Abstract
Crop protection has a very long history during which new methods have been developed whilst, at the same time, the older ones have retained their usefulness in certain conditions. The diversity of agricultural land and production has meant that it was futile to search for a unique and definitive approach or technical solution and, instead, the central concept has always been one of integration, during all the period of pre-Green Revolution and again today within what we call a sustainable agriculture. On a global level, it would seem that the current situation does not fundamentally contradict this idea. Nevertheless, in recent years (since the Second World War), two important advances, presented as the definitive solutions to problems and potentially exceeding previously less effective ones, have led to this integrative approach being questioned. These are agrochemistry and agro-genetics. We will detail, here, the agro-environmental limits of these two “miracle solutions,” followed by a review from an ethical and an epistemological point of view. This enables us to demonstrate the relevance of integrated approaches in agriculture and leads to a definition of crop protection that forms part of a strong approach in sustainable development. By changing the semantics, the epistemic position and our vision of production, we arrive at the proposal of sustainable agriculture.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Here, only the GM crops involved, in a large scale, in crop protection are taken into consideration.
For a good summary of the multiple challenges (ethical, economic, political, epistemological, …) of this issue, see: Lacey (2005).
References
AFSSET, & INSERM. (2008). Expertise collective «Cancers et environnement». Paris: Afsset et Inserm.
Altieri, M. A. (2005). The myth of coexistence: Why transgenic crops are not compatible with agroecologically based systems of production. Bulletin of Science, Technology and Society, 25, 361–371.
AO, F. (2002). World agriculture: Towards 2015/2030. Rome: FAO.
Bellon, S. 2008. Agriculture durable, penser les activités agricoles à partir des enjeux du développement durable. Texte INRA. http://www.inra.fr/la_science_et_vous/apprendre_experimenter/questions_d_actu/2008/agriculture_durable. Accessed February 22, 2011.
Berque, A. (1996). Être humains sur la Terre. Paris: Gallimard.
Beus, C. E., & Dunlap, R. E. (1990). Conventional versus alternative agriculture: The paradigmatic roots of the debate. Rural Sociology, 55, 590–616.
Binimelis, R. (2008). Coexistence of plants, coexistence of farmers. Is an individual choice possible? Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 21, 437–457.
Blandin, P. (2009). De la protection de la nature au pilotage de la biodiversité. Versailles: Edition Quae.
Bonneuil, C. A. N. D., & Thomas, F. (2010). Gènes, pouvoirs et profits. Versailles: Edition Quae.
Bonny, S. (1994). Les possibilités d’un modèle de développement durable en agriculture, le cas de la France. Le courrier de l’environnement, 23, 5–15.
Bouleau, N. 2008. Du pluralisme dans les sciences. Online: http://halshs.archive-ouvertes.fr:halshs-00374576. Accessed February 22, 2011.
Bourg, D., & Besnier, J. M. (2000). Peut-on encore croire au progrès?. Paris: PUF.
Busch, L., & Lacy, W. B. (1983). Science, agriculture and the politics of research. Boulder: Westview Press.
CBD: Convention on Biological Diversity. 2008. Biodiversity and agriculture. Safeguarding biodiversity and securing food for the world. Montreal: Secretariat of the Convention on Biological Diversity.
Ceballos, L. (2008). Plantes insecticides: évaluation de l’impact sur les insectes auxiliaires. Lyon: Edition Rés’OGM Info.
Coutellec, L. 2011. Comment la recherche-action déplace les frontières? Une perspective épistémologique et éthique. In Academos, L’épistémologie des frontières. Paris: Pétra.
Coutellec, L., & Doussan, I. (2010). Attempt to typologize relations between different worlds (human, animal, living) based on legal and ethical questions surrounding the status of GM fish. In C. M. Romeo Casabona, L. Escajedo San Epifanio, & A. Emaldi Cirión (Eds.), Global food security: Ethical and legal challenges (pp. 412–417). Wageningen: Academic Publishers.
Dalgaard, T., Hutchings, N. J., & Porter, J. R. (2003). Agroecology, scaling and interdisciplinarity. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 100, 39–51.
Deguine, J. P., & Ferron, P. (2006). Protection des cultures, préservation de la biodiversité, respect de l’environnement. Cahiers Agricultures, 15, 307–311.
Deguine, J. P., Ferron, P., & Russell, R. (2008). Protection des cultures: de l’agrochimie à l’agroécologie. Versailles: Editions Quae.
Douglas, H. (2000). Inductive risk and values in science. Philosophy of Science, 67, 559–579.
Dufumier, M., Gouyon, P. -H., & Le Maho, Y. (2008). Les OGM, une solution à la famine? Le Monde, 12 février.
Ehler, L. E., & Bottrell, D. G. 2000. The illusion of integrated pest management. Issues in Science and Technology. http://www.issues.org/16.3/ehler.htm. Accessed February 22, 2011.
FAO. 1968. Report of the first session of the FAO panel of experts on integrated pest control. Report no PL/1967/M/7, FAO, Rome.
Ferret, S. (2000). Durable, raisonnée, intégrée, paysanne… le jeu des sept familles. Transrural Initiatives, 161, 4–5.
Ferron, P. (1999). Protection intégrée des cultures: évolution du concept et de son application. Les Dossiers de l’Environnement, 19, 19–28.
Gardner, B. L., & Rausser, G. C. (eds.) 2001. Handbook of agricultural economics. Volume 1A: agricultural production. The Netherlands: Elsevier Science.
Garrau, M., & Le Goff, A. (2010). Care, justice, dépendance. Introduction aux théories du Care. Paris: PUF.
Godart, O., & Hubert, B. 2002. Le développement durable et la recherche scientifique à l’INRA. Rapport à Madame la directrice générale de l’INRA, p. 58.
