Predicted bulk composition of petroleum generated by Lower Cretaceous Wealden black shales, Lower Saxony Basin, Germany

Abstract

The Berriasian Wealden Shale provides the favourable situation of possessing immature to overmature source rock intervals due to differential subsidence within the Lower Saxony Basin. Hydrocarbon generation kinetics and petroleum physical properties have been investigated on four immature Wealden Shale samples situated in different depth intervals and following the PhaseKinetics approach of di Primio and Horsfield (AAPG Bull 90(7):1031–1058, 2006). Kinetic parameters and phase prediction were applied to a thermally calibrated 1D model of the geodynamic evolution at the location of an overmature well. The immature source rocks of all depth intervals comprise kerogen type I being derived from the lacustrine algae Botryococcus braunii. Bulk kinetics of the lower three depth intervals (sample 2–4) can be described by one single activation energy E _a, typical for homogeneous, lacustrine organic matter (OM), whereas sample 1 from the uppermost interval shows a slightly broader E _a distribution which hints to a more heterogeneous, less stable OM, but still of lacustrine origin. Predicted physical properties of the generated petroleum fluids are characteristic of variably waxy, black oil possessing GOR’s below 100 Sm³/Sm³ and saturations pressures below 150 bar. Petroleum fluids from the more heterogeneous OM-containing sample 1 can always be described by slightly higher values. Based on the occurrence of paraffinic, free hydrocarbons in the uppermost horizon of the overmature well and gas/condensate in the lower 3 depth intervals, two scenarios have been discussed. From the first and least realistic scenario assuming no expulsion from the source rock, it can be deduced that phase separation in the course of uplift can only have occurred in the uppermost interval containing the slightly less stable OM but not in the lower intervals being composed of a more stable OM. Therefore and taking secondary cracking into account, all depth intervals should contain gas/condensate. The free hydrocarbons in the upper horizon are interpreted as impregnation from migrated hydrocarbons. The second scenario assumes nearly complete expulsion due to fracturing by the so-called generation overpressure (Mann et al. in Petroleum and basin evolution. Springer, Berlin, 1997). The expelled petroleum might migrate into lower pressurised source rock horizons and reach bubble-point pressures leading to the exsolution of gas and “precipitation” of very high molecular weight bitumen unable to migrate. Subsequent burial of the latter in the course of the basin evolution would lead to secondary cracking and remaining pyrobitumen explaining the high amounts of pyrobitumen in the overmature well Ex-B and relatively enhanced TOC contents at such high maturity levels.

Introduction

The Lower Saxony Basin (LSB) is the most important oil province of Germany as well as the oldest oil-producing basin in the world, with first production starting as early as 1859. Numerous small- to medium-sized reservoir rocks exist containing between 6.8 and 22.6 trillion (10¹²) m³ (240–798 tcf, median: 13 trillion m³ = 459 tcf) gas-in-place of which 10 % are recoverable reserves (BGR 2012) and 75.5 MMbbls of recoverable crude oil (LBEG 2014; WEG 2013). The hydrocarbon fields are more or less aligned in a NW–SE direction in the LSB, an N–S trending region in the Gifhorn Trough and a NE–SW trend in the West and East Holstein Troughs (including the Mittelplate oil field). Oil is mainly extracted from Middle Jurassic siliciclastic reservoirs, though uppermost Triassic, Cretaceous and Tertiary reservoirs are also present. The crude oils are derived from two sources, namely the Wealden and the Posidonia Shale (e.g. Gifhorn Trough, Schwarzkopf and Leythaeuser 1988) with co-sourced petroleums being commonplace. All oil fields occur in the source rock maturity zone 0.5–0.9 % R ₀ (Kockel et al. 1994). Biodegradation plays a major role in defining oil quality (Blumenstein et al. 2008). The oils generally have a low solution gas–oil ratio; density and viscosity vary (Fabian 1963; Lübben 1969). Petroleum sources are readily distinguished by stable isotopic composition, the isotopically lighter signature being attributed to Posidonia Shale and the heavier to Wealden (Kockel et al. 1994). The contribution of the two sources may also be reflected in the composition of the asphaltenes of migrated bitumens in the Hils Syncline, as seen in the Holzener Asphaltkalk (Horsfield et al. 1991).

