Abstract
Introduction
As part of the proposed changes to re-design the Irish health-care system, the Department of Health (money follows the patient—policy paper on hospital financing, 2013b) outlined a new funding model for Irish hospitals—money follows the patient (MFTP). This will replace the existing system which is predominately prospective with hospitals receiving a block grant per annum. MFTP will fund episodes of care rather than hospitals. Thus, hospital revenue will be directly linked to activity [activity-based funding (ABF)].
Theory and literature review
With ABF there is a fundamental shift to a system where hospitals generate their own income and this changes incentive structures. While some of these incentives are intended (reducing cost per case and increasing coding quality), others are less intended and less desirable. As a result, there may be reductions in quality, upcoding, cream skimming and increased pressure on other parts of the health system. In addition, MFTP may distort health system priorities. There are some feasibility concerns associated with the implementation of MFTP. Data collection, coding and classification capacity are crucial for its success. While MFTP can build on existing systems, significant investment is required for its success. This includes investment in coding and classification, infrastructure, skills, IT, contracting, commissioning, auditing and performance monitoring systems.
Conclusions
Despite the challenges facing implementers, MFTP could greatly improve the transparency and accountability of the system. Thus if the downside risks are managed, there is potential for MFTP to confer significant benefits to Irish hospital care.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
DoH (2012) Future health—a strategic framework for reform of the health service 2012–2015. Department of Health, Ireland
DoH (2013) Healthy Ireland, a framework for improved health and wellbeing 2013–2025. In: DoH (ed) Department of Health, Ireland
DoH (2013) Money follows the patient—policy paper on hospital financing. Department of Health, Ireland
DoH (2013) Money follows the patient: policy paper on hospital financing frequently asked questions. Department of Health, Ireland
O'Reilly J, Busse R, Häkkinen U, Or Z, Street A, Wiley M (2012) Paying for hospital care: the experience with implementing activity-based funding in five European countries. Health Econ Policy Law 7(1):73
Wiley MM (2005) The Irish health system: developments in strategy, structure, funding and delivery since 1980. Health Econ 14(S1):S169–S186
O’Reilly J, McCarthy B, Wiley M (2011) Ireland: a review of casemix applications within the acute public hospital system. In: Busse R, Geissler A, Quentin W, Wiley M (eds) Diagnosis-related groups in Europe. Open University Press, Berkshire, England, p 568
Brick A, Nolan A, O’Reill, J, Smith S (2010) Resource allocation, financing and sustainability in health care. Evidence for the expert group on resource allocation and financing in the health sector, vol 1. ESRI
Brick A, Nolan A, O’Reilly J, Smith S (2012) Conflicting financial incentives in the Irish health-care system. Econ Soc Rev 43(2):273–301
Roger France FH (2003) Case mix use in 25 countries: a migration success but international comparisons failure. Int J Med Inf 70(2–3):215–219
Farrar S et al. (2009) Has payment by results affected the way that English hospitals provide care? Difference-in-differences analysis. Br Med J 339:b3047
Walshe K, Smith J (2011) Healthcare management. Open University Press, USA
Geissler A, Quentin W, Scheller-Kreinsen D, Busse R (2011) Introduction to DRGs in Europe: common objectives across different hospital systems. In: Busse R, Geissler A, Quentin W, Wiley M (eds) Diagnosis-related groups in Europe: moving towards transparency, efficiency and quality in hospitals. Open University Press, Berkshire, England, p 9
ESRI (2013) Hospital in-patient enquiry scheme (HIPE). https://www.esri.ie/health_information/hipe/. Accessed 16 August 2013
Duckett SJ (1995) Hospital payment arrangements to encourage efficiency: the case of Victoria, Australia. Health Policy 34(2):113–134
Kahur K, Allik T, Aaviksoo A, Laarmann H, Paat G (2011) Estonia: developing NOrdDRGs within social health insurance. In: Busse R, Geissler A, Quentin W, Wiley M (eds) Diagnosis-related groups in Europe: moving towards transparency, efficiency and quality in hospitals. McGraw-Hill, New York
