# Teacher questioning and invitations to participate in advanced mathematics lectures

## Abstract

We were interested in exploring the extent to which advanced mathematics lecturers provide students with opportunities to play a role in considering or generating course content. To do this, we examined the questioning practices of 11 lecturers who taught advanced mathematics courses at the university level. Because we are unaware of other studies examining advanced mathematics lecturers’ questioning, we first analyzed the data using an open coding scheme to categorize the types of content lecturers solicited and the opportunities they provided students to participate in generating course content. In a second round of analysis, we examined the extent to which lecturers provide students with opportunities to generate mathematical contributions and to engage in reasoning that researchers have identified as important in advanced mathematics. Our findings highlight that, although lecturers asked many questions, lecturers did not provide substantial opportunities for students to participate in generating mathematical content and reasoning. Additionally, we provide several examples of lecturers providing students with some opportunities to generate important contributions. We conclude by providing implications and areas for future research.

## Keywords

Questioning Teaching of advanced mathematics courses Opportunities to participate## Supplementary material

## References

- Aizikovitsh-Udi, E., & Star, J. (2011). The skill of asking good questions in mathematics teaching.
*Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences*,*15*, 1354–1358.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Alcock, L. (2010). Mathematicians’ perspectives on the teaching and learning of proof. In F. Hitt, D. Holton, & P. Thompson (Eds.),
*Research in collegiate mathematics education VII*(pp. 63–92). Washington DC: MAA.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Alcock, L., & Weber, K. (2005). Proof validation in real analysis: Inferring and checking warrants.
*The Journal of Mathematical Behavior*,*24*(2), 125–134.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Artemeva, N., & Fox, J. (2011). The writing’s on the board: The global and the local in teaching undergraduate mathematics through chalk talk.
*Written Communication*,*28*(4), 345–379.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Blair, R. M., Kirkman, E. E., & Maxwell, J. W. (2013).
*Statistical abstract of undergraduate programs in the mathematical sciences in the United States: Fall 2010 CBMS survey*. American Mathematical Society.Google Scholar - Boaler, J., & Brodie, K. (2004). The importance of depth and breadth in the analysis of teaching: A framework for analyzing teacher questions. In D. E. McDougall & J. A. Ross (Eds.),
*Proceedings of the 26th annual meeting of the North American Chapter of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education*(Vol. 2, pp. 773–80). Toronto: Ontario Institute for Studies in Education, University of Toronto.Google Scholar - Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology.
*Qualitative Research in Psychology*,*3*(2), 77–101.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Chi, M. T. H., & Wiley, R. (2014). The ICAP framework: Linking cognitive engagement to active learning outcomes.
*Educational Psychologist*,*49*(4), 219–243.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Duell, O. K., Lynch, D. J., Ellsworth, R., & Moore, C. A. (1992). Wait-time in college classes taken by education majors.
*Research in Higher Education*,*33*(4), 483–495.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Franke, M. L., Webb, N. M., Chan, A. G., Ing, M., Freund, D., & Battey, D. (2009). Teacher questioning to elicit students’ mathematical thinking in elementary school classrooms.
*Journal of Teacher Education*,*60*(4), 380–392.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Fukawa-Connelly, T. P., Johnson, E., & Keller, R. (2016). Can math education research improve the teaching of abstract algebra?
*Notices of the AMs*,*63*(3), 276–281.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Fukawa-Connelly, T. P., & Newton, C. (2014). Analyzing the teaching of advanced mathematics courses via the enacted example space.
*Educational Studies in Mathematics*,*87*(3), 323–349.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Fukawa-Connelly, T. P., Weber, K., & Mejia-Ramos, J. P. (2017). Informal content and student note taking in advanced mathematics classes.
*Journal for Research in Mathematics Education*,*48*(5), 567–579.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Gabel, M., & Dreyfus, T. (2017). Affecting the flow of a proof by creating presence—A case study in number theory.
*Educational Studies in Mathematics*,*96*(2), 187–205.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Heinze, A., & Erhard, M. (2006). How much time do students have to think about teacher questions? An investigation of the quick succession of teacher questions and student responses in the German mathematics classroom.
