Abstract
The Saltpond Basin, situated within the South Atlantic margin of Ghana, is a significant area for petroleum exploration but has received relatively limited research attention. Previous studies have examined source rock composition, but data on crude oil organic chemistry are lacking, hindering understanding of the basin’s petroleum system and evolution. To address this gap, we analyzed biomarkers and stable carbon-isotope ratios in Saltpond Basin crude oil using gas chromatography–mass spectrometry and gas chromatography–isotope ratio mass spectrometry to elucidate organic matter source, depositional environment, and thermal maturity. Findings were compared with oils from the West African segment of the South Atlantic margin, namely the Tano Basin and the Niger Delta Basin, to identify potential correlations and gain insights into regional variations. Molecular and isotopic results unveiled a significant prevalence of organic matter derived from lower marine organisms. Patterns of organic matter deposition and preservation in Saltpond oil samples suggested a suboxic marine transitional environment, contradicting conventional understanding of terrestrial dominance in such settings. Moreover, the potential for degradation processes to obscure differentiation between terrestrial and marine organic matter origins underscores the complex nature of organic matter dynamics in transitional marine environments. Analysis of molecular thermal maturity indices suggested Saltpond oils were expelled from source rocks exhibiting thermal maturity at the early maturity stage. Correlation analysis unveiled genetic disparities among crude oils sourced from the Saltpond Basin and those from the Tano and Niger Delta Basin, primarily due to variations in source input and depositional environment conditions. Saltpond oil exhibits lower terrestrial organic input than Tano Basin’s crude oils, which also have less terrestrial input than Niger Delta Basin crude oils. Additionally, its paleodepositional environment notably differs from oils in the Tano Basin (anoxic transitional marine-lacustrine settings) and the Niger Delta Basin (suboxic–oxic terrigenous deltaic or marine or lacustrine environments). Thermal maturity range of Saltpond oil is comparable to oils in the Tano Basin but lower than oils in the Niger Delta Basin. These findings provide valuable insights into petroleum generation history and unique organic geochemical characteristics within the Saltpond Basin, essential for exploration, production, and environmental management efforts in the region. Furthermore, correlation studies provide evidence that distinct biological, geological, and paleoenvironmental conditions shaped various oil types in the West African segment of the South Atlantic margin.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
1 Introduction
The South Atlantic margin is a significant area for petroleum exploration, harboring significant hydrocarbon reserves that account for approximately 7% of the world’s total reserves (Huc 2004). These reserves are predominantly located in sedimentary basins along the coastlines of West Africa and the eastern seaboard. The favorable geological configuration, which exhibits near symmetry on both sides of the ocean, has facilitated the development of petroleum systems with a shared history (Schiefelbein et al. 2000; Beglinger et al. 2012a, b). Recent advancements in drilling techniques have led to remarkable offshore discoveries in West Africa (Jianping et al. 2010) and the Brazilian coastal margins (Martins et al. 2000).
The Saltpond Basin, operational since the 1970s, remains a significant contributor to the regional hydrocarbon output. Presently, the Saltpond Oil Field produces approximately 550 barrels of oil per day, with estimated reserves of 1.2 million barrels of oil and 20,000 × 109 cubic feet of gas (PCG 2024). Situated in the Gulf of Guinea province of Ghana, the Saltpond Basin covers an area of approximately 12,294 km2 (PCG 2024). With depths ranging from 800 to 4000 m, it is centrally located between the Tano-Cape Three Points and Accra-Keta Basins (Fig. 1a). The basin’s sedimentary deposits, ranging from the Ordovician to Cretaceous ages, were laid down in non-marine to coastal marine environments (Atta Peters et al. 2015; PCG 2024). Characterized by multiple faults, the basin exhibits a complex system of horsts and grabens, serving as traps for hydrocarbon accumulation (Adda 2013). The Lower Paleozoic Petroleum System, the known and proven system in the Saltpond Basin, comprises Devonian source rocks and Devonian to Carboniferous reservoirs (PCG 2024). The main source rocks in the area are the Lower and Upper Takoradi Shales, known for their Type II and Type III kerogen and fair to good total organic carbon and hydrogen index values (Bansah et al. 2014; Atta-Peters et al. 2015). The reservoirs consist mostly of sandstones from the Takoradi Sandstone Formation (Fig. 1b; Adda 2013).
While existing literature extensively documents the biomarkers and isotopic composition of oils within the South Atlantic margin (e.g., Mello et al. 1988; Samuel et al. 2009; Ogbesejana et al. 2020; Amoako et al. 2024), a notable gap persists in data regarding the biomarker and isotope geochemistry of crude oils from the Saltpond Basin. This gap hinders our understanding of the petroleum generation history and system in the Saltpond Basin.
Advancements in mass spectrometry, particularly gas chromatography–mass spectrometry (GC–MS) and gas chromatography–isotope ratio mass spectrometry (GC–IRMS) enable the identification and characterization of biomarkers and stable carbon isotope ratios in both rock extracts and crude oils (e.g., Reddy and Quinn 1999; Konan et al. 2022a, b; Amoako et al. 2023a, b). These techniques offer valuable insights into the origin, thermal maturity, and depositional environment of source rocks and crude oil, which are essential for petroleum exploration. For example, biomarkers such as n-alkanes, steranes, and terpanes act as molecular fossils, providing insights into the organic matter sources, depositional environment, and the maturation history of crude oil (e.g., Brooks et al. 1969; Aquino 1983; Curiale et al. 1989). Similarly, stable carbon isotope ratios in crude oils aid in discerning the origin of organic matter and assessing the thermal maturity of crude oil (Craig 1953; Herz and Dean 1986; Konan et al. 2023; Amoako et al. 2023b). These analytical tools play a crucial role in hydrocarbon exploration and production, facilitating a deeper understanding of petroleum systems and the development of effective exploration strategies.
In this study, our objective was to analyze biomarkers and stable carbon isotopes in crude oil from the Saltpond Basin to infer their origin, depositional environment, and thermal maturity. Additionally, considering the shared geological conditions across basins along the South Atlantic margins (Beglinger et al. 2012a, b), we aimed to explore potential correlations with other types of crude oil in the region, focusing primarily on the Tano Basin and Niger Delta Basin.
