This study examines the relationship between water depth and diatom assemblages from lake-sediment-surface samples at Kelly Lake, California. A total of 40 surface-sediment samples (integrated upper 5 cm) were taken at various depths within the small (~ 3.74 ha) 5.7 m-deep lake. Secchi depths, water temperature, pH, salinity, conductivity, and total dissolved solids were also measured. Some diatom species showed distinct association with depth (e.g., Fragilaria crotonensis, Nitzschia semirobusta). The relationship between the complete diatom assemblages and water depth was analyzed and assessed by depth-cluster analysis, a one-way analysis of similarity, principal components analysis and canonical correspondence analysis. Statistically significant differences were found between the assemblages associated with shallow depth (0–1.25 m), mid-depth (1.25–3.75 m), and deep-water (3.75–5.2 m) locations. The relationship between diatom assemblages and lake depth allowed two transfer models to be developed using the Modern Analogue Technique and Weighted Averaging Partial Least Squares. These models were compared and assessed by residual scatter plots. The results indicate that diatom-inferred transfer models based on surface-sediment samples from a single, relatively small and shallow lake can be a useful tool for studying past hydroclimatic variability (e.g., lake depth) from similar lakes in California and other regions where the large number of lakes required for traditional transfer-function development may not exist.
Paleolimnological transfer functions are often developed from multi-lake-training sets and can be a useful paleolimnological tool for reconstructing many variables including lake depth (Gregory-Eaves et al. 1999; Gomes et al. 2014; MacDonald et al. 2016). However, in many hydrologically sensitive regions, including much of California (CA), natural lakes are relatively rare, making the use of multi-lake-training sets unfeasible. CA has experienced prolonged hydroclimatic anomalies over the twenty-first century (e.g., severe droughts) that appear to be, at least in part, related to anthropogenic climate change (MacDonald et al. 2016; Swain et al. 2018; Dong et al. 2019; Glover et al. 2020; Zamora-Reyes et al. 2021). Understanding how recent CA hydroclimate variability relates to longer timescale (e.g., Holocene), natural variability has been an important topic of research over the past decade (Briles et al. 2011; MacDonald et al. 2016; Kirby et al. 2019). Unfortunately, instrumental climate records only extend back a little more than a century and do not capture the full range of potential natural hydroclimatic variability. Paleoclimatic approaches can provide proxy hydroclimatic records that extend back millennia. The proxy-climate archives provided by lake sediments are one useful source of such information, and although not as plentiful as in some regions, such lake archives are available in areas of CA.
Diatoms (Class: Bacillariophyceae), single-celled algae and phytoplankton, have been shown to be an important proxy indicator useful to investigate hydroclimatic variability as manifest in lake-level changes or changes in lake salinity (Fritz et al. 1991; Gasse et al. 1995; Battarbee 2000; Smol and Cumming 2000; Zhang et al. 2007; Kingsbury et al. 2012; Ramón Mercau and Laprida 2016; Gushulak et al. 2017; Gushulak and Cumming 2020). There are several reasons why diatoms are good paleoenvironmental indicators—they are common in lake environments, they are sensitive to hydrological and limnological changes (e.g., lake depth, water chemistry), and their distinctive silica frustules are well-preserved and readily identified in lake sediments. Many studies have shown that diatoms can be used to reconstruct past variations in lake depth, including providing quantitative estimates using statistical transfer functions based on modern diatom-water-depth relationships (Yang and Duthie 1995; Gregory-Eaves et al. 1999; Laird et al. 2010, 2011; Wolin and Stone 2010; Gomes et al. 2014; MacDonald et al. 2016).
This research will focus on diatom flora and water depth. Lacustrine hydrologic budgets, which are related to lake-water depth, are closely associated with regional hydrologic budgets and the interplay between precipitation and evaporation. This association is especially robust in regions with strong seasonal precipitation/evaporation contrasts, such as CA and the American West, where winter precipitation and summer evaporation dominate the annual hydrologic budget of lakes (Shuman and Donnelly 2006 as cited in Wigdahl-Perry et al. 2016). Changes in lake level are closely related to paleohydroclimatic changes (Fritz 1990; Smol and Cumming 2000; Kirby et al. 2007; Blazevic et al. 2009; Laird et al. 2010; Kingsbury et al. 2012; MacDonald et al. 2016).
There are very few diatom-inferred paleoecological transfer functions from Californian lakes. Bloom et al. (2003) published a paper that established a diatom-inferred salinity and water-temperature-transfer function from a network of lakes (n = 57) in the Sierra Nevada. While the initial study was about salinity and water temperature, not water depth, this was expanded to include a water-depth-transfer function in a subsequent publication (MacDonald et al. 2016). Unfortunately, few areas of CA outside formerly glaciated Sierra Nevada contain an adequate lake density to make a traditional multi-lake-based diatom-transfer-function model.
In recent years, studies have shown that diatom-depth-transfer functions can be successfully developed using multiple sediment-surface samples taken from different depths in a single lake (Laird and Cumming 2009; Laird et al. 2010, 2011; Gushulak et al. 2017). The resulting transfer function can then be applied to sediment cores from the same lake (Laird and Cumming 2009; Laird et al. 2010; Faith and Lyman 2019). This approach is ideal for CA where lake basins in many regions are rare and the development of a multi-lake-transfer function, which requires 30 lakes or more, is not possible. In this study, we address the question of whether or not there is a statistically significant difference in the diatom floral assemblages found in the sediments taken at different depths from a single lake. Moreover, we explore whether or not these relationships are statistically strong enough to develop diatom-depth-transfer functions that could be applied to sediment cores from that same lake. The study site is Kelly Lake, a small lake in the mountains of northwestern CA. The results of this study support the potential wider usefulness of single-lake-transfer-function development in other regions where there are insufficient lakes for traditional training-set development. Kelly Lake is also smaller and deeper than previously published sites from which such transfer functions have been derived, increasing the range of lakes this approach might be applied to.