*ZDM*,*38*(5), 388–398.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Hiebert, J., & Wearne, D. (1993). Instructional tasks, classroom discourse, and students’ learning in second-grade arithmetic.
*American Educational Research Journal*,*30*(2), 393–425.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Lew, K., Fukawa-Connelly, T. P., Mejia-Ramos, J. P., & Weber, K. (2016). Lectures in advanced mathematics: Why students might not understand what the mathematics professor is trying to convey.
*Journal for Research in Mathematics Education*,*47*(2), 162–198.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Mesa, V. (2010). Student participation in mathematics lessons taught by seven successful community college instructors.
*Adults Learning Mathematics*,*5*(1), 64–88.Google Scholar - Mesa, V., Celis, S., & Lande, E. (2014). Teaching approaches of community college mathematics faculty: Do they relate to classroom practices?
*American Educational Research Journal*,*51*(1), 117–151.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Mills, M. (2014). A framework for example usage in proof presentations.
*The Journal of Mathematical Behavior*,*33*, 106–118.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Moyer, P. S., & Milewicz, E. (2002). Learning to question: Categories of questioning used by preservice teachers during diagnostic mathematics interviews.
*Journal of Mathematics Teacher Education*,*5*(4), 293–315.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Nathan, M. J., & Kim, S. (2009). Regulation of teacher elicitations in the mathematics classroom.
*Cognition and Instruction*,*27*(2), 91–120.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Pinto, A. (2013).
*Revisiting university mathematics teaching: A tale of two instructors*. Paper presented in the Eighth Congress of European Research in Mathematics Education (CERME 8), Antalya, Turkey.Google Scholar - Rasmussen, C., & Wawro, M. (2017). Post-calculus research in undergraduate mathematics education. In J. Cai (Ed.),
*Handbook of research in mathematics education*. National Council of Teachers of Mathematics: Reston, VA.Google Scholar - Rowe, M. B. (1974). Wait-time and rewards as instructional variables, their influence on language, logic, and fate control: Part one-wait-time.
*Journal of Research in Science Teaching*,*11*(2), 81–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Rowe, M. B. (1986). Wait time: Slowing down may be a way of speeding up!
*Journal of Teacher Education*,*37*(1), 43–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Sahin, A., & Kulm, G. (2008). Sixth grade mathematics teachers’ intentions and use of probing, guiding, and factual questions.
*Journal of Mathematics Teacher Education*,*11*(3), 221–241.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Selden, A., & Selden, J. (2003). Validations of proofs considered as texts: Can undergraduates tell whether an argument proves a theorem?
*Journal for Research in Mathematics Education,*4–36.Google Scholar - Stein, M. K., Remillard, J., & Smith, M. S. (2007). How curriculum influences student learning. In F. K. Lester (Ed.),
*Second handbook of research on mathematics teaching and learning*. Information Age Pub: Charlotte, NC.Google Scholar - Stylianides, G. J., Stylianides, A. J., & Weber, K. (2017). Research on the teaching and learning of proof: Taking stock and moving forward. In J. Cai (Ed.),
*Handbook of research in mathematics education*(pp. 237–266). Reston, VA: National Council of Teachers of Mathematics.Google Scholar - Swift, J. N., & Gooding, C. T. (1983). Interaction of wait time feedback and questioning instruction on middle school science teaching.
*Journal of Research in Science Teaching*,*20*(8), 721–730.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Tobin, K. (1986). Effects of teacher wait time on discourse characteristics in mathematics and language arts classes.
*American Educational Research Journal*,*23*(2), 191–200.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Viirman, O. (2015). Explanation, motivation and question posing routines in university mathematics teachers' pedagogical discourse: A commognitive analysis.
*International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology*,*46*(8), 1165–1181.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Weber, K. (2001). Student difficulty in constructing proofs: The need for strategic knowledge.
*Educational Studies in Mathematics*,*48*(1), 101–119.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Weber, K. (2004). Traditional instruction in advanced mathematics courses: A case study of one professor’s lectures and proofs in an introductory real analysis course.
*The Journal of Mathematical Behavior*,*23*(2), 115–133.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Wood, T. (1998). Alternative patterns of communication in mathematics classes: Funneling or focusing. In H. Steinbring, M. G. Bartolini Bussi, & A. Sierpinska (Eds.),
*Language and communication in the mathematics classroom*(pp. 167–178). Reston, VA: National Council of Teachers of Mathematics.Google Scholar