Abstract
2D cell culture and preclinical animal models have traditionally been implemented for investigating the underlying cellular mechanisms of human disease progression. However, the increasing significance of 3D vs. 2D cell culture has initiated a new era in cell culture research in which 3D in vitro models are emerging as a bridge between traditional 2D cell culture and in vivo animal models. Additive manufacturing (AM, also known as 3D printing), defined as the layer-by-layer fabrication of parts directed by digital information from a 3D computer-aided design file, offers the advantages of simultaneous rapid prototyping and biofunctionalization as well as the precise placement of cells and extracellular matrix with high resolution. In this review, we highlight recent advances in 3D printing of tissue engineered constructs that recapitulate the physical and cellular properties of the tissue microenvironment for investigating mechanisms of disease progression and for screening drugs.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abidin, F. Z., R. M. Gouveia, and C. J. Connon. Application of retinoic acid improves form and function of tissue engineered corneal construct. Organogenesis 11:122–136, 2015.
Ahn, S. H., M. Montero, D. Odell, S. Roundy, and P. K. Wright. Anisotropic material properties of fused deposition modeling ABS. Rapid Prototyp. J. 8:248–257, 2002.
Alemany-Ribes, M., and C. E. Semino. Bioengineering 3D environments for cancer models. Adv. Drug Deliv. Rev. 79–80:40–49, 2014.
Almela, T., I. M. Brook, and K. Moharamzadeh. Development of three-dimensional tissue engineered bone-oral mucosal composite models. J. Mater. Sci. Mater. Med. 27:65, 2016.
Andersen, M. E. Calling on science: making “Alternatives” the new gold standard. Altex-Altern. Anim. Exp. 27:135–143, 2010.
ASTM International. F2792-12a—Standard Terminology for Additive Manufacturing Technologies. Rapid Manuf. Assoc. pp. 10–12, 2013.
Bandyopadhyay, A., S. Bose, and S. Das. 3D printing of biomaterials. MRS Bull. 40:108–115, 2015.
Bertassoni, L. E., M. Cecconi, V. Manoharan, M. Nikkhah, J. Hjortnaes, A. L. Cristino, G. Barabaschi, D. Demarchi, M. R. Dokmeci, Y. Yang, and A. Khademhosseini. Hydrogel bioprinted microchannel networks for vascularization of tissue engineering constructs. Lab Chip 14:2202–2211, 2014.
Bian, W., D. Li, Q. Lian, X. Li, W. Zhang, K. Wang, and Z. Jin. Fabrication of a bio-inspired beta-Tricalcium phosphate/collagen scaffold based on ceramic stereolithography and gel casting for osteochondral tissue engineering. Rapid Prototyp. J. 18:68–80, 2012.
Chang, R., K. Emami, H. Wu, and W. Sun. Biofabrication of a three-dimensional liver micro-organ as an in vitro drug metabolism model. Biofabrication 2:045004, 2010.
Chang, R., J. Nam, and W. Sun. Direct cell writing of 3D microorgan for in vitro pharmacokinetic model. Tissue Eng. Part C. Methods 14:157–166, 2008.
Chung, T. W., J. Yang, T. Akaike, K. Y. Cho, J. W. Nah, S. Il Kim, and C. S. Cho. Preparation of alginate/galactosylated chitosan scaffold for hepatocyte attachment. Biomaterials 23:2827–2834, 2002.
Costa, P. F., C. Vaquette, J. Baldwin, M. Chhaya, M. E. Gomes, R. L. Reis, C. Theodoropoulos, and D. W. Hutmacher. Biofabrication of customized bone grafts by combination of additive manufacturing and bioreactor knowhow. Biofabrication 6:035006, 2014.
Crump, S. S. Apparatus and method for creating three-dimensional objects. US Patent 5121329 A, 1992.
de Gans, B.-J., P. C. Duineveld, and U. S. Schubert. Inkjet printing of polymers: state of the art and future developments. Adv. Mater. 16:203–213, 2004.
de Souza Carvalho, C., N. de Daum, and C. M. de Lehr. Carrier interactions with the biological barriers of the lung: Advanced in vitro models and challenges for pulmonary drug delivery. Adv. Drug Deliv. Rev. 75:129–140, 2014.