Kelly Lake (41.91° N, 123.52° W; 1346 m asl) is located in the Klamath Mountains (northern California Coast Range), approximately 10 km from the Oregon border (Fig. 1). The study site is in the Confederated Tribes of Grand Ronde, Karuk, Cow Creek Umpqua, and Cayuse, Umatilla and Walla Walla Tribes’ territory (Native Nation Digital 2021). The lake is landslide-formed, small (~ 3.74 ha), with a maximum water depth of 5.7 m. The surface drainage basin is small (~ 47 ha) and sits in sedimentary rocks and metavolcaniclastic sedimentary rocks (Irwin 1994). Although presently a closed basin (as of 2019) with a small inlet, there is a spill point at the east shoreline, approximately 3–4 m above modern lake level, indicating that overflow is possible during wet years. Dead and felled trees are concentrated at the outlet area and suggest a dynamic lake level with flow over the spill. Some active springs characterize the surrounding drainage basin with modern inflow observed occurring at the lake’s northwest shoreline. The vegetation surrounding the lake’s fringe is mostly reeds and sedges, with submergent macrophytes and mosses near the shoreline. Above the shoreline, there is forested vegetation with an overstory of Jeffrey pine (Pinus jeffreyi Grev. & Balf.), Douglas fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii (Mirb.) Franco), sugar pine (Pinus lambertiana Douglas), incense cedar (Calocedrus decurrens (Torr.) Florin) and white fir (Abies concolor (Gord. & Glend.) Lindl. ex Hildebr.).
The mean January and July temperatures of the region are approximately 3 °C and 19 °C, and the mean annual precipitation is 176 mm (Western Regional Climate Center 2016; Fig. 2). This data was collected from the Elk Valley Station (42.00° N, 123.43° W), which is the nearest station to the study site (~ 12 km linear distance) at 521 m asl. The average winter precipitation (December, January, February) is approximately 353 mm, while the average summer precipitation (June, July, August) is roughly 17 mm. Kelly Lake experiences some snow during fall and winter, with ~ 1148 mm of total snowfall. Therefore, Kelly Lake’s annual hydrologic budget is typical of the Mediterranean climate type and driven by variations in winter precipitation and summer evaporation.
In July 2019, 40 surface sediment samples were obtained at various lake-water depths from the upper 5 cm of the sediment–water interface using a mini-Glew gravity corer (Fig. 3). Our sampling technique captured the sediment–water interface, visible in the clear plastic tube, ensuring that we did not over-penetrate into older sediments. The topmost sediments were extremely water-saturated with a diffuse sediment–water interface. We wished to obtain sufficient sediment for diatom analysis and other analyses from each surface site. We also were not aiming at the annual or near-annual resolution, but rather the integration of diatoms from the past decade or so to have an averaged observation of the diatom flora. We have obtained 137Cs data from the central portion of the lake that indicate that the 1963 peak is deeper than 5 cm (5–10 cm) and 210Pb data suggests sedimentation rates of ~ 3 yr/cm (Table S2), therefore the upper 5 cm generally represents perhaps 15 years or so of time. Although there may have been some slight variations in lake conditions over this time period, we believe that our sampling regime captures a reasonable representation of the overall recent conditions of Kelly Lake. The samples were designated as KLSS2019 #. KLSS2019 1 to 26 and KLSS2019 33 to 40 were taken along three transects: nine samples from Transect 1, seventeen samples from Transect 2, and eight samples from Transect 3 (Fig. 3, Fig. S1). Each sediment sample was collected at approximately 2 m distance from adjacent samples. KLSS2019 27 to 32 were collected at the very margin of the lake and from the lake’s inlet emergent vegetation (Fig. 3). Lake-water depths were measured at each sampling point. Secchi-disc depths were also measured at each sampling point to delineate the average depth of the modern photic and aphotic zones and the light conditions at the sediment surface for each sampling point.
The lake’s water chemistry was also measured near the surface at the center of the lake three times and averaged. Table 1 shows the average values of all the measurements. Five variables, such as pH, conductivity, water temperature, total dissolved solids, and salinity, were measured with a digital water testing meter (Apera Instruments PC60 Premium Multiparameter Tester Meter).
Diatom-sample preparation and identification
Approximately 0.2 g of wet surface sample was treated with 5 ml of 30% H2O2 in a 100 ml beaker with 10 ml of distilled water to remove organic materials in the sediments. After the sample was heated on a hot plate at 120 °C for an hour, the top solution was decanted. A micro spatula of sodium hexametaphosphate was put in the beaker for deflocculation. After 15–30 min of reaction, the beaker was filled with distilled water, and let the diatoms be deposited. The prepared diatoms were mounted using Pleurax (mountmedia) on microscope slides. At least 400 diatom valves were counted per sample at 1000 × magnification under a light microscope (Nikon Labophot-2) with oil immersion. For diatom-species identifications we followed the taxonomy of Krammer and Lange-Bertalot (1986, 1988, 1991a, 1991b) with supplementary printed and online sources (Kulikovskiy et al. 2016; Spaulding et al. 2019; Potapova et al. 2020; Jüttner et al. 2022).
