In this Swedish cohort of geriatric patients hospitalized with or without COVID-19, older adults with COVID-19 had a higher incidence of AKI compared to those without COVID-19 who were hospitalized with other diagnoses. COVID-19 infection and poor baseline kidney function are risk factors for AKI during hospitalization. Furthermore, we demonstrated that AKI was associated with higher in-hospital death in both COVID-19 and non-COVID-19 patients.
In our cohort, 29% of older adults with COVID-19 developed AKI during hospitalization, which is a higher proportion than was published for cohorts from China [13, 16], less pronounced compared to patients from the USA [14, 15] and from intensive care units [4, 9]. In one study from China that collectively included 701 COVID-19 cases with a median age of 63 years, the incidence of AKI was only 5.1% [16]. Another Chinese study showed that in 882 older COVID-19 patients with a median age of 71 years, consisting of 50% men, 13% developed AKI [13]. Our 29% incidence of AKI is lower than what has been reported in studies from the USA. In two studies involving 14 hospitals in New York that included 5,800 individuals, median age 64–71 years, 56–61% males, admitted with COVID-19, AKI occurred in 37% and 55%, respectively [14, 15]. In addition, a recent meta-analysis among patients admitted to the ICU showed that the pooled AKI events were 29.2% (4330 patients from 23 studies) [4]. The discrepancy between these reports and our study might be explained by differences in patient population, geographic location and guidelines regarding hospital admission. In our study, the proportion of COVID-19 patients with AKI stage 2 or 3 was higher compared to patients with other diagnoses. In this population none of the patients in AKI stage 3 received renal replacement therapy ([RRT], e.g., dialysis). This may have been due to either transient AKI which improved before the patients met indications for dialysis or, more likely, to the fact that the treating physicians chose not to send older patients to dialysis because it was deemed futile in view of their serious general conditions. Whether these differences in AKI incidence among studies reflect differences in severity of COVID-19 is not clear. In the early spring in Stockholm, with exponentially increasing numbers of COVID-19 patients needing hospital care, the geriatric clinics played an important role in treating, administering and upholding care guidelines for geriatric patients with COVID-19 and many severe patients were admitted to geriatrics units. Another explanation could be that the different age among studies. Patients admitted for COVID-19 in our study and in US studies tended to be older compared to patients from China [29]. In addition, the pattern of comorbidities differed in our geriatric population compared to populations elsewhere; the 40% rate of hypertension, 37% of diabetes, and 16% of COPD in our cohort were much higher than in cohorts from China (33%, 14% and 1.9% respectively) [16]. This could suggest that management of comorbidities will play a large role in preventing AKI during hospitalization.
We found that COVID-19 infection and reduced baseline kidney function may be risk factors for the development of AKI. Several plausible mechanisms have been proposed to explain the link between COVID-19 and AKI. First, the kidney may be a target organ in COVID-19 because SARS-CoV-2 directly damage the kidney via the angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 (ACE2) pathway [6,7,8]. Studies of biopsy samples showed that the presence of SARS-CoV-2 particles in proximal tubule cells and podocytes may support this hypothesis [30, 31]. Second, complications including immune response dysregulation, hypercoagulability, acute tubular necrosis by dehydration, sepsis and hemodynamic instability in the course of COVID-19 infections outside the kidney are associated with AKI [32]. We report an association between the reduced baseline kidney function (assessed by eGFR) and the risk of developing AKI. However, our in-hospital “baseline” kidney function evaluation may have underestimated the risk of kidney function on AKI, and moreover, in our study it was not known whether renal dysfunction was caused by AKI or by a pre-existing chronic renal disease. Our results show similar magnitudes and are consistent with previous studies which also used the lowest in-hospital value of creatinine to calculate eGFR as baseline kidney function [14, 26]. However, the baseline kidney function in patients with AKI in our study was higher than in studies using admission values to estimate baseline kidney function [15, 16]. In addition, it is not yet known whether COVID-19 will increase the risk of CKD long-term in different populations. However in a study from New York among survivors with AKI needing dialysis, 30.6% remained on dialysis at discharge [33].
Our principal finding was that AKI in COVID-19 patients was associated with an eightfold higher in-hospital mortality rate compared to those who did not develop AKI in COVID-19. Moreover, the mortality risk after adjusting for age, gender, lab values, initial vital signs and medications was 80 times higher for those with COVID-19 and AKI, and 10 times higher for those withoutCOVID-19 and with AKI compared to patients without COVID-19 and without AKI. This result showed the same direction but larger magnitude than in several previous meta-analyses showing increased in-hospital mortality in patients with COVID-19 who developed AKI (pooled risk ratios 5–15) [4, 10,11,12]. However, these pooled risk ratios were based on the crude numbers, and our estimates were adjusted for many confounders and compared to non-COVID-19 and non-AKI. Our findings are also similar to other severe infectious diseases associated with AKI. One meta-analysis that collectively included 226 studies from 50 countries of critically ill patients with Influenza A(H1N1) reported a 36% incidence of AKI and 17–44% increased mortality [34]. A recent meta-analysis comparing different coronavirus infections showed that the incidence of AKI in severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) infection was only 6–16%, while AKI in patients with Middle East respiratory syndrome (MERS) coronavirus infection was as high as 27–49%. On the other hand, mortality after developing AKI was 80–90% in SARS and 60–70% in MERS [35]. In general, AKI mortality in COVID-19 in our study is higher than in H1N1 infection, but lower than in SARS or MERS.
Strengths and limitations must be considered when interpreting the results of the present study. The main strength was the inclusion of a relatively large sample of hospitalized older patients including both COVID-19 and non-COVID-19 patients, with a wealth of information concerning potential risk factors and confounders, as well as access to health records during the hospital stay. One important limitation of the study is that we had no information on baseline creatinine measurement prior to hospitalization. Instead, we used the lowest in-hospital creatinine value as the baseline creatinine in the analysis as a proxy for pre-hospital creatinine. We acknowledge that relying on the lowest in-hospital creatinine value may have led to under-estimation of the AKI events and, consequently, to overestimation of AKI-associated events, nonetheless the use of the lowest in-hospital creatinine has been proven to be appropriate and is widely used in many studies [14, 25, 26]. The lack of information on pre-hospital kidney function or urine tests is another limitation of the study. This makes it difficult to study COVID-19 in the special population with chronic kidney disease. In addition, information on the time of onset of peak creatinine was not available, but in clinical practice, treating hospitalized COVID-19 patients follow up of kidney function including repeated creatinine analyses is recommended within 1–7 days (Swedish clinical guidelines published by the Swedish Infectious disease association https://www.internetmedicin.se/behandlingsoversikter/infektion/covid-19/). We acknowledge that the lack of RRT in AKI stage 3 may add a confounding bias in the association of AKI and mortality. Another limitation is that we do not have data on long-term mortality and therefore have reported only in-hospital deaths. The mortality rate may therefore be underestimated. COVID-19 in geriatric patients with a longer follow-up is planned in future studies. Finally, as in all observational and register-based analyses, we acknowledge the possibility of residual and unknown confounders such as socio-economic status and body mass index.