2 Samples and experimental approach
2.1 Samples
Oil samples from the Saltpond oil field were collected from the Ghana National Petroleum Corporation’s head office in Tema, Ghana, for biomarker and stable carbon isotope ratio analysis. To ensure accuracy, triplicate samples were taken and analyzed. An independent laboratory analysis revealed that the Saltpond oil samples exhibit a density at 15 °C of 848.6 kg/m3, a specific gravity of 0.8486, and an API gravity of 35.1 (Appenteng et al. 2013). Geochemical analysis of the Saltpond oil samples was conducted at the Petroleum Geochemistry Laboratory of the China University of Petroleum in Beijing. Moreover, biomarker characteristics and stable carbon isotope ratios in Saltpond crude oil, acquired from our study, were compared with published results of oil samples from the Tano Basin (Amoako et al. 2024) and Niger Delta Basin (Samuel et al. 2009; Ogbesejana et al. 2020), to investigate potential regional correlations.
2.2 Gas chromatography–mass spectrometry analysis
Biomarkers in the Saltpond oil samples were analyzed via gas chromatography–mass spectrometry (GC–MS). The saturated hydrocarbon fractions were analyzed using an Agilent 6890 gas chromatograph coupled with an Agilent 5975i mass selective detector. An HP-5 MS fused silica capillary column (60 m × 0.25 mm i.d., 0.25 μm film coating) was employed with helium as the carrier gas. The initial gas chromatograph settings included an oven temperature of 50 °C and an injection temperature of 300 °C. Subsequently, the oven temperature increased at a rate of 20 °C per minute until reaching 120 °C, followed by a further increase to a final temperature of 310 °C at a rate of 3 °C per minute. The mass selective detector operated using electron impact ionization at 70 eV, scanning from 50 to 600 Da.
The Agilent 5975i gas chromatography–mass spectrometry (GC–MS) system was employed to analyze fractions of aromatic hydrocarbons. The system consists of an HP-5 MS fused silica capillary column (60 m × 0.25 mm i.d., 0.25 μm film thickness) coated with 5% phenyl-methylpolysiloxane. The GC conditions comprised an initial temperature of 80 °C for 1 min, followed by a programmed ramp to 310 °C at a rate of 3 °C/min over 16 min, with the injector temperature maintained at 300 °C. Helium was utilized as the carrier gas, and the mass spectrometer operated in electron impact (EI) mode with a scan range spanning 50–600 Da and an ionization energy of 70 eV.
For sample identification, the retention times of their saturated and aromatic molecular markers were compared against those of a meticulously characterized reference sample utilized as the standard for this investigation.
2.3 Stable carbon isotope ratio analysis
Asphaltene isolates from the Saltpond oil sample were subjected to analysis using an elemental analyzer–isotope ratio mass spectrometer (EA–IRMS). Approximately 0.3 mg of each asphaltene sample and analytical standard was precisely measured and placed into small tin sample cups. These samples were introduced into a Dumas combustion EA through a zero-blank autosampler, combusting at 1030 °C under an oxygen atmosphere. The resulting combustion products were desiccated using an MgCl2 trap and directed into a preparative gas chromatography (GC) column with helium as the carrier gas, effectively separating carbon dioxide (CO2) during chromatography. The purified CO2 was then passively introduced via an open split into the inlet of a Micromass Optima IRMS for subsequent carbon isotope analysis. Carbon isotope values were reported as the average of multiple replicate analyses, typically exceeding two (n > 2), with a standard deviation of less than 0.2 ‰. These values are presented relative to the internationally recognized standard, Vienna Pee Dee Belemnite (VPDB) carbonate.
3 Results
3.1 Aliphatic hydrocarbon distribution
The Saltpond oil displays a wide array of normal alkanes (n-C12 to n-C35) and acyclic isoprenoids (pristane and phytane) within the n-alkane and isoprenoid fraction (m/z 85, Fig. 2a). Notably, n-C15 predominates in the n-alkane fraction. The absence of lighter n-alkanes (≤ n-C12) in the Saltpond crude oil may be attributed to evaporation during sample preparation. The oil samples exhibit a unimodal distribution, with a significant prevalence of lower molecular weight (LMW) homologues (≤ n-C22) (Fig. 2a). The average ratio of (n-C21 + n-C22)/(n-C28 + n-C29) in the Saltpond oil is 3.16 (Table 1). Compared to acyclic isoprenoids, the n-alkane series is notably more abundant in the Saltpond oil (Fig. 2a). The mean Pr/Ph ratio observed in Saltpond oil stands at 1.65, while the mean ratios of Pr/n-C17 and Ph/n-C18 are recorded as 0.25 and 0.16, respectively (Table 1). Additionally, carotene is absent in the Saltpond oil samples (Fig. 2b). In the m/z 191 fragmentogram (Fig. 2c), the Saltpond oil features tri-tetracyclic terpanes and pentacyclic terpanes, including Ts, Tm, C30E, C29 and C30 hopane (h), and moretanes such as C29Ts, C30D, C30 diahopane, gammacerane (g), and C31–C35 homohopanes (HH). The average ratio of Ts/(Ts + Tm) in the Saltpond oil is 0.62, while the ratio of C29H/C30H is 0.42 (Table 1). Additionally, the average ratio of gammacerane/C30αβ hopane in the Saltpond oil is 0.15 (Table 1). A significant abundance of C31 to C35 homohopanes is observed in the Saltpond oil (Fig. 2c), with the average ratio of C35HH/C34HH being 0.51 (Table 1). The C3122S/(22S + 22R) homohopane ratios average 0.59, and the average ratio of C30D/C29Ts in the Saltpond oil is 1.30 (Table 1). Moreover, the Saltpond oil exhibits a comprehensive distribution of tricyclic terpanes (TT) and C24 tetracyclic terpane (TeT) ranging from C19 to C29, including the C27TT peak, with C23TT being the most predominant homologue (Fig. 2c). Longer chain tricyclic terpanes, C30TT and C31TT, are either absent or below the level of detection. Additionally, in the Saltpond oil, the 17α-hopane peak is higher than all the tricyclic and tetracyclic terpanes. In the sterane fraction (m/z 217), the Saltpond oil exhibits homopregnane, pregnane, C27–C29 regular sterane, and diasterane (Fig. 2d). The 4-methyl sterane peaks are either low or below the level of detection in the Saltpond oil (Fig. 2d). The distribution of C27–C29 regular sterane peaks in the oils generally follows the order C27 > C28 < C29 (Table 1). The average ratio of C27diasterane/C27regular sterane in Saltpond oil is 0.93 (Table 1).