Derby, B. Printing and prototyping of tissues and scaffolds. Science 338:921–926, 2012.
Evans, H. J., J. K. Sweet, R. L. Price, M. Yost, and R. L. Goodwin. Novel 3D culture system for study of cardiac myocyte development. Am. J. Physiol. Heart Circ. Physiol. 285:H570–H578, 2003.
Fernández-Muiños, T., L. Recha-Sancho, P. López-Chicón, C. Castells-Sala, A. Mata, and C. E. Semino. Bimolecular based heparin and self-assembling hydrogel for tissue engineering applications. Acta Biomater. 16:35–48, 2015.
Fischbach, C., R. Chen, T. Matsumoto, T. Schmelzle, J. S. Brugge, P. J. Polverini, and D. J. Mooney. Engineering tumors with 3D scaffolds. Nat. Methods 4:855–860, 2007.
Fitzgerald, K. A., J. Guo, E. G. Tierney, C. M. Curtin, M. Malhotra, R. Darcy, F. J. O’Brien, and C. M. O’Driscoll. The use of collagen-based scaffolds to simulate prostate cancer bone metastases with potential for evaluating delivery of nanoparticulate gene therapeutics. Biomaterials 66:53–66, 2015.
Fong, E. L. S., S.-E. Lamhamedi-Cherradi, E. Burdett, V. Ramamoorthy, A. J. Lazar, F. K. Kasper, M. C. Farach-Carson, D. Vishwamitra, E. G. Demicco, B. A. Menegaz, H. M. Amin, A. G. Mikos, and J. A. Ludwig. Modeling Ewing sarcoma tumors in vitro with 3D scaffolds. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 110:6500–6505, 2013.
Frega, M., M. Tedesco, P. Massobrio, M. Pesce, and S. Martinoia. Network dynamics of 3D engineered neuronal cultures: a new experimental model for in vitro electrophysiology. Sci. Rep. 4:1–14, 2014.
Galantucci, L. M., F. Lavecchia, and G. Percoco. Experimental study aiming to enhance the surface finish of fused deposition modeled parts. CIRP Ann. Manuf. Technol. 58:189–192, 2009.
Grayson, W. L., M. Fröhlich, K. Yeager, S. Bhumiratana, M. E. Chan, C. Cannizzaro, L. Q. Wan, X. S. Liu, X. E. Guo, and G. Vunjak-Novakovic. Engineering anatomically shaped human bone grafts. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 107:3299–3304, 2010.
Griffith, L. G., and G. Naughton. Tissue engineering-current challenges and expanding opportunities. Science 295:1009–1014, 2002.
Griffith, L. G., and M. A. Swartz. Capturing complex 3D tissue physiology in vitro. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 7:211–224, 2006.
Groeber, F., M. Holeiter, M. Hampel, S. Hinderer, and K. Schenke-Layland. Skin tissue engineering—in vivo and in vitro applications. Adv. Drug Deliv. Rev. 63:352–366, 2011.
Groll, J., T. Boland, T. Blunk, J. A. Burdick, D. Cho, D. Paul, B. Derby, G. Forgacs, Q. Li, V. A. Mironov, and L. Moroni. Biofabrication: reappraising the definition in an evolving field. Biofabrication 8:013001, 2016.
Guelcher, S. A., A. Srinivasan, J. E. Dumas, J. E. Didier, S. McBride, and J. O. Hollinger. Synthesis, mechanical properties, biocompatibility, and biodegradation of polyurethane networks from lysine polyisocyanates. Biomaterials 29:1762–1775, 2008.
Guillemot, F., V. Mironov, and M. Nakamura. Bioprinting is coming of age: report from the International Conference on Bioprinting and Biofabrication in Bordeaux (3B’09). Biofabrication 2:010201, 2010.
Guo, R., S. Lu, J. M. Page, A. R. Merkel, S. Basu, J. A. Sterling, and S. A. Guelcher. Fabrication of 3D scaffolds with precisely controlled substrate modulus and pore size by templated-fused deposition modeling to direct osteogenic differentiation. Adv. Healthc. Mater. 4:1826–1832, 2015.