The petroleum-generating properties of one of the oil source rocks, the marine Posidonia Shale, have been reported in detail (Rullkötter et al. 1988; Welte et al. 1997 and references therein). For example, the kinetic parameters for petroleum generation from the Posidonia Shale were published by Schaefer et al. (1990) and secondary cracking kinetics by Dieckmann et al. (1998). Source quality, as manifested by chain length distribution, used to define petroleum-type organofacies (Horsfield 1989), was presented by Horsfield and Dueppenbecker (1991); Muscio et al. (1991) showed that these characteristics are carried over from kerogen into genetically related asphaltenes. Petroleum expulsion efficiencies are extremely high, based on mass balance calculations (Rullkötter 1993). It is important to note, within the context of this ICDP Special Issue, that the six shallow research boreholes drilled in the Hils syncline played a key role in enabling fresh (unweathered) sections of the Lias-ε shales (Posidonia Shale) and part of the overlying Dogger-α mudstones to be cored, and thereafter petroleum generation and migration to be studied as a function of maturity (R _m = 0.48–1.45 % V _R) for a constant organofacies provided within a natural laboratory.

By comparison, very little coherent information has been published on the petroleum generation characteristics of the Wealden, in part because of its physical and chemical heterogeneity (Pelzer et al. 1992; Elstner and Mutterlose 1996; Mutterlose and Bornemann 2000), most likely related (cf. Berner et al. 2010; Berner 2011) to the combined effects of climatically driven precipitation changes and tectonically driven marine ingressions. The depositional environment of the LSB during the earliest Cretaceous (Berriasian) comprises lacustrine sediments in the basin centre interfingering with fluvial sediments towards the basin margin as well as terrigenous coal-bearing sequences. The basin consists of western, central and eastern parts which underwent differential subsidence and can furthermore be subdivided according to facies distributions and different sedimentation rates (Nebe 1999). The central basin contains up to 700 m of fluvial–lacustrine mudstones (Elstner and Mutterlose 1996; Mutterlose and Bornemann 2000). Throughout the basin, brackish–lacustrine and marine freshwater conditions alternate, representing short-lived marine ingressions (upper Wealden 2/lower Wealden 3 and upper Wealden 3/lower Wealden 4, lower Wealden 5), until the depositional environment developed to a full marine one during mid-Valanginian times (Wealden 5 and 6).

The recent release of complete cores from three wells, drilled for shale gas exploration in the LSB, has provided new opportunities for examining the organic geochemical characteristics of the Wealden. Rippen et al. (2013) employed geochemical and petrographical methods to determine the maturity, organofacies and depositional environment of Wealden Shale samples stemming from these wells, and Bruns et al. (2013b) included some of that geochemical data in a 3D basin model of the LSB reconstructing the geodynamic basin evolution. Here, we extend our understanding of the Wealden’s source rock properties by predicting the bulk composition of the petroleum it generates as a function of thermal maturity level for each of the major organofacies it displays. The reason for doing so is that the chemical composition of generated petroleum directly controls its physical response (PVT behaviour) to changing pressure and temperature conditions in source and carrier systems during subsidence and uplift, with gas–oil ratio, gas composition and liquid composition having the predominant impact (di Primio et al. 1998; di Primio and Skeie 2004). For instance, an undersaturated petroleum consisting of a single liquid phase containing dissolved gas under sub-surface reservoir conditions will change into a two-phase system during geological uplift or when produced at the surface (England et al. 1987), and the fact remains that a great number of petroleums worldwide have undergone changes in composition due to phase behaviour (England and Mackenzie 1989). The PhaseKinetics approach (di Primio and Horsfield 2006) has been utilised to embed PVT predictive properties in a compositional kinetics matrix. To assist in our analysis, bulk kinetic parameters have been integrated into a 1D model for a mature well (Bruns et al. 2013b and Fig. 1) and the derived phase states compared with the present-day composition of the free hydrocarbons (HC) in a thermally mature well in the LSB (Rippen et al. 2013).

