Long-Term Persistence of Antibody Response with Two Doses of Inactivated Hepatitis A Vaccine in Children

Abstract

Introduction

Hepatitis A virus infection is more severe in adults than children. Although vaccination can protect adults, current childhood programs cover a large population more successfully. Childhood vaccination is, therefore, a solution to protecting adults if it induces lasting immunity. Fifteen-year protection has been demonstrated in children, but longer-term data are only available for adults. We aimed to predict long term persistence of antibody in children beyond 15 years and assess if immunological mechanisms triggered by vaccination support longer-term protection.

Methods

Long-term clinical studies using hepatitis A (HAV) or A/B vaccines (HAB) containing 720 or 1440 Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay Units (EU) of hepatitis A virus antigen were identified. Duration of persistence of antibodies and possible protection was determined by descriptively comparing antibody geometric mean concentration (GMC) kinetics, as well as GMC (95% confidence interval) at 15 years post-vaccination across studies. Immunological mechanism studies describing hepatitis A vaccination were identified.

Results

One study in children 12–15 years (2-dose HAB 720) and four in adults (2-dose HAV 1440 and 3-dose HAB 720) showed comparable GMC kinetics and per year rates of change up to 15 years. At 15 years, the GMC in children [414.7 mEU/ml (336.9; 510.5)] was in the same range as in adults [range 282.6 (217.6; 367.0) to 550.1 (416.0; 727.4)]. Based on these data, mathematical model predictions from adult studies (showing > 85% protected at 50 years) were deemed likely to also apply to children. Studies identified, both humoral and cell-mediated responses are induced following vaccination.

Conclusion

Based on comparable antibody data in adults and children up to 15 years, similar longer-term antibody persistence is expected in children with 2-dose inactivated hepatitis A 720 containing vaccine at least up to 50 years. Accordingly, improving routine childhood hepatitis A vaccination coverage could protect against more severe disease in adulthood.

Trial Registration

ClinicalTrials.gov identifiers, NCT00875485, NCT01000324, NCT01037114, NCT00289757, NCT00291876.

Video: (MP4 39075 kb)

Introduction

The Global Burden of Disease Study 2013 identified viral hepatitis as an increasing leading cause of death (10th in 1990 to 7th in 2013). Worldwide, viral hepatitis deaths increased by 63% and disability-adjusted life-years by 34% from 1990 to 2013, with most of the burden in east and south Asia. While age-specific rates tended to decline, the absolute burden of disease increased due to population growth and changing age structures. With the availability of effective vaccines and other non-pharmaceutical measures, much can still be done to improve public health [1]. Although hepatitis A is a vaccine-preventable disease, its incidence increased by 4.2% between 2005 and 2015, to 114.2 million cases worldwide [2].

Hepatitis A virus infection is typically asymptomatic and self-limiting in children, but age is a risk factor, and more severe symptoms are common in older age groups who can take months to recover, with important societal and economic knock-on effects in affected communities. In parts of the world, hepatitis A endemicity is changing due to improved sanitary conditions, with fewer people being infected in childhood and thus reaching adulthood naïve to hepatitis A and at risk of more severe infection from epidemics. Improved sanitation, access to clean water, food hygiene and vaccination remain the most effective strategies to protect against this virus, and of utmost importance since no treatment option is available to date [3].

Across the globe, countries with routine hepatitis A mass vaccination programs have been successful in targeting children and achieving high coverage. Awareness in adolescents and adults, however, is low, even though they are at higher risk of more complicated severe disease if not immunised earlier in life. Vaccination in childhood, therefore, provides an opportunity for protection against hepatitis A in adulthood, providing the induced immune response lasts long enough [4]. Several well-tolerated, highly immunogenic and effective hepatitis A inactivated vaccines from GSK are available in various doses [360, 720 or 1440 enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay units (EU) of inactivated hepatitis A viral antigen] and schedules (2 or 3 doses), administered as a monovalent hepatitis A vaccine (HAV) or combination hepatitis A and B vaccine (HAB). The safety and immunogenicity of combined hepatitis A and B vaccine are comparable to those of the respective monovalent vaccines [5,6,7].

