Abstract
Phytoremediation can be accelerated if contaminated soils are amended with releasing agents. We tested four such materials, citric acid (CA), EDTA, oxalic acid (OA), and tartaric acid (TA) at two doses, 20 and 40 mmol kg−1, amended in a pot experiment to a heavily contaminated soil cultivated with purslane (Portulaca oleracea). We found that Cd extracted with DTPA remained unchanged in all treatments compared to the control except for the treatment of added EDTA at 40 mmol kg−1 (“EDTA-40”). Similar was the case with Cu, Pb, and Zn. As a consequence, Cd in the aboveground plant material increased significantly from 1.21 (control) to 3.84 at EDTA-40 and 3.55 at EDTA-20 (mg kg−1). Similar was the case with all other metals, with Pb exhibiting an impressive fivefold increase to 280.35 mg kg−1 at EDTA-40 from the control. We conclude that EDTA was the most successful releasing agent among those tested, especially for Pb and Zn. However, we come to the conclusion that, based on calculations of the required time to meaningfully reduce soil metals contents, phytoremediation is not a practical option for extremely metal-elevated soils. These findings should be verified under field conditions.
Similar content being viewed by others
Explore related subjects
Discover the latest articles, news and stories from top researchers in related subjects.Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
1 Introduction
Potentially toxic elements (PTEs) are collectively named those elements that may have toxic effects to plants if found at high contents in soil; among those, Cd, Cu, Pb, and Zn are very important, as half of them are also essential nutrients (Cu and Zn), while Cd and Pb do not have any known physiological functions in plants (Zhao et al. 2023). Metals like those aforementioned are often found at elevated contents in soils affected by heavy industrial activities. One such case is Lavrio, an area in south Attica, Greece, renowned for its Ag and Pb, currently terminated, mining explorations since the 2nd millennium BC (Pappa et al. 2018). Such activities have led to extremities in PTE contents in soils around the wider area of Lavrio (Kalyvas et al. 2018), even in areas inside the town of Lavrio itself (Antoniadis et al. 2022). However high the total PTE contents may be, their availability is greatly dependent on a range of soil physicochemical properties. Although PTE mobility varies to a great extend depending on the nature and properties of soils, it is generally agreed that PTEs deposited over long periods of time (i.e., of centuries or even millennia) exhibit lower mobility compared to those deposited over short periods—a process related to the PTE ageing mechanisms in soil (Luo et al. 2023). Thus, in the case of Lavrio, although total PTE contents are extremely high, their mobility is rather mild or even low. In such case, a viable way of remediating PTE-contaminated soils may be to increase PTE mobility for their accelerated transfer from soil to plant through the process also known as phytoextraction (Lee et al. 2023). This can be achieved with the application to soil of organic substances of low-molecular weight; these low-molecular weight organic substances (LMWOSs) can be naturally occurring (most notable of which are citric, oxalic, and tartaric acids) or may be synthetic (of which, the most highly used is EDTA—ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid). In both cases, LMWOSs have the capability to bind metals to readily create polydentate (thus stable) chelates, which, if of sufficiently low-molecular weight, can be directly absorbed by plant roots, thereby increasing PTE availability (Shaheen and Rinklebe 2015; Zheng et al. 2022; Ahraz et al. 2022). The naturally occurring LMWOSs have two main sources in soil: (a) they are excreted from root tissues of non-stressed plants and tend to increase nutrient and PTE availability (Lu et al. 2021; Ghasemi-Fasaei et al. 2021); (b) they are the result of the decomposition of higher molecular weight organic substances due to microbial activity. The former typically occurs when plants absorb more cations than anions from the soil solution—the exudation of LMWOSs often function as the outcome of the balancing of charges of absorbed ions by plants. The latter is a process expected whenever there is an application of organic material to soil or when there is a flush of microbial activity, e.g., due to temperature increases. Whatever their derivation may be, natural LMWOSs are often found in higher concentration in plant rhizosphere than in non-rhizosphere (Yang et al. 2023). Also they are short-lived in soil, as they are readily decomposed further to simpler organic forms or they undergo a complete turnover into inorganic forms. The availability increase of PTEs depends on a series of factors such as the physicochemical nature of any given PTE, the physicochemical characteristics and contents of the organic substances, soil solution pH, plant species-specific responses, and other environmental conditions (Geng et al. 2020; Han et al. 2018; Singh et al. 2016; Wang and Mulligan 2013; Schwab et al. 2008).
Experimental data indicate that LMWOS-PTE complexes are highly soluble at high soil pH values (Walker et al. 2003). Hydroxylic and carboxylic groups of such organic substances can also be retained onto soil colloidal surfaces, clay minerals and organic matter, limiting the overall cation exchange capacity of soils, an effect that further contributes to the increased formation of organometallic complexes (Caporale and Violante 2016; Zhang et al. 2022). Thus, soil application of LMWOSs increases PTE mobility in the soil–plant interface and also their root-to-shoot translocation. The latter is possible due to the fact that PTE toxicity effects tend to be alleviated when PTEs are absorbed along with LMWOSs (Riyazuddin et al. 2022). Indeed, PTE complexes with LMWOSs exhibit lower toxicity to biomolecules found in the cytoplasm and the vacuoles compared to the toxicity induced by PTEs absorbed as free ions (Irtelli and Navari-Izzo 2006). For example, Solanum nigrum grown in an alkaline soil spiked with 50 mg Cd kg−1 and added with 20 mmol kg−1 of citric acid was found to increase biomass rather than decrease it (Gao et al. 2010). Similar results were reported for Iris halophila grown in a PTE-laden soil from mining activities treated with 10 mmol kg−1 of citric acid, which was found to have a 43% increase in aerial biomass compared to the control (Han et al. 2018). Sun et al. (2021) reported that the effectiveness of the LMWOSs differed greatly among them, with citric acid being the most effective, and oxalic or tartaric acids the least. As for EDTA, it often exhibits higher ability to increase PTE mobility over other LMWOSs (Sabir et al. 2014; Wu et al. 2003). However, the EDTA low-degradation rates in soil, combined with the limited EDTA sorption by soil colloids, may lead to environmental concerns due to increased risk of its extended leaching and plant uptake of PTEs (Ali et al. 2019; Nascimento et al. 2021). In addition, EDTA may lead to phytotoxic symptoms and negative effects on mycorrhizal and soil fungi populations (Grčman et al. 2001; Beltyukova et al. 2023). This is why there have been attempts to test degradable synthetic chelates, like iminodisuccinic acid (ISA) and glutamate–N, N–diacetic acid (GLDA) (Wang et al. 2020). Indeed, natural biostimulants and LMWOSs are rapidly decomposed in soils; therefore, their organometallic complexes are considerably more short-lived compared to EDTA (Ali et al. 2019; Wu et al. 2003; Grammenou et al. 2023). Although there is a lot of research concerning the fate of LMWOSs in forming complexes with PTEs, most of the reported work concerns research efforts where both PTEs and LMWOSs are spiked in the soils (e.g., Jalali et al. 2023). Thus, there is still much to be explored in regard to their effect in soils with extremely high non-spiked PTE contents, especially Cd, Cu, Pb, and Zn. The role of such organometallic complexes may be of high importance if used in phytoremediation programs for soils heavily contaminated with PTEs (Amin et al. 2018; Shaheen et al. 2023). Due to the fact that most of the research works deal with the effects of LMWOSs in soils where PTE have been spiked prior to the experimentation, there is still much to be elucidated for “real life” cases concerning soils already contaminated with PTEs, especially when dramatically enriched. In such cases, the effect of LMWOSs in altering PTE dynamics is not clear and needs to be evaluated.