3.2 Aromatic hydrocarbon distribution
The aromatic fraction of Saltpond oil was initially scrutinized using total ion chromatography (TIC) mode (Fig. 3), revealing a diverse spectrum encompassing 2–3-ring aromatic hydrocarbons, notably featuring compounds such as naphthalene, phenanthrenes, triaromatic steroids, fluorenes (F), dibenzothiophenes (DBT), dibenzofuran (DBF), and their alkyl derivatives, each demonstrating distinct distributions and relative concentrations (Figs. 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9). The TIC mode analysis further unveiled a rich array of 2–3-ring polyaromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), with naphthalene exhibiting conspicuous prominence.
Delving into the molecular ratios of individual PAHs, specific mass chromatograms of aromatic hydrocarbons and their alkyl derivatives were scrutinized across various mass-to-charge ratios (Figs. 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9). Tetra-methyl naphthalene predominantly characterized the naphthalene fractions, while di-methyl phenanthrene exhibited prominence within the phenanthrene fractions (Table 2). Additionally, within the triaromatic steranes fragmentogram (m/z 245), peak predominance was observed for C29 aromatic steroids (Fig. 4). The distribution of heterocyclic aromatic compounds (HTCs) and hydrocarbons, including dibenzothiophene (DBT), dibenzofuran (DBF), and fluorenes (Fs), alongside their alkyl derivatives, displayed non-uniform patterns within the Saltpond oil (Table 2). Relative abundance analysis ranked these HTCs as F > DBF > DBT (Table 2). Notably, both alkyl phenanthrenes and alkyl naphthalenes serve as reliable indicators of thermal maturity in crude oils and other organic matter (Table 2). Ratios of Alkylnaphthalene and alkyl phenanthrene in Saltpond oil are summarized in Table 2. Remarkably, the alkyl phenanthrene index suggests a thermal maturity range from marginally mature to peak mature for the organic matter in Saltpond oil, while the Alkylnaphthalene indices propose a range from peak mature to overly mature.
3.3 Stable carbon isotope ratios
The stable carbon isotope ratios of the Saltpond oil indicate a relatively lighter signature, as summarized in Table 3. The bulk oil presents an average δ13C value of − 29.44‰. Additionally, the average δ13C values for the saturated and aromatic fractions of the Saltpond oil are relatively heavier at − 28.79‰ and − 28.67‰, respectively. Moreover, the average ΔδAro − ΔδSat value, representing the isotopic difference between the saturated and aromatic fractions, is calculated to be 0.12 (Table 3).
4 Discussions
4.1 Origin of organic matter in crude oil
Here, the organic matter source in the Saltpond crude oil was elucidated within the framework of the source rock organic chemistry discussed in previous research (Bansah et al. 2014). Bansah et al. (2014) identified Type II and Type III as the predominant kerogen types in the potential source rocks of the Saltpond Basin. Type II kerogen originates from a complex mixture of zooplankton, phytoplankton, and bacterial remnants typically deposited in reducing environmental conditions (Durand and Espitalie´ 1976). In contrast, Type III kerogen primarily arises from the decomposition of terrestrial plant matter (Durand and Espitalie 1976) or the oxidation of marine organic matter (Khorasani and Michelsen 1992).
In source rocks and crude oils, the distribution of n-alkanes provides insights into their origins, distinguishing between marine and terrestrial sources. The predominance of lower molecular weight (LMW) n-alkanes (≥ n-C22) over higher molecular weight (HMW) n-alkanes (≤ n-C28) (n-C21 + n-C22/n-C28 + n-C29) in the Saltpond oil indicates a greater contribution of organic matter from lower aquatic organisms. Additionally, the composition of C27–C29 regular steranes is instrumental in identifying different sources of organic matter in petroleum and hydrocarbon source rocks. The abundance of C29 steranes typically signifies a higher input from higher plants or green algae, while the presence of C27 steranes suggests the presence of eukaryotic algae and animal phyla (Volkman 2005; Summons and Douglas 2018). The ternary plot of C27–C29 regular steranes (Fig. 10a) indicates that the organic matter in the Saltpond crude oil is predominantly derived from lower aquatic organisms, mainly algae. The high peaks of C29 aromatized steroids in the aromatic fraction (Fig. 4) signal terrestrial input or they may have originated from algal precursors that have been subjected to high thermal conditions (Mackenzie and McKenzie 1983).
The isotopic ratios of 13C–12C within kerogen and organic matter found in source rocks and crude oils are crucial for deciphering the origins and geological evolution of the organic material. δ13C values serve as indicators of the dominant types of plants or algae present in the ancient environment during sediment deposition. Different photosynthetic pathways in plants lead to distinct isotopic signatures. Specifically, C3 plants typically exhibit lighter δ13C values compared to C4 plants, with typical carbon isotope ratios of around − 26.5‰ and − 12.5‰, respectively (Cerling et al. 1989). On the other hand, CAM plants demonstrate highly variable carbon isotope ratios, ranging from − 28‰ to − 12.5‰, depending on the plant species and environmental factors (Messerschmid et al. 2021). Lighter carbon isotope ratios typically characterize terrestrial organic matter, such as plants and soil, while heavier carbon isotope ratios are more common in marine organic matter, such as plankton and algae (Friedman and O'Neil 1977). This is due to the preferential absorption of the lighter isotope, carbon-12, by plants during photosynthesis, leaving a higher proportion of the heavier isotope, carbon-13, in the atmosphere and soil (Larsen et al. 2013). Conversely, the ocean contains a higher concentration of carbon-13 compared to the atmosphere, leading marine organisms to incorporate this isotope into their tissues (Oczkowski et al. 2018). Empirical evidence demonstrates very light carbon isotope ratios in microalgae and phytoplankton. Additionally, lighter isotopic signatures in source rocks and crude oils may suggest higher thermal maturation of organic matter, as lighter isotopes are preferentially released as hydrocarbons during this process (Wada 2009).