Long-term protection with inactivated vaccine has been demonstrated in follow-up studies of clinical trials in adults (17 years and older) [8, 9]. Long-term antibody persistence data in children has not been as widely studied. A study in Alaska comparing three-dose HAV 360 EU in various schedules in children aged 3–6 years found that, after 20 years follow-up, 88.5% had protective antibody concentrations, with modelling predicting protective levels at 30 years [10]. A study in China in children aged 1–8 years found that, after 11 years follow-up, the seroprotection rate was 100% with two doses HAV 720 EU, and modelling predicted that the duration of protection was at least 30 years [11]. A study comparing two doses HAB 720 EU (adult dose) with three doses HAB 360 EU (paediatric dose) in children aged 12–15 years found that 100% of subjects in both groups remained protected against hepatitis A and B after 15 years [12]. There is a need to further demonstrate the longevity of the immune response, but longer-term data are not available to date, and such long-term studies are costly and challenging to conduct. However, it may be possible to use existing data to predict longer-term outcomes. In the studies above, for example, mathematical modelling was used successfully to not only confirm the 20-year outcomes observed in the adult studies but also to predict longer-term protection outcomes in children and adult studies [8,9,10,11].

Vaccines can elicit humoral immunity (B cell/antibody response) as well as cell-mediated immunity (T cell response). The nature of the vaccine determines the resulting type of immune response. T cell-dependent responses can be elicited by toxoid, protein, and inactivated or live-attenuated viral vaccines, and they induce higher-affinity antibodies as well as immune memory. Long-term protection from vaccination requires maintenance of antibody concentrations above a given protective threshold and/or maintenance of immune memory cells that reactivate following subsequent exposure to the virus [13].

The objective of this study was to descriptively compare the immune response observed with the children versus adult hepatitis A dosing schedules, and, if comparable, to extrapolate the duration of antibody persistence in children based on existing long-term data in adults.

Methods

Identification of Studies with Long-Term Immunogenicity Data

To minimise external factors that could bias our findings, the descriptive analysis focussed only on GSK vaccines that are formulated using the same technology and for which long-term data are available.

A search of the GSK clinical studies (available from https://www.gsk-studyregister.com/en/) identified clinical studies of vaccines containing inactivated hepatitis A antigen, either as standalone HAV (Havrix; GSK, Belgium) or combination HAB (Twinrix; GSK, Belgium). Studies with at least 10 years of follow-up of antibody persistence data were included, as well as any longer-term follow-up of these studies using mathematical modelling [8, 9]. In order to extrapolate outcomes in children using data in adults, studies with data on adult vaccine doses of HAB 720 EU or HAV 1440 EU were selected. The group of subjects in the children study given paediatric doses of HAB 360 EU [12] was excluded as this dose is not used in clinical practice. Children were defined as anyone aged under 18 years old, as the recommended inactivated vaccination dose and schedule is the same for this age group.

All procedures in the studies involving human participants were performed in accordance with the Good Clinical Practice Guidelines, as defined by the International Conference on Harmonization, the Declaration of Helsinki and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards.

Investigating Comparability of Antibody Kinetics Across Dosing Schedules

Anti-hepatitis A antibody geometric mean concentrations (GMC, in mEU/ml) were calculated at various timepoints in each study (e.g. months and years since vaccination). The GMCs and the fold change in GMC (i.e. per year rate of GMC change, calculated as previous year GMC/current year GMC) were plotted by year since vaccination for each study. The first fold change is therefore computed by considering the GMC 1 month post-last dose (that is after dose 2 or 3) as previous year GMC. The kinetics in the plotted GMC curves and change curves over time for each study (and, by extension, for each dosage schedule) were descriptively compared, in order to extrapolate the longer-term antibody kinetics following two doses of HAB 720 EU in children.

Extrapolating Long-Term Persistence

Mathematical models have previously been published [8, 9] to confirm the long-term outcomes collected in studies on three doses of HAB 720 EU and two doses of HAV 1440 EU, as well as to predict longer-term outcomes with these vaccines from the individual patient data collected. In these studies, a linear-mixed model was used to predict long-term seropositivity rates after vaccination. The models were fitted with the individual trial population observed long-term immunogenicity data. The mean trend for observed antibody levels and calculation of the coefficient of simple determination (R²) and the D index of agreement were based on Hens et al. [14]. Data from subjects who received a booster dose or with obvious outliers (e.g. abnormal rise in titres following vaccination) were excluded from the model [8]. The proportion of seropositive subjects was estimated, and uncertainty assessed using non-parametric bootstrapping to obtain 95% confidence intervals. The Akaike Information Criterion was used for model selection. Goodness of fit was assessed using standard diagnostic tools for linear mixed models.

If the comparison of GMC data (described above) show kinetics similar in adults and children, the long-term antibody persistence in children with two doses of HAB 720 EU could be predicted, using the longer-term mathematical modelling results from adult data. If, at the 15-year follow-up, the GMC from the study in children is in the same range as the GMC intervals from adult studies, then longer-term predictions of the percent of seropositive subjects will be made for children based on longer-term model predictions for adults.

Figure 1 elaborates on the findings in a form that can be shared with patients by healthcare professionals.