Purslane (Portulaca oleracea) may be used both for human consumption and for non-food purposes (i.e., medicinal uses; Petropoulos et al. 2016; Subpiramaniyam 2021). Purslane growth in soils with elevated PTE contents has been tested in the past (Wei et al. 2005; Levizou et al. 2016; Javed et al. 2017; Elshamy et al. 2019). However, this species has never been tested in relation to PTE bioavailability in non-spiked soils where PTEs have been deposited over long periods of millennia and where PTE uptake is tested when LMWOSs are added with the aim of boosting their uptake. The aim of this work was to (a) study the bioavailability of Cd, Cu, Pb, and Zn in the soil–plant interface of a heavily contaminated soil; (b) assess the effectiveness of four LMWOSs as mobilizing agents (three of which naturally occurring—citric acid, oxalic acid, tartaric acid, and one synthetic—EDTA) for increasing the uptake of PTEs; and (c) evaluate purslane as a potential species to be used for the phytoremediation of this soil heavily contaminated with Cd, Cu, Pb, and Zn. By this study, there may be significant benefits concerning the exploration of phytomanagement programs of heavily contaminated soils with inorganic contaminants by a variety of soil end-users, such as soil practitioners, soil scientists, and policy makers.
2 Materials and Methods
2.1 Experimental Design, Plant Growth and Measurements
A pot experiment was established using a soil sampled from an olive field in the town of Lavrio (37.719311° Ν, 24.044154° Ε). The exact settings of sampling can be found in Antoniadis et al. (2022). The area is renowned for its historical (now discontinued) mining activities known to have commenced in ca. the 2nd millennium BC (Panagopoulos et al. 2009). These activities have resulted in extremely high pseudo-total contents in soil concerning Cd (measured in that specific spot as equal to 101.9), Pb (26,526.4), and Zn (17,652.6), while Cu was mildly elevated (181.6) (all values in mg kg−1). The soil was calcareous (CaCO3 7.9%), hence alkaline (pH 8.0; 1:2.5 H2O), and also light-textured (sand 79.6%, silt 11.6%, clay 8.8%—a loamy sand), with low organic C content (1.1%), and electrical conductivity of 192 μS cm−1 (analyses as per Rowell 1994). This heavily contaminated soil was transferred to the Laboratory of Soil Science in the University of Thessaly, where it was allowed to be air-dried. After this, it was passed through a sieve with openings of 5 mm, and 1000-g portions of it were placed into 2-L pots. A total of 90 pots were filled with this quantity of soil. The pots were then watered, and soil moisture in pots was kept constant with frequent water additions to 2/3 of the soil’s water holding capacity. Seeds of purslane (Portulaca oleracea) were planted in seedling trays filled with that same soil and watered regularly. After 25 days of planting, the vigorous seedlings were transplanted to the pots—one seedling per pot. The transplanting date was considered the first day of the experiment (21st of October 2020). The pots were placed in a greenhouse where they were protected from the elements, although light and temperature were not controlled. During the plant growth, pots’ positions were exchanged regularly to compensate for any differences in light and temperature. On Day 10 (the 30th of October 2020) of the experiment, NPK were applied at an equivalent rate of 200 kg N ha−1, 188 kg of P2O5 ha−1 and 212 kg of K2O ha−1 (accounting for effective rhizosphere depth of 15 cm and soil bulk density 1.33 g cm−3). On Day 40, an additional amendment equivalent to 100 kg N ha−1 was also dispensed to all treatments. On Day 45 of the experiment (5th of December 2020), commercially obtained low-molecular weight organic substances (LMWOSs; citric, oxalic and tartaric acids, and the synthetic chelate EDTA), were applied to the pots at two concentrations equal to 20 and 40 mmol kg−1 soil. For the application, solutions of 200 mmol L−1 of the four LMWOSs were prepared by solubilizing in four different flasks 38.42 g of citric acid (CA; C6H8O7), 18.01 g of oxalic acid (OA; C2H2O4), 30.02 g of tartaric acid (TA; C4H6O6), and 67.24 g of EDTA-Na2 (EDTA; C10H14N2O8.2Na.2H2O) per L of H2O. For the treatment of 20 mmol kg−1, 100 mL of these 200-mM solutions were applied per pot, while 200 mL were applied for the 40 mmol kg−1. Thus, the treatments are thereafter referred to as CA-20 (for citric acid added at 20 mmol kg−1), CA-40 (citric acid added at 40 mmol kg−1), and, similarly, OA-20 and OA-40 for oxalic acid at 20 and 40 mmol kg−1, TA-20 and TA-40 for tartaric acid at 20 and 40 mmol kg−1, and EDTA-20 and EDTA-40 at 20 and 40 mmol kg−1. Each treatment of the four agents at the two concentrations resulted in nine different treatments (i.e., control plus 4 agents × 2 concentrations) and was replicated 10 times, hence resulting in 90 pots. These PTE-mobilizing agents were applied relatively late in the growth experiment due to the fact that the naturally occurring LMWOSs are typically short-lived, so that their effect would be more evident to the plants (Meers et al. 2005). The added agents are highly soluble and thus homogenous distribution within the pots was not considered to be a problem.
The experiment ran until the 21st of December 2020, i.e., it lasted for 61 days. On the harvest day, plant height was recorded just before aerial plant tissues were cut with non-metallic scissors at the soil level and rinsed with distilled water. The aerial biomass was then harvested and placed in pre-weighed paper bags. Immediately after the aerial plant harvest, soil was also sampled taking three cores from top to bottom in each pot and then the three subsamples per pot were mixed together into one composite sample. Soil samples were placed into paper bags, taken to be air-dried (for 3–4 days), and then sieved through a 2-mm sieve. On the same day after the soil sampling, plant roots were also recovered by delicately rinsing all adhered soil particles from root hairs and placed into pre-weighed paper bags. All plant biomass (aerial and roots) were placed in a forced-draught oven at 70 °C for 2 days, after which the dry biomass was recorded.
Subsequently, Cd, Cu, Pb, and Zn were extracted and analyzed both in plant biomass and soil as follows: For the biomass (roots and aerial biomass), 1.0 g of pulverized plant tissue was dry-ashed at 500 °C for 4 h and extracted with 10 mL of 20% HCl (Jones and Case 1990). For the soil samples, there was a 2-h extraction with DTPA-CaCl2 in a 1:2 soil:solution suspension which was then centrifuged at 2000 rpm and filtered through a slow filter paper (Lindsay and Norvell 1978). In all plant and soil extracts, the four metals were measured with atomic absorption spectrophotometry (Perkin Elmer A330).
2.2 Secondary Indices
Based on the primary data, some indices were calculated as follows: (a) soil-to-plant transfer (transfer coefficient, TC), equal to metal content in plant aerial biomass over the metal pseudo-total content in soil (Antoniadis et al. 2017); (b) root-to-shoot translocation (translocation factor, TF), equal to metal content in aerial biomass over metal content in roots. For these two indices, values approaching, or exceeding, 1.0 are indications of the plant species being suitable to be used for phytoextraction (Yan et al. 2020). Moreover, we calculated metal uptake as follows: Uptake by the plant (units, mg of PTE in aerial biomass per pot or per kg soil), equal to the multiplication of PTE contents in biomass (in mg PTE kg−1 plant) with biomass yield (in g of plant per pot or per kg soil) divided by 103 for unit conversion from g to kg. Also, based on Uptake, the number of harvests of the aerial biomass in order to halve the pseudo-total soil content of PTEs (H1/2) was calculated, as follows: H1/2 = 0.5 × (pseudo-total soil PTE content, mg of PTE in soil per kg soil)/Uptake per harvest (mg of PTE in plant per kg soil per harvest).
2.3 Statistical Analysis and Data Quality Control
Data quality control was performed by systematically using blanks and soil and plant reference materials in each extraction batch. The percentage of recovery of the four extracted metals from the soil and plant reference materials ranged between 92 and 108%. All analyses were performed in triplicates and acceptable coefficient of variation was less than 15%. The primary data underwent a one-way ANOVA (analysis of variance). Such analysis was preferred because (a) of its simplicity, and (b) it provides sufficient in-depth information so that significant differences may be easily identified. The level of significance of 95% (p < 0.05) was selected after testing for the normal distribution and homogeneity of variances; also data underwent a Post-hoc analysis according to Duncan. In this analysis, the factor was the treatments of added LMWOSs and dependent variables of the soil and plant analyzed parameters.