The work here focuses of the main phase of petroleum generation and migration and upon cumulative petroleum charges because interest in conventional petroleum systems in Germany remains relatively high. While the Wealden is one of three potential target horizons for shale gas in Germany (the others are the Posidonia Shale and Lower Carboniferous), its unconventional gas potential at high thermal maturity (R _m > 1.2 %) is not considered directly here. Our results are nevertheless relatable to shale (tight) oil potential in a general sense.

Materials and methods

Sample set and bulk characterisation

The wells Ex-A and Ex-B were drilled in the LSB during 2008 and 2009 in order to sample and test the Wealden for its ability to generate and store hydrocarbons. Both wells were drilled penetrating the central basin facies which consist of thick, homogeneous to laminated mudstone sequences with variable mineral composition and shell fossil content. Samples have been taken from four different depth intervals of the Berriasian Wealden Shale representing dark shales and marlstones. According to Rippen et al. (2013), the samples of the middle depth intervals 2–3 of wells Ex-A and Ex-B represent the lithostratigraphic unit Wealden 3. Correspondingly, samples in stratigraphically higher or lower intervals are of younger or older age, respectively.

A set of 293 samples was geochemically and petrographically described in detail by Rippen et al. (2013), and organic petrography and random vitrinite reflectance (VR_r) measurements revealed that organic matter in well Ex-A is thermally immature to early mature with vitrinite reflectances between 0.5 and 0.6 % VR_r. Organic matter in well Ex-B is clearly overmature exhibiting an average vitrinite reflectance of 2.3 %. The molecular maturity indices investigated by Rippen et al. (2013) are in good accordance with the vitrinite reflectance measurements.

Here, we have selected four samples (Table 1), chosen for their high TOC contents (full range 0.3–17.5 %), which represent the four depth intervals of well Ex-A and which are characterised by slightly different depositional environments. The organic matter consists mainly of kerogen type I (telalginite and lamalginite) derived from Botryococcus braunii. Variability in Rock–Eval T _max from low to high values (429–452 °C) is related to differences in kerogen structure at a single maturity level.

Table 1 Depth intervals of the early mature well Ex-A and their representative samples characterised by Rock–Eval pyrolysis data

Open-system pyrolysis [results described in Rippen et al. (2013) and shown in Fig. 2] revealed that kerogen in samples 1–4 yields a pyrolysate which is dominated by intermediate to long, straight-chained aliphatic hydrocarbons and shows only minor concentrations of aromatic compounds, cycloalkanes as well as sulphur- and oxygen-bearing compounds. A paraffinic high-wax oil-generating organofacies can be inferred from the ternary diagram in Fig. 2 (Horsfield 1989). This pyrolysate composition is typically observed for type I organic matter most likely derived from the selective preservation of a highly aliphatic biomacromolecule (algaenan) present in the outer cell walls of lacustrine algae such as B. braunii (Metzger and Largeau 2005; Largeau et al. 1984; Tegelaar et al. 1989). As stated above, algal bodies of B. braunii were proven in all studied samples of well Ex-A by petrographical observations (Rippen et al. 2013). Interestingly, the pyrolysate of sample 1 plots on the border to the paraffinic, naphthenic, aromatic low-wax and high-wax oil-generating organofacies fields in Fig. 2, which might be indicative of either input of marine-influenced algal and hence shorter alkyl-chain-dominated organic material, or a stronger oxidising depositional environment (might explain a higher OI of this sample; compare Table 1 and Sachsenhofer et al. (1995) or higher input (presence) of microbial, bacterial organic matter (Gelpi et al. 1970; Kenig et al. 1990). In any case, sample 1 comprises slightly more heterogeneous organic matter than samples 2–4. It should be also noted that samples of similar depth intervals were shown (Rippen et al. 2013; Fig. 2) to plot in the wax-richer as well as in the wax-poorer part of the paraffinic high-wax field, indicating that the wax-poorer signature is not necessarily evidence for a marine depositional environment.