Data selection and analysis
The taxa used for statistical analysis and calibration-set development were selected after screening the diatom data. Taxa that appear at more than 5% abundance were selected for constructing the stratigraphic diatom diagram and constrained clustering, and taxa occurring at more than 1% abundance in at least one sample were chosen for statistical analyses and transfer-function development. A diatom-stratigraphy diagram was drawn in R version 4.1.3 (RStudio Team 2020) using the rioja package (Juggins 2020). A depth-constrained cluster analysis (CONISS) was also performed in R with the vegan package (Oksanen et al. 2020) to determine if lake-depth zones could be discerned in the diatom assemblages from Kelly Lake. The cluster analysis-based zones were calculated with the Bray–Curtis distance method to measure the dissimilarity between communities (Grimm 1987). A one-way analysis of similarity (ANOSIM) was also conducted using PAST (PAleontological STatistics, version 4.01) software package to test statistically the differences in the distribution of diatom assemblages among the identified depth zones (Hammer et al. 2001). Principal component analysis (PCA) was conducted in R on the covariance matrix to further explore differences in the diatom assemblages from different lake depths and the important diatom taxa contributing to those differences. Canonical correspondence analysis (CCA) with Monte Carlo permutation tests (999 permutations) was also performed in R with the vegan and CCP packages to examine if water depth is a significant variable on the diatom distribution for developing a transfer function (Oksanen et al. 2020; Menzel 2022). The CCA incorporated 22 diatom taxa from 40 surface samples and two environmental variables—water depth of the surface-sample location and its depth below the photic zone as measured using the Secchi disc. Lastly, two diatom-inferred water-depth-transfer functions were developed with the modern analogue technique (MAT), and with weighted average partial-least squares (WA-PLS) using the PAST software. The dissimilarity for MAT was measured using squared chord distance. The root mean square error of prediction (RMSEP) was estimated for both models, and the RMSEP values are based on the degree of error between the observed and the expected value. Thus, the lower the value, the more significant it is.
We identified over 150 diatom taxa in Kelly Lake. Among them, 21 taxa (14 genera and 17 species) were selected for statistical analysis. These all appeared at > 5% abundances in at least one sample (Fig. 4). There were thirteen benthic taxa (Navicula spp., Achnanthidium spp., Achnanthicium rosenstockii (Lange-Bertalot) Lange-Bertalot, Gogorevia exilis (Kützing) Kulikovskiy & Kociolek, Gomphonema acuminatum Ehrenberg, Grunowia tabellaria Rabenhorst, Meridion constrictum Ralfs, Nitzschia semirobusta Lange-Bertalot, Pseudostaurosira parasitica (W.Smith) E. Morales, Staurosira construens Ehrenberg, S. venter (Ehrenberg) Cleve & J.D.Möller, Melosira spp., Fragilariforma nitzschioides (Grunow) Lange-Bertalot), five planktonic taxa (Aulacoseira spp., A. italica (Ehrenberg) Simonsen, A. pusilla (F.Meister) A.Tuji & A.Houki, Fragilaria crotonensis Kitton, Fragilaria spp.), and three tychoplanktonic taxa (Achnanthidium minutissimum (Kützing) Czarnecki, Staurosirella pinnata (Ehrenberg) D.M.Williams & Round, Pseudostaurosira brevistriata (Grunow) D.M.Williams & Round). Due to the difficulties in identification under 100 × light microscopy, some Staurosira spp., Staurosirella spp., and Pseudostaurosira spp. are counted together as S & S & P spp. Figure 4 shows the diatom diagram and the CONISS dendrogram where the Kelly Lake surface-sediment samples are divided into three diatom-water-depth zones: shallow (0–1.25 m), mid-depth (1.25–3.75 m), and deep-water zones (3.75–5.2 m).
A one-way analysis of similarity (ANOSIM)
According to the CONISS analysis, Kelly Lake was divided descriptively into three depth zones, which are shallow (0–1.25 m), mid-depth (1.25–3.75 m), and deep (3.75–5.2 m). The deep-water zone generally represents samples where the sediment–water interface is in the aphotic zone of the lake. A cluster analysis that was unconstrained by depth and thus allowed samples to be freely grouped was also performed (Fig. S2). It displays prominent clusters of samples from the constrained cluster zones, particularly samples from the shallow and deep-water zones. However, there are also some clustering of mixed samples and some samples which do not cluster closely with any others. ANOSIM was subsequently conducted to determine whether there was a statistically significant difference between the three depth zones by examining the similarity of the diatom communities (Elmslie et al. 2020).
There are statistically significant differences between the three depth zones based on the result of ANOSIM. The P values in Table 2a indicate significant differences between the groups. The values are close to 0, which allowed us to reject the null hypothesis (“there is no difference”) and indicated that there were statistically significant differences between the diatom assemblages from the three different water-depth zones (i.e., shallow, mid-depth, and deep zones).
R values were also calculated in ANOSIM, which showed the strength of the depth factors on the samples. Generally, if an R value is lower than 0.2, it means that the factors had a small effect on the variables. However, the R values in Table 2b were larger than 0.2. Accordingly, it further indicates that the lake depth was influential on the composition of diatom communities observed in the lake sediments and the differences between the depth zones.
Therefore, the ANOSIM results indicate that there were differences in the diatom communities by specific depth zones, and lake depth was an influential factor in the diatom-assemblage composition in the sediments of Kelly Lake.
Principal component analysis (PCA)
The cumulative variation of PCA axis 1 and axis 2 was 70.5%, the first two axes were considered in this study (Fig. 5). The diatom assemblages were clustered on the PCA biplot by depth, reinforcing the conclusion that lake depth has a strong control on the diatom assemblages preserved in the sediments. PCA axis 1 appears to represent water depths between middle to deep, while PCA axis 2 reflects shallow to middle water depths. The three most important diatom taxa in determining these PCA axes were Staurosirella pinnata, Staurosira venter and Nizschia semirobusta.
