Abstract
We propose a novel approach to background-oriented schlieren (BOS) tomography (BOST) that unifies the deflection sensing and reconstruction algorithms. BOS is a 2D flow visualization technique that renders light deflections due to refraction in the fluid. Simultaneous BOS measurements from unique views can be reconstructed by tomography to estimate the fluid’s 3D refractive index field. The cameras are focused through the fluid on textured background patterns. Deflections between an undistorted reference image and distorted image are typically determined by gradient-based optical flow (OF), which is a complex inverse problem and potential source of error in BOST. This paper presents an alternative approach to BOST that unifies the OF equations and deflection model. Our new operator simultaneously calculates the image distortions seen by each camera for a discrete refractive index distribution. Unified BOST (UBOST) thus reconstructs observed image distortions instead of inferred deflections, which are influenced by user-selected OF parameters. The UBOST operator has one third as many equations as the classical BOST operator. We show that our formulation reduces the effects of model error and the computational cost of reconstruction. These advantages are demonstrated with a numerical experiment using phantoms of varied complexity. Best practice UBOST reconstructions were more accurate than classical reconstructions of the exact deflections for each phantom. Moreover, UBOST estimates converged substantially faster, resulting in a \(\ge \) 62.5% speedup with our solver.
Graphic abstract
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Axisymmetric BOST uses a single camera but implies the same set of deflections for infinite rotations of this view, so the same argument applies in that case.
References
Agrawal AK, Butuk NK, Gollahalli SR, Griffin D (1998) Three-dimensional rainbow schlieren tomography of a temperature field in gas flows. Appl Opt 37(3):479–485
Andersen AH, Kak AC (1984) Simultaneous algebraic reconstruction technique (SART): a superior implementation of the ART algorithm. Ultrason Imaging 6(1):81–94
Atcheson B, Heidrich W, Ihrke I (2009) An evaluation of optical flow algorithms for background oriented schlieren imaging. Exp Fluids 46(3):467–476
Atcheson B, Ihrke I, Heidrich W, Tevs A, Bradley D, Magnor M, Seidel HP (2008) Time-resolved 3D capture of non-stationary gas flows. ACM Trans Graph 27:132
Baker S, Scharstein D, Lewis J, Roth S, Black MJ, Szeliski R (2011) A database and evaluation methodology for optical flow. Int J Comput Vis 92(1):1–31
Bathel BF, Weisberger J, Jones SB, Klemkowsky JN, Clifford C, Thurow BS (2019) Development of tomographic background-oriented schlieren capability at NASA Langley Research Center. In: AIAA Aviation 2019 Forum, p 3288
Born M, Wolf E, Bhatia AB, Clemmow PC, Gabor D, Stokes AR, Taylor AM, Wayman PA, Wilcock WL (1999) Principles of optics: electromagnetic theory of propagation, interference and diffraction of light, 7th edn. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Brox T, Bruhn A, Papenberg N, Weickert J (2004) High accuracy optical flow estimation based on a theory for warping. In: European Conference on Computer Vision, Springer, pp 25–36
Cai S, Mémin E, Dérian P, Xu C (2018) Motion estimation under location uncertainty for turbulent fluid flows. Exp Fluids 59(1):8
Cassisa C, Simoens S, Prinet V, Shao L (2011) Subgrid scale formulation of optical flow for the study of turbulent flow. Exp Fluids 51(6):1739–1754
Chen X, Zillé P, Shao L, Corpetti T (2015) Optical flow for incompressible turbulence motion estimation. Exp Fluids 56(1):8
Clem M, Brown C, Fagan A (2013) Background oriented schlieren implementation in a jet-surface interaction test. In: 51st AIAA aerospace sciences meeting including the new horizons forum and aerospace exposition, p 38
Corpetti T, Heitz D, Arroyo G, Mémin E, Santa-Cruz A (2006) Fluid experimental flow estimation based on an optical-flow scheme. Exp Fluids 40(1):80–97
Dalziel S, Hughes GO, Sutherland BR (2000) Whole-field density measurements by ’synthetic schlieren’. Exp Fluids 28(4):322–335
Daun KJ, Grauer SJ, Hadwin PJ (2016) Chemical species tomography of turbulent flows: discrete ill-posed and rank deficient problems and the use of prior information. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transf 172:58–74
Davies ER (2004) Machine vision: theory, algorithms, practicalities. Elsevier, Oxford