Organic matter in samples of well Ex-B is late mature to overmature and hence thermally depleted in hydrogen-rich moieties and relatively enriched in aromatic compounds. It exhibits only slightly lower TOC contents than organic matter from well Ex-A and can be classified as type III to IV kerogen, or solid bitumen, according to the S2 versus TOC plot and HI versus T _max diagram (Fig. 6 in Rippen et al. 2013). From the latter plot, it can be deduced that the OM classification of the mature samples of well Ex-B does not reflect the initial kerogen type which is supposed to be of the same quality as in well Ex-A. From open pyrolysis, it can be revealed that the residual OM has a potential for gas and condensate generation left. An interesting feature, revealed by thermovaporisation (compare Rippen et al. 2013), is the presence of paraffinic, waxy oil in the upper depth intervals of well Ex-B, whereas in the lower depth intervals only gas and condensates in relatively low amounts are encountered. This could neither be tracked back to the initial organic matter type, which was shown to be an only slightly different kerogen type I for all depth intervals in well Ex-A, nor to the impact of thermal stress (secondary cracking), as similar free hydrocarbon signatures do as well occur in a less mature well (well Ex-C; VR ~1.6 %; compare Rippen et al. (2013)). Alternative explanations might be hydrothermal solution circulating at the base of the successions (Lüders et al. 2012) or, a topic that shall be discussed in the present manuscript, phase separation related to pressure decrease during upwards migration or uplift of a single petroleum phase.

Methods

PhaseKinetics is a compositional kinetic modelling approach based on open- and closed-system (MSSV)–pyrolysis gas chromatography to determine petroleum-type organofacies, bulk petroleum generation parameters and bulk compositions at selected transformation ratios and, finally, tuning to configure results in a PVT-amenable format. Here, we perform this workflow on four German Wealden Shale samples and then apply the results in a 1D petroleum system model of a local well (Ex-B) within the LSB. The bulk characterisation of this sample set and hence the petroleum typing has already been published by Rippen et al. (2013) (for description, see previous chapter).

Bulk kinetics using source rock analyzer

Bulk kinetic modelling is used to determine the kinetic parameters of primary bulk petroleum generation from kerogen using non-isothermal open-system pyrolysis. Whole rock samples were artificially matured at four different heating rates (0.7, 2, 5 and 15 K/min) using a source rock analyzer (SRA-TPH/IR) from Humble Instruments. 2.2–29.9 mg of sample amount, depending on heating rate and organic matter richness, was weighted into small vessels and heated to temperatures as high as 640 °C. Generated bulk petroleum products are transported to an FID (flame ionisation detector) by a constant helium flow (50 mL/min). Gained raw data were computed to discrete activation energy (E _a) distributions consisting of n = 25 or fewer parallel reactions regularly spaced by 1 kcal/mol (Schaefer et al. 1990; Schenk and Horsfield 1993) and a single variable frequency factor (A in 1/s) by using KINETICS2000 and KMOD^® (Burnham et al. 1987). The mathematical routine for the first-order kinetic scheme is based on the Arrhenius law (Schenk et al. 1997b; van Heek and Jüntgen 1968) and has been described by Schaefer et al. (1990).

Micro-scale-sealed vessel pyrolysis (MSSV-Py-GC-FID)

