Abstract
In examining how reform-leading supranational institutions respond to public criticism, this article advances current theory on their institutional accountability mechanisms and extends research on this topic by focusing on their responses to public criticism of alleged reform failures. We consider the case of the International Monetary Fund’s (IMF’s) involvement in the Greek economic crisis, as the structural adjustment reforms it imposed to stabilize the economy. We show how these controversial and, by many accounts, failed policies have profoundly impacted the well-being of the recipient country by reducing social cohesion and impoverishing the most vulnerable groups. In explaining the IMF’s institutional response mechanism for fending off such criticism, we offer moral regulatory appropriation (MRA) as a processual framework and present the IMF’s organizing logic of institutional legitimation processes in four domains of action: agentic mission, reform policies, institutional policy negotiations, and moral appropriation. We argue that this enables institutions to maintain moral legitimacy despite evidence of their reforms’ policy failure and various negative consequences for their populations. The proposed framework has theoretical implications for conceptualizing the rhetorical deployment of moral legitimation to secure and defend institutional accountability. We also highlight the limitations and boundaries of such an approach by the IMF and similar reform-leading institutions.
Similar content being viewed by others
Change history
15 January 2023
The original online version of this article was revised: Formatting codes that erroneously appeared in the text were removed.
References
Aerts, W., & Cormier, D. (2009). Media legitimacy and corporate environmental communication. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 34(1), 1–27.
Alfred, C. (2015). These economists are calling for an end to Greece’s austerity nightmare. Huffington Post, February 7.
Anesa, M., Gillespie, N., Spee, A. P., & Sadiq, K. (2019). The legitimation of corporate tax minimization. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 75, 17–39.
Ashforth, B., Gioia, D. A., Robinson, S. L., & Trevino, L. (2008). Re-viewing institutional corruption. Academy of Management Review, 33(3), 670–684.
Baur, D., & Palazzo, G. (2011). The moral legitimacy of NGOs as partners of corporations. Business Ethics Quarterly, 21(4), 579–604.
BBC (2013). Christine Lagarde, Managing Director, IMF. HARDTalk, April 22.
BBC (2015). Grexit: Why the IMF thinks Greece deal won’t work. BBC Radio 5 Live News Special. https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p02x3pkm.
BBC (2016). Christine Lagarde, Managing Director, IMF. HARDTalk, April 18.
Bealing, W. E., Dirsmith, M. W., & Fogarty, T. (1996). Early regulatory actions by the SEC: An institutional theory perspective on the dramaturgy of political exchanges. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 21(4), 317–338.
Blanchard, O. (2015). Institute of International Finance. IMF Publishing.
Blanchard, O. J., & Leigh, D. (2013). Growth forecast errors and fiscal multipliers. The American Economic Review, 103(3), 117–120.
Bloomberg, (2012) Europe Pushed by IMF’s Lagarde to Consider Greek Debt Write-Off. Accessed online from URL: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2012-09-25/europe-pushed-by-imf-s-lagarde-to-consider-greek-debt-write-off.
Boltanski, L., & Thévenot, L. (1999). The sociology of critical capacity. European Journal of Social Theory, 2(3), 359–377.
Boughton, M. J., & Mourmouras, A. (2004). Whose programme is it? Policy ownership and conditional lending. In D. Vines & L. C. Gilbert (Eds.), The IMF and its critics: Reform of global financial architecture (pp. 225–253). Cambridge University Press.
Breton, G., & Côté, L. (2006). Profit and the legitimacy of the Canadian banking industry. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 19(4), 512–539.
Caprar, V. D., & Neville, A. B. (2012). “Norming” and “conforming”: Integrating cultural and institutional explanations for sustainability adoption in business. Journal of Business Ethics, 110, 231–245.
Carpenter, V. L., & Feroz, E. H. (2001). Institutional theory and accounting rule choice: An analysis of four US state governments’ decisions to adopt generally accepted accounting principles. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 26(7–8), 565–596.
Coslor, E., & Spaenjers, C. (2016). Organizational and epistemic change: The growth of the art investment field. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 55, 48–62.
Covaleski, M. A., Dirsmith, M. W., & Samuel, S. (2003). Changes in the institutional environment and the institutions of governance: Extending the contributions of transaction cost economics within the management control literature. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 28(5), 417–441.