Guo, R., A. R. Merkel, J. A. Sterling, J. M. Davidson, and S. A. Guelcher. Substrate modulus of 3D-printed scaffolds regulates the regenerative response in subcutaneous implants through the macrophage phenotype and Wnt signaling. Biomaterials 73:85–95, 2015.
Gurkan, U. A., R. El Assal, S. E. Yildiz, Y. Sung, A. J. Trachtenberg, W. P. Kuo, and U. Demirci. Engineering anisotropic biomimetic fibrocartilage microenvironment by bioprinting mesenchymal stem cells in nanoliter gel droplets. Mol. Pharm. 11:2151–2159, 2014.
Gurski, L. A., N. J. Petrelli, X. Jia, and M. C. Farach-Carson. 3D matrices for anti-cancer drug testing and development. Oncol. Issues 25:20–25, 2010.
Hirschhaeuser, F., H. Menne, C. Dittfeld, J. West, W. Mueller-Klieser, and L. A. Kunz-Schughart. Multicellular tumor spheroids: an underestimated tool is catching up again. J. Biotechnol. 148:3–15, 2010.
Hollister, S. J. Porous scaffold design for tissue engineering. Nat. Mater. 4:518–524, 2005.
Horning, J. L., S. K. Sahoo, S. Vijayaraghavalu, S. Dimitrijevic, J. K. Vasir, T. K. Jain, A. K. Panda, and V. Labhasetwar. 3D tumor model for in vitro evaluation of anticancer drugs. Mol. Pharm. 5:849–862, 2008.
Horváth, L., Y. Umehara, C. Jud, F. Blank, A. Petri-Fink, and B. Rothen-Rutishauser. Engineering an in vitro air-blood barrier by 3D bioprinting. Sci. Rep. 5:7974, 2015.
Huang, T. Q., X. Qu, J. Liu, and S. Chen. 3D printing of biomimetic microstructures for cancer cell migration. Biomed. Microdev. 16:127–132, 2014.
Hull, C. W. Apparatus for production of three dimensional objects by stereolithography. US Patent 4575330 A, 1986.
Hutmacher, D. Scaffolds in tissue engineering bone and cartilage. Biomaterials 21:2529–2543, 2000.
Hutmacher, D. W., T. Schantz, I. Zein, K. W. Ng, S. H. Teoh, and K. C. Tan. Mechanical properties and cell cultural response of polycaprolactone scaffolds designed and fabricated via fused deposition modeling. J. Biomed. Mater. Res. 55:203–216, 2001.
Jain, R. K., P. Au, J. Tam, D. G. Duda, and D. Fukumura. Engineering vascularized tissue. Nat. Biotechnol. 23:821–823, 2005.
Johnson, B., K. Lancaster, I. B. Hogue, F. Meng, Y. L. Kong, L. Enquist, and M. McAlpine. 3D printed nervous system on a chip. Lab Chip 16:1393–1400, 2016.
Kang, H. W., S. J. Lee, I. K. Ko, C. Kengla, J. J. Yoo, and A. Atala. A 3D bioprinting system to produce human-scale tissue constructs with structural integrity. Nat. Biotechnol. 34:312–319, 2016.
Khademhosseini, A., R. Langer, J. T. Borenstein, and J. P. Vacanti. Microscale technologies for tissue engineering and biology. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 103:2480–2487, 2006.
Kimlin, L., J. Kassis, and V. Virador. 3D in vitro tissue models and their potential for drug screening. Expert Opin. Drug Discov. 8:1455–1466, 2013.
Knowlton, S., S. Onal, C. H. Yu, J. J. Zhao, and S. Tasoglu. Bioprinting for cancer research. Trends Biotechnol. 33:1–10, 2015.
Kock, L., C. C. van Donkelaar, and K. Ito. Tissue engineering of functional articular cartilage: the current status. Cell Tissue Res. 347:613–627, 2012.