Non-isothermal MSSV closed-system pyrolysis (Horsfield et al. 1989) is a micro-analytical method to artificially mature sedimentary organic matter to different stages of conversion and to qualify and quantify the composition of generated products. It provides the possibility to determine primary and secondary reaction kinetics of specific compound groups and to extrapolate their generation to geological heating rates. This technique consists of two sequential steps: (1) artificial maturation of small aliquots of the original samples in a closed glass tube (micro-scale-sealed vessel) to distinct end temperatures and (2) investigation of the generated products qualitatively and quantitatively on a molecular level by gas chromatography. Small one-sided closed glass capillary tubes of approximately 40 µL volume with a bore diameter of 1.0 mm and a flexure of 120° were used to carry the weighted sample material. Between 5.0 and 15.5 mg of sample material was filled into the elbow portion of the tube and held by glass wool and quartz sand. The tube was closed by a hydrogen flame. Sample aliquots were artificially matured in a pyrolysis oven consisting of a massive, cylindrical metal block acting as a circular sample holder. A central heating cartridge provided a very homogeneous temperature field throughout the core which is controlled by a thermocouple introduced into one sample holder. For the analytical procedure, a pyrolysis–gas chromatograph from AGILENT Instruments has been used (AGILENT GC 6890A Chromatograph). The MSSV tubes were purged for 5 min at 300 °C and then cracked open manually by a purpose-built piston device. Sample products were flushed by a helium flow (30 mL/min) to a cryogenic trap which, after removal of the liquid nitrogen-containing Dewar vessel, was ballistically heated to 300 °C after 10 min. Hydrocarbons fixed in the trap were released via a 50 m × 0.32 mm capillary column (J&W Scientific HP-Ultra 1 [Dimethylpolysiloxane phase], 0.52-µm film thickness) heated from 30 to 320 °C at 5 °C/min. Products were detected using a flame ionisation detector (FID) and displayed as an electric current response in pA. n-Butane has been used as an external standard. Prominent hydrocarbons have been identified with the aid of reference chromatograms and manually quantified with “AGILENT ChemStation offline” software by peak area integration.

Compositional kinetic modelling

After acquiring bulk kinetic parameters of primary petroleum formation from bulk open-system pyrolysis and the composition of first-formed petroleum at transformation ratios of 10, 30, 50, 70 and 90 % from MSSV–pyrolysis, a compositional kinetic model for the prediction of petroleum physical properties (GOR, B_O, P _sat) under subsurface conditions was determined using the PhaseKinetics approach of di Primio and Horsfield (2006). The GOR is the volumetric gas-to-oil ratio of the total gas fraction (C_1–5) and the total liquid hydrocarbon fraction (C₆₊) at standard surface conditions (Sm³/Sm³). B_O, the formation volume factor, is the ratio of liquid volume in sub-surface to that at surface conditions in m³/Sm³. P _sat, the saturation pressure, is the pressure when the solution capacity of gas in oil is reached.

PVT modelling is performed using a compositional resolution containing 14 compounds. The seven compounds of the gas range (C₁, C₂, C₃, i-C₄, n-C₄, i-C₅ and n-C₅) are determined by MSSV pyrolysis. As the gas composition is the main controlling factor on phase behaviour and consistently lacks in methane (di Primio and Horsfield 2006), a gas correction was employed based on GOR—gas wetness correlation from natural black oils (di Primio et al. 1998). The liquid range contains a pseudo C₆ (corresponding to all compounds eluting after n-C₅ until n-C₆) and a C₇₊ fraction subdivided into six pseudo-compounds (C_7–15, C_16–25, C_26–35, C_36–45, C_46–55 and C_56–80). The C₇₊ fraction is characterised by molecular weight and density which is determined by the above-described gas correction and an estimation procedure of di Primio et al. (1998).

1D petroleum system modelling

The evolution of the LSB has been unravelled by Petmecky et al. (1999), Bruns et al. (2013b) and selected references therein. Of note to the current article was the rapid subsidence starting at Kimmeridgian (Upper Jurassic) times and reaching its maximum burial depth during Upper Cretaceous times (Petmecky et al. 1999). At the beginning of this tectonic pulse, the LSB became finally differentiated in horst and graben structures indicated by lateral thickness variations (Betz et al. 1987; Petmecky et al. 1999). The following structural inversion of the basin in the Late Cretaceous was most intensive in the former basin centre and led to uplift and erosion of large amounts of Cretaceous and locally older strata of up to 6,700 m (Fig. 1) (Bruns et al. 2013b). The transition from Late Jurassic to Early Cretaceous times was dominated by a regression causing an isolation of sedimentary basins throughout northern Europe (Mutterlose and Bornemann 2000). Smaller Cenozoic inversions during the mid-Paleocene, associated with the Pyrenean tectonic pulse (de Jager 2003), and the Late Eocene again affected the sediments of the LSB (Betz et al. 1987) but insignificantly influenced the general basin history (Fig. 2).

