Cells on uniform PDMS substrates with different elasticity
Mechanical properties of PDMS substrates, tuned by time of UV irradiation, were measured using AFM-based force spectroscopy, providing Young modulus equal to 0.24 and 1.67 MPa for soft (UV irradiated for 5 h) and stiff (not irradiated) PDMS, respectively. Other physicochemical properties of the substrate, i.e. chemical composition, wettability, surface energy and topography were not affected by the tuning of elasticity procedure (Raczkowska et al. 2016).
To investigate potential effect of elasticity on cellular behavior, non-malignant HCV29 cells were cultured onto sof and stiff PDMS substrates. The representative fluorescence micrographs, recorded after 24 and 144 h of culture are presented in Fig. 2.
Recorded fluorescence micrographs indicate the elasticity dependent proliferation already after 24 h of incubation. Although for both substrates rare, separated cells can be observed their amount is slightly higher for soft substrate. For longer incubation time (t = 144 h), the impact of elasticity becomes significantly more profound and evident. For stiff PDMS the numerous, distinguishable cells are observed, whereas for the soft one the confluent, monocellular layer is formed, with individual cells hardly visible.
To quantify changes in cell growth for PDMS substrates with different elasticity, the number of cells was determined as a function of culture time (Fig. 3). Numerical results validate previous observations. Although for both substrates the number of cells increase monotonically with time of incubation, the proliferation process is approximately twice more effective for cells cultured on soft substrate. After 144 h of incubation number of HCV29 cells increases by 16 times on soft and only 8 times on stiff PDMS.
The results presented here, together with our previous studies on cancerous prostate and melanoma cells (Prauzner-Bechcicki et al. 2015) indicate similarity among cancerous cells. However, it should be noted that effect of stiffness-dependent cytocompatibility is highly cell-specific (Brown et al. 2005; Park et al. 2010).
Cells on PDMS substrates with continuous elasticity gradient
To analyze more precisely impact of substrate elasticity on proliferation of HCV29 cells, PDMS with continuous elasticity gradient, changing gradually from 0.24 to 1.67 MPa was prepared and used as substrate for cell culture. For each sample, fluorescence micrographs were recorded in three regions – at both ends and in the central part of the sample, i.e. for soft, stiff and ‘medium’ PDMS. However, as the elasticity of the substrate does not change linearly with the UV irradiation time, stiffness of ‘medium’ PDMS is shifted towards lower values (E ~ 0.6 MPa (Raczkowska et al. 2016)). Elasticity maps, determined using quantitative imaging mode and presented in upper row of Fig. 4 show high homogeneity of PDMS mechanical properties over a large scan area.
Representative fluorescence micrographs, recorded after 144h of HCV29 cell culture and presented in bottom row of Fig. 4, show cellular behavior analogous to the one observed on substrates with discrete elasticities - density of cells decreases with increasing stiffness of substrate. For soft and medium PDMS, cells cover whole available surface, creating confluent layer, with single cells hardly distinguishable. In contrast, for stiff substrate the number of cells is significantly reduced and separated individual cells may be still observed.
Cells on PDMS substrates with discrete elasticity gradient
In living organisms, cells sense strong variations of local elasticity, changing even few orders of magnitude, especially at the interfaces (Engler et al. 2006; Kandow et al. 2007; Seidi et al. 2011; Sunyer et al. 2012; Tse and Engler 2011), which affect strongly their behavior. Therefore proliferation of HCV29 cells was analyzed on substrates with sharp interface between soft and stiff region.
First, to verify formation of sharp elasticity interface, spatial distribution of the PDMS elastic properties was measured in the border area, using QI-AFM mode. In addition to phase contrast image (Fig. 5a), also AFM topography (Fig. 5b) and error (Fig. 5c) micrographs depicted nonlinear but sharp border between two regions of the sample – UV-irradiated and not irradiated. QI-AFM measurements performed in these two areas clearly show difference in the mechanical properties of the substrate. Recorded maps of elasticity depict substrate stiffness significantly higher in upper, not irradiated region of the sample (Fig. 5c), as compared to the bottom one, UV-irradiated for 5 h (Fig. 5d). Obtained results undoubtedly confirm formation of discrete elasticity gradient on PDMS substrates, UV-irradiated through the printed mask.
Subsequently, these substrates were used to study the influence of discrete elasticity gradient on proliferation process of HCV29 cells. For this purpose large scale fluorescence micrographs were recorded on soft and stiff PDMS region, as well as at their interface (Fig. 6).
In accordance to the previous results, cells proliferate significantly more effective on soft part of the substrate than on the stiff one. The micrographs recorded at the interface of both regions show sharp increase of number of cells, mirroring perfectly the change in elastic properties of the sample.
These results indicate strongly that it should be possible to create substrates with elasticity patterns, enabling precise positioning of cells in desired areas, which is crucial for potential application in cell based biosensors and micro assays.
To test this hypothesis, PDMS substrate with two types of patterns, i.e. alternating soft and stiff stripes and soft squares surrounded by stiff matrix were prepared (Fig. 7) simply by UV-irradiation of PDMS through the printed mask (see Experimental for details).
Then, they were used as substrates to culture HCV29 cells. Fluorescence micrographs, recorded after 72 h of incubation, show preferential proliferation of cells on soft regions of the sample, leading to formation of well-ordered cellular patterns. These results confirm the strong impact of substrate elasticity on cellular behavior, being the driving force enabling precise positioning of analyzed cancerous cells in a wide range of dimensions (Fig. 8, bottom row) and over a large area (Fig. 8, upper row).
Possibility to create PDMS substrates with elasticity patterns of desired shapes and dimensions enables precise positioning of both, individual cells and groups of them (Fig. 9). This gives the powerful tool to study individual and collective cell – substrate interaction as well as the influence of different external factors on adhesion and proliferation process at the single cell level, which remains the key issue in many biological and medical fields.