Compliance with Ethics Guidelines

This article is based on previously conducted studies and does not contain any studies performed by any of the authors with human participants or animals.

Results

The search in the GSK database identified five studies with over 10 years of clinical data on vaccine containing hepatitis A antigen (Table 1) (NCT00875485, NCT01000324, NCT01037114, NCT00289757, and NCT00291876; www.clinicaltrials.gov): one study in children (two doses HAB 720 EU) with 15 years of clinical follow-up data [12], four studies in adults (three doses HAB 720 EU [9], and two doses HAV 1440 EU [8, 15, 16]) with up to 20 years of clinical follow-up. The adult studies also had longer-term immunogenicity data based on mathematical modelling predictions [8, 9]. The demographic details of the groups included in this descriptive analysis are presented in Table 1.

Table 1 Demographic characteristics of the subjects (TVC cohort)

Comparison of Antibody Persistence Across Different Dose Schedules

At 1-month post-schedule completion, GMC (mEU/ml) was 5313.5 (children 2-dose HAB 720); 6200.0 and 4620.1 (adult 3-dose HAB 720 studies); and 5243.0 and 3462.7 (adult 2-dose HAV 1440 studies). The GMCs remained over the protective threshold level of 20 mEU/mL until the end of the follow-up period across all studies in children and adults.

Figure 2 shows the anti-hepatitis A antibody GMC, by study and dose schedule, at each follow-up after primary vaccination. Higher and comparable GMCs 18-months post-completion of vaccination schedule are observed in all studies in children and adults. Across all studies, the GMC decrease over time follows a comparable trend and does not appear to differ significantly in the children study versus adult studies.

Fig. 2

Antibody geometric mean concentration by study (TVC cohort). There was a change in the assay used during follow-up (year 6 and year 11 for 3-dose and 2-dose adult studies, respectively). The cut-off used in the new assay differed, as seen by the peak in the graphs for these years. GMC geometric mean concentration, EU enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay units, HAB combination hepatitis A and B virus vaccine, HAV hepatitis A virus vaccine, TVC total vaccinated cohort

Figure 3 shows the fold change in antibody GMCs over time by study. There is an initial rapid decrease in GMC in the first years following vaccination, after which the rate of change per year reached a plateau that persisted until the end of each study’s follow-up period. The pattern for rate of change in antibody GMC appears to be very similar across children and adult studies and dosage schedules, and antibody GMCs appear to remain relatively constant in the long term.

Based on the similarities observed in Figs. 2 and 3 across children and adult studies with their respective dosing schedules, it appears very likely that the GMCs in the children dosing schedule would follow the same kinetics after 15 years as in the adult studies.

Fig. 3

Antibody geometric mean concentration fold change by study (TVC cohort). There was a change in the assay used during follow-up (year 6 and year 11 for 3-dose and 2-dose adult studies, respectively). The cut-off used in the new assay differed, as seen by the peak in the graphs for these years. GMC geometric mean concentration (enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay units), HAB combination hepatitis A and B virus vaccine, HAV hepatitis A virus vaccine, TVC total vaccinated cohort

Estimation of Persistence Based on Mathematical Modelling Data

Mathematical modelling was previously applied to the adult study data to predict longer-term persistence beyond 20 years. The models predicted that over 90% and over 85% of subjects would remain seropositive at year 40 and year 50, respectively, following 2-dose HAV 1440 EU vaccination [8]. Similarly, over 97% of subjects were predicted to remain seropositive at year 40 following 3-dose HAB 720 EU vaccination [9].

Table 2 shows the adult and children study data (GMC and 95% confidence intervals; CI) and model predictions at several timepoints post vaccination. Based on 15-year follow-up data, GMCs varied between 282.6 and 550.1 mEU/ml for adult studies. The children study GMC point estimate (414.7) appears to be comparable to two adult studies (i.e. fits within the 95% CI): a 3-dose HAB 720 and a 2-dose HAV 1440, and appears to fit in between the other two studies which had the highest and lowest GMC, respectively. Based on these findings and the similar kinetic trends above (Fig. 2, 3), it is likely that a mathematical model predicting longer-term outcomes for the children study would also predict findings at least comparable to the lower predictions made for the 2-dose HAV 1440 studies, namely > 85% remain protected after 50 years.

