A proposed algorithm for combining transcranial Doppler ultrasound monitoring with cerebral and somatic oximetry: a case report

Abstract

Purpose

Transcranial Doppler (TCD) ultrasound is a non-invasive monitor of cerebral blood velocity that can be used intraoperatively. The purpose of this report is to describe how different patterns seen on TCD can help identify the cause of cerebral desaturation when near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) oximetry is used concomitantly.

Clinical features

A 69-yr-old male patient undergoing coronary revascularisation and aortic valve replacement developed perioperative complications that were detected using a combination of transtemporal TCD of the middle cerebral artery along with cerebral and somatic NIRS. Initial brain desaturation was secondary to hypocapnia during which TCD-derived blood velocity and somatic NIRS values remained unchanged. After the procedure, a second episode of brain desaturation occurred secondary to a technical issue with the aortic valve prosthesis requiring a return to cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB); there were no high-intensity transient signals (HITS) on TCD. Brain desaturation occurred a third time following the second attempt to separate from CPB at which time TCD detected a significant amount of HITS suggesting air emboli that were associated with acute right ventricular dysfunction; there was also a reduction in somatic NIRS.

Conclusions

Combining TCD with cerebral NIRS allows for the rapid identification of three different mechanisms of brain desaturation. An algorithm is proposed to help identify the origin of NIRS cerebral desaturation. Prospective clinical trials are needed to investigate potential benefits of multimodal brain monitoring and its impact on short and/or long-term clinical outcomes.

Résumé

Objectif

L’échographie par Doppler transcrânien (DTC) est un moniteur non invasif de la vélocité sanguine cérébrale qui peut être utilisé en période peropératoire. L’objectif de ce compte rendu est de décrire comment différents tracés observés sur le DTC peuvent aider l’anesthésiologiste à identifier la cause de la désaturation cérébrale lorsque l’oxymétrie par spectroscopie proche infrarouge (SPIR) est utilisée de manière concomitante.

Éléments cliniques

Un homme de 69 ans subissant une revascularisation coronarienne et un remplacement de valve aortique a présenté des complications périopératoires détectées grâce à la combinaison d’un DTC trans-temporal de l’artère cérébrale moyenne et d’une SPIR cérébrale et somatique. La désaturation cérébrale initiale était secondaire à une hypocapnie, pendant laquelle la vélocité sanguine dérivée du DTC et les valeurs de SPIR somatique sont demeurées inchangées. Après l’intervention, un deuxième épisode de désaturation cérébrale est survenu suite à un problème technique avec la prothèse de valve aortique, nécessitant un retour sous circulation extracorporelle (CEC); il n’y avait pas de signaux transitoires de haute intensité (HITS) sur le DTC. Il y a eu un troisième épisode de désaturation cérébrale suite à la deuxième tentative de sevrage de la CEC; à ce moment-là, le DTC a détecté une quantité significative de HITS, suggérant des embolies gazeuses associées à une insuffisance ventriculaire droite aiguë; une réduction de la SPIR somatique a également été observée.

Conclusion

La combinaison du DTC à la SPIR cérébrale a permis d’identifier trois différents mécanismes de désaturation cérébrale. Un algorithme est proposé pour aider le clinicien à déterminer l’origine de la désaturation cérébrale sur la SPIR. Des études cliniques prospectives sont nécessaires afin d’explorer les avantages potentiels d’un monitorage cérébral multimodal et son impact sur les devenirs cliniques à court et à long terme.

Transcranial Doppler ultrasound (TCD) is a non-invasive technique to monitor cerebral blood velocities and to detect high-intensity transient signals (HITS) that represent cerebral embolic events.1 Monitoring of patients undergoing carotid endarterectomy using a combination of TCD and cerebral near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) has previously been reported,2 and both modalities can also be used to evaluate cerebral autoregulation.3 At the author’s institution, TCD monitoring is increasingly used, particularly in complex cardiac surgeries, in addition to our routine monitoring with NIRS for all patients undergoing cardiac surgery on cardiopulmonary bypass. Herein, we report the concomitant use of TCD and NIRS in a patient who underwent complex cardiac surgery. Cerebral and somatic NIRS were combined with TCD to identify three different mechanisms of cerebral oxygen desaturation. An algorithm to treat desaturation using TCD combined with cerebral and somatic NIRS is proposed to address the various causes of desaturation in different clinical situations.