3 Results
3.1 Purslane Growth Characteristics and its Cd, Cu, Pb, and Zn Contents in Aerial Parts and Roots
Plant growth parameters measured were height, and dry weights of the aerial biomass and roots of purslane (Table 1). As for the height, the various treatments did not affect it, as average values across amendments were found with non-significant differences, ranging from 20.25 cm (control) to 23.47 cm (at EDTA-40). Similar was the case with the aerial dry weight, where differences were marginal and non-significant (minimum was 0.472 g at control and maximum 0.656 g at EDTA-20). Root dry weight was similarly found to have no significant differences among treatments; they ranged from 0.124 g (control) to 0.174 g (OA-20).
Cadmium content in purslane roots was 10.72 mg kg−1 at control, and increased to 14.34 mg kg−1 at CA-20, although the difference was not significant. At OA-20 Cd content was decreased to 6.19 mg kg−1, significantly different from the control (Fig. 1). Copper in roots increased significantly from 9.49 mg kg−1 (the lowest, at control) to 15.18 mg kg−1 at CA-40, while all other treatments exhibited non-significant differences. Lead at control (215.03 mg kg−1) was the lowest and increased significantly to 425.87 mg kg−1 at CA-40, with all other treatments being non-significant compared to the control. In the case of Zn, its content at control was 344.34 mg kg−1, and had a significant 4.5-fold increase at CA-20 (1572.96 mg kg−1); Zn at control also differed significantly from that at CA-40 (1200.62 mg kg−1) and TA-40 (872.82 mg kg−1).
As for the content of Cd in the aerial parts of purslane, it was 1.21 at control, and it exhibited a significant increase at CA-40 (2.52), while it was 2.55 at EDTA-20, and 3.84 at EDTA-40 (all values in mg kg−1), with all other treatments having non-significant differences from the control (Fig. 1). Copper at control was 3.52, a value that exhibited significant differences only 2 to Cu at EDTA-20 (5.18) and EDTA-40 (5.19), with the two EDTA treatments having no differences between them (values in mg kg−1). Similar was the case for Pb, where the value at EDTA-40 (280.35) was fivefold higher than that at control (53.73), while that at EDTA-20 (187.66) was significantly different from both EDTA-40 and the control (values in mg kg−1). As for Zn, EDTA-40 was, similar to all other metals, the highest among the treatments with a value of 464.04, significantly higher from all other treatments; compared to the control (180.17), the treatments with significantly higher Zn content were CA-20, CA-40, and EDTA-20 (with values of 338.71, 329.47, 336.82, respectively) (all values in mg kg−1).
3.2 Soil Extractions of Cd, Cu, Pb, and Zn with DTPA
Soil extraction of available Cd with DTPA was 7.06 at control and exhibited a significant increase at EDTA-40 to 9.74 (values in mg kg−1; Fig. 2). No other treatment was significantly different from the control. As for Cu, EDTA-40 was the highest (3.61) and differed significantly from all other treatments, while the control (2.05, both values in mg kg−1), which was the lowest, also differed from all other treatments. Lead extraction at control equalled 607.35; the only two treatments with significant differences were those of EDTA-20 (997.55) and EDTA-40 (1356.75); the two EDTA treatments were also different between each other (values in mg kg−1). Similar to the previous metals, DTPA-extractable Zn had its highest value at EDTA-40 (662.00) and was significantly different from all other treatments. Zinc at control (254.130) was the lowest (units in mg kg−1).
3.3 Soil and Plant Indices
The index of the soil-to-plant transfer of Cd (TC) was the highest at EDTA-40 (37.7 × 10–3; unitless), significantly different from the control (11.9 × 10–3—the lowest among the Cd TC values), and all other treatments except for EDTA-20 (Table 2). As for Cu, its TC at EDTA-20 and EDTA-40 were almost identical (28.5 × 10–3 and 28.6 × 10–3, respectively), and significantly higher from all other treatments, except for CA-40 and TA-40. Lead TC did not differ among any of the treatments, except for EDTA-20 (7.1 × 10–3) and EDTA-40 (10.6 × 10–3) which were significantly higher than the rest of the treatments. Zinc TC had a similar trend as the aforementioned metals, with EDTA-40 exhibiting the highest value (26.3 × 10–3) and that of control (10.2 × 10–3) being low and non-significant compared to most of the other treatments (more precisely, OA-20, OA-40, TA-20, and TA-40). When comparisons were made among metals across same treatments, Cd was found to be the metal with the highest TC value in 8 out of the 9 treatments and Pb the metal with the lowest TC in all treatments.
The TF for Cd revealed that the highest value was recorded at EDTA-40 (0.386), significantly higher from the control (0.130—the lowest), CA-20, and OA-40 (Table 2). Concerning the Cu TF, three treatments exhibited the highest values, EDTA-40 (0.539), TA-40 (0.518), EDTA-20 (0.504), while that of the control (0.362) did not have significant difference from these values. The Pb TF surpassed the threshold of unity at EDTA-40 (1.014), a value which was non-significantly different to that of EDTA-20 (0.878), but was significantly different from all other treatments. As for the Zn TF, the threshold of TF = 1.0 was surpassed in both EDTA treatments, with EDTA-40 having a TF = 2.017 and EDTA-20 a TF = 1.670; both values being significantly higher than all other treatments. When the four metals were compared across same treatments, it was revealed that Zn had the highest TF value compared to Cd, Cu, and Pb in almost all treatments, except for CA-20, CA-40, OA-40, and TA-40, where the differences among metals were non-significant.
Uptake of the four studied elements, an index combining metal contents and aerial plant biomass yield, showed that EDTA-20 (2.69) and EDTA-40 (2.41) had the highest uptake (units, μg of Cd in plant per pot or per kg soil), while all other treatments were lower and non-significant among them (Table 3). Likewise, Cu uptake was significantly higher at the two EDTA treatments compared to the other treatments (EDTA-20 = 3.93; EDTA-40 = 3.26 μg pot−1). Lead uptake was 174.92 μg pot−1 at EDTA-40 and 141.79 μg pot−1 at EDTA-20, both of which were significantly higher than all other treatments. Similar trends were also recorded for Zn uptake: that at EDTA-40 was the highest (299.68), significantly different from the control (the lowest—93.70), CA-40, OA-20, OA-40, TA-20, and TA-40 (units; μg pot−1). Based on the metal uptake data, we calculated the number of harvests needed to halve the pseudo-total metal contents (H1/2; Table 3). In all four metals, EDTA lowered H1/2 compared to the control: In Cd, however, all amendments were significantly lower from the control but without further differences among them. For Cu, H1/2 was 23 × 103 at EDTA-20 (the lowest), a significant ca. twofold decrease from the control (54 × 103). As for Pb, H1/2 at EDTA-40 exhibited a significant 6.5-fold decrease compared to the control (85 × 103 vs. 553 × 103), and Zn H1/2 showed a similar ca. threefold decrease at EDTA-40 compared to the control (with EDTA-20 being identical to EDTA-40).