Table 2 Antibody geometric mean concentrations (95% CI) and model predicted % seropositive

Discussion

Vaccination remains a key means to prevent hepatitis A disease [3]. Childhood vaccination offering long-term protection provides a means to protect children as they grow into adolescents and adults, who are difficult to vaccinate in large numbers. With current practice, it is easier to vaccinate children, but moving forward a trend towards vaccinating adolescents and adults as part of healthy ageing would be welcomed. A long-term childhood vaccination study with inactivated hepatitis A vaccine showed 100% of subjects remained protected at 15 years follow-up after 2 doses of HAB 720 EU [10]. Long-term data from children in Argentina vaccinated with another 2-dose inactivated hepatitis A vaccine also found good long-term persistence, as 97.9% of children at the 10-year follow-up still had protective concentrations of hepatitis A antibody [17]. However, longer-term data beyond this are needed.

We found that antibody GMC trends from the study in children were comparable to those from studies in adults that used 3-dose HAB 720 EU and 2-dose HAV 1440 EU with 20-year follow-up and up to 50-year model-predicted outcomes. Based on the very similar GMC outcomes and 15-year trends across these studies, we conclude that childhood vaccination is likely to provide comparable longer-term protection that will extend to adulthood.

Both humoral and cell-mediated immune responses are induced after one dose of vaccine, and can be boosted after receiving a second dose, with cell-mediated immunity providing long-term protection regardless of decreasing antibody levels. The GMC trends over time showed that antibody levels tend to decline faster initially, which could be due to short-lived plasma cells. However, after a certain period, antibody GMC decline slows, due to long lived plasma cells that continue to produce antigen-specific antibodies [18]. This suggests that, even if antibody titres decline over time, vaccinated individuals coming into contact with hepatitis A virus will be able to mount an appropriate immune response as a result of a deposit of memory immune cells.

Immunological Mechanisms for Long-Term Immunity Persistence with Hepatitis A Vaccine

Detectable antibody levels of 10–33 EU/ml, depending on the assay, are used to indicate protection from hepatitis A infection. However, from clinical experience, vaccine-induced protection may exist, even in the absence of detectable anti-hepatitis A antibodies [19], which is usually due to the cell-mediated immune response.

A World Health Organization review (2011) reported evidence of inactivated hepatitis A vaccination leading to an important and long-lasting cell-mediated immune response that can be boosted, in addition to its rapid effective humoral response. The response was seen within 2 weeks of vaccination, reaching a peak after 1 month, followed by a subsequent decline in T cells and B cells; this decline could be reversed, with a booster dose at week 24 following the primary vaccination, leading to a significant increase in humoral and cell-mediated immunity [20].

Evidence from long-term follow-up clinical studies and mathematical models have shown that humoral responses to hepatitis A vaccination lasts for decades, with second dose resulting in rapid proliferation of memory B cells and high antibody titres. In studies where a challenge dose was administered 15–20 years after primary immunisation with HAB 720 [9] and HAV 1440 [8, 16], subjects mounted a strong anamnestic response indicating the presence of immune memory.

The evidence supporting the role of vaccine-induced cell-mediated immunity, through cytokines and T-helper cells, was based on documented interferon (IFN) gamma secretion [21, 22], IFN gamma and interleukin (IL)-10 production by peripheral blood lymphocytes 10 days after vaccination [23], and observation of a direct correlation between cytokine concentrations (IL-2, IFN gamma and IL-10) and anti-hepatitis A antibody levels before and after booster vaccination [24]. In one study, peripheral blood mononuclear cells were observed in 100% of vaccinees 1 month after a single dose of HAV 1440 EU, and the subsequent 60% decline of cellular immune responses by week 12 was reversed after a 6-month booster dose producing an over sevenfold increased response compared to that following primary vaccination [25].

The main limitations of this study relate to the methodology of extrapolating data to ascertain long-term persistence of immunity in children instead of doing the actual follow-up for that period. It was not possible to carry out a long-term study (this would have taken decades in real time). The only study in children in the analysis had a mean age of 13.4 years. Similar long-term persistence would, however, be expected in younger children vaccinated with inactivated hepatitis A vaccine. A non-GSK study in children in China (mean age 3.7 years) found that after 11 years of follow-up, all children vaccinated with two doses of HAV 720 remained seroprotected [11].

Despite these limitations, hepatitis A studies worldwide show that the vaccine is highly immunogenic, has long-term persistence and has been successful in disease control. A national two-dose hepatitis A toddler program started in 1999 in Israel, and has had a positive long-term impact with significant incidence declines in all age groups: overall, a 95% decline after 3 years [26] and a 98% decline after 9 years [27] was observed in annual incidence compared with the pre-vaccination period.

Conclusions

Our study suggests that existing long-term data in children would follow the same trends as the adult data, providing high levels of protection likely to last several decades, at least up to 50 years. Therefore, greater efforts are needed to improve hepatitis A vaccine coverage in routine childhood programs to prevent more severe and complicated disease later in life.