Integrating isotope data with complementary biomarker information is essential for obtaining a comprehensive understanding of the origins and historical evolution of organic matter during the petroleum formation process. This approach enables the contextualization of the complex biological, environmental, and geological processes involved in converting organic matter into petroleum. Consistent with the C27–C29 sterane triangular plot (Fig. 10a) and high C27/C29 sterane ratios (>1; Table 1), the lighter δ13C values observed in the whole, saturated, and aromatic fractions of the Saltpond oil suggest a greater contribution from lower aquatic organisms.
4.2 Depositional environment
In this section, the paleoenvironmental conditions of the Saltpond oil are assessed based on selected biomarker ratios. Acyclic isoprenoid ratios, such as Pr/Ph, found in rock extracts and crude oils, serve as proxies for the redox conditions of the depositional environment (Ten Haven et al. 1987). The Pr/Ph ratio operates under the assumption that pristane is derived from phytol via an oxidative pathway, whereas phytane forms through multiple reductive pathways (Powell and McKirdy 1973). In general, a reducing redox environment is characterized by a Pr/Ph ratio below 1, while a sub-oxic environment typically falls between 1 and 2, and an oxidizing environment shows a Pr/Ph ratio exceeding 2 (Didyk et al. 1978; Ten Haven et al. 1987). The average Pr/Ph ratio of 1.65 (Table 1) observed in the Saltpond oil implies suboxic conditions prevailed during deposition. The C35HH/C34HH parameter, representing homohopane (HH) ratios, is commonly utilized to assess redox conditions in marine source rocks (Peters and Moldowan 1991). Elevated C35HH/C34HH ratios typically indicate the presence of marine carbonates or anoxic environments (Clark and Philip 1989). Conversely, lower C35HH/C34HH ratios, accompanied by notable C31HH and C32HH signals, suggest a sub-oxic to oxic environment (Table 1). In line with the Pr/Ph ratio, an average C35HH/C34HH ratio of approximately 0.5 lends support to the conclusion that the Saltpond oil was preserved under sub-oxic redox conditions (Table 1).
Gammacerane serves as a robust biomarker for assessing water column stratification (Hills et al. 1966; Moldowan et al. 1985; Damsté et al. 1995). While it is commonly identified in sediments formed under hypersaline conditions, its presence extends beyond such environments. Gammacerane can also be detected in lacustrine deposits, particularly in lakes within temperate regions experiencing summer stratification (Damsté et al. 1995). Although the precise mechanisms underlying its formation remain uncertain, it is hypothesized that gammacerane originates from the reduction of tetrahymanol during diagenesis, as proposed by Venkatesan and Dahl (1989). Tetrahymanol, synthesized by various bacteria and a specific subset of ciliates and terrestrial eukaryotes, serves as its precursor (Banta et al. 2015). Due to their ability to delineate depositional conditions, the gammacerane index serves as a valuable parameter for distinguishing between saline and freshwater environments. Elevated ratios (>0.2) typically indicate saline conditions, whereas ratios below 0.2 suggest brackish to freshwater conditions (Moldowan et al. 1985). As depicted in Table 1, the gammacerane index of 0.15 observed in the Saltpond oil suggests deposition under brackish water conditions.
Tricyclic and tetracyclic terpane ratios serve as valuable indicators for characterizing the depositional environments of source rocks and crude oils. The prevalence of C23TT relative to other C19TT–C23TT homologs is frequently observed in marine or saline lacustrine source rocks and their associated oils (Neto 1983; Amoako et al. 2023a, b). In contrast, coal samples typically display a higher abundance of C19TT (Zhu 1997; Fu et al. 2019). Recently, Xiao et al. (2019) introduced a ternary diagram capable of distinguishing between source rock depositional environments and associated oils by analyzing C19TT–C23TTs from a comprehensive dataset comprising 104 source rocks and 113 oils across multiple basins. Generally, swamp source rocks characterized by significant terrigenous organic matter input exhibit elevated concentrations of C19TT and C20TT, while sediments deposited in freshwater lacustrine environments are characterized by a predominance of C21TT. The ternary plot of C19TT + C20TT, C21TT, and C23TT (Fig. 10b) suggests that the Saltpond oil aligns with zone 4, indicating a fluvial or deltaic environment.
Li et al. (2013) employed a ternary plot comprising fluorene (Fl), dibenzofuran (DBF), and dibenzothiophene (DBT) to distinguish between various depositional facies, including marine carbonate, fluvial/deltaic/fresh lacustrine shale, and swamp, in 165 crude oil samples. Their analysis revealed that oils originating from marine shale display similar FL and DBF proportions, positioning them between the zones associated with fluvial/deltaic/fresh lacustrine shale and swamp, albeit with slightly higher DBT abundance. Oils sourced from brackish/saline lacustrine environments exhibited intermediate DBT concentrations with a wide range, partially overlapping with those from marine shale. Subsequently, a ternary plot (Fig. 10c) was generated based on Li et al.’s (2013) methodology to elucidate the depositional environment of the Saltpond oil. The results indicate that oils within the Saltpond basin are affiliated with marine shales, suggesting a notable marine influence.
The presence of higher marine organic precursors compared to terrestrial organic precursors, as shown by the steranes ternary plot (Fig. 10a), along with the elevated ratios of n-C21 + nC22/n-C28 + n-C29 (3.16; Table 1) in the Saltpond oil, leads to the conclusion that the oils in the Saltpond Basin were deposited in a marine transitional environment. This conclusion is further supported by independent palynomorph studies on potential source rocks in the Saltpond Basin conducted by Atta Peters et al. (2015).
In marine transitional environments, the prevailing understanding has been that source rocks and crude oils contain a higher proportion of terrestrial organic matter, as highlighted by Zhang et al. (2018). However, our current molecular and isotopic data present a contrasting view. Specifically, the crude oil from the Saltpond Basin indicates a dominance of marine-sourced organic matter over terrestrial sources in the crude oil samples, as depicted in Fig. 10a. Notably, studies by Hedges et al. (1997) and Kumar et al. (2016) have demonstrated that terrestrial organic matter is capable of undergoing degradation processes that can alter its composition to closely resemble marine organic matter signatures, adding a layer of complexity to the interpretation of organic matter sources in such environments.