4 Discussion
In soil, all studied PTEs exhibited an impressive increase in extractability, when the soil was amended with LMWOSs. In the case of Cd, it was EDTA-40 that caused a significant increase, while for Pb it was both EDTA-20 and EDTA-40 (Fig. 2). However, in the case of Cu and Zn, all amended LMWOSs were successful in increasing the extractability of these metals, not only EDTA as in the case of Cd and Pb. The causation of this effect, as explained by Jalali et al. (2023), may be twofold: (a) Decreased soil pH: the naturally occurring substances are of acidic character, causing a time-limited depression of soil pH, which in turn increases cationic element availability; (b) Formation of soluble and stable organometallic complexes: Increased complexation of the added LMWOSs with the studied PTEs can lead to enhanced solubility of cationic metals in the soil solution. The former effect has indeed been well documented in the literature (e.g., Shaheen and Rinklebe 2015; Yuan et al. 2007; Ding et al. 2014). This effect is also observed in batch sorption–desorption tests, routinely reporting enhanced desorption and reduced sorption of PTEs by soil in the presence of LMWOSs (Qin et al. 2004; Najafi and Jalali 2015). As for the latter effect, the extent that PTE bioavailability increases after LMWOS addition is associated to the number of their carboxylic groups found in their structure. Citric acid bears three carboxylic groups, while tartaric, malic or oxalic acids two carboxylic groups (Suherman et al. 2019; Ding et al. 2014). However, it is not only the number of reactive groups but also their dissociation constants in relation to soil pH: If soil pH is below the negative logarithm of their dissociation constant (pKa), then the carboxylic group is protonated, and thus inert. But if soil pH is above the given pKa, the carboxylic group is stripped from its H+, hence fully reactive. Citric acid’s three dissociation constants are pKa1 = 3.13, pKa2 = 4.76, and pKa3 = 6.40, while those of the oxalic acid are pKa1 = 1.27, pKa2 = 4.28, of malic acid pKa1 = 3.40 and pKa2 = 5.11, and of tartaric acid pKa1 = 2.98 and pKa2 = 4.34 (Jalali et al. 2023). This implies that in our alkaline soil, all carboxylic groups of all tested substances were fully deployed for PTE retention, thus for the formation of the organometallic complexes. EDTA, although it functions in a different way, is also known to have a pH-dependent behaviour, with its effectiveness being proportional to soil pH. In agreement with our findings, literature shows that EDTA is more potent than other, naturally occurring, substances, for increasing PTE bioavailability (e.g., as per Wu et al. 2003; Shaheen and Rinklebe 2015, reporting for Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Fe, Ni, Pb and Zn). The high complexation affinity of EDTA to Pb that resulted in the higher bioavailability increase compared to low molecular weight organic acids complexes with Pb that were characterized as relatively weak, was also stressed by Shaheen and Rinklebe (2015) and Shahid et al. (2012).
However, this effect is known to be short-lived: LMWOSs are readily decomposed in soil and pH values, hence PTE bioavailability, are restored back to the situation prior to LMWOS application (Macias-Benitez et al. 2020; Yin et al. 2018). For example, in a work by Macias-Benitez et al. (2020), it was reported that additions of LMWOSs up to 50 mmol kg−1 resulted in a pH reduction from 7.91 to 7.61 (for citric acid) and to 7.50 (for oxalic acid). In that same work it was reported that pH levels were restored back to the initial levels upon LMWOS decomposition: 50% of added LMWOSs were decomposed within only 5 days, while complete decomposition occurred 12 days after application. However, concerning EDTA, findings indicate extremely low decomposition (e.g., as per Bloem et al. 2017, who added 1500 kg EDTA ha−1, equivalent to, for comparison with our work, ca. 350 mg kg−1 or 1.20 mmol kg−1).
Purslane was chosen as a test plant due to the fact that it was previously used in other studies as a potential species for the phytoremediation of PTE-contaminated soils (e.g., Thalassinos et al. 2023 for Pb; Thalassinos et al. 2021 for Cr(VI); Levizou et al. 2016 for Cd and Zn). The contents of Cd, Pb, and Zn in purslane aerial biomass were very high in the untreated control due to the extremely high contents of these metals in soil; Cd was above 10 mg kg−1 in the roots at control and above 1 mg kg−1 in the aerial biomass. It is notable that expected contents of Cd in plants grown in non-contaminated soils is close to zero (Han et al. 2023). As for Pb, its plant contents were so high that are rarely seen anywhere in the literature. For example, in Antoniadis et al. (2021), where 12 plant species were tested for their phytoremediation capacity, no test plant achieved so high content of ca. 200 mg kg−1 in roots and ca. 50 mg kg−1 in the aerial biomass in the unamended control. Due to the fact that Pb is a non-essential element, its expected plant contents in aerial plant parts are also close to zero (Mazumder et al. 2023). The reason Pb was traced in aerial biomass is the extremely high-total Pb content in soil of 26,526.44 mg kg−1. Similar to Pb, Zn extreme soil content of 17,652.63 mg kg−1 led to contents in plant of ca. 200 mg kg−1 in the aerial biomass at control, a ca. fourfold higher value from the normally expected Zn contents of ca. 40–50 mg kg−1. Unlike these three metals, Cu contents in plant was rather at normal levels of less than 5 mg kg−1 in aerial biomass, a reflection of the metal’s relatively low soil content of 181.62 mg kg−1.
The added LMWOSs in this study were intended to serve as PTE-releasing agents, materials that increase the mobility of PTEs in soil. Due to the high-degradation rates of these substances, in phytoremediation projects LMWOSs should be applied when plants have developed their maximum biomass. At that point, the toxic effects to plants are limited and PTE uptake due to the increased bioavailability is maximized (Tariq et al. 2016). The addition of the four LMWOSs resulted in the increased contents of PTEs in both roots and shoots. In roots, (Fig. 1) citric acid caused an increase in Cu and Pb at 40 mmol kg−1, and that of Zn at both CA-20 and CA-40. As for the aerial biomass, citric acid increased Cd at 40 mmol kg−1, and, like the case of roots, it also increased Zn at both CA-20 and CA-40 (while it failed to affect Cu and Pb in the aerial biomass). Citric acid is one of the most potent LMWOSs, known to form organometallic complexes in soil, which are readily absorbed by roots. Our findings suggest that citric acid mostly favoured Zn, as it boosted its content in purslane in both roots and shoots and in both amended rates. The formed complexes are polydentate, hence stable, yet soluble in the soil solution. As for the oxalic acid, its effect in boosting PTE contents in purslane was less pronounced: in roots it only increased Cu at 40 mmol kg−1, and in aerial biomass Zn at 40 mmol kg−1. In the case of the tartaric acid, it only caused an increase in root Zn at 40 mmol kg−1, while in the aerial biomass it increased Zn at both 20 and 40 mmol kg−1. Thus among the naturally occurring LMWOSs, the most pronounced PTE-releasing effect was recorded for citric acid, followed by the tartaric and oxalic acids. The superiority of citric acid over other tested LMWOSs was also reported by Najafi and Jalali (2015), Zhang et al. (2022), and Almaroai et al. (2012) (vs. oxalic acid), by Wang et al. (2013) (vs. tartaric, malic and oxalic acids), and by Yang et al. (2020) (vs. oxalic and acetic acids). However, not all literature data are in agreement with our findings: Nworie et al. (2017) reported that oxalic acid was more successful in boosting As, Cu, Fe, Mn, Pb, and Zn availability over citric and malic acids. On the other hand, the behaviour of EDTA, a synthetic LMWOS frequently used in phytoremediation programs for boosting PTE content, was very characteristic in the sense that it did not affect any of the metals in roots (i.e., none of them increased compared to the control when EDTA was added), while in the aerial biomass all four PTE increased significantly at both EDTA-20 and EDTA-40. Especially at EDTA-40 in the case of Cd (with a ca. fourfold increase), Pb (ca. fivefold), and Zn (ca. twofold), the increase recorded was highly notable. Thus concerning the aerial biomass, EDTA seemed to be the most successful among the amended substances in boosting PTE aerial biomass content. The impressive recorded efficiency of EDTA to cause a fivefold increase in aerial tissue Pb content, as well as Cd, Cu, and Zn, has been previously reported in the literature (Chen et al. 2022; Macias-Benitez et al. 2020; Shinta et al. 2021; Gul et al. 2020). However, despite the increased ability of EDTA for PTEs, an effect that could lead to increased phytoremediation potential for a series of cationic elements, the low-degradation rates of EDTA may lead to increased PTE bioavailability for unpredictable long periods of time. This could cause environmental concerns associated with PTE leaching to ground water bodies or with undesirable uptake by a range soil organisms (Nascimento et al. 2021). In parallel to the increased availability of cationic elements after low-molecular weight organic acid application, increased activity of Zn/Fe transporters was noticed for the species Oryza sativa, leading to increased absorption of Mn2+, Fe2+, Cd2+, Co2+, Ni2+ and Zn2+ (Yang et al. 2022). However, for the LMWOSs exhibiting high rate of decomposition in soil (i.e., the naturally occurring substances), the increased bioavailability of PTEs is rather temporal (Macias-Benitez et al. 2020).