Case presentation

A 69-yr-old man with significant coronary artery disease, severe aortic valve (AV) insufficiency, left ventricular (LV) dilatation, and an LV ejection fraction of 35% underwent coronary revascularisation and AV replacement. Written informed consent for this report was obtained from the patient. Prior to induction of anesthesia, standard anesthesia monitors,4 radial artery catheter, bifrontal cerebral and somatic NIRS (baseline value 72% on the right brain and 73% on the right thigh) (Nonin Medical Inc., Plymouth, MN, USA), and processed electroencephalography (Sedline Masimo, Irvine, CA, USA) were utilized for this patient. Transcranial Doppler ultrasound monitoring of the middle cerebral artery (ST3 Digital Transcranial Doppler System, Model PMD 150, Spencer Technologies, Seattle, WA, USA) was installed after adequate localization of the circle of Willis using color Doppler mode of the handheld ultrasound device as previously described.5 Following anesthesia induction, central venous, pulmonary artery (PA), and femoral artery catheters were inserted. Hemodynamic monitoring initially indicated significant pulmonary hypertension and an abnormal right ventricular (RV) diastolic pressure waveform (Fig. 1a).6 A transesophageal echocardiography (TEE) exam performed prior to cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) confirmed diffuse LV hypokinesis and RV dysfunction. Abdominal ultrasonography examination using TEE showed > 50% portal vein pulsatility (Fig. 1b).7,8 Upon initiation of CPB, cerebral NIRS saturation decreased by 18% relative to baseline, while somatic NIRS saturation values remained stable, secondary to inadvertent hypocapnia (Fig. 1c) with no significant changes in TCD signals. The initial arterial carbon dioxide partial pressure (PaCO₂) was 39 mmHg and decreased to 31 mmHg during brain desaturation. Reducing ventilation corrected the hypocapnia and restored the PaCO₂ to 45 mmHg. During the first weaning attempt, a significant 25 mmHg radial-to-femoral mean arterial pressure (MAP) gradient occurred (Fig. 1d). Upon weaning from CPB, a second episode of cerebral NIRS desaturation occurred and was associated with an abnormally elevated PA pressure without any appearance of HITS on the TCD exam (Fig. 1e). A TEE examination revealed significant insufficiency of the bioprosthetic AV, which resulted in immediate return to CPB. An AV leaflet restriction by an aberrant stitch on the bioprosthetic leaflet was identified as the underlying etiology and was repaired. Transesophageal echocardiography examination during the second CPB weaning attempt showed resolution of AV insufficiency. Nevertheless, a third cerebral NIRS desaturation episode occurred with new onset of severe RV dysfunction and a large amount of residual air in the LV. At that time, TCD monitoring showed numerous HITS (Fig. 1f) and the somatic NIRS was reduced. Cardiopulmonary bypass was resumed a third time and intratracheal milrinone (5 mg) was administered to support RV function.9 The patient was finally weaned from CPB using 0.1 µg·kg⁻¹·min⁻¹ epinephrine, 0.3 µg·kg⁻¹·min⁻¹ norepinephrine, and 2.4 U·hr⁻¹ vasopressin.

Fig. 1

(A) Hemodynamic parameters prior to cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB). Pulmonary and systemic hypertension is present, with an abnormal systemic-to-pulmonary mean arterial pressure ratio (106/37 = 2.9; normal > 4).23 The right ventricular (RV) pressure waveform (Prv, blue trace) shows an abnormal diastolic slope suggesting RV diastolic dysfunction.6 (B) Significant portal vein pulsatility ([19cm/s – 9cm/s]/19cm/s = 52%; normal < 30%)8 was present in this patient initially. (C) Cerebral and somatic oxygen saturation monitoring using near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) during CPB. Baseline cerebral saturation was 72% on the right brain and somatic saturation 73% on the right thigh with an arterial carbon dioxide partial pressure (PaCO₂) of 39 mmHg (point 1). Cerebral desaturation to 66% upon initiation of CPB with unchanged somatic value (point 2) pointed to hypocapnia (PaCO₂ of 31 mmHg) as seen on subsequent arterial blood gas analysis; ventilation was corrected and the cerebral saturation returned to baseline (point 3; PaCO₂ of 45 mmHg). (D) Hemodynamic parameters and transtemporal transcranial Doppler (TCD) ultrasound monitoring of both middle cerebral artery (MCA) blood velocities (E) during the first CPB weaning attempt. Note the significant gradient (mean of 25 mmHg) between the mean femoral arterial pressure (Pfa) and radial arterial pressure (Pra). The increase in the pulmonary artery pressure (Ppa) was secondary to aortic prosthetic valvular dysfunction. Transtemporal TCD velocities of both MCA after the first (E) and second (F) separation from CPB. Note the absence of high-intensity transient signals (HITS) upon the first weaning attempt. (F) A significant increase in HITS was present upon the second weaning attempt. This preceded the development of right ventricular dysfunction and implicated air embolization to the right coronary artery. AUC = area under the curve; CVP = central venous pressure; EDV = end-diastolic velocity; HR = heart rate; MV = mean velocity; PaCO₂ = arterial carbon dioxide partial pressure; PI = pulsatility index; PSV = peak systolic velocity; RF = baseline reference value; SaO₂ = arterial oxygen saturation

