Abstract
This paper begins with an introduction to the philosophy and methodology of Critical Systems Heuristics (CSH). Following this, various citicisms of CSH are reviewed. One particularly important criticism is that CSH should not be seen as a replacement for other systems approaches, but as complementary to them. It is this idea of complementarity that has led several Critical Systems thinkers to take CSH, along with a number of other systems methods, and try to show that they are most appropriately used in different contexts. CSH, it is said, is at its most useful when we are confronted with coercive situations. However, in this paper it is argued that coercion is usually characterised by closure of debate. Therefore CSH, which depends upon the possibility of communication (or arbitration) between stakeholder groups, becomes redundant when coercion is experienced. It is further argued that coercion can only be addressed adequately by widening our definition of systems practice to include campaigning and direct political action. There is still considerable scope for developing these areas in the systems domain.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ackoff, R. L. (1981).Creating the Corporate Future, John Wiley and Sons, New York.
Adorno, T. W. (1957). Soziologie und Empirische Forschung. In Zeigler, K. (ed.),Wesen und Wirklichkeit des Menschen, Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, Göttingen.
Albert, H. (1971). Theorie und Praxis: Max Weber und das Problem der Wertfreiheit und der Rationalität. In Albert, H., and Topitsch, E. (eds.),Werturteilsstreit, Wissenschaftliche Buchgesselschaft, Darmstadt.
Brown, M. (1996). A framework for assessing participation. In Flood, R. L., and Romm, N. R. A. (eds.),Critical Systems Thinking: Current Research and Practice, Plenum, New York.
Churchman, C. W. (1970). Kant—A decision theorist?Theory Decis. 1, 107–116.
Churchman, C. W. (1979).The Systems Approach and Its Enemies, Basic Books, New York.
Cohen, C., and Midgley, G. (1994).The North Humberside Diversion from Custody Project for Mentally Disordered Offenders: Research Report, Centre for Systems Studies, Hull.
Flood, R. L. (1990).Liberating Systems Theory, Plenum, New York.
Flood, R. L. (1995).Solving Problem Solving, John Wiley and Sons, Chichester.
Flood, R. L., and Jackson, M. C. (1991a).Creative Problem Solving: Total Systems Intervention, John Wiley and Sons, Chichester.
Flood, R. L. and Jackson M. C. (1991b). Critical systems heuristics: Application of an emancipatory approach for police strategy toward the carrying of offensive weapons.Syst. Pract. 4, 283–302.
Flood, R. L., and Jackson, M. C. (1991c).Critical Systems Thinking: Directed Readings, John Wiley and Sons, Chichester.
Flood, R. L., and Romm, N. R. A. (1995). Enhancing the process of choice in TSI, and improving chances of tackling coercion.Syst. Pract.,8, 377–408.
Flood, R. L., and Romm, N. R. A. (1996a).Diversity Management: Triple Loop Learning, John Wiley and Sons, Chichester.
Flood, R. L., and Romm, N. R. A. (1996b).Critical Systems Thinking: Current Research and Practice, Plenum, New York.
Flood, R. L., and Ulrich, W. (1990). Testament to conversations on critical systems theory between two systems practitioners.Syst. Pract. 3, 7–29.
Foucault, M. (1980).Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writtings, 1972–1977, Gordon, C. (ed.), Harvester Press, Brighton.
Gregory, W. J. (1992).Critical Systems Thinking and Pluralism: A New Constellation, Ph.D. thesis, City University, London.
Gregory, W. J. (1996). Dealing with diversity. In Flood, R. L., and Romm, N. R. A. (eds.),Critical Systems Thinking: Current Research and Practice, Plenum, New York.
Gregory, W. J., Romm, N. R. A., and Walsh, M. P. (1994).The Trent Quality Initiative: A Multi-Agency Evaluation of Quality Standards in the National Health Service, Centre for Systems Studies, Hull.
Habermas, J. (1972).Knowledge and Human Interests. Heinemann, London.
Habermas, J. (1974).Theory and Practice, Heinemann, London.
Habermas, J. (1976).Communication and the Evolution of Society, Heinemann, London.
Horkheimer, M. (1937). Traditionelle und Kritische Theorie.Z. Sozialforsch. 6, 245–294.
Ivanov, K. (1991). Critical systems thinking and information technology.J. Appl. Syst. Anal. 18, 39–55.
Jackson, M. C. (1982). The nature of soft systems thinking: The work of Churchman, Ackoff and Checkland.J. Appl. Syst. Anal. 9, 17–29.
Jackson, M. C. (1985). The itinerary of a critical approach: Review of Ulrich's “Critical Heuristics of Social Planning.”J. Operat. Res. Soc. 36, 878–881.
Jackson, M. C. (1987a). Present positions and future prospects in management science.Omega 15, 455–466.