Decamp S, Kozack C, Sutherland B (2008) Three-dimensional schlieren measurements using inverse tomography. Exp Fluids 44(5):747–758
Freitag M, Klein M, Gregor M, Nauert A, Geyer D, Schneider C, Dreizler A, Janicka J (2005) Mixing analysis of a swirling recirculating flow using DNS and experimental data. Int J Heat Fluid Flow 27(4):636–643
Goldhahn E, Seume J (2007) The background oriented schlieren technique: sensitivity, accuracy, resolution and application to a three-dimensional density field. Exp Fluids 43(2–3):241–249
Grauer SJ, Hadwin PJ, Daun KJ (2017) Improving chemical species tomography of turbulent flows using covariance estimation. Appl Opt 56(13):3900–3912
Grauer SJ, Unterberger A, Rittler A, Daun KJ, Kempf AM, Mohri K (2018) Instantaneous 3D flame imaging by background-oriented schlieren tomography. Combust Flame 196:284–299
Hashimoto Y, Fujii K, Kameda M (2017) Modified application of algebraic reconstruction technique to near-field background-oriented schlieren images for three-dimensional flows. Trans Jpn Soc Aeronaut Sp Sci 60(2):85–92
Hayasaka K, Tagawa Y, Liu T, Kameda M (2016) Optical-flow-based background-oriented schlieren technique for measuring a laser-induced underwater shock wave. Exp Fluids 57(12):179
Horn BK, Schunck BG (1981) Determining optical flow. Artif Intell 17(1–3):185–203
Iffa ED, Aziz ARA, Malik AS (2010) Concentration measurement of injected gaseous fuel using quantitative schlieren and optical tomography. J Eur Opt Soc Rapid Publ 5
Ihrke I, Ziegler G, Tevs A, Theobalt C, Magnor M, Seidel HP (2007) Eikonal rendering: Efficient light transport in refractive objects. ACM Trans Gr 26(3):59
Ilg E, Mayer N, Saikia T, Keuper M, Dosovitskiy A, Brox T (2017) Flownet 2.0: Evolution of optical flow estimation with deep networks. In: Proceedings of the IEEE conference on computer vision and pattern recognition, pp 2462–2470
Jonassen DR, Settles GS, Tronosky MD (2006) Schlieren “PIV”for turbulent flows. Opt Lasers Eng 44(3–4):190–207
Kirby R (2018) Tomographic background-oriented schlieren for three-dimensional density field reconstruction in asymmetric shock-containing jets. In: 2018 AIAA aerospace sciences meeting, p 0008
Lang HM, Oberleithner K, Paschereit CO, Sieber M (2017) Measurement of the fluctuating temperature field in a heated swirling jet with BOS tomography. Exp Fluids 58(7):88
Lanzillotta L, Léon O, Donjat D, Le Besnerais G (2019) 3D density reconstruction of a screeching supersonic jet by synchronized multi-camera background oriented schlieren. In: 8th European conference for aeronautics and space sciences
Leopold F, Ota M, Klatt D, Maeno K (2013) Reconstruction of the unsteady supersonic flow around a spike using the colored background oriented schlieren technique. J Flow Control Meas Visualization
Liu T, Merat A, Makhmalbaf M, Fajardo C, Merati P (2015) Comparison between optical flow and cross-correlation methods for extraction of velocity fields from particle images. Exp Fluids 56(8):166
Lucas BD, Kanade T (1981) An iterative image registration technique with an application to stereo vision. In: Proceedings DARPA image understanding workshop, pp 121–130
Meier G (2002) Computerized background-oriented schlieren. Exp Fluids 33(1):181–187
Meier W, Keck O, Noll B, Kunz O, Stricker W (2000) Investigations in the TECFLAM swirling diffusion flame: laser Raman measurements and CFD calculations. Appl Phys B 71(5):725–731
Mohri K, Görs S, Schöler J, Rittler A, Dreier T, Schulz C, Kempf A (2017) Instantaneous 3D imaging of highly turbulent flames using computed tomography of chemiluminescence. Appl Opt 56(26):7385–7395
Nicolas F, Donjat D, Léon O, Le Besnerais G, Champagnat F, Micheli F (2017a) 3D reconstruction of a compressible flow by synchronized multi-camera BOS. Exp Fluids 58(5):46
Nicolas F, Donjat D, Plyer A, Champagnat F, Le Besnerais G, Micheli F, Cornic P, Le Sant Y, Deluc J (2017b) Experimental study of a co-flowing jet in ONERA’s F2 research wind tunnel by 3D background oriented schlieren. Meas Sci Technol 28(8):085302
Nicolas F, Todoroff V, Plyer A, Le Besnerais G, Donjat D, Micheli F, Champagnat F, Cornic P, Le Sant Y (2016) A direct approach for instantaneous 3D density field reconstruction from background-oriented schlieren (BOS) measurements. Exp Fluids 57(1):13
Nicolas F, Donjat D, Micheli F, Le Besnerais G, Plyer A, Cornic P, Champagnat F, Michou Y (2018) Experimental study of a counter-flow jet in ONERA’s S1MA wind tunnel by 3D background oriented schlieren. In: Proceedings 18th international symposium on flow visualization