Covaleski, M. A., Dirsmith, M. W., & Weiss, J. M. (2013). The social construction, challenge and transformation of a budgetary regime: The endogenization of welfare regulation by institutional entrepreneurs. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 38(5), 333–364.
Danaher, K. (1999). Fifty years is enough: The case against the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund. USA: South End Press.
Denzin, N. (1978). The research act: A theoretical introduction to sociological methods. McGraw-Hill.
Denzin, N. (2012). Triangulation 2.0. Journal of Mixed Methods Research, 6(2), 80–88.
Dhanani, A., & Connolly, C. (2015). Non-governmental organizational accountability: Talking the talk and walking the walk? Journal of Business Ethics, 129, 613–637.
Donnan, S. (2016). Christine Lagarde wants softer, kinder IMF to face populist anger. Financial Times, July 13.
Doyle, P. (2015). The IMF needs less Lagarde. Huffington Post, January 21.
El-Erian, M. A. (2019). The IMF can (and must) disrupt itself. IMF Finance & Development, 56(2), 24–26.
Elliott, L. (2016). IMF’s own watchdog criticises its handling of Eurozone crisis. The Guardian, July 28.
Erskine, T. (2003). Can institutions have responsibilities? Collective moral agency and international relations. Palgrave Macmillan.
Eyraud, L., & Weber, A. (2013). The challenge of debt reduction during fiscal consolidation. IMF Working Paper 13/67, Washington, DC.
Fairclough, I., & Fairclough, N. (2012). Political discourse analysis: A method for advanced students. Routledge.
Fairclough, N. (1995a). Critical discourse analysis. Longman.
Fairclough, N. (1995b). Media discourse. Edward Arnold.
Fairclough, N. (1998). Political discourse in the media: An analytical framework. In A. Bell & P. Garrett (Eds.), Approaches to media discourse (pp. 142–162). Blackwell.
Flanagan, J. C. (1954). The critical incident technique. Psychological Bulletin, 51(4), 327–358.
Fotaki, M. (2010). Why do public policies fail so often? Exploring Health Policy Making as an Imaginary/symbolic Construction. Organization, 17(6), 703–720.
Fotaki, M., & Hyde, P. (2015). Organizational blind spots: Splitting, blame and idealization in the National Health Service. Human Relations, 68(3), 441–462.
Fransen, L. (2013). The embeddedness of responsible business practice: Exploring the interaction between national-institutional environments and corporate social responsibility. Journal of Business Ethics, 115, 213–227.
FT (2014). Lagarde warns of ‘new mediocre’ era. Accessed online from URL: https://www.ft.com/content/2bfa11d6-4a44-11e4-8de3-00144feab7de.
Galbraith, K. J. (2015). What is reform? The strange case of Greece and Europe. The American Prospect, June 12.
Gilbert, D. U., Rasche, A., & Waddock, S. (2011). Accountability in a global economy: The emergence of international accountability standards. Business Ethics Quarterly, 21(1), 23–44.
Glaser, B. G., & Strauss, A. L. (1967). The discovery of grounded theory: Strategies for qualitative research. Aldine.
Graeber, D. (2011). Debt. New York, NY: Melville House.
Gruber, L. (2000). Ruling the world: Power politics and the rise of supranational institutions. Princeton University Press.
Hayne, C., & Free, C. (2014). Hybridized professional groups and institutional work: COSO and the rise of enterprise risk management. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 39(5), 309–330.
Heath, C., Hindmarsh, J., & Luff, P. (2010). Video in qualitative research: Analysing social interaction in everyday life. Sage.
Hoggett, P. (2006). Conflict, ambivalence, and the contested purpose of public organizations. Human Relations, 59(2), 175–194.
IEO. (2016). The IMF and crises in Greece, Ireland and Portugal: An evaluation by the Independent Evaluation Office. IMF.
IMF. (2013). Greece: Ex post evaluation of exceptional access under the 2010 stand-by arrangement. IMF.
IMF (2016a) Fiscal Monitor. Acting Now. Acting Together. Washington DC: IMF Publications
IMF (2016b). Country report No. 16/130: Greece. Washington, DC: IMF.