Jackson, M. C. (1987b). New directions in management science. In Jackson, M. C. and Keys, P. (eds.),New Directions in Management Science, Gower, Aldershot.
Jackson, M. C. (1991).Systems Methodology for the Management Sciences, Plenum, New York.
Jahoda, A., Cattermole, M., and Markova, I. (1989). Day services for people with memtal handicaps: A purpose in life?Ment. Handicap 17, 136–139.
Kant, E. (1787),The Critique of Pure Reason, 2nd ed. (Smith, N. K., trans.), Macmillan, Basingstoke (1933).
Kant, E. (1788).Critique of Practical Reason and Other Writings in Moral Philosophy, (Beck, L., trans.), University of Chicago Press, Chicago (1949).
Lorenzen, P. (1969).Normative Logic and Ethics, Bibliographisches Institut, Mannheim.
Luhmann, N. (1989).Ecological Communication, Polity Press, Cambridge.
Midgley, G. (1992a). Pluralism and the legitimation of systems science.Syst. Pract. 5, 147–172.
Midgley, G. (1992b). Power and languages of co-operation: A critical systems perspective. InSistsemica '92: Ira Conferencia Internacional de Trabjao del Instituto Andino de Sistemas (IAS), Lima, Peru, 23–28 Aug.
Midgley, G. (1995).Mixing Methods: Developing Systemic Intervention, Research Memorandum 9, Centre for Systems Studies, University of Hull, Hull.
Midgley, G., Munlo, I., and Brown, M. (1997).Sharing Power: Integrating User, Involvement and Multi-Agency Working to Improve Housing for Older People, Policy Press, Bristol.
Mingers, J. (1980). Toward an appropriate social theory for applied, systems thinking: Critical theory and soft systems methodology.J. Appl. Syst. Anal. 7, 41–50.
Mingers, J. (1992). Recent developments in critical management science.J. Operat. Res. Soc. 43, 1–10.
Offe, C. (1972).Strukturprobleme des Kapitalistischen Staates, Suhrkamp, Frankfurt am Main.
Oliga, J. C. (1988). Methodological foundations of systems methodologies.Syst. Pract. 1, 87–112.
Oliver, M. (1992). Review of “Critical Issues in the Lives of People with Severe Disabilities” edited by Meyer, L. H., Peck, C. A. and Brown, L.Syst. Pract. 5, 475–476.
Popper, K. R. (1972).Objective Knowledge, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Romm, N. R. A. (1994).Continuin Tensions Between Soft Systems Methodology and Critical Systems Heuristics, Working Paper Number 5, Centre for Systems Studies, University of Hull, Hull.
Romm, N. R. A. (1995a). Some anomalies in Ulrich's critical inquiry and problem-solving approach. In K. Ellis, A. Gregory, B. Mears-Young and G. Ragsdell (eds.),Critical Issues in Systems Theory and Practice, Plenum, New York.
Romm, N. R. A. (1995b). Knowing as intervention: Reflections on the application of systems ideas.Syst. Pract. 8, 137–167.
Spinner, H. (1974).Pluralismus als Erkenntnismodell, Suhrkamp, Frankfurt am Main.
Ulrich, W. (1983).Critical Heuristics of Social Planning: A New Approach to Practical Philosophy, Haupt, Bern.
Ulrich, W. (1986).Critical Heuristics of Social Systems Design, Working Paper 10, Department of Management Systems and Sciences, University of Hull, Hull.
Ulrich, W. (1988a). Systems thinking, systems practice, and practical philosophy: A program of research.Syst. Pract. 1, 137–163.
Ulrich, W. (1988b). Churchman's “Process of unfolding”—Its significance for policy analysis and evaluation.Syst. Pract. 1, 415–428.
Ulrich, W. (1993). Some difficulties of ecological thinking, considered from a critical systems perspective: A plea for critical holism.Syst. Pract. 6, 583–611.
Ulrich, W. (1994). Can we secure future-responsive management through systems thinking and design?Interfaces 24, 26–37.
Ulrich, W. (1996).A Primer to Critical Systems Heuristics for Action Researchers, Centre for Systems Studies, Hull.
Wellmer, A. (1970).The Critical Theory of Society, Herder & Herder, New York.
Whittaker, A., Gardner, S., and Kershaw, J. (1991).Service Evaluation by People with Learning Difficulties, King's Fund Centre, London.
Willmott, H. (1989). OR as a problem situation: From soft systems methodology to critical science. In Jackson, M. C., Keys, P., and Cropper, S. A. (eds.),OR and the Social Sciences, Plenum, New York.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Midgley, G. Dealing with coercion: Critical Systems Heuristics and beyond. Systems Practice 10, 37–57 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02557850
Received:
Revised:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02557850