Kolesky, D. B., R. L. Truby, A. S. Gladman, T. A. Busbee, K. A. Homan, and J. A. Lewis. 3D bioprinting of vascularized, heterogeneous cell-laden tissue constructs. Adv. Mater. 26:3124–3130, 2014.
Kraus, D., V. Boyle, N. Leibig, G. Stark, and V. Penna. The Neuro-spheroid—A novel 3D in vitro model for peripheral nerve regeneration. J. Neurosci. Methods 246:97–105, 2015.
Kundu, J., J. H. Shim, J. Jang, S. W. Kim, and D. W. Cho. An additive manufacturing-based PCL-alginate-chondrocyte bioprinted scaffold for cartilage tissue engineering. J. Tissue Eng. Regen. Med. 9:1286–1297, 2015.
LeCluyse, E. L., R. P. Witek, M. E. Andersen, and M. J. Powers. Organotypic liver culture models: meeting current challenges in toxicity testing. Crit. Rev. Toxicol. 42:501–548, 2012.
Lee, W., J. C. Debasitis, V. K. Lee, J. H. Lee, K. Fischer, K. Edminster, J. K. Park, and S. S. Yoo. Multi-layered culture of human skin fibroblasts and keratinocytes through three-dimensional freeform fabrication. Biomaterials 30:1587–1595, 2009.
Lozano, R., L. Stevens, B. C. Thompson, K. J. Gilmore, R. Gorkin, E. M. Stewart, M. in het Panhuis, M. Romero-Ortega, and G. G. Wallace. 3D printing of layered brain-like structures using peptide modified gellan gum substrates. Biomaterials 67:264–273, 2015.
Macchiarini, P., P. Jungebluth, T. Go, M. A. Asnaghi, L. E. Rees, T. A. Cogan, A. Dodson, J. Martorell, S. Bellini, P. P. Parnigotto, S. C. Dickinson, A. P. Hollander, S. Mantero, M. T. Conconi, and M. A. Birchall. Clinical transplantation of a tissue-engineered airway. Lancet 372:2023–2030, 2008.
Malda, J., T. B. F. Woodfield, F. van der Vloodt, C. Wilson, D. E. Martens, J. Tramper, C. A. van Blitterswijk, and J. Riesle. The effect of PEGT/PBT scaffold architecture on the composition of tissue engineered cartilage. Biomaterials 26:63–72, 2005.
Mastro, A. M., and E. A. Vogler. A three-dimensional osteogenic tissue model for the study of metastatic tumor cell interactions with bone. Cancer Res. 69:4097–4100, 2009.
Melchels, F. P. W., J. Feijen, and D. W. Grijpma. A review on stereolithography and its applications in biomedical engineering. Biomaterials 31:6121–6130, 2010.
Miller, J. S., K. R. Stevens, M. T. Yang, B. M. Baker, D. H. T. Nguyen, D. M. Cohen, E. Toro, A. A. Chen, P. A. Galie, X. Yu, R. Chaturvedi, S. N. Bhatia, and C. S. Chen. Rapid casting of patterned vascular networks for perfusable engineered three-dimensional tissues. Nat. Mater. 11:768–774, 2012.
Moreira-Teixeira, L. S., N. Georgi, J. Leijten, L. Wu, and M. Karperien. Cartilage tissue engineering. Endocr. Dev. 21:102–115, 2011.
Murphy, S. V., and A. Atala. 3D bioprinting of tissues and organs. Nat. Biotechnol. 32:773–785, 2014.
Neiman, J. A. S., R. Raman, V. Chan, M. G. Rhoads, M. S. B. Raredon, J. J. Velazquez, R. L. Dyer, R. Bashir, P. T. Hammond, and L. G. Griffith. Photopatterning of hydrogel scaffolds coupled to filter materials using stereolithography for perfused 3D culture of hepatocytes. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 112:777–787, 2015.
Olson, H., G. Betton, D. Robinson, K. Thomas, A. Monro, G. Kolaja, P. Lilly, J. Sanders, G. Sipes, W. Bracken, M. Dorato, K. Van Deun, P. Smith, B. Berger, and A. Heller. Concordance of the toxicity of pharmaceuticals in humans and in animals. Regul. Toxicol. Pharmacol. 32:56–67, 2000.