Ozawa RW, Cox TJ, Ahmed K (2018) Three-dimensional measurements of supersonic flow using tomographic background oriented schlieren. In: 2018 AIAA aerospace sciences meeting, p 1622
Papenberg N, Bruhn A, Brox T, Didas S, Weickert J (2006) Highly accurate optic flow computation with theoretically justified warping. Int J Comput Vis 67(2):141–158
Pettit M, Coriton B, Gomez A, Kempf A (2011) Large-eddy simulation and experiments on non-premixed highly turbulent opposed jet flows. Proc Combust Inst 33(1):1391–1399
Proch F, Kempf AM (2014) Numerical analysis of the Cambridge stratified flame series using artificial thickened flame LES with tabulated premixed flame chemistry. Combust Flame 161(10):2627–2646
Qin X, Xiao X, Puri IK, Aggarwal SK (2002) Effect of varying composition on temperature reconstructions obtained from refractive index measurements in flames. Combust Flame 128(1–2):121–132
Raffel M (2015) Background-oriented schlieren (BOS) techniques. Exp Fluids 56(3):60
Raffel M, Tung C, Richard H, Yu Y, Meier G (2000) Background oriented stereoscopic schlieren (BOSS) for full scale helicopter vortex characterization. In: 9th International symposium on flow visualization, pp 23–24
Rajendran LK, Zhang J, Bhattacharya S, Bane SP, Vlachos PP (2019) Uncertainty quantification in density estimation from background oriented schlieren (BOS) measurements. arXiv preprint arXiv:190906643
Ramanah D, Mee D (2006) Scramjet flow visualization using background oriented schlieren in hypersonic impulse facilities. In: 14th AIAA/AHI space planes and hypersonic systems and technologies conference, p 8004
Ramanah D, Raghunath S, Mee D, Rösgen T, Jacobs P (2007) Background oriented schlieren for flow visualisation in hypersonic impulse facilities. Shock Waves 17(1–2):65–70
Ruhnau P, Kohlberger T, Schnörr C, Nobach H (2005) Variational optical flow estimation for particle image velocimetry. Exp Fluids 38(1):21–32
Röder M, Dreier T, Schulz C (2013) Simultaneous measurement of localized heat-release with OH/CH\(_2\)O-LIF imaging and spatially integrated OH* chemiluminescence in turbulent swirl flames. Proc Combust Inst 34(2):3549–3556
Schmidt B, Sutton J (2019) High-resolution velocimetry from tracer particle fields using a wavelet-based optical flow method. Exp Fluids 60(3):37
Schneider C, Dreizler A, Janicka J (2005) Fluid dynamical analysis of atmospheric reacting and isothermal swirling flows. Flow Turbul Combust 74(1):103–127
Settles GS (2001) Schlieren and shadowgraph techniques: Visualizing phenomena in transparent media. Springer, Berlin
Settles GS, Hargather MJ (2017) A review of recent developments in schlieren and shadowgraph techniques. Meas Sci Technol 28(4):042001
Singh B, Rajendran LK, Bane SP, Vlachos P (2018) Characterization of fluid motion induced by nanosecond spark plasmas: Using particle image velocimetry and background oriented schlieren. In: 2018 AIAA aerospace sciences meeting, p 0680
Twynstra MG, Daun KJ, Waslander SL (2014) Line-of-sight-attenuation chemical species tomography through the level set method. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transf 143:25–34
Venkatakrishnan L, Meier G (2004) Density measurements using the background oriented schlieren technique. Exp Fluids 37(2):237–247
Venkatakrishnan L, Suriyanarayanan P (2009) Density field of supersonic separated flow past an afterbody nozzle using tomographic reconstruction of BOS data. Exp Fluids 47(3):463–473
Westerweel J (1997) Fundamentals of digital particle image velocimetry. Meas Sci Technol 8(12):1379–1392
Winter KO, Hargather MJ (2019) Three-dimensional shock wave reconstruction using multiple high-speed digital cameras and background-oriented schlieren imaging. Exp Fluids 60(6):93
Zille P, Corpetti T, Shao L, Chen X (2014) Observation model based on scale interactions for optical flow estimation. IEEE Trans Image Process 23(8):3281–3293
Acknowledgements
The authors thank Dr. Andreas Rittler and Prof. Khadijeh Mohri for their assistance with the swirl flame phantom. The authors also gratefully acknowledge financial support from the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Grauer, S.J., Steinberg, A.M. Fast and robust volumetric refractive index measurement by unified background-oriented schlieren tomography. Exp Fluids 61, 80 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00348-020-2912-1
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00348-020-2912-1