Abstract
The purpose of the study is to compare problem based learning (PBL) and lecture-based learning (LBL) in Hong Kong secondary students’ science achievement. Secondary One students were divided into two groups: group A (n = 37), was taught two topics: “Human Reproduction” and “Density” through PBL; group B (n = 38) was taught the same topics by LBL. Multiple choice questions and short structured response items were used to assess students’ academic performance. Pre and post tests were categorized into three domains: knowledge, comprehension and application according to Bloom’s Taxonomy (Bloom 1956). The results of this study suggest first that PBL is at least as effective as LBL in gaining the knowledge required to achieve the syllabus’ learning objectives; secondly, the PBL group shows a significant improvement in students’ comprehension and application of knowledge over an extended time. Seemingly, PBL is favored for knowledge retention compared to a more conventional teaching approach, by these early adolescent children in Hong Kong. An ongoing longitudinal study on students’ interactions will further determine whether students taught through PBL develop improved learning in relation to high order skills, in a local situation which still tends to focus on factual recall but where higher skills are being demanded by systemic reform.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Barrows, H. S., & Tamblyn, R. S. (1980). Problem based learning, an approach to medical education. New York: Springer.
Bickley, H., Donner, R. S., Walker, A. N., & Tift, J. P. (1990). Pathology education in a problem-based medical curriculum. Teaching and Learning in Medicine, 2(1), 38–41.
Biggs, J. B. (1987). Student approaches to learning and studying. Hawthorn: ACER.
Biggs, J. B., & Collis, K. B. (1982). Evaluating the quality of learning: the SOLO Taxonomy. New York: Academic.
Bloom, B. S. (1956). Taxonomy of educational objectives: The classification of educational goals: Handbook I, cognitive domain. New York: Longmans.
Boud, D. J., & Feletti, G. (1997). The challenge of problem-based learning. New York: St. Martin’s.
BouJaoude, S. (1992). The relationship between students' learning strategies and the change in their misunderstandings during a high school chemistry course. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 29(7), 687–699. doi:10.1002/tea.3660290706.
Cariaga-Lo, L., & Encarson, C. (2001). Influence of curriculum type on student performance in the United States Medical Licensing Examination step 1 and step 2 exams: Problem-based learning vs. lecture-based curriculum. Medical Education, 35, 1050–1055. doi:10.1046/j.1365-2923.2001.01058.x.
Checkley, K. (1997). Problem-based learning. ASCD Curriculum Update Summer, 6–7.
Colliver, J. (2000). Effectiveness of problem-based learning curricula: research and theory. Academic Medicine, 75, 259–266. doi:10.1097/00001888-200003000-00017.
Colvin, R. B., & Wetzel, M. S. (1989). Pathology in the new pathway of medical education at Harvard Medical School. American Journal of Clinical Pathology, 92, 22–30.
Curriculum Development Council (1998). Syllabuses for secondary Schools (secondary 1–3). Hong Kong: Government Printer.
Curriculum Development Council (2000). Learning to learn: The way forward in curriculum development. Hong Kong: Government Printer.
Dewey, J. (1938). Experience and education. New York: Collier.
Donner, R. S., & Bickley, H. (1990). Problem-based learning: An assessment of its feasibility and cost. Human Pathology, 21, 881–885. doi:10.1016/0046-8177(90)90170-A.
Donner, R. S., & Bickley, H. (1993). Problem-based learning in American medical education: An overview. Bulletin of the Medical Library Association, 81, 294–298.
Finch, P. M. (1999). The effect of problem based learning on the academic performance of students studying podiatric medicine in Ontario. Medical Education, 33, 411–417. doi:10.1046/j.1365-2923.1999.00347.x.
Fitzgerald, K. (1997). Instructional methods selection, use, and evaluation. In S. B. Bastable (Ed.), Nurse as educator: Principles of teaching and learning (pp. 261–286). Toronto: Jones and Barlett.
Gagne, R. M. (1965). The conditions of learning. New York: Holt Rinehart and Winston.
Gallagher, S. A., Sher, B. T., Stepien, W. J., & Workman, D. (1995). Implementing problem-based learning in science classrooms. School Science and Mathematics, 95(3), 136–146.
Geban, D. L., Askar, P., & Ozkan, I. (1992). Effects of computer simulations and problem solving approaches on high school students. The Journal of Educational Research, 86, 5–10.
Goodnough, K., & Cahsion, M. (2003). Fostering inquiry through problem-based learning. Science Teacher (Normal, Ill.), 70(9), 21–25.
Greeno, J. G. (1978). Natures of problem-solving abilities. In W. K. Estes (Ed.), Handbook of Learning and Cognitive Process, Vol. V (pp. 239–270). Hillsdale: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Greenwald, N. L. (2000). Learning from problems. Science Teacher (Normal, Ill.), 67(4), 28–32.