Pati, F., J. Jang, D.-H. Ha, S. Won Kim, J.-W. Rhie, J.-H. Shim, D.-H. Kim, and D.-W. Cho. Printing three-dimensional tissue analogues with decellularized extracellular matrix bioink. Nat. Commun 5:3935, 2014.
Pedron, S., E. Becka, and B. A. Harley. Spatially gradated hydrogel platform as a 3D engineered tumor microenvironment. Adv. Mater. 27:1567–1572, 2015.
Ramaiahgari, S. C., M. W. Den Braver, B. Herpers, V. Terpstra, J. N. M. Commandeur, B. Van De Water, and L. S. Price. A 3D in vitro model of differentiated HepG2 cell spheroids with improved liver-like properties for repeated dose high-throughput toxicity studies. Arch. Toxicol. 88:1083–1095, 2014.
Raman, R., B. Bhaduri, M. Mir, A. Shkumatov, M. K. Lee, G. Popescu, H. Kong, and R. Bashir. High-resolution projection microstereolithography for patterning of neovasculature. Adv. Healthc. Mater. 2015. doi:10.1002/adhm.201500721.
Rimann, M., E. Bono, H. Annaheim, M. Bleisch, and U. Graf-Hausner. Standardized 3D bioprinting of soft tissue models with human primary cells. J. Lab. Autom. 2015. doi:10.1177/2211068214567146.
Rizvi, I., J. P. Celli, C. L. Evans, A. O. Abu-Yousif, A. Muzikansky, B. W. Pogue, D. Finkelstein, and T. Hasan. Synergistic enhancement of carboplatin efficacy with photodynamic therapy in a three-dimensional model for micrometastatic ovarian cancer. Cancer Res. 70:9319–9328, 2010.
Ruppender, N. S., A. R. Merkel, T. J. Martin, G. R. Mundy, J. A. Sterling, and S. A. Guelcher. Matrix rigidity induces osteolytic gene expression of metastatic breast cancer cells. PLoS One 5:1–10, 2010.
Sanz-Herrera, J. A., P. Moreo, J. M. García-Aznar, and M. Doblaré. On the effect of substrate curvature on cell mechanics. Biomaterials 30:6674–6686, 2009.
Sarkar, U., D. Rivera-Burgos, E. M. Large, D. J. Hughes, K. C. Ravindra, R. L. Dyer, M. R. Ebrahimkhani, J. S. Wishnok, L. G. Griffith, and S. R. Tannenbaum. Metabolite profiling and pharmacokinetic evaluation of hydrocortisone in a perfused three-dimensional human liver bioreactor. Drug Metab. Dispos. 43:1091–1099, 2015.
Schuessler, T. K., X. Y. Chan, H. J. Chen, K. Ji, K. M. Park, A. Roshan-Ghias, P. Sethi, A. Thakur, X. Tian, A. Villasante, I. K. Zervantonakis, N. M. Moore, L. A. Nagahara, and N. Z. Kuhn. Biomimetic tissue-engineered systems for advancing cancer research: NCI strategic workshop report. Cancer Res. 74:5359–5363, 2014.
Smith, K. E., S. L. Hyzy, M. Sunwoo, K. A. Gall, Z. Schwartz, and B. D. Boyan. The dependence of MG63 osteoblast responses to (meth)acrylate-based networks on chemical structure and stiffness. Biomaterials 31:6131–6141, 2010.
Snyder, J. E., Q. Hamid, C. Wang, R. Chang, K. Emami, H. Wu, and W. Sun. Bioprinting cell-laden matrigel for radioprotection study of liver by pro-drug conversion in a dual-tissue microfluidic chip. Biofabrication 3:034112, 2011.
Soman, P., J. A. Kelber, J. W. Lee, T. N. Wright, K. S. Vecchio, R. L. Klemke, and S. Chen. Cancer cell migration within 3D layer-by-layer microfabricated photocrosslinked PEG scaffolds with tunable stiffness. Biomaterials 33:7064–7070, 2012.