4.3 Thermal maturity
To assess the thermal maturity of organic matter in the Saltpond crude oil samples, various aliphatic and aromatic thermal maturity parameters were utilized. To avoid underestimating or overestimating the thermal maturity of the oils based on molecular parameters (Alexander et al. 1986; Amoako et al. 2023a), the thermal maturity of potential source rocks (low to poor) in the Saltpond Basin determined in previous studies (Bansah et al. 2014) served as a control. Within the aliphatic fraction, the following parameters were used: Ts/(Ts + Tm) (Table 1; Seifert and Moldowan 1979), C31HH22S/(22S + 22R), and C2920S/(20S + 20R) (Table 1; Mackenzie et al. 1980; Seifert and Moldowan 1980). Within the phenanthrene fragmentogram of the aromatic fraction (Fig. 6), the following maturity parameters were used: MPI-1; MPI-2; Rc-MPI-1; MPR; MDR (Radke 1988). Within the naphthalene fraction of the aromatic fraction (Fig. 5), the following thermal maturity parameters were analyzed: MNR; DNR-1; TNR-1; TMNr; and TrMN (Table 2; Radke 1988). Amoako et al. (2024) recently noted that Ts/(Ts + Tm) greater than 0.4 in some Ghanaian offshore sediments is indicative of higher thermal maturity, although this parameter is sensitive to lithofacies (Seifert and Moldowan 1979). Ratios of C31HH 22S/(22S + 22R) petroleum samples between 0.50 and 0.54 suggest an early oil generation stage and from 0.57 to 0.62 during the main oil generation stage (Seifert and Moldowan 1986). Once isomerization equilibrium is reached, the 22S/(22 S + 22 R) ratio remains constant, providing no further insight into maturity (Seifert and Moldowan 1986). Similarly, C2920S/(20S + 20R) ratio greater than 0.3 is indicative of higher thermal maturity (Peters et al. 2005; Xiao et al. 2018; Amoako et al. 2024). As indicated in Table 1, the higher Ts/(Ts + Tm) (0.62), C31HH 22S/(22S + 22R) (0.59), and C2920S/(20S + 20R) (0.46) suggest the oils have reached at least the early oil generation phase. Given the greater stability, wider maturity range, and higher sensitivity of aromatic molecular parameters to maturity changes, these factors make aromatic parameters valuable tools for assessing the thermal maturity and evolutionary history of crude oil. Within the naphthalene fraction, the aforementioned parameters indicate a thermal maturity range from peak maturity to overmature, whereas the phenanthrene thermal maturity parameters suggest a thermal maturity range between early-peak mature. Consistent with the thermal maturity of the potential source rocks within the Saltpond Basin, it appears the phenanthrene maturity indices are more sensitive to the thermal maturity range of oil in the Saltpond Basin than the naphthalene maturity indices. Amoako et al. (2023a, b) also found that phenanthrene maturity indices are more sensitive to the thermal maturity of Cretaceous sediments in offshore wells in the Gulf of Guinea, indicating their reliability as maturity indicators in the region.
4.4 Regional correlation with crude oils in the South Atlantic margin
The correlation of crude oil types holds significant importance across various domains of the petroleum industry, including exploration, production, refining, and environmental management (Peters et al. 2005; Wang et al. 2002).
In this section, a comparative examination of the organic geochemistry of crude oil sourced from the Saltpond Basin with various crude oil types found in the West African portion of the South Atlantic margin was undertaken. The goal was to discern any similarities or differences in the geochemical composition between Saltpond Basin crude oil and oils in that region. Specifically, comparisons were made between the Saltpond Basin crude oil and oils from the Cretaceous-aged Tano Basin and the Cretaceous-Tertiary-aged Niger Delta Basin. These basins were selected for correlation due to their integration within the broader tectonic framework of the South Atlantic rift basin, which originated during the Early Cretaceous period through the separation of Africa and South America (Schiefelbein et al. 2000; Brownfield and Charpentier 2006; Beglinger et al. 2012a, b). Previous molecular and isotopic studies on the Tano Basin (Amoako et al. 2024), and the Niger Delta Basin (Ogbesejana et al. 2020; Samuel et al. 2009), provided essential data for the correlation studies. The analysis was conducted within the context of three main factors: source input, depositional environment, and thermal maturity.
Geochemical findings and independent analyses using molecular and isotopic parameters indicate a ranking of terrestrial sourced organic matter signatures in the oils as follows: Niger Delta Basin > Tano Basin > Saltpond Basin (Fig. 11; Amoako et al. 2024; Samuel et al. 2009). This suggests the presence of distinct source input factors influencing hydrocarbon generation potential and petroleum characteristics in oils from the West African segment of the South Atlantic margin.
Regarding the depositional environment, molecular ratio analysis suggests that Saltpond Basin oil originated from a marine transitional environment. Independent analyses using molecular and isotopic parameters revealed that oils from the Tano Basin originated from anoxic transitional marine-lacustrine settings (Fig. 11; Amoako et al. 2024). In the Niger Delta Basin, they fall within suboxic–oxic terrigenous deltaic or marine or lacustrine environments (Fig. 11; Samuel et al. 2009). This diversity underscores the varied depositional settings that preserved oils from the West African portion of the South Atlantic margin. Additionally, distinct redox conditions influenced organic matter preservation in oils from these basins, with the Tano Basin oil preserved under anoxic conditions and the Niger Delta oils mainly preserved under suboxic to oxic conditions (Fig. 11; Samuel et al. 2009; Amoako et al. 2024). These findings highlight the dynamic and varied redox conditions that prevailed over time during the petroleum formation process in the West African segment of the South Atlantic margin.
In terms of thermal maturity, Amoako et al. (2024) showed that the oils in the Tano Basin were generated during the early mature phase (Fig. 11), while oils from the Niger Delta Basin were expelled during the early-peak mature stages (Fig. 11; Samuel et al. 2009). This shows that the oils in the Saltpond Basin have comparable maturity levels with those in the Tano Basin but differ from oils in the Niger Delta Basin in terms of thermal maturity (Fig. 11).
In summary, correlation studies suggest that Saltpond Basin oil is genetically different from oils found in the Tano Basin and Niger Delta Basin. This distinction is mainly influenced by the sources of organic matter in the oils as well as the depositional environment conditions that preserved them. This closely aligns with the findings of Jian-Ping et al. (2008).