Fig. 1

Basin evolution of the Lower Saxony Basin at the location of well Ex-B, extracted from the 3D basin model provided by the EMR of RWTH Aachen, and displaying the subsurface temperatures throughout geological time

Fig. 2

Open pyrolysis GC-FID: petroleum-type organofacies using the ternary diagram of Horsfield (1989) and GC fingerprints of the corresponding samples of the distinct depth intervals; full circles refer to n-alkanes, open circles display alkenes, the small hexagons represent aromates, and numbers refer to the carbon number of n-alkanes/alkenes

The results of PhaseKinetics and compositional kinetic modelling are linked to the thermal history of a pseudo-well at the drill location of well Ex-B which comprises the highest mature Wealden Shale samples available in this study. The 1D basin model provided by EMR (RWTH Aachen University) using PetroMod 2012© was extracted from an already compiled 3D basin model of the LSB containing lithology, source rock characteristics and the kinetic models of the Wealden Shale (Bruns et al. 2013b). As can be revealed from Fig. 1, two major inversion events occurred during the basin evolution of which one had an impact on the burial of the Wealden formation at the location of well Ex-B. The Wealden formation in well Ex-B has been buried up to 4,800 m during Lower to Upper Cretaceous times and experienced a heating rate of 3.4 °C/Ma (Fig. 1). Due to the differential subsidence of the basin (Betz et al. 1987; Brink et al. 1992), this heating rate is only valid at this specific area. In a last step and for kinetic considerations, bulk kinetic parameters of samples 1 and 4 have been assigned to the Wealden shale formation. These samples were selected because they are representative for the deposition of the Wealden Shale which was mainly of lacustrine origin intercalated with short-termed marine transgressions (Elstner and Mutterlose 1996). For more detailed descriptions of the basin model and its boundary conditions, refer to Bruns et al. (2013b).

Results

Lability of organic matter (bulk kinetic parameters)

The calculated activation energy distributions (E _a ) and single pre-exponential factors (A) for the four Wealden Shale samples are given in Table S2 (Supplementary) and shown in Fig. 3. The data hint to the origin of the organic matter within distinct organofacies as the width of the E _a distribution is more or less directly related to kerogen heterogeneity and hence depositional environment (e.g. Tissot et al. 1987). Thus, sample 1 shows a marine signature, at least in the classical sense (Tegelaar and Noble 1994; Pepper and Dodd 1995), by displaying a relatively broad E _a distribution with values ranging between 44 and 64 kcal/mol and a main energy at 55 kcal/mol accounting for 45 % of the total kerogen to petroleum conversion reaction, whereas Wealden Shale samples 2–4 from the lower depth intervals display an E _a distribution which is dominated by one single E _a, between 58 and 60 kcal/mol, accounting for at least 96 % of the total kerogen to petroleum conversion reaction. Domination of a single activation energy is commonly thought to be characteristic for lacustrine type I source rocks (Pepper and Corvi 1995) and reflects a homogeneous mainly polymethylene kerogen structure which is most likely inherited by selectively preserved aliphatic algaenan, the resistant biopolymer from within the outer cell walls of microalgae, such as B. braunii (de Leeuw and Largeau 1993; Tegelaar and Noble 1994), and comprises only a limited range of chemically stable bonds. The frequency factor of the more heterogeneous sample 1 (3.84E + 14 s⁻¹) is also lower than those of samples 2–4 (1.12E + 15 to 5.30E + 15 s⁻¹) indicating a lower thermal stability.

Fig. 3

Computed generation rate curves and transformation ratio curves for a geological heating rate of 3 °C/Ma for the investigated Wealden Shale samples

With respect to the broader E _a distribution of sample 1, it should be noted that heterogeneous (broad E _a distributions) as well as homogeneous (single E _a ) type I kerogens are found in lacustrine settings, as reported, for example, in the Laney Shale and Luman Tongue of the Green River Shale (Horsfield et al. 1994) or in the ES4 member of the Shahejie Formation in the Western Depression of the Liaohe Basin, NE China (Fuhrmann et al. 2004). It is clear that kinetic parameters vary appreciably, even within lacustrine settings, and therefore, evaluations should be conducted on a case-by-case basis. It is therefore also clear that based solely on the E _a distribution sample 1 cannot be assigned a marine depositional origin.