In contrast to EDTA, the naturally occurring substances are found in soil as a result of the decomposition of organic matter or as root exudates when there is an imbalance in the plant uptake of anions vs. cations from the soil solution (Jones 1998). When uptake of cations in equivalent mass (i.e., in mEq per mass soil or per volume of soil solution) surpasses that of anions, plants counter-balance this unstable situation by eluting back to soil substances functioning as the equivalent of proton (H+), i.e., organic substances of low-molecular weight of acidic reaction (Wang et al. 2013; Naidu and Harter 1998). Most usual such substances include, apart from the three used here, malic, fumaric, and succinic acids (Kozdroj and van Eisas 2000).
Although the amendment of the releasing agents resulted in increased PTE contents in purslane, its growth parameters (height and dry biomass of stems, leaves and roots; Table 1) did not seem to be affected negatively, due to the fact that plants have certain defence mechanisms against PTE exposure (Narayanan and Ma 2023). This suggests that the beneficial effects of the absorbed substances overcame any possible negative effects of boosted PTE contents, a finding also agreed by Thalassinos et al. (2023), in a work where the toxic effects of elevated added Pb to purslane was masked by generous additions of N, which boosted plant vigor. Plant height and tissue dry weight were not negatively affected by the LMWOS application. The absence of negative effects on plant growth could be attributed to the fact that metals often conjugate with low molecular weight organic acids and synthetic chelates that result in promoting the transport of complexed metal into the vacuole (Pinto and Ferreira 2015; Osmolovskaya et al. 2018; Sabir et al. 2014; Han et al. 2018; Zhang et al. 2018).
All the same, there seems to be a downside of the boosted plant uptake of PTEs: It can lead to limited uptake of nutrients from plants (as per Gul et al. 2020, who referred to Na, Ca, K, P, Mg, Zn, Fe, and Cu). YSL transporters mediate Ni, Zn, Cd, Mn, and Cu besides Fe transport. Especially for elements such as Cd and Zn, due to their similar physicochemical characteristics, common intake pathways are possible (Yang et al. 2022). Furthermore, high contents of Zn, Cd, Co, Ni, and Mn may significantly reduce Fe uptake from IRT1 transporter, and in many cases Fe low contents in plant tissues are accompanied with high Zn and Cd contents (Lešková et al. 2017). Similarly, Mn, Cd, and Zn contents may significantly affect Fe uptake due to the low selectivity of NRAMP and ZIP transporters (Fan et al. 2018). For plant species Arabidopsis thaliana and Populus glauca grown under Cd stress, limited Fe uptake was found to have led to Fe deficiency symptoms that were alleviated upon Fe supply (Solti et al. 2008; Hermans et al. 2011). In this work, however, Fe uptake did not seem to be significantly affected (data not shown).
Although added LMWOSs caused the aforementioned increase in plant PTE contents, the TC of any metal was found to fall far short from satisfying the criterion of approaching the unity (Table 2). Although TC values of all metals increased in most LMWOS additions, especially at EDTA-20 and EDTA-40, they were at least one order of magnitude lower than unity. There are two possible reasons for this behaviour: First, TC is associated with the total levels of soil PTEs: Although plant content increases with soil content, this increase is never linear; it is rather exponential, heading towards a “plant saturation” plateau as soil PTE contents increase, causing a decrease in TC at very high soil PTE levels (Levizou et al. 2016; Antoniadis et al. 2017). Thus at extreme soil PTE enrichment, such as the case here, TC cannot be expected to have a value anywhere close to unity. Second, the requirement of such high TC values are often dictated by, and is often found in, works where PTE are spiked to soil just prior to the commencement of the experimentation. In such cases, PTEs are highly mobile and are frequently found to cause plant toxicities (Thalassinos et al. 2023). However, in cases where PTEs have been deposited over long periods of time of centuries or even millennia (such as the case in our work), PTEs are expected to be gradually transferred to inactive and residual soil pools—an effect known as “PTE ageing” (Antoniadis et al. 2017). As for the TF, the requirement for a TF > 1.0 for a plant to be characterized as hyperaccumulator, was indeed achieved for Pb and Zn in the EDTA treatments: for Pb at EDTA-40 (1.014) and for Zn at EDTA-20 (1.670) and EDTA-40 (2.017) (Table 2). Such high values have previously been reported for Artemisia vulgaris (Antoniadis et al. 2021), but tested plants in that work were grown in a soil with a lot lower total soil PTE contents than in our study.
Although TC and TF are the main requirements for plants to be characterized as suitable species for phytoremediation, they have a certain shortcoming: they are solely content-related. However, our data suggest that there is a highly important “hidden” restrictive factor that is often overlooked: the produced plant biomass able to be harvested and taken away from the contaminated area. This was recorded in our case with uptake, an index incorporating, apart from content, plant biomass as well (Table 3). This analysis exhibited rather bluntly the apparent failure of the process of phytoremediation, especially in our soil with extremely high PTE soil levels: The number of harvests required to reduce soil content to half was beyond any consideration of practical applicability. This was evident even in the cases of Zn and Pb when added with EDTA, a treatment seemingly successful for these two metals concerning TF. The vast number of required harvests indicates the degree of the problem regarding scalability to real-field conditions; remediation solutions need to have a foreseeable horizon in time into which a viable ecosystem restoration concerning decreased contamination may be achieved—but this seems to fail as an ambition concerning phytoremediation. It also indicates a problem concerning the economic viability: the application of EDTA or other LMWOSs as a sprayed solution at field scale at rates such as those applied here (even if taken at 20 mmol substance kg−1 soil) would mean the necessity of the application of 23.4 t of EDTA ha−1—merely the cost of purchase of the substance would be in the area of half a million euros per hectare. Moreover, the possible longevity of added EDTA to soil may be undesirable, as it may result in secondary environmental burdens before EDTA is decomposed in soil: possible toxic effects of EDTA added at high doses should not be ruled out. This unwanted effect, as well as a possible leachability and persistent mobilization of PTEs with the chelates, especially synthetic like EDTA, may constitute a major drawback concerning its universal applicability (Zuluaga et al. 2023). Lastly, it also shows that it is far more practically viable for highly polluted soils to have a paradigm shift towards ecosystem phytomanagement rather than phytoremediation when dealing with ecosystem management. Phytomanagement would not aim at cleaning soils from PTEs with the use of cultivated plants, but rather to achieve high plant biomass yields of non-food plants. This is a more conservative management practice that would give sufficient income for the producers, and produced biomass would be targeting uses of industrial interest—a process that would also reduce the need for primary natural resources, as plant materials are considered as recycled matter.
