Abstract
Despite a caveat at the end of A Framework for Understanding Poverty (1996/2005), Ruby Payne’s deficit model has led researchers to criticize her effect on White pre-service teaching students (Smiley and Helfenbein in Multicult Perspect 13(1):5–15, 2011; Gorski in Educ Leadersh 65:32–36, 2008a, Equity Excell Educ 41(1):130–148, b). However, according to the cover, there are over one million copies of Payne’s Framework in circulation and the text remains pervasive in both K-12 school districts and schools of education across the country. As educators will likely encounter the ideas in the Framework, if not the text itself, in their teacher education program or shortly thereafter, this paper suggests that those who teach the teachers explicitly engage in a critical dialogue with the Framework in the hopes of leading educators to deeper understandings of their own positionality in teaching the Other. The authors propose a cultural studies approach that seeks to contextualize both the discursive strategies of the Framework but also to disrupt the “perceived wisdom” of the majoritarian narratives in Payne’s book as illustrated by the "push and pull" experienced by this teacher. By using data and counter-storytelling, teacher educators can lead teacher candidates to observe the struggles of teachers in the field and infuse a more ethical foundation for their interactions with the Other (Solórzano and Yosso in Qual Inq 8(1):23–44, 2002).
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Baldwin, S. C., Buchanan, A. M., & Rudisill, M. E. (2007). What teacher candidates learned about diversity, social justice, and themselves from service-learning experiences. Journal of Teacher Education, 58(4), 315–327.
Creswell, J. W. (2007). Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five traditions. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
Fordham, S., & Ogbu, J. U. (1986). Black students’ school success: Coping with the “‘burden of ‘acting white”‘. The Urban Review, 18(3), 176–206.
Gay, G. (2010). Culturally responsive teaching: Theory, research, and practice. New York, NY: Teachers College.
Gorski, P. (2006). The classist underpinnings of Ruby Payne’s framework. TCRecord, 1–5. Retrieved from www.TCRecord.org.
Gorski, P. (2008a). The myth of the “culture of poverty”. Educational Leadership, 65, 32–36.
Gorski, P. C. (2008b). Peddling poverty for profit: Elements of oppression in Ruby Payne’s framework. Equity and Excellence in Education, 41(1), 130–148.
Grossberg, L. (1996). History, politics and postmodernism: Stuart Hall and cultural studies. In S. Hall, D. Morley, & K. Chen (Eds.), Stuart Hall: Critical dialogues in cultural studies (pp. 151–173). London: Routledge.
Grossberg, L., Nelson, C., & Treichler, P. A. (1992). Cultural studies: An introduction. In L. Grossberg, C. Nelson, & P. A. Treichler (Eds.), Cultural studies (pp. 1–8). New York: Routledge.
Grumet, M. R. (1988). Bitter milk: Women and teaching. Amherst, MA: University of Massachusetts Press.
Harvey, D. L., & Reed, M. H. (1996). The culture of poverty: An ideological analysis. Sociological Perspectives, 39(4), 465–495.
Helfenbein, R. J. (2003). Troubling multiculturalism: The New Work order, anti anti-essentialism, and a cultural studies approach to education. Multicultural Perspectives, 5(4), 10–16.
Hooks, B. (2013). Writing beyond race: Living theory and practice. New York, NY: Routledge.
Ingersoll, R., & May, H. (2011, September). Recruitment, retention and the minority teacher shortage. (Rep. No. CPRE Research Report # RR‐69). Retrieved http://www.cpre.org/what-national-data-tell-us-about-minority-teacher-turnover (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED526355).
Jupp, J. C., & Slattery, G. P, Jr. (2012). Becoming teachers of inner-city students: Identification creativity and curriculum wisdom of committed white male teachers. Urban Education, 47(1), 280–311.
Keller, B. (2006). Payne’s pursuit: A former teacher with a message on educating children from poor backgrounds is influencing school leaders anxious to close the achievement gap. Education Week. Retrieved May 3, 2006 from www.edweek.org.
Kleinfeld, J. (1975). Effective teachers of Eskimo and Indian students. The School Review, 83(2), 301. doi:10.1086/443191.
Kohl, H. R. (1991). I won’t learn from you: The role of assent in learning. Minneapolis, MN: Milkweed Editions.
Ladson-Billings, G. (1994). The dreamkeepers: Successful teachers of African American children. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Lester, J., & Barbour, K. (2005). Let’s talk about race. New York, NY: HarperCollins.
Ng, J. C., & Rury, J. L. (2006). Problematizing Payne and understanding poverty: An Analysis with Data from the 2000 Census. Journal of Educational Controversy. Retrieved May 1, 2013 from http://www.wce.wwu.edu/Resources/CEP/eJournal/v004n001/a001.shtml.
Osei-Kofi, N. (2005). Pathologizing the poor: A framework for understanding Ruby Payne’s work. Equity and Excellence in Education, 38, 367–375.
Patton, M. Q. (2002). Qualitative research and evaluation methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
Payne, R. K. (1996/2005). A framework for understanding poverty. Highlands, TX: Aha! Process.
Rogalsky, J. (2009). “Mythbusters”: Dispelling the culture of poverty myth in the urban classroom. Journal of Geography, 108(4–5), 198–209.
Samuelson, R. J. (1997). The culture of poverty [Editorial]. The Washington Post, p. A21. Retrieved September 20, 2012 from http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/politics/special/welfare/stories/op043097.htm.
Sleeter, C. E. (2001). Preparing teachers for culturally diverse schools: Research and the overwhelming presence of whiteness. Journal of Teacher Education, 52(2), 94–106.
Smiley, A. D., & Helfenbein, R. J. (2011). Becoming teachers: The Payne effect. Multicultural Perspectives, 13(1), 5–15. doi:10.1080/15210960.2011.548177.
Solorzano, D. (1997). Images and words that wound: Critical race theory, racial stereotyping, and teacher education. Teacher Education Quarterly, 24(3), 5–19.
Solórzano, D. G., & Yosso, T. J. (2002). Critical race methodology: Counter-storytelling as an analytical framework for education research. Qualitative Inquiry, 8(1), 23–44. doi:10.1177/107780040200800103.
Stake, R. E. (1995). The art of case study research. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
Tatum, B. D. (1997). “Why are all the Black kids sitting together in the cafeteria?” and other conversations about race. New York, NY: BasicBooks.
Taubman, P. M. (2009). Teaching by numbers: Deconstructing the discourse of standards and accountability in education. New York, NY: Routledge.
Valentine, C. A. (1971). Deficit, difference, and bicultural models of Afro-American behavior. Harvard Educational Review, 41(2), 137–157.
Ware, F. (2006). Warm demander pedagogy: Culturally responsive teaching that supports a culture of achievement for African American students. Urban Education, 41(4), 427–456.
Warren, J. T., & Hytten, K. (2004). The faces of whiteness: Pitfalls and the critical democrat. Communication Education, 53(4), 321–339.
Wise, T. J. (2008). White like me: Reflections on race from a privileged son. Brooklyn, NY: Soft Skull Press.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Boucher, M.L., Helfenbein, R.J. The Push and the Pull: Deficit Models, Ruby Payne, and Becoming a “Warm Demander”. Urban Rev 47, 742–758 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11256-015-0332-y
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11256-015-0332-y