Hacking, I. (1999). The social construction of what?. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Holt, J. S., & LeBaron, H. M. (1990). Significance and distribution of herbicide resistance. Weed Technology, 4, 141–149.
IGAS. (2003). Rapport annuel 2003. Santé, pour une politique de prévention durable (p. 399). Paris: La documentation française.
INRA. (2005). Pesticides, agriculture et environnement, réduire l’utilisation des pesticides et en limiter les impacts environnementaux. Paris: Editions INRA et CEMAGREF.
INRA. (2010). Synthèse du rapport de l’étude Ecophyto RandD. Quelles voies pour réduire l’usage des pesticides?. Paris: INRA.
Jennings, B. (1988). Foundations of international agricultural research. Boulder: Westview Press.
Lacey, H. 2001. The ways in which the sciences are and are not value free. Presented at the conference, “value free science: Illusion or ideal?” Center for Ethics and Values in the Sciences, University of Alabama at Birmingham, February 23–25, 2001.
Lacey, H. (2005). Values and objectivity in science: The current controversy about transgenic crops. Lanham: Lexington Books.
Landais, E. (1998). Agriculture durable: les fondements d’un nouveau contrat social. Dossier de l’environnement de l’INRA, 27, 23–39.
Larrère, C. 2007. Protections de la nature et éthiques environnementales. Revue Mouvements. http://www.mouvements.info/Protection-de-la-nature-et.html. Accessed February 22, 2011.
Larrère, R., Lizet, B., & Berlan-Darque, M. (2009). Histoire des parcs nationaux, comment prendre soin de la nature?. Versailles: Editions Quae.
Laugier, S., & Paperman, P. (2006). Le souci des autres–éthique et politique du care. Paris: Ed. de l’EHESS.
Lawrence, R. J., & Despres, C. (2004). Futures of transdisciplinarity. Futures, 36, 397–405.
Lévèque, C. (2009). Recherche et Développement Durable: l’utopie d’une approche systémique? In B. Villalba (Ed.), Appropriations du développement durable. Paris: Presses universitaires du Septentrion.
Lyson, T. (2002). Advanced agricultural biotechnologies and sustainable agriculture. Trends in Biotechnology, 20, 193–196.
Lyson, T. (2004). Civic agriculture. Reconnecting farm, food and community. Hanover: Tufts University Press.
Mazoyer, M. A. N. D., & Roudart, L. (1997). Histoire des agricultures du monde. Paris: Seuil.
Nicolino, F., & Veillerette, F. (2007). Pesticides. Révélations sur un scandale français. Paris: Editions Fayard.
OILB/SROP. 1977. Vers la production agricole intégrée, par la lutte intégrée. Bulletin de OILB/SROP 4.
Ost, F. (2003). La nature hors la loi, l’écologie à l’épreuve du droit. Paris: La découverte.
Pellizoni, L. (2003). Uncertainty and participatory democracy. Environmental Value, 12, 195–224.
Pervanchon, F., & Blouet, A. (2002). “Agriculture raisonnée” and “integrated farming”: How are they linked? Cahiers de l’agriculture, 11, 151–157.
Pintureau, B. (2009). La lutte biologique et les trichogrammes. Application au contrôle de la pyrale du maïs. Paris: Le Manuscrit.
Pintureau, B., Grenier, S., Mouret, H., Sauge, M. H., Sauphanor, B., Sforza, R., et al. (2009). La lutte biologique. Application aux arthropodes ravageurs et aux adventices. Paris: Ed. Ellipses.
Putnam, H. (2004). The collapse of the fact/value dichotomy and other essays. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
RA, I. N. (2009). Agriculture et biodiversité, valoriser les synergies. Versailles: Editions Quae.
Radosevich, S. R., Holt, J. S., & Ghersa, C. M. (2007). Ecology of weeds and invasive plants: Relationship to agriculture and natural resource management (3rd ed.). New York: Wiley.
Schmid, A.-F., & Legay, J.-M. (2004). Philosophie de l’interdisciplinarité. Paris: Pétra.
Sfez, L. (1995). La santé parfaite. Critique d’une nouvelle utopie. Paris: Seuil.
Suffert, F. (2005). Cadre théorique de la notion de complémentation caractérisant des stratégies de protection des cultures. Phytoprotection, 86, 89–92.
Toler, D. 2000. Biotechnology Not the Solution. The Toronto Star, 25 July.
Tronto, J. (2009). Moral boundaries: A political argument for an ethic of care. Paris: La Découverte.
Van Helden, J. 2003. OGM: les dangers d’une approche réductionniste des systèmes complexes. SPS. http://www.pseudo-sciences.org/spip.php?article44. Accessed February 22, 2011.
van Wijk, J. (2000). Biotechnology and hunger: Challenges for the biotech industry. Biotechnology and Development Monitor, 41, 2–7.
Vélot, C. (2009). OGM, tout s’explique. Athée: Ed. Goutte de sable.
Viveret, P. (2004). L’humanisation de l’humain. Cahier Millénaire, 3, 63–68.
Way, M. J., & Emden, H. F. (2000). Integrated pest management in practice—Pathways towards successful application. Crop Protection, 19, 81–103.
Worster, D. (1998). Les pionniers de l’écologie. Paris: Editions du Sang de la Terre.
Acknowledgments
I would like to thank the anonymous reviewers of an earlier version of this paper for their helpful comments.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Léo, C., Pintureau, B. Crop Protection Between Sciences, Ethics and Societies: From Quick-Fix Ideal to Multiple Partial Solutions. J Agric Environ Ethics 26, 207–230 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-011-9363-x
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-011-9363-x