5 Conclusions
In a soil with extremely high contents of Cd, Pb, and Zn, but mildly elevated in Cu, low-molecular-weight organic substances (LMWOSs), both of natural occurrence (citric, oxalic, and tartaric acids) and synthetic (EDTA), were amended to soil to facilitate PTE phytoextraction by purslane (Portulaca oleracea). In the case of Cd and Pb, soil extractability was increased only with added EDTA, while for the other two metals all added LMWOSs were successful in increasing their extractability. At plant level, added LMWOSs increased the aerial biomass contents of all PTEs at EDTA, while in the case of Zn all added LMWOSs were successful. Also the PTE root-to-shoot translocation was found to be higher than unity for Pb and Zn in the treatment of EDTA. Although such results seem to be promising, when “PTE uptake” (in units of PTE mass in plant per pot—an index incorporating plant biomass apart from soil and plant contents alone) was recorded, the shortcomings of the phytoremediation process were exhibited. Based on uptake, the harvests needed to reduce the dramatically high soil PTE contents to half were found to be beyond any practical consideration. Based on these findings, we come to a conclusion that bears significant environmental implications: There needs to be a paradigm shift in our demands of soils being cleaned from PTEs via phytoextraction, when soil PTE content is dramatically elevated, such as in the case of our study. Even if plants seem to achieve certain content-based criteria, such as those of TC and TF approaching or surpassing unity, the process may still be practically impossible. Instead, there should be an approach of acquiring phytomanagement, a much more viable process that generates income for producers and recycled plant biomass-based materials for certain biobased industrial volarization pathways. We consider this work as a first attempt to address this much needed paradigm shift; more research is certainly needed under real-field conditions and with the use of more plant species, soil improvers that would tend to stabilize, rather than release, soil PTEs, especially in soils dramatically elevated with such pollutants. Also tests should be conducted in soils with varying properties so that soil geochemical processes of PTEs may be better elucidated.
Data Availability
Data sets generated during the current study are available from the corresponding author upon request.
References
Ahraz U, Ahmad H, Shafqat H, Babar M, Munir HMS, Sagir M, Arif M, Hassan A, Rachmadona N, Rajendran S, Mubashir M, Khoo KS (2022) Remediation techniques for elimination of heavy metal pollutants from soil: a review. Environ Res 214:113918. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.2022.113918
Ali S, Bhattacharyya D, Sinha D, Paul M, Chaudhury S (2019) Evaluation of multiple applications of EDTA and LMWOAs on phytotoxicity and phytoextraction of Zn, Cd, Pb and Cu in soil with Tagetes sp. Indian J Soil Conserv 47:45–54
Almaroai YA, Usman ARA, Ahmad M, Kim K-R, Moon DH, Lee SS, Ok YS (2012) Effects of synthetic chelators and low-molecular-weight organic acids on chromium, copper, and arsenic uptake and translocation in maize (Zea mays L.). Soil Sci. https://doi.org/10.1097/SS.0b013e31827ba23f
Amin H, Arain BA, Abbasi MS, Jahangir TM, Amin F (2018) Potential for phytoextraction of Cu by Sesamum indicum L. and Cyamopsis tetragonoloba L.: a green solution to decontaminate soil. Earth Syst Environ 2:133–143. https://doi.org/10.1007/s41748-018-0038-x
Antoniadis V, Levizou E, Shaheen SM, Ok YS, Sebastian A, Baum C, Prasad MNV, Wenzel WW, Rinklebe J (2017) Trace elements in the soil-plant interface: phytoavailability, translocation, and phytoremediation—a review. Earth-Sci Rev 171:621–645. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.earscirev.2017.06.005
Antoniadis V, Shaheen SM, Stärk H-J, Wennrich R, Levizou E, Merbach I, Rinklebe J (2021) Phytoremediation potential of twelve wild plant species for toxic elements in a contaminated soil. Environ Int 146:106233. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envint.2020.106233
Antoniadis V, Thalassinos G, Levizou E, Wang J, Wang S, Shaheen S, Rinklebe J (2022) Hazardous enrichment of toxic elements in soils and olives in the urban zone of Lavrio, Greece, a legacy, millennia-old silver/lead mining area and related health risk assessment. J Hazard Mater 434:128906. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2022.128906
Beltyukova M, Kuryntseva P, Galitskaya P, Selivanovskaya S, Brusko V, Dimiev A (2023) Biodegradation rate of EDTA and IDS and their metal complexes. Horticulturae 9:623. https://doi.org/10.3390/horticulturae9060623
Bloem E, Haneklaus S, Haensch R, Schnug E (2017) EDTA application on agricultural soils affects microelement uptake of plants. Sci Total Environ 577:166–173. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.10.153
Caporale AG, Violante A (2016) Chemical processes affecting the mobility of heavy metals and metalloids in soil environments. Curr Pollut Rep 2:15–27. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40726-015-0024-y
Chen L, Beiyuan J, Hu W, Zhang Z, Duan C, Cui Q, Zhu X, He H, Huang X, Fang L (2022) Phytoremediation of potentially toxic elements (PTEs) contaminated soils using alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.): a comprehensive review. Chemosphere 293:133577. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2022.133577
Ding YZ, Song ZG, Feng RW, Guo JK (2014) Interaction of organic acids and pH on multi-heavy metal extraction from alkaline and acid mine soils. Int J Environ Sci Technol 11:33–42. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13762-013-0433-7
Elshamy M, Heikal YM, Bonanomi G (2019) Phytoremediation efficiency of Portulaca oleracea L. naturally growing in some industrial sites, Dakahlia District, Egypt. Chemosphere 225:678–687. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2019.03.099
Fan W, Liu C, Cao B, Qin M, Long D, Xiang Z, Zhao A (2018) Genome-wide identification and characterization of four gene families putatively involved in cadmium uptake, translocation and sequestration in mulberry. Front Plant Sci 9:879. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2018.00879
Gao Y, Miao C, Mao L, Zhou P, Jin Z, Shi W (2010) Improvement of phytoextraction and antioxidative defense in Solanum nigrum L. under cadmium stress by application of cadmium-resistant strain and citric acid. J Hazard Mater 181:771–777. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2010.05.080
Geng H, Wang F, Yan C, Tian Z, Chen H, Zhou B, Yuan R, Yao J (2020) Leaching behavior of metals from iron tailings under varying pH and low-molecular-weight organic acids. J Hazard Mater 383:121136. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2019.121136
Ghasemi-Fasaei R, Paridar Z, Ronaghi A (2021) The role of low molecular weight organic acids in release kinetics of zinc and cadmium in polluted calcareous soil in the presence of fish scales derivatives. Chem Ecol 37:50–63. https://doi.org/10.1080/02757540.2020.1849153
Grammenou A, Petropoulos SA, Thalassinos G, Rinklebe J, Shaheen SM, Antoniadis V (2023) Biostimulants in the soil–plant interface: agro-environmental implications—a review. Earth Syst Environ 7:583–600. https://doi.org/10.1007/s41748-023-00349-x
Grčman H, Velikonja-Bolta Š, Vodnik D, Kos B, Leštan D (2001) EDTA enhanced heavy metal phytoextraction: metal accumulation, leaching and toxicity. Plant Soil 235:105–114. https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1011857303823
Gul I, Manzoor M, Kallerhoff J, Arshad M (2020) Enhanced phytoremediation of lead by soil applied organic and inorganic amendments: Pb phytoavailability, accumulation and metal recovery. Chemosphere 258:127405. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.127405
Han Y, Zhang L, Gu J, Zhao J, Fu J (2018) Citric acid and EDTA on the growth, photosynthetic properties and heavy metal accumulation of Iris halophila Pall. cultivated in Pb mine tailings. Int Biodeter Biodegr 128:15–21. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ibiod.2016.05.011
Han R, Wang Z, Wang S, Sun G, Xiao Z, Hao Y, Nriagu J, Teng HH, Li G (2023) A combined strategy to mitigate the accumulation of arsenic and cadmium in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Sci Total Environ 896:165226. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2023.165226