Extrapolation of the petroleum-forming reaction to geological heating rates might yield better clues concerning the depositional origin of the samples. Assuming a hypothetical geological heating rate of 3 °C/Ma, transformation ratio rate curves (Fig. 3) indicate that samples 2–4 exhibit higher onset (10 % TR) temperatures (152–157 °C) and peak petroleum generation temperatures (T _max = 165–170.5 °C) than sample 1 from the uppermost depth interval (see Table S2). Nevertheless, onset and peak petroleum generation temperatures for sample 1, 133.2 °C and 148.4 °C, respectively, hint as well to a rather high thermal stability. On the one hand, its geological T _max value resembles those of the stable, S-poor, type II marine shales sample set of Tegelaar and Noble (1994) and Braun et al. (1991) in which T _max values range between 142 and 150 °C. On the other hand, the extrapolation is also comparable to geological predictions for thermally less stable lacustrine samples (e.g. from wells AP24: Anvil Points 24 gal/ton and GOVT: Government 33-4 from the Uinta Basin) published in Braun et al. (1991), which exhibit calculated T_max values between 147 and 149 °C, as well as for lacustrine type I samples from the ES4 member of the Shahejie Formation in the Western Depression of the Liaohe Basin, NE China, published in Fuhrmann et al. (2004), which exhibit calculated T _max values between 148 and 159 °C.

Predictions to geological heating rates for Wealden Shale samples 2–4 result in thermal stabilities which are slightly higher than predictions for most of the lacustrine kerogens poor in sulphur and aromatic compounds compiled by Tegelaar and Noble (1994) and Braun et al. (1991). Green River Shale samples (e.g. from wells Brotherson 1-23B4 and Government 33-4) from Uinta Basin (Braun et al. 1991) and Pematang samples [Indonesian Brown Shale, (Tegelaar and Noble 1994)] exhibit maximum generation potentials (T _max) ranging between 147 and 165 °C. Horsfield et al. (1994) reported geological T _max values of 150–170 °C for the Laney Shale member and T _max values of 170–175 °C for the Luman Tounge member of the Green River Formation (Washakie Basin). In the case of an Australian Torbanite composed of the remains of B. braunii, an even higher maximum petroleum generation rate temperature of 180 °C was reached (Tegelaar and Noble 1994). In a related context, Behar et al. (1995) have shown that different B. braunii races possess different thermal stabilities, for example, the structure of race L contains C₄₀ isoprenoid chains with a lycopene-type skeleton which are less stable than the long polymethylenic chains of the race B cell walls consist. Botryococcus braunii algae within Wealden Shale samples 2–4 might therefore be derived from algal remains belonging to a rather stable race.

Compositional kinetic model and calculated fluid physical properties

Compositional kinetic models were generated for four samples of which each represents a depth interval of the immature well Ex-A. The compositional evolution and physical properties of the fluids generated at increasing degrees of transformation were determined using MSSV pyrolysis and are shown in Table S3 and Fig. 4. The observations made based on the activation energy distributions and carbon chain length distributions from pyrolysis are generally supported by the results shown. A paraffinic high-wax petroleum type was predicted for all samples; thus, the fluids generated fall within the black oil class, as defined by petroleum engineers (McCain 1990). Even at 90 % TR they do not reach saturation pressures of 200 bars (approximate start of volatile oil) and exhibit, over the entire primary kerogen conversion range, more or less uniform and very low saturation pressures around 80–115 bar in the case of the wax-richer samples 2–4 and between 113 and 150 bar in the case of sample 1. The same is true for GOR values that range around 50 Sm³/Sm³ in the case of the wax-richer samples 2–4 and between 75 and 103 Sm³/Sm³ in the case of sample 1. The evolution of the physical properties, that is, more or less uniform GOR’s and saturation pressures, of fluids generated from all samples can therefore be described as typically lacustrine, whereas the physical properties of fluids generated from the rather heterogeneous, less stable sample 1 are simply slightly increased.

