynolds, L. T. (2007). Fair trade bananas: Broadening the movement and market in the United States. In L. T. Raynolds, D. L. Murray, & J. Wilkinson (Eds.), Fair trade: The challenges of transforming globalization (pp. 63–82). London and New York: Routledge Press.
Raynolds, L. T., & Long, M. A. (2007). Fair/alternative trade: Historical and empirical dimensions. In L. T. Raynolds, D. L. Murray, & J. Wilkinson (Eds.), Fair trade: The challenges of transforming globalization (pp. 15–32). London and New York: Routledge Press.
Raynolds, L. T., Murray, D. L., & Wilkinson, J. (Eds.). (2007). Fair trade: The challenges of transforming globalization. London and New York: Routledge Press.
Seyfang, G. (2006). Ecological citizenship and sustainable consumption: Examining local organic food networks. Journal of Rural Studies, 22, 383–395.
Shaw, D., & Newholm, T. (2002). Voluntary simplicity and the ethics of consumption. Psychology & Marketing, 19, 167–185.
Smithers, J., Lamarche, J., & Joseph, A. E. (2008). Unpacking the terms engagement with local food at the farmers’ market. Insights from Ontario. Journal of Rural Studies, 24, 337–350.
Snow, D. A., & Benford, R. D. (1992). Master frames and cycle of protest. In A. D. Morris & C. M. Mueller (Eds.), Frontiers in social movement theory (pp. 133–155). London: Yale University Press.
Snow, D. A., & Benford, R. D. (2000). Clarifying the relationship between framing and ideology in the study of social movements: A comment on Oliver and Johnston. Mobilization, 5, 55–60.
Starr, A., Card, A., Benepe, C., Auld, G., Lamm, D., Smith, K., et al. (2003). Sustaining local agriculture: Barriers and opportunities to direct marketing between farmers and restaurants in Colorado. Agriculture and Human Values, 20, 301–321.
Stevens-Garmon, J., Huang, C. L., & Lin, B.-H. (2007). Organic demand: A profile of consumers in the fresh produce market. Choices, 22, 109–132.
Stewart, D. W., Shamdasani, P. N., & Rook, D. W. (2007). Focus groups: Theory and practice (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Szmigin, I., & Carrigan, M. (2005). Exploring the dimensions of ethical consumption. In K. M. Ekström & H. Brembeck (Eds.), Advances in consumer research (pp. 608–613). Duluth, MN: Association for Consumer Research.
Szmigin, I., Carrigan, M., & McEachern, M. G. (2009). The conscious consumer: Taking a flexible approach to ethical behavior. International Journal of Consumer Studies, 33, 224–231.
Tallontire, A., Rentsendorj, E., & Blowfield, M. (2001). Ethical consumers and ethical trade: A review of current literature, Policy Series 12. Kent: Natural Resources Institute.
Tanner, C., & Kast, S. W. (2003). Promoting sustainable consumption: Determinants of green purchases by Swiss consumers. Psychology & Marketing, 20, 883–902.
Thilmany, D., Bond, C. A., & Bond, J. K. (2008). Going local: Exploring consumer behavior and motivations for direct food purchases. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 90, 1303–1309.
Thompson, G. D., & Kidwell, J. (1998). Explaining the choice of organic produce: Cosmetic defects, prices and consumer preferences. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 80, 277–278.
Tovey, H. (1997). Food, environmentalism and rural sociology: On the organic farming movement in Ireland. Sociologia Ruralis, 37, 21–37.
USDA (United States Department of Agriculture). (2009). 2007 census of agriculture. DC: Washington.
USDA (United States Department of Agriculture). (2010). Farmers markets and local food marketing. Washington D.C: http://www.ams.usda.gov/AMSv1.0/FARMERSMARKETS.US. Assessed February 10 2011.
Van Loo, E., Caputo, V., Nayga, R. M., Jr, Meullenet, J.-F., Crandall, P. G., & Ricke, S. C. (2010). Effect of organic poultry frequency on consumer attitudes toward organic poultry meat. Journal of Food Science, 75(7), S384–S397.
Vermeir, I., & Verbeke, W. (2006). Sustainable food consumption: exploring the consumer ‘attitude-behavior intention’ gap. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 19, 169–194.
Winter, M. (2003). Embeddedness, the new food economy and defensive localism. Journal of Rural Studies, 19, 23–32.
Zepeda, L., & Leviten-Reid, C. (2004). Consumers’ views on local food. Journal of Food Distribution Research, 35(3), 1–6.
Zepeda, L., & Li, J. (2007). Characteristics of organic food shoppers. Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics, 39, 17–28.
Acknowledgments
We would like to thank Bill Friedland, Laura Raynolds, Tom Shriver and the anonymous reviewers of earlier versions of this paper for their helpful comments.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Long, M.A., Murray, D.L. Ethical Consumption, Values Convergence/Divergence and Community Development. J Agric Environ Ethics 26, 351–375 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-012-9384-0
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-012-9384-0