Hermans C, Chen J, Coppens F, Inze D, Verbruggen N (2011) Low magnesium status in plants enhances tolerance to cadmium exposure. New Phytol 192:428–436. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-8137.2011.03814.x
Irtelli B, Navari-Izzo F (2006) Influence of sodium nitrilotriacetate (NTA) and citric acid on phenolic and organic acids in Brassica juncea grown in excess of cadmium. Chemosphere 65:1348–1354. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2006.04.014
Jalali M, Jalali M, Antoniadis V (2023) The release of Cd, Cu, Fe, Mn, Ni, Pb, and Zn from clay loam and sandy loam soils under the influence of various organic amendments and low-molecular-weight organic acids. J Hazard Mater 459:132111. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2023.132111
Javed MT, Akram MS, Habib N, Tanwir K, Ali Q, Niazi NK, Gul H, Iqbal N (2017) Deciphering the growth, organic acid exudations, and ionic homeostasis of Amaranthus viridis L. and Portulaca oleracea L. under lead chloride stress. Environ Sci Pollut Res 25:2958–2971. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-017-0735-2
Jones DL (1998) Organic acids in the rhizosphere—a critical review. Plant Soil 205:25–44. https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1004356007312
Jones JBJ, Case VW (1990) Chapter 15 “sampling, handling, and analyzing.” In: Westerman RL (ed) Soil testing and plant analysis. Soil Science Society of America Inc., Madison, pp 389–427
Kalyvas G, Gasparatos D, Papassiopi N, Massas I (2018) Topsoil pollution as ecological footprint of historical mining activities in Greece. Land Degrad Dev 29:2025–2035. https://doi.org/10.1002/ldr.2963
Kozdroj J, van Elsas JD (2000) Response of the bacterial community to root exudates in soil polluted with heavy metals assessed by molecular and cultural approaches. Soil Biol Biochem 32:1405–1417. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0038-0717(00)00058-4
Lee Y-Y, Lee SY, Cho K-S (2023) Long-term comparison of the performance of biostimulation and phytoextraction in soil contaminated with diesel and heavy metals. Chemosphere 337:139332. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2023.139332
Lešková A, Giehl R, Hartmann A, Fargašová A, von Wirén N (2017) Heavy metals induce iron deficiency responses at different hierarchic and regulatory levels. Plant Physiol 174:1648–1668. https://doi.org/10.1104/pp.16.01916
Levizou E, Antoniadis V, Papatheodorou S (2016) Without exceeding the limits: industrial soil rich in Zn and Cd has no effect on purslane and lettuce but promotes geranium growth. Environ Earth Sci 75:1256. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12665-016-6070-y
Lindsay WL, Norvell WA (1978) Development of a DTPA soil test for zinc, iron, manganese and copper. Soil Sci Soc Am J 42:421–428. https://doi.org/10.2136/sssaj1978.03615995004200030009x
Lu H, Qiao D, Han Y, Zhao Y, Bai F, Wang Y (2021) Low molecular weight organic acids increase Cd accumulation in sunflowers through increasing Cd bioavailability and reducing Cd toxicity to plants. Minerals 11:243. https://doi.org/10.3390/min11030243
Luo H, Tu C, He D, Zhang A, Sun J, Li J, Xu J, Pan X (2023) Interactions between microplastics and contaminants: a review focusing on the effect of aging process. Sci Total Environ 899:165615. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2023.165615
Macias-Benitez S, Garcia-Martinez AM, Caballero Jimenez P, Gonzalez JM, Tejada Moral T, Parrado Rubio J (2020) Rhizospheric organic acids as biostimulants: monitoring feedbacks on soil microorganisms and biochemical properties. Front Plant Sci 11:633. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2020.00633
Mazumder P, Dash S, Khwairakpam M, Kalamdhad AS (2023) Ecological and health risk assessment associated with translocation of heavy metals in Lycopersicum esculentum from farmland soil treated with different composts. J Environ Manag 344:118577. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2023.118577
Meers E, Ruttens A, Hopgood MJ, Samson D, Tack FM (2005) Comparison of EDTA and EDDS as potential soil amendments for enhanced phytoextraction of heavy metals. Chemosphere 58:1011–1022. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2004.09.047
Naidu R, Harter RD (1998) Effect of different organic ligands on cadmium sorption by and extractability from soils. Soil Sci Soc Am J 62:644–650. https://doi.org/10.2136/sssaj1998.03615995006200030014x
Najafi S, Jalali M (2015) Effects of organic acids on cadmium and copper sorption and desorption by two calcareous soils. Environ Monit Assess 187:585. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10661-015-4804-z
Narayanan M, Ma Y (2023) Metal tolerance mechanisms in plants and microbe-mediated bioremediation. Environ Res 222:115413. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.2023.115413
Nascimento CWA, Biondi CM, Silva FBV, Lima LHV (2021) Using plants to remediate or manage metal polluted soils: an overview on the current state of phytotechnologies. Acta Scientiarum Agron 43:e58283. https://doi.org/10.4025/actasciagron.v43i1.58283
Nworie OE, Qin J, Lin C (2017) Differential effects of low-molecular-weight organic acids on the mobilization of soil-borne arsenic and trace metals. Toxics 5:18. https://doi.org/10.3390/toxics5030018
Osmolovskaya N, Dung VV, Kuchaeva L (2018) The role of organic acids in heavy metal tolerance in plants. Biol Commun 63:9–16. https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu03.2018.103
Panagopoulos I, Karayannis A, Adam K, Aravossis K (2009) Application of risk management techniques for the remediation of an old mining site in Greece. Waste Manag 29:1739–1746. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wasman.2008.11.017
Pappa FK, Tsabaris C, Patiris DL, Androulakaki EG, Eleftheriou G, Betsou G, Michalopoulou V, Kokkoris M, Vlastou R (2018) Historical trends and assessment of radionuclides and heavy metals in sediments near an abandoned mine, Lavrio, Greece. Environ Sci Pollut Res 25:30084–30100. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-018-2984-0
Petropoulos S, Karkanis A, Martins N, Ferreira ICFR (2016) Phytochemical composition and bioactive compounds of common purslane (Portulaca oleracea L.) as affected by crop management practices. Trends Food Sci Technol 55:1–10. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tifs.2016.06.010
Pinto E, Ferreira IMPLVO (2015) Cation transporters/channels in plants: tools for nutrient biofortification. J Plant Physiol 179:64–82. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jplph.2015.02.010
Qin F, Shan X, Wei B (2004) Effects of low-molecular-weight organic acids and residence time on desorption of Cu, Cd, and Pb from soils. Chemosphere 57:253–263. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2004.06.010
Riyazuddin R, Nisha N, Ejaz B, Khan MIR, Kumar M, Ramteke PW, Gupta R (2022) A comprehensive review on the heavy metal toxicity and sequestration in plants. Biomol 12:43. https://doi.org/10.3390/biom12010043
Rowell DL (1994) Soil science: methods and applications. Longman Group UK Ltd., London
Sabir M, Hanafi MM, Zia-Ur-Rehman M, Ahmad SR, Hakeem KR, Aziz T (2014) Comparison of low-molecular-weight organic acids and ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid to enhance phytoextraction of heavy metals by maize. Commun Soil Sci Plant Anal 45:42–52. https://doi.org/10.1080/00103624.2013.848879
Schwab AP, Zhu DS, Banks MK (2008) Influence of organic acids on the transport of heavy metals in soil. Chemosphere 72:986–994. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2008.02.047
Shaheen SM, Rinklebe J (2015) Phytoextraction of potentially toxic elements by Indian mustard, rapeseed, and sunflower from a contaminated riparian soil. Environ Geochem Health 37:953–967. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10653-015-9718-8
Shaheen SM, Mosa A, Natasha JPGSA, Hassan NEE, Yang X, Antoniadis V, Li R, Wang J, Zhang T, Niazi NK, Shahid M, Sharma G, Alessi DS, Vithanage M, Hseu Z-Y, Sarmah AK, Sarkar B, Zhang Z, Hou D, Gao B, Wang H, Bolan N, Rinklebe J (2023) Pros and cons of biochar to soil potentially toxic element mobilization and phytoavailability: environmental implications. Earth Syst Environ. https://doi.org/10.1007/s41748-022-00336-8