Canonical correspondence analysis (CCA) with Monte Carlo permutation tests
Analysis of diatom-lake-environment variables using CCA analysis, including data sets used for transfer-function development, typically yield a percentage of diatom variance explained of between 4 and 23% (Finkelstein et al. 2014; Weckström and Korhola 2001). The CCA analysis indicates that the depth of the sampling site is important in determining the taxonomic composition of the diatom flora recovered. CCA axis 1, which is strongly associated with lake depth at the surface-sample location, accounted for 15.5% of the variance (Fig. 6). CCA axis 2 is more associated with the depth below the photic zone and accounted for 1.3%. CCA axis 1 was indicated as significant by Monte Carlo permutation texts (p ≤ 0.01; Fig. S3). Species 8 = Fragilariforma nitzschioides and 12 = Meridion constrictum are associated with shallow and ephemeral sites and were found at the shallowest sampling sites at the edge of the lake and ordinate at the extreme negative end of CCA axis 1, while 6 = Fragilaria crotonensis, 20 = Staurosira construens, 21 = Staurosira venter, 22 = Staurosirella pinnata are considered as planktonic and tychoplanktonic species, more likely to be relatively abundant in deeper waters, and ordinate at the positive end of CCA axis 1.
Two diatom-lake-depth-transfer functions were developed using MAT and WA-PLS. Model construction incorporated diatom taxa that occur > 1% in at least one sample.
The first diatom-inferred water-depth-inference model was developed using WA-PLS (Fig. 7a). The R2 value is 0.96 and indicates a high degree of correlation between the observed depths and diatom-inferred depths. In this study, the third component for WA-PLS has the lowest RMSEP value (0.66). Therefore, the third component was selected for the WA-PLS transfer function. As seen in the graphs (Fig. 7a), the WA-PLS model performed better in mid-depths between 2 and 3 m than in shallow and deep depths.
The second transfer function was developed using the MAT method (Fig. 7b). The R2 value of the MAT transfer function is 0.98, and the RMSEP value is 0.39. In general, the MAT model displays good performance; it performs well in shallow and deep zones and shows a slight over-representation in the mid-depths.
Residual scatter plots
Residual scatter plots (Fig. 8) determined whether there is a trend, and thus a bias, in the models. This was done to determine whether there is a trend in residuals, and thus a bias, in the models. The residuals in the MAT model show a lower trend than the residuals in the WA-PLS model according to the R2 values. The residuals in MAT are more scattered in the mid-depths, while the ones in WA-PLS are more scattered at the edges of the depths. Even though MAT shows a lower trend than WA-PLS, both have small R2 values and small slopes. Thus, the residuals in both MAT and WA-PLS do not suggest a strong bias.
The statistical analysis indicates that the diatom assemblages found in the surface sediments at Kelly Lake can be statistically grouped into three different depth zones. There are at present a few studies that have examined the relationship between the composition of the diatom community and water depth from a single small lake (Laird and Cumming 2009; Laird et al. 2010, 2011; Gushulak et al. 2017). It is notable that the studies cited above are from boreal Canada and represent lakes that are both much larger (19–1808 ha) and deeper (18–32 m) than Kelly Lake. Not only do our results extend the potential usefulness of single lake-transfer functions to the Mediterranean climate region of CA, but they also demonstrate its applicability to relatively small and shallow lakes. Our study adds to growing evidence that differences in diatom assemblages related to lake depth are preserved in the sediments of small lakes and have the potential for developing lake-specific diatom-depth-transfer functions. Some aspects of diatom ecology pertinent to the results, and the water-depth-inference models developed here are discussed below.
Although there are a variety of factors that affect diatom assemblages in the lacustrine environment, this study indicates that the diatom-assemblage compositions in Kelly Lake have a clear correlation with lake-water depths. There are three depth zones identified in Kelly Lake: shallow (0–1.25 m), mid-depth (1.25–3.75 m), and deep zones (3.75–5.2 m). These three distinct depth zones are similar to those discerned for a previous single lake conducted in Canada; although there are many co-occuring diatom species in the Canadian lakes and this study, there were few equivalent major diatom assemblages (Laird and Cumming 2009; Laird et al. 2010). Recent work by Gushulak and Cumming (2020) indicates that light availability may be the most important factor controlling such depth-dependent diatom-assemblage distributions within individual lakes. It is notable that at Kelly Lake the deep zone identified by the constrained cluster analysis is largely within the aphotic zone that ranges in depth from 3.3 to 4.9 m.
Although details of the ecology of many diatom species remain uncertain, the statistical results from Kelly Lake regarding depth and diatom assemblages can be assessed in light of the known ecology for some individual diatom taxa that show strong depth preferences. Some individual diatom taxa show strong depth preferences. For example, Fragilaria crotonensis rarely appears at shallow depths, but it begins to appear at middle depths and becomes dominant in deep zones (Fig. 4). Fragilaria crotonensis is known as planktonic and non-motile (Morales et al. 2013). The species forms ribbon-like floating colonies and are associated with the pelagic zone. They prefer strong turbulence to stay afloat (Rioual 2000). Staurosirella pinnata is also one of the predominant species in the deep zone. Although some studies demonstrated S. pinnata as benthic or planktonic (Fluin et al. 2010; Laird et al. 2011; Hofmann et al. 2020; Park et al. 2017), it can be considered as tychoplankton because of its lifestyle (Hobbs et al. 2017). The species is also known as well adapting to low light-penetration conditions (Laird et al. 2010). These characteristics of S. pinnata explain why it appears dominantly at larger depths in Kelly Lake, even under some low photic or aphotic conditions (Fig. S1) because it could inhabit greater depths as tychoplankton, or as a benthic form tolerant to low light conditions.
There are also many distinguishing species for mid-depth zones in Kelly Lake. Nitzschia semirobusta is the predominant species for the mid-depth zone. This species is known as a motile benthic species and has a wide tolerance for trophic status even though it favors oligotrophic conditions (Bartozek et al. 2018). As the water-chemistry results from Kelly Lake indicate oligotrophic to mesotrophic conditions, it seems the water chemistry of the lake is favorable to N. semirobusta. Also, the environment with enough light penetration and the species’ motility help this species to be dominant in mid-depth areas.
