Skip to main content

Advertisement

SpringerLink
Log in

Systems In Organic Dairy Production

  • Published:
Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

The aim of this study was to explore stakeholder perceptions of the contribution of an Automatic Milking System (AMS) to sustainable development of organic dairy production in Denmark and the Netherlands. In addition, reasons for the current difference in AMS use on organic dairy farms between both countries were explored. To answer above mentioned aims, farmers and advisors in both countries were interviewed using a focus group approach. Questions of the interviews were based on a literature review on sustainability issues affected by introduction of AMS. Participants expressed no moral problems regarding AMS use. They, however, pointed out uncertainty about the economic gain, difficulties with grazing, adaptation problems to technology, and image problems towards consumers. The latter results from a reduction in grazing time affecting both animal welfare and product quality. The participants did not recognize eutrophication, as result of high stocking density on farmstead lots, as a problem caused by AMS. The milk quality problem related to AMS use, although acknowledged as crucial towards consumers, was not prioritized very highly, especially not by the farmers in both countries. All groups were, however, unanimous in their perception of how important image was as far as the consumers are concerned. The perception analysis revealed that Dutch participants were more concerned about the economic payoff of AMS use, and showed more reluctance towards enlargement than Danish ones. In addition, they acknowledged the small-scale naturalness of organic production. These differences in perception could possibly explain observed differences in AMS use in organic dairy production between Denmark and the Netherlands.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Log in via an institution

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  • Alrøe, H. and E. S. Kristensen, Organic Principles (2000). Retrieved April 2006 from http://www.darcof.dk/discuss/Princip.pdf

  • Alrøe, H. and E. S. Kristensen (2004), “Basic Principles for Organic Agriculture. Why? And What Kind of Principles?” Ecology and Farming 36, pp. 27–30

    Google Scholar 

  • Anonymous, The Principles of Organic Agriculture (2005a). http://www.ifoam.org/about_ifoam/principles/index.html. Accessed April 2006

  • Anonymous, IFOAM’s Mission and Goals (2005b). http://www.ifoam.org/about_ifoam/inside_ifoam/mission.html. Accessed April 2006

  • Anonymous, IFOAM Standards and Norms (2005c). http://www.ifoam.org/about_ifoam/standards/norms.html. Accessed April 2006

  • Anonymous, Dairy Statistics (2006a). http://www.mejeri.dk/smcms/mejeri_dk/Statistik/Dansk/9_Oekologiske/9_a__Antal/Index.htm?ID=3711. Accessed April 2006

  • Anonymous, Organic Europe (2006b). http://www.organic-europe.net/country_reports/default.asp. Accessed April 2006

  • Anonymous, Statement on Dairy Cattle. Danish Ministry of Justice, Report: Ethical Council for Livestock (2006c). http://www.justitsministeriet.dk/fileadmin/downloadsPressemeddelelser2006/Udtalelse_om_malkekvaeg.pdf. Accessed April 2006

  • Audsley, E., A. Alber, R. Clift, P. Crettaz, S. Cowell, G. Gaillard, J. Haunsheer, O. Jolliett, R. Kleijn, B. Mortensen, D. Pearce, E. Roger, H. Teulon, B. Weidema, and H. van Zeijts, Harmonisation of Environmental Life Cycle Assessment for Agriculture. Final Report, Concerted Action AIR3-CT94-2028, European Commission DG VI, Brussels, Belgium (1997)

  • Benbrook, C. and F. Kischenmann, Proposed Principles for Evaluating the Organic “Rules” (1997). http://www.pmac.net/ppeor2.htm. Accessed April 2006

  • Biao X., W. Xiaorong D. Zhuhong, Y. Yaping 2003. Critical Impact Assessment of Organic Agriculture. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 16:297–311

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Collomb M., U. Butikofer, R. Sieber, B. Jeangros, J. O. Bosset 2002. Correlation Between Fatty Acids in Cows’ Milk Fat Produced in the Lowlands, Mountains and Highlands of Switzerland and Botanical Composition of the Fodder. International Dairy Journal 12:661–666

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • de Boer I. J. M. 2003. Environmental Impact Assessment of Conventional and Organic Milk Production. Livestock Production Science 80:69–77

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • de Koning C. J. A. M., J. Rodenburg 2004. Automatic Milking: State of the Art in Europe, North America. In A. Meijering, H. Hogeveen, C. J. A. M. de Koning (eds.), Automatic Milking (pp. 27–37). Wageningen: Wageningen Academic Publishers

    Google Scholar 

  • Eastwood C., D. Chapman, M. Paine. 2005. Information Management Within Australian Precision Dairy. In S. Cox (ed.), Precision Livestock Farming. (pp 313–318). Wageningen: Wageningen Academic Publishers