IMF (2021). The IMF at a glance. IMF website, March 3.
Jamali, D. (2010). MNCs and international accountability standards through an institutional lens: Evidence of symbolic conformity or decoupling. Journal of Business Ethics, 95(4), 617–640.
Karadimitriou, N., & Pagonis, T. (2019). Planning reform and development rights in Greece: Institutional persistence and elite rule in the face of the crisis. European Planning Studies, 27(6), 1217–1234.
Kaufman, M., & Covaleski, M. A. (2019). Budget formality and informality as a tool for organizing and governance amidst divergent institutional logics. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 75, 40–58.
Keen S. (2015). It’s all the Greeks fault. Forbes 21st January 2015. https://www.forbes.com/sites/stevekeen/2015/01/21/its-all-the-greeks-fault/?sh=537d923c2ed4.
Kincaid, R. G. (2016). The IMF’s role in the Euro area crisis: What are the lessons from the IMF’s participation in the Troika? Washington, DC: IMF Independent Evaluation Office (BP/16–02/06).
Kokkinidis, T. (2021). Greece has third highest debt to GDP ratio in the world. Greek Reporter, June 30. https://greekreporter.com/2021/06/30/greece-third-highest-debt-gdp-ratio/.
Kopits, G. (2016). The IMF and the Euro area crisis: The fiscal dimension. Washington, DC: IMF Independent Evaluation Office (BP/16–02/07).
Koster, M., Simaens, A., & Vos, B. (2019). The advocate’s own challenges to behave in a sustainable way: An institutional analysis of advocacy NGOs. Journal of Business Ethics, 157(2), 483–501.
Krugman, P. (2015). The case for cuts was a lie. Why does Britain still believe it? The austerity delusion. The Guardian, April 29.
Lagarde, C. (2013) One-on-One: An Investigative Interview with Christine Lagarde - 43rd St. Gallen Symposium. [Video] YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kyy1aQzvDeo.
Lagarde, C. (2015b, Sept.22) Implementing the post-2015b development agenda: A conversation with Christine Lagarde. [Video] YouTube. Implementing the post-2015b development agenda: A conversation with Christine Lagarde.
Lagarde, C. (2015a, Oct.9) IMF Managing Director Press Conference. [Video]. IMF https://www.imf.org/en/Videos/view?vid=3830218299001.
Liddicoat, A. J. (2007). An introduction to conversation analysis. Continuum.
Lipton (2016, May 25) David Lipton: Can Globalization Still Deliver?. Peterson Institute for International Economics. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9i5HL7GiWwo&ab_channel=PetersonInstituteforInternationalEconomics.
Mashaw, J. L. (2006). Accountability and institutional design: Some thoughts on the grammar of governance. In M. Dowdle (Ed.), Public accountability: Designs, dilemmas and experiences (pp. 115–156). Cambridge University Press.
Masters, J., Schatzky, A., & Siripurapu, A. (2021). The IMF: The world’s controversial financial firefighter. Council on Foreign Relations. Septmeber 8. https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/imf-worlds-controversial-financial-firefighter.
Matten, D., & Crane, A. (2005). Corporate citizenship: Towards an extended theoretical conceptualization. Academy of Management Review, 30(1), 166–179.
May, P. (2015). Implementation failures revisited. Public Policy and Administration, 30(3–4), 277–299.
McConnell, A. (2015). What is policy failure? A primer to help navigate the maze. Public Policy and Administration, 30(3–4), 221–242.
Mehta, J., & Winship, C. (2010). Moral power. In S. Hitlin & S. Vaisay (Eds.), Handbook of the sociology of morality (pp. 425–438). Springer.
Messner, M. (2009). The limits of accountability. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 34(8), 918–938.
Mitsushiro, F. (2016, March 22) IMF's Long Term Growth Prospects for The Middle East And Central Asia. Foreign Policy Institute, Johns Hopkins University’s Paul H. Nitze School of Advanced International Studies [Video]. John Hopkins https://sais.jhu.edu/imf-long-term-growth-prospects-middle-east-central-asia.