Cots F, Salvador X, Chiarello P, Bustins M, Castells X (2011) Spain: a case study on diversity of DRG use—the Catalan experience. In: Busse R, Geissler A, Quentin W, Wiley M (eds) Diagnosis-related groups in Europe: moving towards transparency, efficiency and quality in hospitals. McGraw-Hill, New York
Ellis RP (1998) Creaming, skimping and dumping: provider competition on the intensive and extensive margins. J Health Econ 17(5):537–555
Sussex J, Farrar S (2009) Activity-based funding for National Health Service hospitals in England: managers’ experience and expectations. Eur J Health Econ 10(2):197–206
Cots F, Chiarello P, Salvador X, Castells X, Quentin W (2011) DRG-based hospital payment: intended and unintended consequences. In: Busse R, Geissler A, Quentin W, Wiley M (eds) Diagnosis-related groups in Europe: moving towards transparency, efficiency and quality in hospitals. Open University Press, Berkshire, England, p 75
Böcking W, Ahrens U, Kirch W, Milakovic M (2005) First results of the introduction of DRGs in Germany and overview of experience from other DRG countries. J Public Health 13(3):128–137
Gallagher P, O’Callaghan N, Henry C (2013) Do relatives of elderly patients block the discharge process? Ir Med J 106(6)
IMO (2013) IMO submission to the Department of Health consultation on the draft money follows the patient—policy paper on hospital financing. Irish Medical Organisation, Dublin
Casale AS, Paulus RA, Selna MJ, Doll MC, Bothe AE, McKinley KE, Berry SA, Davis DE, Gilfillan RJ, Hamory BH, Steele GD (2007) “ProvenCareSM”: a provider-driven pay-for-performance program for acute episodic cardiac surgical care. Ann Surg 246(4):613–623
Reilly J, Minster for Health (2013) Dail debates: written answers: hospital services, no 698. Houses of the Oireachtas, Ireland
HSE (2013) Orthopaedic funding project. Health Matters 9(2):25
Mulholland P (2013) The road to universal health. Irish Medical News, 1 March 2013
Kjerstad E (2003) Prospective funding of general hospitals in Norway—incentives for higher production? Int J Health Care Finance Econ 3(4):231–251
Ruane F (2010) Report of the expert group on resource allocation and financing in the health sector. Department of Health and Children, Dublin. http://www.dohc.ie/publications/resource_allocation/resource_allocation_report_hiRes.pdf?direct=1. Accessed 16 Aug 2013
HSE (2013) Ready reckoner of acute hospital inpatient and daycase activity and costs (summarised by DRG) relating to 2011 costs and activity. In: National casemix programme, Ireland
IMO (2006) Competition in the private health insurance market Irish Medical Organisation to the health insurance authority and competition authority. Irish Medical Organisation, Dublin
Turner B, Shinnick E (2008) The development of the Irish private health insurance market and evidence of selection effects therein. In: Working paper series, 02 August 2008, Department of Economics, University College Cork, Cork
Bibbee A, Padrini F (2006) Balancing health care quality and cost containment: the case of Norway. Economics Department, ECO/WKP(2006)9
Keeler EB et al (1990) Changes in sickness at admission following the introduction of the prospective payment system. J Am Med Assoc 264(15):1962–1968
Louis DZ, Yuen EJ, Braga M, Cicchetti A, Rabinowitz C, Laine C, Gonnella JS (1999) Impact of a DRG-based hospital financing system on quality and outcomes of care in Italy. Health Serv Res 34(1 Pt 2):405
O’Callaghan A et al (2012) A critical evaluation of HIPE data. Ir Med J 105(1):21–23
McElroy B, Murphy A (2013) Patient level costing in Ireland: process, challenges and opportunities. In: Working paper series (13-01), Department of Economics, University College Cork, Cork
DoH (2012) Health in Ireland: key trends 2012. http://www.dohc.ie/publications/pdf/KeyTrends_2012.pdf?direct=1. Accessed 17 October 2013
Blunt I, Bardsley M (2012) Use of patient-level costing to increase efficiency in NHS trusts. Nuffield Trust, London
Conflict of interest
Dr. Murphy has nothing to disclose; Dr. McElroy has nothing to disclose.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
McElroy, B., Murphy, A. An economic analysis of money follows the patient. Ir J Med Sci 183, 15–22 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11845-013-1050-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11845-013-1050-7