Pseudostaurosira parasitica is mainly found in shallow depth zones, and this is readily explainable because the species is benthic and must remain in the photic zone to survive (Morales 2010a). Abundant Aulacoseira spp. are indicative of the shallow zone. The genus is well-known for including a variety of planktonic species, especially meroplankton (having both benthic and planktonic characteristics depending on their life-cycle stages). There are possible reasons why Aulacoseira spp. appear more predominantly in the shallow than the deep in Kelly Lake. Some Aulacoseira spp. (e.g., A. pusilla) prefer shallow depths to take in more nutrients and light (Rioual 2000) or low lake level and enhanced convective mixing (Dean et al. 1984 as cited in Rioual 2000). These reasons might suggest why Aulacoseira spp. appears in shallow depth sediments in Kelly Lake.
In addition to the relationships between taxa and three depth zones, there are also a few species typically found in environments at the very margin/edge of the lake or near the shore (e.g., Meridion constrictum and Odontidium mesodon). These species inhabit very shallow or flowing water or live on emergent plants (Potapova 2009; Hoidal 2013; Leira et al. 2017).
Conversely, some species are abundant at a wide range of depths, such as Achnanthidium minutissimum and Pseudostaurosira brevistriata. For example, A. minutissimum is ubiquitous in diatom-based, paleolimnological studies. Although they are normally classified as benthic, their habitat preferences are variable. Some studies have found that A. minutissimum occurs at ~ 2 m or shallower depths (Yang and Duthie 1995; Moos et al. 2005), while another study found it occurs at a broad range of depths (Laird et al. 2010). One study concluded that the species is largely found on submerged Isoetes (Haberyan 2018). While A. minutissimum may not be a useful species for representing distinct depth zones, it may signify zones of overall ecotone changes within a lake (Moos et al. 2005). Similarly, P. brevistriata has a complex ecology, classified as tychoplanktonic and non-motile (Morales 2010b). As a result, it is not surprising that P. brevistriata is found at various depths at Kelly Lake.
By interpreting diatom assemblages according to each species’ habitat preferences and the subsequent statistical results, we conclude that there are clear divisions based upon water-depth zones, and water depth is a crucial factor in the composition of diatom assemblages preserved in the Kelly Lake surface sediments.
A good transfer-function model should meet two conditions: (1) observations and estimates must be strongly positively correlated, (2) there should be no trends in the residuals (Yoon et al. 2017). There are many ways to develop a transfer function, and WA-PLS and MAT are the two of the most common techniques (Bloom et al. 2003; Cunningham et al. 2005; Laird et al. 2011; Park 2011; Faith and Lyman 2019). In this study, both MAT and WA-PLS perform well in terms of the requisite conditions. However, overall, the MAT transfer model showed better performance than the WA-PLS model with higher R2 and lower RMSEP values. However, for both transfer functions, the R2 values were higher than 0.95, and both models showed good representations of diatom-inferred water depths.
In this study, the dissimilarity measure for MAT was determined using a squared chord, which is a metric to assess the signal-to-noise relationship. This distance metric is considered the best for evaluating modern analogs (Jackson and Williams 2004 as cited in Kemp and Telford 2015). It is said that chord-squared distance is more acceptable for closed compositional assemblage data, such as relative abundances, because it highlights the major patterns, while it down-weights rare species (Kemp and Telford 2015). Both MAT and WA-PLS are vulnerable to uneven sampling of the elevation gradient (Kemp and Telford 2015), but most of the samples in this study have been collected evenly, so the weakness should not be influential here.
There are over- and under-estimations at deep and shallow depths in the WA-PLS model within the 95% confidence ellipse, and this could reflect the “edge effect” problem common for weighted average-based models, such as WA and WA-PLS (Birks 2010). This problem causes over- or under-estimations at the edges of the sample depths. However, Kemp and Telford (2015) argued that the influence of “edge effects” is lessened in WA-PLS. The results of our study show that WA-PLS does seem to present some “edge effect” as there are more variable residuals at deep and shallow depths (the edges; Fig. 8b). The WA-PLS performs better for the middle depths. Conversely, there are over-estimations in the MAT model for the mid-depth ranges, especially in the range of 2 and 3 m. Both models have over- or under-estimations at different depth zones; therefore, inferences of past depths might best be made by using both models.
There are clear, statistically significant differences between diatom assemblages and lake depth in the surface sediments of Kelly Lake. The correlations are strong enough to develop single-lake diatom-inferred lake-depth-transfer models. Our findings indicate that a quantitative reconstruction of past lake depth using diatom assemblages is reasonable for Kelly Lake. As in many parts of the world, CA has few natural lakes outside of the formerly glaciated Sierra Nevada Mountains, yet regional information on long-term hydroclimatic variability throughout the state is very important in providing a context for twenty-first century climate change. Kelly Lake is in a different climatic zone and is also smaller in area and shallower in depth than the Canadian lakes previously examined to develop single lake-transfer functions for depth. This suggests a potentially wider applicability of this approach in terms of region being studied and lake characteristics. The ability to use surface samples from a single lake, coupled with a core from that lake to reconstruct past lake depths, is an important and still developing methodological advance for reconstructing past hydroclimatic variations.