Mody, A. (2015). A programme for Greece: Follow the IMF’s research. VOXEU, June 18. https://voxeu.org/article/programme-greece-follow-imf-s-research.
Moll, J., & Hoque, Z. (2011). Budgeting for legitimacy: The case of an Australian university. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 36(2), 86–101.
Mouritsen, J. (1994). Rationality, institutions and decision making: Reflections on March and Olsen’s Rediscovering institutions. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 19(2), 193–211.
Mulgan, R. G. (2003). Holding power to account: Accountability in modern democracies. Palgrave Macmillan.
Neu, D., Saxton, G., Everett, J., & Shiraz, A. R. (2018). Speaking truth to power: Twitter reactions to the Panama Papers. Journal of Business Ethics, 162(2), 473–485.
Newton, T. (2005). Practical idealism: An oxymoron? Journal of Management Studies, 42(4), 869–884.
Nicol, O. (2018). No body to kick, no soul to damn: Responsibility and accountability for the Financial Crisis (2007–2010). Journal of Business Ethics, 151(1), 101–114.
Nielsen, P. R., & Massa, G. F. (2013). Reintegrating ethics and institutional theories. Journal of Business Ethics, 115(1), 135–147.
Press Office (2017) Europegroup statement on Greece. Statements and Remarks. 375/15 Accessed online fromhttps://www.consilium.europa.eu/press.
Painter-Morland, M. (2006). Redefining accountability as relational responsiveness. Journal of Business Ethics, 66(1), 89–98.
Palazzo, G., & Scherer, A. G. (2006). Corporate legitimacy as deliberation: A communicative framework. Journal of Business Ethics, 66(1), 71–88.
Papava, V. (2009). The “rosy” mistakes of the IMF and World Bank in Georgia. Problems of Economic Transition, 52(7), 44–55.
Patriotta, G., Gond, J. P., & Schultz, F. (2010). Maintaining legitimacy: Controversies, orders of worth, and public justifications. Journal of Management Studies, 48(8), 1804–1836.
Peet, R. (2000). Unholy trinity: The IMF, World Bank and WTO (2nd ed.). Zed Books.
Pénet, P. (2018). The IMF failure that wasn’t: Risk ignorance during the European debt crisis. British Journal of Sociology, 69(4), 1031–1055.
People’s Global Conference (2018) People’s global conference concludes, vows to develop wider movements against IMF-WB https://peoplesglobalconference.weebly.com/news11.html.
Peters, B. G. (2015). State failure, governance failure and policy failure: Exploring the linkages. Public Policy and Administration, 30(3–4), 261–276.
Phillips, N., Lawrence, B. T., & Hardy, C. (2004). Discourse and institutions. Academy of Management Review, 29(4), 635–652.
Pleines, H. (2022). Opposition to the Washington Consensus: The IMF and social policy reforms in Post-Soviet Russia. In F. Nullmeier, D. González de Reufels, & H. Obinger (Eds.), International impact on social policy. Short histories in global perspective (pp. 275–286). Basingstoke: Palgrave.
Powell, A. (2004). Countries in payments difficulties: What can the IMF do? In D. Vines & L. C. Gilbert (Eds.), The IMF and its critics: Reform of global financial architecture (pp. 263–416). Cambridge University Press.
Power, M. K. (2003). Auditing and the production of legitimacy. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 28(4), 379–394.
Ramoglou, S. (2018). A false morality tale blocks the resolution of the Greek debt crisis. The Conversation, May 24. https://theconversation.com/a-false-morality-tale-blocks-the-resolution-of-the-greek-debt-crisis-59754.
Rice, G. (2017) Transcript of a Press Briefing with Gerry Rice, Director of the IMF Communications Department and IMF Spokesman. [Speech Transcript] https://www.imf.org/en/News/Articles/2017/03/09/TR030917-Transcript-of-a-Press-Briefing-with-Gerry-Rice.
Roxas, B., & Coetzer, A. (2012). Institutional environment, managerial attitudes and environmental sustainability orientation of small firms. Journal of Business Ethics, 111(4), 461–476.
Scott, W. R. (1993). Recent developments in organizational sociology. Acta Sociologica, 36(1), 63–68.
Scott, W. R. (1995). Institutions and organizations. Sage.