Sun, C., N. Fang, D. M. Wu, and X. Zhang. Projection micro-stereolithography using digital micro-mirror dynamic mask. Sensors Actuators A Phys. 121:113–120, 2005.
Sun, T., S. Jackson, J. W. Haycock, and S. MacNeil. Culture of skin cells in 3D rather than 2D improves their ability to survive exposure to cytotoxic agents. J. Biotechnol. 122:372–381, 2006.
Tasoglu, S., and U. Demirci. Bioprinting for stem cell research. Trends Biotechnol 31:10–19, 2013.
Taylor, M. P., O. Kobiler, and L. W. Enquist. Alphaherpesvirus axon-to-cell spread involves limited virion transmission. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 109:17046–17051, 2012.
Temple, J. P., D. L. Hutton, B. P. Hung, P. Y. Huri, C. A. Cook, R. Kondragunta, X. Jia, and W. L. Grayson. Engineering anatomically shaped vascularized bone grafts with hASCs and 3D-printed PCL scaffolds. J. Biomed. Mater. Res. Part A 102:4317–4325, 2014.
Van Bael, S., Y. C. Chai, S. Truscello, M. Moesen, G. Kerckhofs, H. Van Oosterwyck, J. P. Kruth, and J. Schrooten. The effect of pore geometry on the in vitro biological behavior of human periosteum-derived cells seeded on selective laser-melted Ti6Al4 V bone scaffolds. Acta Biomater. 8:2824–2834, 2012.
Vörsmann, H., F. Groeber, H. Walles, S. Busch, S. Beissert, H. Walczak, and D. Kulms. Development of a human three-dimensional organotypic skin-melanoma spheroid model for in vitro drug testing. Cell Death Dis. 4:e719, 2013.
Xu, F., J. Celli, I. Rizvi, S. Moon, T. Hasan, and U. Demirci. A three-dimensional in vitro ovarian cancer coculture model using a high-throughput cell patterning platform. Biotechnol. J. 6:204–212, 2011.
Yamada, K. M., and E. Cukierman. Modeling tissue morphogenesis and cancer in 3D. Cell 130:601–610, 2007.
Zadpoor, A. A. Bone tissue regeneration: the role of scaffold geometry. Biomater. Sci. 3:231–245, 2015.
Zanotelli, M. R., H. Ardalani, J. Zhang, Z. Hou, E. H. Nguyen, S. Swanson, B. K. Nguyen, J. Bolin, A. Elwell, L. L. Bischel, A. W. Xie, R. Stewart, D. J. Beebe, J. A. Thomson, M. P. Schwartz, and W. L. Murphy. Stable engineered vascular networks from human induced pluripotent stem cell-derived endothelial cells cultured in synthetic hydrogels. Acta Biomater. 35:32–41, 2016.
Zein, I., D. W. Hutmacher, K. C. Tan, and S. H. Teoh. Fused deposition modeling of novel scaffold architectures for tissue engineering applications. Biomaterials 23:1169–1185, 2002.
Zhang, D., M. Pekkanen-Mattila, M. Shahsavani, A. Falk, A. I. Teixeira, and A. Herland. A 3D Alzheimer’s disease culture model and the induction of P21-activated kinase mediated sensing in iPSC derived neurons. Biomaterials 35:1420–1428, 2014.
Zhao, Y., R. Yao, L. Ouyang, H. Ding, T. Zhang, K. Zhang, S. Cheng, and W. Sun. Three-dimensional printing of Hela cells for cervical tumor model in vitro. Biofabrication 6:035001, 2014.
Acknowledgments
Research reported in this publication was supported in part by the National Cancer Institute of the National Institutes of Health under award number R01CA163499. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the National Institutes of Health.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Associate Editor Jos Malda oversaw the review of this article.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Vanderburgh, J., Sterling, J.A. & Guelcher, S.A. 3D Printing of Tissue Engineered Constructs for In Vitro Modeling of Disease Progression and Drug Screening. Ann Biomed Eng 45, 164–179 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-016-1640-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-016-1640-4