Bartozek ECR, Zorzal-Almeida S, Bicudo DC (2018) Surface sediment and phytoplankton diatoms across a trophic gradient in tropical reservoirs: new records for Brazil and São Paulo State. Hoehnea 45:69–92. https://doi.org/10.1590/2236-8906-51/2017
Battarbee RW (2000) Palaeolimnological approaches to climate change, with special regard to the biological record. Quat Sci Rev 19:107–124. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0277-3791(99)00057-8
Birks HJB (2010) Numerical methods for the analysis of diatom assemblage data. In: Stoermer EF, Smol JP (eds) The diatoms: applications for the environmental and earth sciences, 2nd edn. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 23–54
Blazevic MA, Kirby ME, Woods AD, Browne BL, Bowman DD (2009) A sedimentary facies model for glacial-age sediments in Baldwin Lake, Southern California. Sediment Geol 219:151–168. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sedgeo.2009.05.003
Bloom AM, Moser KA, Porinchu DF, MacDonald GM (2003) Diatom-inference models for surface-water temperature and salinity developed from a 57-lake calibration set from the Sierra Nevada, California, USA. J Paleolimnol 29:235–255. https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1023297407233
Briles CE, Whitlock C, Skinner CN, Mohr J (2011) Holocene forest development and maintenance on different substrates in the Klamath Mountains, northern California, USA. Ecology 92:590–601. https://doi.org/10.1890/09-1772.1
Cunningham L, Raymond B, Snape I, Riddle MJ (2005) Benthic diatom communities as indicators of anthropogenic metal contamination at Casey Station, Antarctica. J Paleolimnol 33:499–513. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10933-005-0814-0
Dean WE, Bradbury JP, Anderson RY, Bamovsky CW (1984) The variability of Holocene climate change: evidence from varved lake sediments. Science 226:1191–1194
Dong C, MacDonald G, Okin GS, Gillespie TW (2019) Quantifying drought sensitivity of Mediterranean climate vegetation to recent warming: a case study in Southern California. Remote Sens 11:2902. https://doi.org/10.3390/rs11242902
Elmslie BG, Gushulak CA, Boreux MP et al (2020) Complex responses of phototrophic communities to climate warming during the Holocene of northeastern Ontario, Canada. The Holocene 30:272–288. https://doi.org/10.1177/0959683619883014
Faith JT, Lyman RL (eds) (2019) Transfer functions and quantitative paleoenvironmental reconstruction. In: Paleozoology and paleoenvironments: fundamentals, assumptions, techniques. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 234–265. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108648608.009
Finkelstein SA, Bunbury J, Gajewski K, Wolfe AP, Adams JK, Devlin JE (2014) Evaluating diatom-derived Holocene pH reconstructions for Arctic lakes using an expanded 171-lake training set. J Quat Sci 29(3):249–260. https://doi.org/10.1002/jqs.2697
Fluin J, Tibby J, Gell P (2010) The palaeolimnological record from lake Cullulleraine, lower Murray River (south-east Australia): implications for understanding riverine histories. J Paleolimnol 43:309–322. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10933-009-9333-8
Fritz SC (1990) Twentieth-century salinity and water-level fluctuations in Devils Lake, North Dakota: test of a diatom-based transfer function. Limnol Oceanogr 35:1771–1781. https://doi.org/10.4319/lo.19220.127.116.111
Fritz SC, Juggins S, Battarbee RW, Engstrom DR (1991) Reconstruction of past changes in salinity and climate using a diatom-based transfer function. Nature 352:706–708. https://doi.org/10.1038/352706a0
Gasse F, Juggins S, Khelifa LB (1995) Diatom-based transfer functions for inferring past hydrochemical characteristics of African lakes. Palaeogeogr Palaeoclimatol Palaeoecol 117:31–54. https://doi.org/10.1016/0031-0182(94)00122-O
Glover KC, Chaney A, Kirby ME, Patterson WP, MacDonald GM (2020) Southern California vegetation, wildfire, and erosion had nonlinear responses to climatic forcing during marine isotope stages 5–2 (120–15 ka). Paleoceanogr Paleoclimatol 35:e2019PA003628. https://doi.org/10.1029/2019PA003628
Gomes DF, Albuquerque ALS, Torgan LC, Turcq B, Sifeddine A (2014) Assessment of a diatom-based transfer function for the reconstruction of lake-level changes in Boqueirão Lake, Brazilian Nordeste. Palaeogeogr Palaeoclimatol Palaeoecol 415:105–116. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.palaeo.2014.07.009
Gregory-Eaves I, Smol JP, Finney BP, Edwards ME (1999) Diatom-based transfer functions for inferring past climatic and environmental changes in Alaska, USA. Arct Antarct Alp Res 31(4):353–365. https://doi.org/10.1080/15230430.1999.12003320
Grimm EC (1987) CONISS: a FORTRAN 77 program for stratigraphically constrained cluster analysis by the method of incremental sum of squares. Comput Geosci 13:13–35. https://doi.org/10.1016/0098-3004(87)90022-7
Gushulak CAC, Cumming BF (2020) Diatom assemblages are controlled by light attenuation in oligotrophic and mesotrophic lakes in northern Ontario (Canada). J Paleolimnol 64:419–433. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10933-020-00146-w
Gushulak CAC, Laird KR, Bennett JR, Cumming BF (2017) Water depth is a strong driver of intra-lake diatom distributions in a small boreal lake. J Paleolimnol 58:231–241. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10933-017-9974-y
Haberyan KA (2018) A > 22,000 yr diatom record from the plateau of Zambia. Quat Res 89:33–42. https://doi.org/10.1017/qua.2017.31
Hammer O, Harper DAT, Ryan PD (2001) PAST: paleontological statistics software package for education and data analysis. Palaeontol Electron 4:1–9
Hobbs WO, Edlund MB, Umbanhowar CE Jr, Camil P, Lynch JA, Geiss C, Stefanova V (2017) Holocene evolution of lakes in the forest-tundra biome of northern Manitoba, Canada. Quat Sci Rev 159:116–138. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.quascirev.2017.01.014
