Abstract
This article contends that Charles Sanders Peirce (1839–1914) may enhance our understanding of educational beliefs and that Peirce’s logic may be a tool to distinguish between a dogmatic and a pragmatic justification of such beliefs. The first part of the article elaborates on Peirce’s comprehension of beliefs as mediated, socially situated and future-oriented. The second part points to how Peirce promotes his “method of inquiry” as an ethos of science. The method is not judged by the conclusions it lead to or by the knowledge it may produce. Contrary, as the results are unavoidably provisional and rectifiable, Peirce holds the method productive due to the norms guiding the inquiry: (1) the pragmatic principle, (2) the social principle, (3) fallibilism and (4) abduction. In sum, when adopting a peircean conception, educational research, theory building and practice should be characterized as a mutual commitment towards shared processes of joint learning. In that, Peirce’s method of inquiry may be fruitful in sorting dogmatism from pragmatism.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
D.R. Anderson (1987) Creativity and the philosophy of C. S. Peirce Martinus Nijhoff Publishers Dordrecht
K.O. Apel (1995) Charles S. Peirce. From pragmatism to pragmaticism University of Massachusetts Press Amherst
G.J.J. Biesta G.J.J.M. Stams (2001) ArticleTitleCritical thinking and the question of critique: Some lessons from deconstruction Studies in Philosophy and Education 20 IssueID1 57–74 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1005290910306
P. Bourdieu (1988) Homo academicus Polity Press Cambridge
J. Brent (1998) Charles Sanders Peirce. A life Indiana University Press Bloomington
J. Derrida (1971/1982) White mythology: Metaphor in the text of philoosphy Derrida (Eds) Derrida: Margins of philosophy Harvester Wheatsheaf New York 207–271
J. Derrida (1995) Points. Interviews, 1974–1994 Stanford University Press Stanford
J. Dewey ((1897/1998)) My pedagogic creed Hickman Alexander (Eds) The essential Dewey NumberInSeriesVol. 1 Bloomington: Indiana University Press Bloomington 229–235
J. Dewey (1916/1985) Democracy and education Southern Illinois University Press Carbondale
J. Habermas (1968/1971) Knowledge and human interests Beacon Press Boston
C.R. Hausman (1993) Charles S Peirce’s evolutionary philosophy Cambridge University Press Cambridge
W. James (1898/1992) Philosophical conceptions and practical results William James (Eds) Writings 1879–1899 Literary Classics of the United States, Inc New York 1077–1097
W. James (1907/1992) Pragmatism’s conception of truth William James (Eds) Writings 1902–1910 Literary Classics of the United States, Inc New York 572–590
H. Joas (1993) Pragmatism and social theory The University of Chicago Press Chicago
W. Klafki (1998) Characteristics of a critical-constructive didaktik Gundem Hopmann (Eds) Didaktik and/or curriculum. Peter Lang New York
W. Klafki (2001) Dannelsesteori og didaktik. Nye studier [Theory of bildung and didactics. New studies] Forlaget Klim København
T. Kuhn ((1962/1996)) The structure of scientific revolutions EditionNumber3rd edition The University of Chicago Press Chicago
T. Kuhn (1970/1996) Logic of discovery or psychology of research? Lakatos Musgrave (Eds) Criticism and the growth of knowledge Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1–23
J.J. Liszka (1996) A general introduction to the semeiotic of Charles Sanders Peirce Indiana University Press Bloomington and Indianapolis
R.K. Merton (1942/1996) On social structure and science The University of Chicago Press Chicago
R.K. Merton (1968) Social theory and social structure The Free Press Chicago
H.O. Mounce (1997) The two pragmatisms from Peirce to Rorty Routledge London
R. Owen (1824/1969) Robert Owen on education The University Press Cambridge
Peirce C. S. (1931 - 58). Collected Papers, 8 vols. C. Hartsthorne & P. Weiss (Vols. 1–6) (eds) and A. Burks (Vols. 7–8) (ed). Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press
C.S. Peirce (1882/1966) Logic and liberal education Philip P. Wiener (Eds) Charles S. Peirce: Selected writings. Values in a universe of change Dover Publications Newyork 336–337
Peirce, C.S. (1900/1966). Clark University, 1889 – 1899: Decennial celebration. In P.P. Wiener (ed). Charles S. Peirce: Selected writings. Values in a universe of change (pp. 331–334). New York: Dover Publications
K. Popper (1963/1989) Conjenctures and refutations: The growth of scientific knowledge Routledge and Kegan Paul London
K. Popper (1970) Normal science and its dangers Lakatos Musgrave (Eds) Criticism and the growth of knowledge Cambridge University Press Cambridge 51–58
H. Putnam (1987) The many faces of realism the Paul Carus lectures Open Court Publishing Company LaSalle Ill
S.C. Rockefeller (1991) John Dewey. Religious faith and democratic humanism Columbia University Press New York
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Strand, T. Peirce on Educational Beliefs. Stud Philos Educ 24, 255–276 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11217-005-3848-x
Received:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11217-005-3848-x