Scott, W. R. (1996). The mandate is still being honoured: In defence of Weber’s disciples. Administrative Science Quarterly, 41(1), 163–171.
Scott, W. R. (2001). Institutions and organizations. Sage.
Shah, S. G. S., & Farrow, A. (2020). A commentary on “World Health Organization declares global emergency: A review of the 2019 novel coronavirus (COVID-19).” International Journal of Surgery, 76, 128–129.
Shearer, T. (2002). Ethics and accountability: From the for-itself to the for-the-other. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 27(6), 541–573.
Sinclair, A. (1995). The chameleon of accountability: Forms and discourses. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 20(2–3), 219–237.
Snelson, C. (2011). YouTube across the disciplines: A review of the literature. MERLOT Journal of Online Learning and Teaching, 7(1), 159–169.
Spiegel, P., & Harding, R. (2013). IMF admits to errors in international bailout of Greece. Financial Times, June 5.
Stein, M. (2011). A culture of mania: A psychoanalytic view of the incubation of the 2008 credit crisis. Organization, 18(2), 173–186.
Stiglitz, E. J., & Guzman, M. (2015). Argentina shows Greece there may be life after default. Huffington Post, June 30.
Strauss, A. L., & Corbin, J. (1990). Basics of qualitative research (1st ed.). Sage.
Strauss, A. L., & Corbin, J. (1994). Basics of qualitative research: Grounded theory procedures and techniques. Sage.
Suchman, M. C. (1995). Managing legitimacy: Strategic and institutional approaches. Academy of Management Review, 20(3), 571–610.
Suddaby, R., Elsbach, K., Greenwood, R., Meyer, J., & Zilber, T. B. (2010). Organizations and their institutional environments: Bringing meaning, culture and values back in—introduction to the special research forum. Academy of Management Journal, 53(6), 1234–1240.
Suddaby, R., & Greenwood, R. (2005). Rhetorical strategies of legitimacy. Administrative Science Quarterly, 50(1), 35–67.
Tallberg, J. (2003). The agenda-shaping power of the EU Council presidency. Journal of European Public Policy, 10(1), 1–19.
The Economist (2016). A torrential leak: The Panama papers. The Economist, 419(8984), 61.
The Economist (2021). Poul Thomsen on the story of dealing with Greece's debt and bail-out. [Video] YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q6BKNmRoji8&ab_channel=EconomistImpactSEEuropeEvents.
Tost, L. P. (2011). An integrative model of legitimacy judgments. Academy of Management Review, 36(4), 686–710.
Varoufakis, Y. (2016). And the weak suffer what they must?: Europe, austerity and the threat to global stability. Vintage.
Vinals, J. (2010, Oct. 6) Press briefing on the International Monetary Fund's Global Financial Stability Report. [Webcast] https://www.imf.org/en/Videos/view?vid=626113269001.
Vines, D., & Gilbert, L. C. (Eds.). (2004). The IMF and its critics. Reform of global financial architecture. Cambridge University Press.
Vreeland, R. J. (2007). The International Monetary Fund: Politics of conditional lending. Routledge.
Woods, N. (2004). Accountability, governance and the reform of the IMF. In D. Vines & L. C. Gilbert (Eds.), The IMF and its critics: Reform of global financial architecture (pp. 396–416). Cambridge University Press.
Wooffitt, R. (2005). Conversation analysis and discourse analysis. Sage.
Wyplosz, C., & Sgherri, S. (2016). The IMF’s role in Greece in the context of the 2010 stand-by arrangement. IMF Independent Evaluation Office.
Zittoun, P. (2015). Analysing policy failure as an argumentative strategy in the policymaking process: A pragmatist perspective. Public Policy and Administration, 30(3–4), 243–260.
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the anonymous reviewers and the editor for their help and guidance. Their constructive comments have been very useful in helping us improve the paper. We seek to acknowledge their support.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
Not applicable.
Research involving Human Participants and/or Animals
Not applicable.
Informed Consent
Not applicable
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Avakian, S., Fotaki, M. Accounting for Failure Through Morality: The IMF’s Involvement in (Mis)managing the Greek Crisis. J Bus Ethics 189, 817–841 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-022-05312-w
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-022-05312-w