5 Conclusion
Gas Chromatography–Mass Spectrometry and Gas Chromatography–Isotope Ratio Mass Spectrometry were used for comprehensive analyses of the molecular and isotopic composition of crude oil from the Saltpond Basin. The primary objectives were to determine the origin of organic matter, characterize the depositional environment, and evaluate thermal maturity levels. Correlation analyses were performed on the Saltpond oil samples alongside existing data from crude oils in the Tano Basin and Niger Delta Basin to uncover potential regional correlations.
From our comprehensive analyses, the following conclusions were drawn:
Specific biomarker ratios, such as n-C21 + n-C22/n-C28 + n-C29 (3.16) and a high C27/C29 sterane ratio (1.24), in addition to light δ13C values (approximately − 29‰) of the bulk oil, suggest that the oils from the Saltpond basin originated from multiple sources, predominantly lower marine aquatic organisms.
Elevated pristane/phytane ratios (1.65), absence of carotenoids, ternary plot of C19–C23 tricyclic terpane series, along with dibenzofuran-dibenzothiophene-fluorene ternary plot, collectively indicate that the crude oil from the Saltpond Basin was deposited in a suboxic marine transitional environment. The prevalence of organic matter sourced from lower marine organisms in the Saltpond Basin crude oil challenges the established paradigm of terrestrial predominance in marine transitional environments. Furthermore, the capacity of degradation processes to conceal the distinction between terrestrial and marine organic matter sources highlights the complex organic matter dynamics inherent in marine transitional environments.
Molecular maturity indices, particularly C31HH22S/(22S + 22R), C2920S/(20S + 20R), and methyl phenanthrene indices, suggest that the Saltpond Basin crude oil was expelled from source rocks exhibiting thermal maturity at the early maturity stage.
Correlation analysis unveiled the genetic uniqueness of Saltpond crude oil in contrast to oils from the Tano and Niger Delta Basin. Notably, the Niger Delta Basin displays the highest terrigenous organic matter input, followed by the Tano Basin and then the Saltpond Basin. Additionally, differences in depositional environments were noted between Saltpond oil and those from the Tano Basin (anoxic transitional marine-lacustrine settings) and Niger Delta Basin which were either deposited in terrigenous deltaic or marine or lacustrine environments. Additionally, the thermal maturity of the Saltpond oil is comparable to oils found in the Tano Basin but lower than those found in the Niger Delta Basin.
Although this study offers valuable insights, it is essential to recognize specific limitations that could impact the generalization of the results. Specifically, the study is constrained by the limited availability of oil samples from the Saltpond Basin and the absence of source rock samples for oil–source correlation analysis. To enhance the reliability and extend the applicability of the findings presented herein, future research efforts should strive to include a larger number of both oil and source rock samples to facilitate comprehensive oil–oil and oil–source correlations.
In summary, our findings highlight the distinct organic geochemical traits of crude oil in the Saltpond Basin compared to those in the Niger Delta and Tano Basins. They also underscore the diverse biological, geological, and paleoenvironmental factors influencing different types of crude oil within the West African segment of the South Atlantic margin. This information is crucial for regional exploration efforts, production, and environmental management initiatives in the area.
Data availability
Not applicable.
References
Adda GW (2013) The petroleum geology and prospectivity of the Neo-Proterozoic, Paleozoic, and Cretaceous sedimentary Basins in Ghana. Search Discov Articl. 10544:1–8.
Alexander R, Strachan MG, Kagi RI, Van Bronswijk W (1986) Heating rate effects on aromatic maturity indicators. Org Geochem. 10(4–6):997–1003.
Amoako K, Ningning Z, Osei-Boakye NP, Foli G, Appau PO, Apesegah E (2023a) Molecular and isotopic signatures of indigenous and non-indigenous hydrocarbons in Campanian sediments from the Tano Basin, Ghana. Appl Geochem. 155:105719.
Amoako K, Osei-Boakye NP, Zhong N, De Sales Konan NGF, Foli G, Appau PO, Fenyi C, Apesegah E (2023b) Geochemical fingerprints and hydrocarbon potential of Paleocene mudrocks in the Tano Basin, Ghana: Insights from biomarkers and stable carbon isotopes. Acta Geochim. 43:1–25.
Amoako K, Zhong N, Shi S, Osei-Boakye NP, Foli G, Appau PO, Fenyi C, Apesegah E (2024) Organic geochemical heterogeneity of cretaceous mudrocks and reassessment of oil sources in the Tano Basin, Ghana. Mar Pet Geol. 162:106697.
Appenteng MK, Golow AA, Carboo D, Narley VK, Kaka EA, Salifu M, Aidoo F (2013) Physicochemical characterization of the Jubilee crude oil. Appl Chem. 54:12513–12517.
Aquino NF (1983) Occurrence and formation of tricyclic and tetracyclic terpanes in sediments and petroleum. Adv Org Geochem. 1981:659–667.
Atta-Peters D, Achaegakwo CA, Garrey P (2015) Palynofacies, organic geochemical analyses and hydrocarbon potential of the Takoradi 11–1 well, Saltpond Basin, Ghana. Pet Coal. 57(5):478.
Bansah S, Nyantakyi EK, Awuni LA, Borkloe JK, Qin G (2014) Geochemical characterization of potential source rock of the Central (Saltpond) Basin, Ghana. Int J Oil Gas Coal Eng. 2:2–19.
Banta AB, Wei JH, Welander PV (2015) A distinct pathway for tetrahymanol synthesis in bacteria. Proc Natl Acad Sci. 112:13478–13483.
Beglinger SE, Doust H, Cloetingh S (2012a) Relating petroleum system and play development to basin evolution: West African South Atlantic basins. Mar Pet Geol. 30:1–25.
Beglinger SE, Doust H, Cloetingh S (2012b) Relating petroleum system and play development to basin evolution: Brazilian South Atlantic margin. Pet Geosci. 18:315–336.
Brooks JD, Gould K, Smith JW (1969) Isoprenoid hydrocarbons in coal and petroleum. Nature. 222:257–259. https://doi.org/10.1038/222257a0
Brownfield ME, Charpentier RR (2006) Geology and total petroleum systems of the west-central coastal province (7203), west Africa (No. 2207-B). US Geological Survey.