    Google Scholar 

  • Elgersma A., G. Ellen, H. van der Horst, H. Boer, P. R. Dekker, S. Tamminga. 2004. Quick Changes in Milk Fat Composition from Cows After Transition from Fresh Grass to a Silage Diet. Animal Feed Science and Technology 117:13–27

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Halkier, B., Fokusgrupper [Focus Groups] (Samfundsliteratur and Roskilde Universitetsforlag, Roskilde, 2002)

  • Hoeksma, J., Karakteristiek van biologische melkveebedrijven met een automatisch melksysteem (AMS) in Nederland [Characteristics of Organic Dairy Farms with an Automatic Milking System (AMS) in the Netherlands]. Master Project at Wageningen University and Research, Animal Production Science (2005)

  • Johnson G., K. Scholes. 1997. Exploring Corporate Strategy, 4th ed. Prentice Hall, London

    Google Scholar 

  • Jørgensen, A. and S. Pedersen, Ens driftsresultat i 2002 mellem økologisk og konventionelle mælkeproducenter [Similar Gross Margin for Organic and Conventional Dairy Farmers] (2004). http://www.lr.dk/kvaeg/informationsserier/lk-meddelelser/1276.htm. Accessed April 2006

  • Ketelaar-de Lauwere C. C., A. H. Ipema, C. Lokhorst, J. H. M. Metz, J. P. T. M. Noordhuizen, W. G. P. Schouten, A. C. Smits 2000. Effect of Sward Height and Distance Between Pasture and Barn on Cows Visits to an Automatic Milking System and Other Behavior. Livestock Production Science 65:131–142

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Kramer C., Afgræsning og automatisk malkning [Grazing and Robotic Milking]. Master Project at Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University, Copenhagen (2006)

  • Kristensen, T., A. Danfær, H. C. Christiansen, J. Sehested, K. L. Ingvardsen, L. Mogensen, T. Larsen, T. S. Nielsen, E. M. Straarup, K. Sejrsen, P. Madsen, and T. Villumsen, Økologisk mælkeproduktion, fodring og management ved hØj selvforsyning [Organic Dairy Production, Feeding and Management with High Self Support]. DARCOF Report. Ed. Troels Kristensen, Foulum, Denmark (2005a)

  • Kristensen T., K. Søegaard, I. S. Kristensen. 2005b. Management of Grasslands in Intensive Dairy Livestock Farming. Livestock Production Science 96:61–73

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Kristensen T., F. W. Oudshoorn, K. Søegaard, L. Munksgaard. 2007. Effect of Time at Pasture Combined with Restricted Indoor Feeding on Production and Behavior in Dairy Cows. Animal 1, 439–448

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Kvale S. 1994. InterView. Copenhagen: Hans Reitzels Forlag

    Google Scholar 

  • Mathijs E. 2004. Socio-Economical Aspects of Automatic Milking. In A. Meijering, H. Hogeveen, C. J. A. M. de Koning (eds.), Automatic Milking. (pp. 46–55). Wageningen: Wageningen Academic Publishers

    Google Scholar 

  • Meijering, A., H. Hogeveen, and C.J.A.M. de Koning (2004), ‹Automatic Milking: A Better Understanding’. Wageningen: Wageningen Academic Publishers

  • Meskens, L. and E. Mathijs, Socio-Economical Aspects of Automatic Milking. Deliverable D2 EU Report QLK5-2000-31006 (2002). http://www.automaticmilking.nl. Accessed April 2006

  • Meskens, L., M. Vendermersch, and E. Mathijs, Implications of the Introduction of Automatic Milking on Dairy Farms. Deliverable D1 EU Report QLK5-2000-31006 (2001). http://www.automaticmilking.nl. Accessed April 2006

  • Mogensen, L., Organic Milk Production Entirely Based on Home-Grown Food. PhD dissertation, Danish Institute of Agricultural Sciences (2005)

  • Mollenhorst H., I. J. M. de Boer. 2004. Identifying Sustainability Issues Using Participatory SWOT Analysis: A Case Study of Egg Production in the Netherlands. Outlook on Agriculture 33:267–276

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Munksgaard, L. and E. Søndergaard, Velfærd hos mælkekøer og kalve [Welfare for Dairy Cows and Young Stock]. Danish Institute of Agricultural Sciences; Livestock production report nr. 74 (2006)

  • Nielsen, J. H., Effect of Dairy Management on Quality Characteristics of Milk (Survey Approach) (2005). http://www.qlif.org. Accessed April 2006