Hofmann AM, Geist J, Nowotny L, Raeder U (2020) Depth-distribution of lake benthic diatom assemblages in relation to light availability and substrate: implications for paleolimnological studies. J Paleolimnol 64:315–334. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10933-020-00139-9
Hoidal N (2013) Meridion circulare var. constrictum. In: Diatoms N. Am. https://diatoms.org/species/meridion_circulare_var._constrictum. Accessed 8 May 2022
Irwin WP (1994) Geologic map of the Klamath Mountains, California and Oregon. In: USGS Natl. Geol. Map Database. https://ngmdb.usgs.gov/Prodesc/proddesc_10149.htm. Accessed 1 May 2022
Jackson ST, Williams JW (2004) Modern analogs in quaternary paleoecology: here today, gone yesterday, gone tomorrow? Annu Rev Earth Planet Sci 32:495–537. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.earth.32.101802.120435
Juggins S (2020) Rioja: analysis of Quaternary science data. In: R Package Version 09-26. https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/rioja/index.html. Accessed 8 May 2022
Jüttner I, Carter C, Chudaev D et al (2022) Diatom flora of Britian and Ireland. In: Amgueddfa Cymru - Natl. Mus. Wales. https://naturalhistory.museumwales.ac.uk/diatoms/. Accessed 8 May 2022
Kemp AC, Telford RJ (2015) Transfer functions. In: Handbook of sea-level research. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, pp 470–499. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118452547.ch31
Kingsbury MV, Laird KR, Cumming BF (2012) Consistent patterns in diatom assemblages and diversity measures across water-depth gradients from eight Boreal lakes from north-western Ontario (Canada). Freshw Biol 57:1151–1165. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2427.2012.02781.x
Kirby ME, Lund SP, Anderson MA, Bird BW (2007) Insolation forcing of Holocene climate change in Southern California: a sediment study from Lake Elsinore. J Paleolimnol 38:395–417. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10933-006-9085-7
Kirby MEC, Patterson WP, Lachniet M et al (2019) Pacific Southwest United States Holocene droughts and pluvials inferred from sediment δ18O(calcite) and grain size data (Lake Elsinore, California). Front Earth Sci 7:74. https://doi.org/10.3389/feart.2019.00074
Krammer K, Lange-Bertalot H (1986) Bacillariophyceae. 1: Teil: Naviculaceae. In: Ettl H, Gärtner G, Gerloff J, Heynig H, Mollenhauer D (eds) Süßwasserflora von Mitteleuropa, Band 2/1. Gustav Fischer Verlag, Stuttgart
Krammer K, Lange-Bertalot H (1988) Bacillariophyceae 2: Teil: Bacillariaceae, Epithmiaceae, Surirellaceae. In: Ettl H, Gärtner G, Gerloff J, Heynig H, Mollenhauer D (eds) Süßwasserflora von Mitteleuropa, Band 2/2. Gustav Fischer Verlag, Stuttgart
Krammer K, Lange-Bertalot H (1991a) Bacillariophyceae. 3: Teil: Centrales, Fragilariaceae, Eunotiaceae. In: Ettl H, Gärtner G, Gerloff J, Heynig H, Mollenhauer D (eds) Süßwasserflora von Mitteleuropa, Band 2/3. Gustav Fischer Verlag, Stuttgart
Krammer K, Lange-Bertalot H (1991b) Bacillariophyceae. 4: Teil: Achnanthaceae. In: Ettl H, Gärtner G, Gerloff J, Heynig H, Mollenhauer D (eds) Süßwasserflora von Mitteleuropa, Band 2/4. Gustav Fischer Verlag, Stuttgart
Kulikovskiy MS, Glushchenko AM, Genkal SI, Kuznetsova IV (2016) Identification book of diatoms from Russia. Filigran Yarosl
Laird KR, Cumming BF (2009) Diatom-inferred lake level from near-shore cores in a drainage lake from the Experimental Lakes Area, northwestern Ontario, Canada. J Paleolimnol 42:65–80. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10933-008-9248-9
Laird KR, Kingsbury MV, Cumming BF (2010) Diatom habitats, species diversity and water-depth inference models across surface-sediment transects in Worth Lake, northwest Ontario, Canada. J Paleolimnol 44:1009–1024. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10933-010-9470-0
Laird KR, Kingsbury MV, Lewis CFM, Cumming BF (2011) Diatom-inferred depth models in 8 Canadian boreal lakes: inferred changes in the benthic: planktonic depth boundary and implications for assessment of past droughts. Quat Sci Rev 30:1201–1217. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.quascirev.2011.02.009
Leira M, del Carmen López-Rodríguez M, Carballeira R (2017) Epilithic diatoms (Bacillariophyceae) from running watersin NW Iberian Peninsula (Galicia, Spain). An Jardín Bot Madr 74:e062–e062. https://doi.org/10.3989/ajbm.2421
MacDonald GM, Moser KA, Bloom AM, Potito AB, Porinchu DF, Holmquist JR, Hughes J, Kremenetski KV (2016) Prolonged California aridity linked to climate warming and Pacific sea surface temperature. Sci Rep 6:33325. https://doi.org/10.1038/srep33325
Menzel U (2022) Package ‘CCP’ In: R Package Version 1.2. https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/CCP/index.html. Accessed 29 September 2022
Moos TM, Laird KR, Cumming BF (2005) Diatom assemblages and water depth in Lake 239 (Experimental Lakes Area, Ontario): implications for paleoclimatic studies. J Paleolimnol 34:217–227. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10933-005-2382-8
Morales E (2010a) Pseudostaurosira parasitica. In: Diatoms N. Am. https://diatoms.org/species/pseudostaurosira_parasitica. Accessed 8 May 2022
Morales E (2010b) Pseudostaurosira brevistriata. In: Diatoms N. Am. https://diatoms.org/species/pseudostaurosira_brevistriata. Accessed 8 May 2022
Morales E, Rosen B, Spaulding S (2013) Fragilaria crotonensis. In: Diatoms N. Am. https://diatoms.org/species/fragilaria_crotonensis. Accessed 8 May 2022
Native Nation Digital (2021) Welcome. In: Native. https://native-land.ca/. Accessed 27 Jan 2023