Grow, P. L., & Plucker, J. A. (2003). Good problems to have. Science Teacher (Normal, Ill.), 70(9), 31–35.
Herreid, C. F. (2003). The death of problem-based learning. Journal of College Science Teaching, 32, 364–366.
Hmelo, C. E. (1998). Cognitive consequences of PBL for the early development of medical expertise. Teaching and Learning in Medicine, 10, 92–100. doi:10.1207/S15328015TLM1002_7.
Hong Kong Education Commission (1986). Report No. 2. Hong Kong: Government Printer.
Huffman, D., Lawernz, F., & Minger, M. (1997). Within-class analysis of ninth-grade science students’ perceptions of the learning environment. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 34(8), 791–804. doi:10.1002/(SICI)1098-2736(199710)34:8<791::AID-TEA3>3.0.CO;2-Q.
Jones, D. (1996a). The advantages of PBL. Retrieved April 3, 2003, from http://edweb.sdsu.edu/clrit/learningtree/PBL/PBLadvantages.html
Jones, D. (1996b). Disadvantages of problem based learning. Retrieved April 3, 2003, from http://edweb.sdsu.edu/clrit/learningtree/PBL/DisPBL.html.
Kaufman, D. M., & Mann, K. V. (1999). Achievement of students in a conventional and problem-based learning(PBL) curriculum. Advances in Health Sciences Education, 4, 245–260. doi:10.1023/A:1009829831978.
Matthews, M. R. (2000). Constructivism in science and mathematics education. In D. C. Phillips (Ed.), National Society for the Study of Education, 99th Yearbook (pp. 161–192). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Morris, P. (1990). Curriculum development in Hong Kong: Education Paper 7. Hong Kong: Faculty of Education, University of Hong Kong.
Mpofu, D. J. S., Schmidt, H. G., Das, M., Lanphear, J., & Dunn, E. (1998). A review of problem-based learning: Perceptions of students and tutors at the United Arab Emirates University. Education for Health, 11(2), 203–213.
Norman, G. R., & Schmidt, H. G. (2000). Effectiveness of problem-based learning curricula: Theory, practice and paper darts. Medical Education, 34(9), 721–728. doi:10.1046/j.1365-2923.2000.00749.x.
Petersen, C., Maier, S. F., & Seligman, M. E. P. (1995). Learned helplessness: A theory for the age of personal control. New York: Oxford University Press.
Rideout, E., England-Oxford, V., Brown, B., Fothergill-Bourbonnais, F., Ingram, C., Benson, G., et al. (2002). A comparison of problem-based and conventional curricula in nursing education. Advances in Health Sciences Education, 7, 3–17. doi:10.1023/A:1014534712178.
Saunders, W. L., & Shepardson, D. (1987). A comparison of concrete and formal science instruction upon science achievement and reasoning ability of sixth grade students. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 24, 39–51. doi:10.1002/tea.3660240105.
Senocak, E., Taskesenligil, Y., & Sozbilir, M. (2007). A study on teaching gases to prospective primary science teachers through problem-based learning. Research in Science Education, 37(3), 279–290. doi:10.1007/s11165-006-9026-5.
Stepien, W. J., Gallagher, S. A., & Workman, D. (1993). Problem-based learning for traditional and interdisciplinary classrooms. Journal for the Education of the Gifted, 4, 338–345.
Webb, W. H. (1999). The educator's guide to solutioning. Thousand Oaks: Corwin.
Whitehill, T. L., Stokes, S. F., & MacKinnon, M. M. (1997). Problem-based learning and the Chinese learner. In R. Murray-Harvey, & H. C. Silins (Eds.), Learning and teaching in higher education: Advancing international perspectives (pp. 129–146). Adelaide: Flinders.
Willis, S. C., Jones, A., Bundy, C., Burdett, K., Whitehouse, C. R., & O'Neill, P. A. (2002). Small-group work and assessment in a PBL curriculum: A qualitative and quantitative evaluation of student perceptions of the process of working in small groups and its assessment. Medical Teacher, 24, 495–501. doi:10.1080/0142159021000012531.
Wong, K. H., & Day, J. (2006). Problem based learning improves students awareness of their learning in science. Proceeding of the 6th International Conference on Problem-based Learning, Lima, Peru
Wood, E. J. (1994). The problems of problem-based learning. Biochemical Education, 22, 78–82. doi:10.1016/0307-4412(94)90080-9.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Appendix
Appendix
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Wong, K.K.H., Day, J.R. A Comparative Study of Problem-Based and Lecture-Based Learning in Junior Secondary School Science. Res Sci Educ 39, 625–642 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11165-008-9096-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11165-008-9096-7