Shahid M, Pinelli E, Dumat C (2012) Review of Pb availability and toxicity to plants in relation with metal speciation; role of synthetic and natural organic ligands. J Hazard Mater 220:1–12. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2012.01.060
Shinta YC, Zaman B, Sumiyati S (2021) Citric acid and EDTA as chelating agents in phytoremediation of heavy metal in polluted soil: a review. IOP Conf Ser Earth Environ Sci 896:012023. https://doi.org/10.1088/1755-1315/896/1/012023
Singh S, Parihar P, Singh R, Singh VP, Prasad SM (2016) Heavy metal tolerance in plants: role of transcriptomics, proteomics, metabolomics, and ionomics. Front Plant Sci 6:1143. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2015.01143
Solti A, Gáspár L, Mészáros I, Szigeti Z, Lévai L, Sárvári E (2008) Impact of iron supply on the kinetics of recovery of photosynthesis in Cd-stressed poplar (Populus glauca). Ann Bot 102:771–782. https://doi.org/10.1093/aob/mcn160
Subpiramaniyam S (2021) Portulaca oleracea L. for phytoremediation and biomonitoring in metal-contaminated environments. Chemosphere 280:130784. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2021.130784
Suherman M, Rosyidah AK, Suratman A, Aprilita NH, Morita M, Morita K (2019) Study of chromium desorption from polluted soil around tannery industry: effect of low molecular weight organic acid (LMWOA). Rasayan J Chem 12:1279–1286. https://doi.org/10.31788/RJC.2019.1235203
Sun Y, Luo T, Zhong S, Zhou F, Zhang Y, Ma Y, Fu Q (2021) Long-term effects of low-molecular-weight organic acids on remobilization of Cd, Cr, Pb, and As in alkaline coastal wetland soil. Environ Pollut Bioavail 33:266–277. https://doi.org/10.1080/26395940.2021.1982406
Tariq SR, Ashraf A (2016) Comparative evaluation of phytoremediation of metal contaminated soil of firing range by four different plant species. Arab J Chem 9:806–814. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.arabjc.2013.09.024
Thalassinos G, Nastou E, Petropoulos SA, Antoniadis V (2021) Nitrogen effect on growth-related parameters and evaluation of Portulaca oleracea as a phytoremediation species in a Cr(VI)-spiked soil. Horticulturae 7:192. https://doi.org/10.3390/horticulturae7070192
Thalassinos G, Petropoulos SA, Antoniadis V (2023) The response of purslane (Portulaca oleracea) to soil-added Pb: is it suitable as a potential phytoremediation species? Toxics 11:153. https://doi.org/10.3390/toxics11020153
Walker DJ, Clemente R, Roig A, Bernal MP (2003) The effects of soil amendments on heavy metal bioavailability in two contaminated Mediterranean soils. Environ Pollut 122:303–312. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0269-7491(02)00287-7
Wang S, Mulligan CN (2013) Effects of three low-molecular-weight organic acids (LMWOAs) and pH on the mobilization of arsenic and heavy metals (Cu, Pb, and Zn) from mine tailings. Environ Geochem Health 35:111–118. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10653-012-9461-3
Wang G, Pan X, Zhang S, Zhong Q, Zhou W, Zhang X, Wu J, Vijver MG, Peijnenburg WJGM (2020) Remediation of heavy metal contaminated soil by biodegradable chelator–induced washing: efficiencies and mechanisms. Environ Res 186:109554. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.2020.109554
Wang J, Lv J, Fu Y (2013) Effects of organic acids on Cd adsorption and desorption by two anthropic soils. Front Environ Sci Eng 7:19–30. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11783-012-0424-
Wei S, Zhou Q, Wang X (2005) Identification of weed plants excluding the uptake of heavy metals. Environ Int 31:829–834. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envint.2005.05.045
Wu LH, Luo YM, Christie P, Wong MH (2003) Effects of EDTA and low molecular weight organic acids on soil solution properties of a heavy metal polluted soil. Chemosphere 50:819–822. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0045-6535(02)00225-4
Yan A, Wang Y, Tan SN, Mohd YML, Ghosh S, Chen Z (2020) Phytoremediation: a promising approach for revegetation of heavy metal-polluted land. Front Plant Sci 11:359. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2020.00359
Yang X, Liu L, Tan W, Liu C, Dang Z, Qiu G (2020) Remediation of heavy metal contaminated soils by organic acid extraction and electrochemical adsorption. Environ Pollut 264:114745. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envpol.2020.114745
Yang Z, Yang F, Liu JL, Wu HT, Yang H, Shi Y, Liu J, Zhang YF, Luo YR, Chen KM (2022) Heavy metal transporters: functional mechanisms, regulation, and application in phytoremediation. Sci Total Environ 809:151099. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.151099
Yang J, Liu X, Fei C, Lu H, Ma Y, Ma Z, Ye W (2023) Chemical-microbial effects of acetic acid, oxalic acid and citric acid on arsenic transformation and migration in the rhizosphere of paddy soil. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf 259:115046. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoenv.2023.115046
Yin D, Wang Y, Jiang T, Qin C, Xiang Y, Chen Q, Xue J, Wang D (2018) Methylmercury production in soil in the water-level-fluctuating zone of the three gorges reservoir, China: the key role of low-molecular-weight organic acids. Environ Pollut 235:186–196. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envpol.2017.12.072
Yuan S, Xi Z, Jiang Y, Wan J, Wu C, Zheng Z, Lu X (2007) Desorption of copper and cadmium from soils enhanced by organic acids. Chemosphere 68:1289–1297. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2007.01.046
Zhang X, Zhong B, Shafi M, Guo J, Liu C, Guo H, Peng D, Wang Y, Liu D (2018) Effect of EDTA and citric acid on absorption of heavy metals and growth of Moso bamboo. Environ Sci Pollut Res 25:18846–18852. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-018-2040-0
Zhang H, Zhang R, Lu T, Qi W, Zhu Y, Lu Y, Qi Z, Chen W (2022) Enhanced transport of heavy metal ions by low-molecular-weight organic acids in saturated porous media: link complex stability constants to heavy metal mobility. Chemosphere 290:133339. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2021.133339
Zhao X, Joo JC, Du D, Li G, Kim GY (2023) Modelling heavy-metal phytoextraction capacities of Helianthus annuus L. and Brassica napus L. Chemosphere 337:139341. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2023.139341
Zheng Y, Lu J, Zhang Z, Li Y, Tan Y, Cai W, Ma C, Chen F (2022) Effect of low-molecular organic acids on the migration characteristics of nickel in reclaimed soil from the Panyi mine area in China. Toxics 10:798. https://doi.org/10.3390/toxics10120798
Zuluaga MYA, Cardarelli M, Rouphae Y, Cesco S, Pii Y, Colla G (2023) Iron nutrition in agriculture: from synthetic chelates to biochelates. Sci Hortic 312:111833. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scienta.2023.111833
Acknowledgements
The third and fourth authors acknowledge the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) who funded their contribution (Project ID: 01DH20006) in the frame of the same PRI-MA project (PRI-MA/0009/2019).
Funding
Open access funding provided by HEAL-Link Greece. The authors declare that no funds, grants, or other support were received during the preparation of this manuscript.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
GT: Performed the experiments, conducted the investigation, analysis, and data collection, methodology, and wrote the draft of the manuscript. EL: Supervision, data analysis, editing. JR: Review, editing, and proof reading. SMS: Review, editing, and proof reading. VA: Supervising, experimental guiding, technical facilities, foundation, writing, corrections and amendments on the manuscript, editing, proof reading, and corresponding author.
Corresponding authors
Ethics declarations
Conflict of Interest
On behalf of all authors, the corresponding author states that there is no conflict of interest. The authors have no relevant financial or non-financial interests to disclose.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Thalassinos, G., Levizou, E., Rinklebe, J. et al. Enhancing the Phytoextraction of Cd, Cu, Pb, and Zn by Portulaca oleracea in a Heavily Contaminated Soil Using Low Molecular Weight Organic Substances: Is Phytoremediation Viable?. Earth Syst Environ 8, 923–936 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/s41748-024-00386-0
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s41748-024-00386-0