Oksanen J, Blanchet FG, Friendly M et al (2020) Vegan: community ecology package. In: R Package Version 2.5-7. https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/vegan/index.html. Accessed 8 May 2022
Park J (2011) A modern pollen–temperature calibration data set from Korea and quantitative temperature reconstructions for the Holocene. The Holocene 21:1125–1135. https://doi.org/10.1177/0959683611400462
Park J, Han J, Jin Q et al (2017) The link between ENSO-like forcing and hydroclimate variability of coastal East Asia during the last millennium. Sci Rep 7:8166. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-017-08538-1
Potapova M (2009) Odontidium mesodon. In: Diatoms N. Am. https://diatoms.org/species/odontidium_mesodon. Accessed 8 May 2022
Potapova MG, Minerovic AD, Veselá J, Smith CR (2020) Diatom new taxon file at the academy of natural sciences (DNTF-ANS). In: Diatom New Taxon File Acad. Nat. Sci. DNTF-ANS. http://symbiont.ansp.org/dntf/. Accessed 8 May 2022
Ramón Mercau J, Laprida C (2016) An ostracod-based calibration function for electrical conductivity reconstruction in lacustrine environments in Patagonia, Southern South America. Ecol Indic 69:522–532. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolind.2016.05.026
Rioual P (2000) Diatom assemblages and water chemistry of lakes in the French Massif Central: a methodology for reconstruction of past limnological and climate fluctuations during the Eemian period. University of London, University College London, United Kingdom
RStudio Team (2020) RStudio: Integrated Development for R. https://www.rstudio.com/. Accessed 8 May 2022
Shuman B, Donnelly JP (2006) The influence of seasonal precipitation and temperature regimes on lake levels in the northeastern United States during the Holocene. Quat Res 65:44–56. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.yqres.2005.09.001
Smol JP, Cumming BF (2000) Tracking long-term changes in climate using algal indicators in lake sediments. J Phycol 36:986–1011. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1529-8817.2000.00049.x
Spaulding SA, Bishop IW, Edlund MB et al (2019) Diatoms of North America. In: Diatoms N. Am. https://diatoms.org/. Accessed 8 May 2022
Swain DL, Langenbrunner B, Neelin JD, Hall A (2018) Increasing precipitation volatility in twenty-first-century California. Nat Clim Change 8:427–433. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41558-018-0140-y
Weckström J, Korhola A (2001) Patterns in the distribution, composition and diversity of diatom assemblages in relation to ecoclimatic factors in Arctic Lapland. J Biogeogr 28(1):31–45. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2699.2001.00537.x
Western Regional Climate Center (2016) Elk Valley, California (049749). In: West. Reg. Clim. Cent. https://wrcc.dri.edu/cgi-bin/cliMAIN.pl?ca2749. Accessed 8 May 2022
Wigdahl-Perry CR, Saros JE, Schmitz J et al (2016) Response of temperate lakes to drought: a paleolimnological perspective on the landscape position concept using diatom-based reconstructions. J Paleolimnol 55:339–356. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10933-016-9883-5
Wolin JA, Stone JR (2010) Diatom as indicators of water-level change in freshwater lakes. In: The diatoms: applications for the environmental and earth sciences. Cambridge University Press, New York, pp 174–185. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511763175.010
Yang J-R, Duthie HC (1995) Regression and weighted averaging models relating surficial sedimentary diatom assemblages to water depth in lake Ontario. J Gt Lakes Res 21:84–94. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0380-1330(95)71023-1
Yoon S-O, Hwang B, Hwang S (2017) Reconstruction of paleo-temperature during the Holocene using WA-PLS analysis of modern pollen from the surface soil in the southeastern part of the Korean peninsula. J Korean Geomorphol Assoc 24:13–25. https://doi.org/10.16968/JKGA.24.4.13
Zamora-Reyes D, Black B, Trouet V (2021) Enhanced winter, spring, and summer hydroclimate variability across California from 1940 to 2019. Int J Climatol. https://doi.org/10.1002/joc.7513
Zhang E, Jones R, Bedford A et al (2007) A chironomid-based salinity inference model from lakes on the Tibetan Plateau. J Paleolimnol 38:477–491. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10933-006-9080-z
This project is funded by the National Science Foundation Division of Earth Sciences (#1702825) to GM, MK, JC, Reza Ramezan, and Kevin Nichols. Additional support came from the UCLA Geography of California and the American West endowment. We want to thank Jen Leidelmeijer, Kyle Campbell, Jazleen Barbosa, Cody Poulson, and Dr. Laura Levy for the cheerful and cooperative fieldwork in 2019. We want to thank Matt Zebrowski for the pretty maps. Also, special thanks to Dr. Kota Katsuki and Dr. Scott Starratt for helping us identify a mystery diatom, and special thanks to Dr. Sergey Ivanovich Genkal for kindly sending the “Identification Book of Diatoms from Russia”. We also thank the editor, Dr. Margarita Caballero, and the reviewers, Dr. Jeffery Stone and one anonymous reviewer, for their insightful and valuable comments that greatly improved this manuscript. Lastly, we want to acknowledge that we are conducting research on the traditional territory of Confederated Tribes of Grand Ronde, Karuk, Cow Creek Umpqua, and Cayuse, Umatilla and Walla Walla nations.
This manuscript was supported by National Science Foundation #1702825.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Han, J., Kirby, M., Carlin, J. et al. A diatom-inferred water-depth transfer function from a single lake in the northern California Coast Range. J Paleolimnol 70, 23–37 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10933-023-00281-0
- Klamath Mountains
- Kelly Lake
- Lake level
- Surface sediment samples
- Inference model