Discussion

This case shows the utility of combining TCD with cerebral and somatic NIRS. Initially, the isolated cerebral desaturation that we saw was secondary to excessive ventilation resulting in hypocapnia. In that situation, somatic NIRS was normal indicating that the problem was affecting cerebral vasculature and was not from a systemic low flow state. Although hypocapnia has been associated with a reduction in mean cerebral blood velocity from 2.5 to 3.9% per mmHg,10 those TCD changes are not as easily detected as they are with NIRS, as this amount of change is within the variation that can be seen depending on other cerebral autoregulation factors.11 On the other hand, if both cerebral and somatic desaturation occur, then a systemic low flow state such as heart failure or bleeding should be expected as the underlying etiology. In a systemic low flow situation, both cerebral blood flow estimated from TCD velocities and NIRS would have been reduced.12 In our experience, air emboli detected by TCD will often be observed before RV failure becomes apparent on TEE examination, as in the current case, or before the appearance of electrocardiographic changes of ischemia.13 Preferential embolization of air in the right coronary artery can be explained by the non-dependent position of its ostium in the aortic root. Cerebral hypoperfusion would be suspected if mean, systolic, and diastolic cerebral blood velocities of the middle cerebral artery are reduced as opposed to venous congestion where only diastolic cerebral blood velocities will be attenuated with the systolic values remaining unchanged.14 During venous congestion and elevation in central venous pressure, diastolic cerebral blood velocity from TCD will be reduced and the pulsatility index ([systolic velocities – diastolic velocities]/mean velocities) (normal: 0.81–0.97) increased,10,15 with reductions in both cerebral and somatic NIRS values. Similar signals will be observed with intracranial hypertension,16 although somatic NIRS values would remain normal. Chronic aortic regurgitation with reduced aortic diastolic pressure can also be associated with elevated pulsatility index regardless of NIRS value.17 When combined cerebral and somatic NIRS desaturations occur, the mechanism is not cerebral. Similarly, TCD can also be interpreted with both cerebral and somatic values (Fig. 2). If Doppler interrogation of a somatic artery like the splenic artery (Fig. 2c)13 shows reduced diastolic blood velocity and elevated pulsatility index, then the abnormal cerebral TCD is not the result of an intracranial process but could be secondary to chronic aortic regurgitation, for example. Finally, if both the NIRS and TCD signals are normal but the radial arterial pressure is reduced, pseudo radial hypotension could explain this situation, as encountered here after the first weaning attempt.18 Systolic radial-to-femoral gradients ≥ 25 mmHg and MAP gradients ≥ 10 mmHg can be observed in one third of cardiac surgical patients.19 A proposed approach of combining cerebral and somatic NIRS to TCD is summarized in Fig. 3. Further validation in a larger patient cohort is required.

Fig. 2

Transcranial Doppler-derived blood velocity (A) before and (B) after aortic valve repair (AVR) in a 69-yr-old man with severe chronic aortic regurgitation. Note the reduced end-diastolic velocities (EDV) and the elevated pulsatility index (PI) from 1.86 and 2.04 (normal: 0.8–1.2) in the left and right middle cerebral artery which normalized after AVR. (C) Simultaneously obtained splenic artery Doppler velocities from a transgastric abdominal ultrasound. Note the reversed diastolic velocities (arrows) before AVR. (D) After AVR, increased diastolic velocities were observed. % = percentage mean velocity (MV) values compared with baseline; ESV = end-systolic velocity; PSV = peak systolic velocity; HITS = high-intensity transient signals