Cerling TE, Quade J, Wang Y, Bowman JR (1989) Carbon isotopes in soils and palaeosols as ecology and palaeoecology indicators. Nature. 341:138–139.
Clark J, Philp R (1989) Geochemical characterization of evaporite and carbonate depositional environments and correlation of associated crude oils in the Black Creek Basin, Alberta. Bull Can Pet Geol. 37:401–416.
Craig H (1953) The geochemistry of the stable carbon isotopes. Geochim Cosmochim. Acta 3:53–92. https://doi.org/10.1016/0016-7037(53)90001-5
Curiale JA, Odermatt JR (1989) Short-term biomarker variability in the Monterey formation, Santa Maria Basin. Org Geochem. 14:1–13. https://doi.org/10.1016/0146-6380(89)90023-4
Damsté JSS, Kenig F, Koopmans MP, Köster J, Schouten S, Hayes JM, de Leeuw JW (1995) Evidence for gammacerane as an indicator of water column stratification. Geochim Cosmochim Acta. 59(9):1895–1900.
Didyk BM, Simoneit BRT, Brassell ST, Eglinton G (1978) Organic geochemical indicators of palaeoenvironmental conditions of sedimentation. Nature. 272:216–222.
DurandEspitalié BJ (1976) Geochemical studies on the organic matter from the Douala Basin (Cameroon)-II. Evolution of kerogen. Geochim Cosmochim Acta. 40:801–808.
Friedman I, O’Neil JR (1977) Data of geochemistry: compilation of stable isotope fractionation factors of geochemical interest. Chapter KK, vol 440. US Government Printing Office.
Fu J, Zhang Z, Chen C, Wang TG, Li M, Ali S, Lu X, Dai J (2019) Geochemistry and origins of petroleum in the Neogene reservoirs of the Baiyun Sag, Pearl River Mouth Basin. Mar Pet Geol. 107:127–141.
Hedges JI, Keil RG, Benner R (1997) What happens to terrestrial organic matter in the ocean? Org Geochem. 27(5–6):195–212.
Herz N, Dean NE (1986) Stable isotopes and archaeological geology: the Carrara marble, northern Italy. Appl Geochem. 1:139–151. https://doi.org/10.1016/0883-2927(86)90055-3
Hills IR, Whitehead EV, Anders DE, Cummins JJ, Robinson WE (1966) An optically active triterpane, gammacerane in Green River, Colorado, oil shale bitumen. Chem Commun. 20:752–754.
Huc AY (2004) Petroleum in the south Atlantic. Oil Gas Sci Technol. 59(3):243–253.
Jian-Ping Liu, Pan XH, Jun M, Tian ZJ, Chen YJ, Wan LK (2008) Petroleum geology and resources in West Africa: An overview. Pet Explor Dev. 35(3):378–384.
Jianping L, Xiaohua P, Jun M, Zuoji T, Lunkun W (2010) Exploration targets in the Côte d’Ivoire-Ghana transform margin in Equatorial West Africa. Pet Explor Dev. 37(1):43–50.
Khorasani GK, Michelsen JK (1992) Primary alteration—oxidation of marine algal organic matter from oil source rocks of the North Sea and Norwegian Arctic: New findings. Org Geochem. 19(4–6):327–343.
Konan NGFDS, Li M, Shi S, Liu X, Tang Y, Kojo A, Toyin A (2022a) Simple column chromatography separation procedure for polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons: Controlling factor (s). Arab J Geosci. 15(15):1350.
Konan NGFDS, Li M, Shi S, Kojo A, Toyin A, Boakye NPO, Li T (2022b) Stable carbon isotopic composition of selected alkylnaphthalenes and alkylphenanthrenes from the tarim oilfields, NW China. Energies. 15(19):7145.
Konan NGFDS, Li M, Shi S, Toyin A, Tine AHL, Amoako K, Appau PO (2023) Distribution and isotopic compositions of phenanthrene and methylphenanthrenes in crude oils: implications for source input delineation and grouping oil families. Appl Geochem. 158:105795. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apgeochem.2023.105795
Kumar V, Tiwari M, Nagoji S, Tripathi S (2016) Evidence of anomalously low δ13C of marine organic matter in an Arctic fjord. Sci Rep. 6(1):36192.
Larsen T, Ventura M, Andersen N, O’Brien DM, Piatkowski U, McCarthy MD (2013) Tracing carbon sources through aquatic and terrestrial food webs using amino acid stable isotope fingerprinting. PLoS ONE. 8:e73441.
Li M, Wang T, Zhong N, Zhang W, Sadik A, Li H (2013) Ternary diagram of fluorenes, dibenzothiophenes and dibenzofurans: Indicating depositional environment of crude oil source rocks. Energy Explor Exploit. 31(4):569–588.
Mackenzie AS, McKenzie D (1983) Isomerization and aromatization of hydrocarbons in sedimentary basins formed by extension. Geol Mag. 120(5):417–470.
Mackenzie AS, Patience RL, Maxwell JR, Vandenbroucke M, Durand B (1980) Molecular parameters of maturation in the Toarcian shales, Paris Basin, France, I. Changes in the configurations of acyclic isoprenoid alkanes, steranes and triterpanes. Geochim Cosmochim Acta. 44:1709–1721.
Martins FSB, Santos OLA, de Paula IL (2000) Well control in campos basin-Brazil. In: SPE/IADC drilling conference and exhibition. SPE, pp SPE-59244.
Mello MR, Gaglianone PC, Brassell SC, Maxwell JR (1988) Geochemical and biological marker assessment of depositional environments using Brazilian offshore oils. Mar Pet Geol. 5:205–223. https://doi.org/10.1016/0264-8172(88)90002-9
Messerschmid TF, Wehling J, Bobon N, Kahmen A, Klak C, Los JA, Kadereit G (2021) Carbon isotope composition of plant photosynthetic tissues reflects a crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) continuum in the majority of CAM lineages. Perspect Plant Ecol Evol Systemat. 51:125619.
Moldowan JM, Seifert WK, Gallegos EJ (1985) Relationship between petroleum composition and depositional environment of petroleum source rock. Am Assoc Pet Geol Bull. 69:1255–1268.
