Abstract
In this paper we present an analysis of chemistry texts (mainly textbooks) published during the first half of the 20th century. We show the evolution of the explanations therein in terms of atoms and of atomic structure, when scientists were interpreting phenomena as evidence of the discontinuous, corpuscular structure of matter. In this process of evidence construction, new contributions from physicists and physical chemists that were incorporated to chemical research acquired ‘chemical’ meaning, since they were related to research questions that genuinely came from chemistry. Conversely, the core ideas of 19th-century chemical atomism, among which we must highlight valence and Mendeleev’s periodic system, provided ‘clues’ for imagining an atom in terms of the elements adjusted to their chemical behaviour, which changed periodically as a function of atomic mass. With this, chemistry ceased to be a descriptive science and began to be a ‘law-based’, theoretical science. Little by little, chemistry teaching became the teaching of the internal structure of atoms, which were arranged in the Periodic Table according to criteria and ‘construction rules’ related to quantum mechanics. We pose the question: ‘how can we now teach general chemistry in a way that does not disregard current knowledge about the structure of the atom yet, at the same time, gives priority to chemical criteria, thus making such structure useful to interpret chemical change?’.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
We have also analysed papers published in the Journal of Chemical Education from 1923 (the year in which it was established) until 1950 (cf., Linares and Izquierdo-Aymerich 2004).
In Eric Scerri’s recent book (2007), all of the stages of such a process are very well documented.
References
Adúriz-Bravo A, Izquierdo-Aymerich M (2005) Utilising the “3P-Model” to characterise the discipline of didactics of science. Sci Educ 14(1):29–41. doi:10.1007/s11191-004-0068-7
Bensaude-Vincent B (1979) Comment Definir l’Élément Chimique?: Point de Vue du XIX Siècle. Cah Fontenay, 19–33.
Bensaude-Vicent B (1994) Le Langage Chimique à la Recherche de l’Élément Chimique. Actual Chim (July-August):51–55
Echeverría J (1995) Filosofía de la Ciencia. Akal, Madrid
Fernández-Rañada A (2004) Ciencia Incertidumbre y Conciencia. Heisenberg, Nívola, Madrid
Furió C, Guisasola G, Azcona R (2002) Revisión de Investigaciones sobre la Enseñanza de los Conceptos Cantidad de Substancia y Mol. Ensenanza Cienc 20(2):229–242
Hiebert EN (1959) The experimental basis of Kekulé’s valence theory. J Chem Educ 36(7):320–327
Izquierdo-Aymerich M (2006) La Enseñanza de la Química Frente a los Retos del Tercer Milenio. Educ Quimica 17:286–299
Klein U (2001) The creative power of paper tools in early nineteenth-century chemistry. In: Klein U (ed) Tools and modes of representation in the laboratory sciences. Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp 13–34
Linares R, Izquierdo-Aymerich M (2004) Elemento, Átomo y Sustancia Simple: Diversas Lecturas de la Tabla Periódica. Colombia: Ciencia y Tecnología 22(3):34–43
Moreno A (2006) Atomismo versus Energetismo. Ensenanza Cienc 24(3):411–428
Nye MJ (1996) Before big science. Twaine, New York
Nye MJ (2000) From student to teacher. In: Lundgren A, Bensaude-Vincent B (eds) Communicating chemistry: textbooks and their audiences. Watson, Canton, pp 397–414
Pacault A (1994) ‘L’Élément Chimique Aujourd’Hui’. L’Actualité Chimique 4:51–62
Rocke A (1993) The quiet revolution. University of California Press, Berkeley
Scerri E (2007) The periodic table: its story and its significance. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Wolke RL (1988) Marie Curie’s doctoral thesis: prelude to a nobel prize. J Chem Edu 65(7):561–573
Sources analysed for this paper
Bohr N (1913) On the constitution of atoms and molecules. Munksgaard, Copenhagen
Brunold C (1930) Le Problème de l’Affinité Chimique et l’Atomistique. Masson, Paris
De Broglie L (1940) Átomos, Radiactividad, Transmutaciones. Hachette, Paris
Lewis GN (1916) The atom and the molecule. J Am Chem Soc 38:762–785
Lewis GN (1923) Valence and the structure of atoms and molecules. The Chemical Catalog Company, New York
Mendeleev D (1868–70/1897?) Principes de Chimie, Bernard Tignol, Paris. (1st [1897?] edition of the French translation of the Russian original.)
Nerst W (1922) Traité de Chimie Générale. Hermann, Paris (Translated from the 10th German edition.)
Noyes AA (1922) A course of study in chemical principles. MacMillan, New York
Pauling L (1947) General chemistry: an introduction to descriptive chemistry and modern chemical theory. Freeman, San Francisco
Perrin J (1920) Les Atomes. Alcan, Paris
Renault R (1941) Atomistique et Chimie Générale. Brunold, Paris
Thomson JJ (1922) Électricité et Matière. Gauthier-Villars, Paris. (Selection of lectures at Yale University, 1903.)
Urbain G (1926) Les Notions Fondamentales d’Élément Chimique et d’Atome. Gauthier-Villars, Paris. (Collection “Science et Civilisation”.)
Acknowledgements
We thank the editor, reviewers and language advisor provided by Science & Education for their help with our manuscript
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Izquierdo-Aymerich, M., Adúriz-Bravo, A. Physical Construction of the Chemical Atom: Is it Convenient to Go All the Way Back?. Sci & Educ 18, 443–455 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11191-008-9156-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11191-008-9156-4