Fig. 3

Proposed approach to the use of transcranial Doppler (TCD) ultrasound together with cerebral and somatic near infrared spectroscopy (NIRS). If brain desaturation occurs in conjunction with a high burden of high-intensity transient signal (HITS), this may lead to right ventricular (RV) dysfunction from embolization into the right coronary artery (RCA). In that situation, global somatic desaturation will also be observed. If brain desaturation occurs without HITS, then the cerebral blood velocities and pulsatility index (PI) should be examined. Hypoxemia or reduction in arterial oxygen partial pressure (PaO₂) will be typically associated with normal or elevated cerebral blood velocity values.24 Reduction in cerebral blood velocities will be observed during hypocapnia or reduction in arterial carbon dioxide partial pressure (PaCO₂) but also in situations where cardiac output is reduced such as left ventricular (LV) dysfunction, acute valvular heart disease, and blood loss. An increase in PI can be associated with elevated intracranial pressure (ICP) or with elevation of the central venous pressure.14,15,^–16,25,26 Global somatic desaturation will be present if the reduced TCD diastolic velocity and elevated PI is secondary to venous congestion. Nevertheless, global somatic saturation will be normal or maintained if the mechanism of brain desaturation, reduced TCD diastolic velocity, and elevated PI is secondary to intracranial hypertension. An exception would be superior vena cava syndrome in which case the somatic saturation from upper extremity would be reduced but normal in the lower extremity.12,14 CBF = cerebral blood flow

There are, however, limitations in using brain monitoring modalities, particularly when different mechanisms of brain desaturation can occur simultaneously such as bleeding and right heart failure. For instance, air emboli in the right coronary artery do not always result in acute RV failure. If the acute RV failure is severe and associated with reduced cardiac output, then both systolic and diastolic TCD velocities might be proportionally reduced with minimal change in the pulsatility index. In RV dysfunction with preserved LV systolic function, the elevation in venous pressure may result in a decrease in the diastolic TCD velocities and an increase in the pulsatility index. The use of TCD in cardiac surgery is limited by the experience of the operator, availability of the equipment, and the presence of a suitable transtemporal cerebral acoustic window. We have previously described a technique using point-of-care ultrasound with two-dimensional imaging of the brain to identify the window prior to positioning TCD monitoring.5 In 95 out of 100 patients, we were able to identify at least an adequate unilateral window. Compared with NIRS and processed electroencephalography, monitoring with TCD is reusable as with any ultrasound machine. Newer NIRS modalities that can identify oxy and deoxy hemoglobin could represent an alternative to TCD in identifying the mechanism of brain desaturation20 (Fig. 4). Nevertheless, they do not detect HITS and their ability to identify the exact mechanism of brain desaturation, though promising, remains to be shown. Finally, outcome studies would be necessary to document the usefulness of this type of monitoring strategy and algorithm. The word monitoring comes from the latin word “monere”, which means “warning”. Pederson et al., in a Cochrane review reported that the value of perioperative monitoring with pulse oximetry is questionable21 despite the fact that it is a standard of care in anesthesia practice.4 The use of TEE has been relatively routine in cardiac surgery for more than 20 years. Only recently, however, were favourable outcomes from its use seen in a study of 219,238 valve surgery patients.22 Therefore, it is unlikely that TCD will be studied in sufficient numbers to clearly be associated with improvement in overall outcomes. We use TCD in the operating room and in the intensive care unit as a warning device to detect unilateral or bilateral brain malperfusion, venous hypertension, intracranial hypertension, air embolism or HITS, and as a complement to oximetry and processed electroencephalographic monitoring. Each of these brain monitors provides different and complementary information to safeguard brain function.

Fig. 4

Near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) and transcranial Doppler in a 65-year-old man undergoing aortic valve replacement. (A) The baseline NIRS values were 67% on the left and 65% on the right. The NIRS components are displayed and include oxyhemoglobin (∆O₂Hb) in red and deoxyhemoglobin (∆HHb) in blue, the sum of which equals the total cerebral hemoglobin (∆cHb) in pink. Note that at the end of the case, the overall brain saturation (77% on both sides) was higher than at the beginning. This was associated with an increase in ∆O₂Hb on both sides. The transtemporal TCD velocities of the middle cerebral arteries at the beginning (B) and at the end (C) are displayed. The TCD velocities and the percentage of velocities compared with baseline were also higher at the end of the case. This suggests that the higher NIRS values were associated with higher ∆cHb as a result of elevated ∆O₂Hb. The higher TCD velocities and ∆O₂Hb suggest increased cerebral blood flow. AUC = area under the curve; EDV = end-diastolic velocities; HITS = high-intensity transient signals; MV = mean velocities; PI = pulsatility index; PSV = peak systolic velocities; ∆base = NIRS value in relation to baseline; ∆SpO₂ = change in pulse oximetry

In summary, combining cerebral and somatic NIRS to TCD in a multimodal neurologic monitoring approach allows continuous monitoring during complex cardiac surgery, providing the possibility for instantaneous and targeted treatments to better understand cerebral physiology and eventually improve patient outcome.