Neto A (1983) Occurrence and formation of tricyclic and tetracyclic terpanes in sediments and petroleums. (No Title) 659.
Oczkowski A, Taplin B, Pruell R, Pimenta A, Johnson R, Grear J (2018) Carbon stable isotope values in plankton and mussels reflect changes in carbonate chemistry associated with nutrient enhanced net production. Front Mar Sci. 5:43.
Ogbesejana AB, Bello OM, Ali T (2020) Origin and depositional environments of source rocks and crude oils from Niger Delta Basin: Carbon isotopic evidence. China Geol. 3(4):602–610.
Peters KE, Moldowan JM (1991) Effects of source, thermal maturity, and biodegradation on the distribution and isomerization of homohopanes in petroleum. Org Geochem. 17:47–61.
Peters KE, Walters CC, Moldowan JM (2005) The biomarker guide, vol 1. Cambridge University Press.
Petroleum Commission Ghana (2024) Sedimentary basins of Ghana. https://www.petrocom.gov.gh/sedimentary-basins/
Powell TG, McKirdy DM (1973) Relationship between ratio of pristane to phytane, crude oil composition and geological environment in Australia. Nat Phys Sci. 243:37–39.
Radke M (1988) Application of aromatic compounds as maturity indicators in source rocks and crude oils. Mar Pet Geol. 5(3):224–236.
Radke M, Welte DH, Willsch H (1986) Maturity parameters based on aromatic hydrocarbons: Influence of the organic matter type. Org Geochem. 10:51–63. https://doi.org/10.1016/0146-6380(86)90008-2
Reddy CM, Quinn JG (1999) GC-MS analysis of total petroleum hydrocarbons and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in seawater samples after the North Cape oil spill. Mar Pollut Bull. 38(2):126–135.
Samuel OJ, Cornford C, Jones M, Adekeye OA, Akande SO (2009) Improved understanding of the petroleum systems of the Niger Delta Basin, Nigeria. Organ Geochem. 40(4):461–483.
Schiefelbein C, Zumberge J, Cameron N, Brown SW (2000) Geochemical comparison of crude oil along the South Atlantic margins. In: Mello MR, Katz BJ (eds) Petroleum systems of South Atlantic margins, vol 73. AAPG Memoir, pp 15–26.
Seifert WK, Moldowan JM (1979) The effect of biodegradation on steranes and terpanes in crude oils. Geochim Cosmochim Acta. 43:111–126.
Seifert WK, Moldowan JM (1980) The effect of thermal stress on source-rock quality as measured by hopane stereochemistry. Phys Chem Earth. 12:229–237.
Seifert W, Moldowan J (1986) Use of biological markers in petroleum exploration. Methods Geochem Geophys. 24:261–290.
Summons RE, Douglas HE (2018) Chemical clues to the earliest animal fossils. Science. 361:1198–1199.
Ten Haven H, De Leeuw J, Rullkötter J, Damsté JS (1987) Restricted utility of the pristane/phytane ratio as a palaeoenvironmental indicator. Nature. 330:641–643.
Venkatesan MI, Dahl J (1989) Organic geochemical evidence for global fires at the Cretaceous/Tertiary boundary. Nature. 338:57–60.
Volkman JK (2005) Sterols and other triterpenoids: Source specificity and evolution of biosynthetic pathways. Org Geochem. 36:139–159. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.orggeochem.2004.06.013
Wada E (2009) Stable δ15N and δ13C isotope ratios in aquatic ecosystems. Proc Jpn Acad Ser B. 85:98–107.
Wang RL, Scarpitta SC, Zhang SC, Zheng MP (2002) Later Pleistocene/Holocene climate conditions of Qinghai–Xizhang Plateau (Tibet) based on carbon and oxygen stable isotopes of Zabuye Lake sediments. Earth Planet Sci Lett. 203:461–477. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0012-821X(02)00829-4
Xiao H, Wang TG, Li M, Fu J, Tang Y, Shi S, Yang Z, Lu X (2018) Occurrence and distribution of unusual tri- and tetracyclic terpanes and their geochemical significance in some Paleogene oils from China. Energy Fuels. 32:7393–7403.
Xiao H, Li M, Yang Z, Zhu Z (2019) The distribution patterns and geochemical implication of C19–C23 tricyclic terpanes in source rocks and crude oils occurred in various depositional environment. Acta Geochem. 48:161–170 (in Chinese with English abstract).
Zhang J, Li X, Zhang X, Zhang M, Cong G, Zhang G, Wang F (2018) Geochemical and geological characterization of marine–Continental transitional shales from Longtan Formation in Yangtze area, South China. Mar Pet Geol. 96:1–15.
Zhu Y (1997) Geochemical characteristics of terrestrial oils of the Tarim Basin. Acta Sedimentol Sin. 15:26–30 (in Chinese with English abstract).
Funding
Open Access funding enabled and organized by Projekt DEAL. This work is a segment of the corresponding author’s master’s thesis, and the expenses related to this research were funded by the State Key Petroleum Lab of Petroleum Resources and Prospecting at China University of Petroleum (Beijing).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
Conceptualization: Kojo Amoako and Nancy Pearl Osei-Boakye; Data Curation: Kojo Amoako; Formal Analysis: Kojo Amoako, Nancy Pearl Osei-Boakye; Funding Acquisition: Kojo Amoako; Investigation: Kojo Amoako, Nancy Pearl Osei-Boakye; Methodology: Kojo Amoako, Nancy Pearl Osei-Boakye; Project Administration: Zhong Ningning; Resources: Zhong Ningning, Ebenezer Apesegah; Software: Zhong Ningning; Supervision: Zhong Ningning; Validation: Zhong Ningning, Kojo Amoako, Nancy Pearl Osei-Boakye, and Ebenezer Apesegah; Writing-Original Draft: Kojo Amoako; Writing-Review and Editing: Zhong Ningning, Ebenezer Apesegah; All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflicts of interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Amoako, K., Zhong, N., Osei-Boakye, N.P. et al. The organic geochemistry of crude oil in the Saltpond Basin (Ghana): Organic source input, depositional environment, and thermal maturity. Acta Geochim 43, 424–440 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11631-024-00692-4
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11631-024-00692-4