  • Nielsen, L. A. H. and M. Vestergaard, “Erfaringer og økonomisk resultat ved automatisk malkning [Experiences and Economical Results of Farms with Automatic Milking]” in M. Vestergaard (ed.), Produktionsøkonomi [Dairy Production Economy] (2003), 28–31. http://www.lr.dk/oekonomijura/oekonomiogjura/07-1-17pjece2003.htm. Accessed April 2006

  • Noe E., N. Halberg, J. Reddersen 2005. Indicators of Biodiversity and Conservational Wildlife Quality on Danish Organic Farms for use in Farm Management: A Multidisciplinary Approach to Indicator Development and Testing. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 18, 383–414

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Oudshoorn F. W., I. J. M. de Boer 2005. Survey of the Sustainability Aspects of Automatic Milking Systems (AMS) in Organic Dairy Production. In S. Cox (ed.), Precision Livestock Farming ’05. (pp. 193–199). Wageningen: Wageningen Academic Publishers

    Google Scholar 

  • Rasmussen, J. B., Arbejdsbehov ved AMS [Labour use with AMS]. Farm test report (2000). www.lr.dk/bygningerogmaskiner/informationsserier/farmtest/arbejdsfirbrug_ams.html. Accessed April 2006

  • Raun, C. and M. D. Rasmussen, Afgræsningens effekt på malkefrekvens, mælkeydelse og driftsøkonomi i automatiske malkesystemer [The Effect of Grazing on Milking Frequency, Milk Yield and Gross Margin for Automatic Milking Systems]. Report No. 26, Livestock Production, Danish Institute of Agricultural Sciences, Foulum (2001). http://web.agrsci.dk/djfpublikation/index.asp?action=show&id=539. Accessed April 2006

  • Rotz C. A., C. U. Coiner, K. J. Soder 2003. Automatic Milking Systems, Farm Size, and Milk Production. Journal of Dairy Science 86:4167–4177

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Søegaard, K., P. Lund, J. Vinther, S. O. Petersen, and O. Aaes, Afgræsning med malkekøer i praksis, afgrødekvalitet, botanisk sammensætning og management [Grazing with Dairy Cows, Practice, Forage Quality, Botanical Composition and Management]. Report No. 51, Livestock Production, Danish Institute of Agricultural Sciences, Denmark (2001). http://web.agrsci.dk/djfpublikation/index.asp?action=show&id=546. Accessed April 2006

  • Somers J. G. C. J., K. Frankena, E. N. Noordhuizen-Stassen, J. H. M. Metz 2003. Prevalence of Claw Disorders in Dutch Dairy Cows Exposed to Several Floor Systems. Journal of Dairy Science 86:2082–2093

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Torjusen, H., L. Sangstad, K. O’Doherty Jensen, and K. Kjærness, European Conceptions of Organic Food. A Review of Available Research (National Institute for Consumer Research, Oslo, 2004). http://orgprints.org/00002490. Accessed April 2006

  • van der Zijpp, A. J., Animal Production Systems: On Integration and Diversity. Inaugural address, Wageningen University and Research (2001)

  • van Dooren, H. J. C., E. Spörndly, and H. Wiktorsson, Automatic Milking and Grazing, Applied Grazing Strategies. Deliverable 25, QLK5-2000-31006, 2002, 26–27 (2003). http://www.automaticmilking.nl. Assessed April 2006

  • van Ruiterbeek, B., EKO Monitor 2005 [Organic Monitor 2005] (2005). http://www.biologica.nl/eko-monitor/. Accessed April 2006

  • Verhoog H.,M. Matze, E. Lammerts van Bueren, T. Baars. 2003. The Role of the Concept of Nature (Naturalness) in Organic Farming. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 16: 29–49

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Veysset, P., P. Wallet, and E. Prugnard, “Automatic milking systems: characterizing the farms equipped with AMS, impact and economic simulations” in A. Rosati, S. Mihina, and C. Mosconi (eds.), ICAR Technical Series 7, Rome, Italy (2001), pp. 141–150

  • Water, C., Economische resultaten geven reden tot zorg [Economic Results Give Reason to Worry] (2002). On request from Dutch extension service http://www.dlv.nl

Download references

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

  1. Department of Agricultural Engineering, University of Aarhus, Research Centre Bygholm, 8700, Horsens, Denmark

    Frank W. Oudshoorn, Reint Jan Renes & Imke J. M. De Boer

Authors
  1. Frank W. Oudshoorn
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

  2. Reint Jan Renes
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

  3. Imke J. M. De Boer
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Frank W. Oudshoorn.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Oudshoorn, F.W., Renes, R.J. & De Boer, I.J.M. Systems In Organic Dairy Production. J Agric Environ Ethics 21, 205–228 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-007-9082-5

Download citation

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-007-9082-5

Keywords

Search

Navigation