Fig. 4

Physical properties of representative early mature Wealden Shale samples originating from different depositional environments plotted in a P _sat versus B_O diagram (upper left), P _sat versus GOR (upper right) and GOR as well as P _sat versus TR representing maturity (lowermost diagrams)

Natural hydrocarbon fluids generated from the same source rock as a function of increasing maturity display a linear correlation of P _sat and GOR and of P _sat and B_O (di Primio et al. 1998). This has also been proven to be valid for source rock maturation series investigated by MSSV pyrolysis (di Primio and Horsfield 2006). The petroleum fluids from all here investigated samples show a slight increase in P _sat and B_O with increasing TR and in a cross plot of these two properties plot in the area of naturally occurring petroleum fluids (Fig. 4). It can be seen in the P _sat versus B_O plot (Fig. 4) that the generated fluids range only within a very limited area which is a typical behaviour for homogeneously structured kerogens of lacustrine origin (see discussion in Horsfield (1989)). Nevertheless, overall slightly lower B_O/GOR/P _sat fluids were generated from samples 2–4 containing homogeneous and more stable kerogen (Fig. 4).

It should be noted that for all samples GORs slightly increase when reaching a transformation ratio of 90 %. This indicates higher gas generation most likely related to the onset of secondary cracking of primarily formed petroleum compounds.

Discussion

Phase envelopes

The predicted phase envelopes of cumulative fluids generated from Wealden Shale rock samples at five transformation ratios were calculated using PVTsim© and are displayed in Fig. 5. The shape of the phase envelopes strongly depends on the composition of the fluids and thus on maturity or precursor origin; the quantity of light hydrocarbons dissolved in the liquid phase (GOR) has the largest influence. As can be deduced from Fig. 6, the Wealden Shale samples possess a high oil generation potential of around 90 % throughout maturation and hence a low gas generation potential (8–12 %) of which methane accounts for one-third. Thus, “loaf-shaped” phase envelopes, which are characteristic for black oils, can be observed for all investigated samples, but nevertheless the phase envelopes of the homogeneous samples 2–4 are “flatter” than those of the more heterogeneous sample 1. This can be explained by a slightly higher gas generation potential of the latter sample in comparison with samples 2–4. The cricondentherm and critical point are influenced by molecular weight and density of the C₇₊ fraction. High molecular weights and densities result in a high cricondentherm, a low GOR and a low P _sat, a feature qualitatively observable for all investigated samples. Homogeneous samples 2–4 show almost identical pT-characteristics with similar cricondenbar (138–141 bar) and cricondentherm values (564–574 °C) as well as more or less similar critical points ranging between 466 and 481 °C, respectively, 109 and 116 bar at a transformation ratio of 70 %. The fluid composition at 70 % TR can be viewed as being characteristic of cumulatively generated primary petroleum, whereas at 90 % TR cracking of C₆₊ compounds might have already led to the formation of secondary gas. The more heterogeneous sample 1 exhibits phase envelopes with bubble-point curves extending to higher cricondenbars (176 bar at 70 % TR) and dew point curves extending to lower cricondentherms (535 °C at 70 % TR). This is consistent with the sample’s slightly higher gas-generative potential induced by differences in the organic matter structure of petroleum precursors (di Primio et al. 1998).

Fig. 5

Phase envelopes of the petroleum generated primarily at different transformation ratios of samples 1–4. Additionally, calculated present-day pT-conditions (hydrostatic) within the overmature well Ex-B are indicated as well as pT-conditions of the primary generation window as revealed from bulk kinetics (Fig. 3 and Table S2)

Fig. 6

Activation energy distributions of four immature Wealden Shale samples with integrated compositional information

In general and with increasing maturity (10–90 % TR), a systematic decrease in cricondentherm and increase in cricondenbar can be expected for type II and type III kerogens, as well as a shift of the critical point towards higher pressures and lower temperatures (di Primio et al. 1998). Interestingly, for all investigated samples, critical points move towards higher pressures but not progressively to lower temperatures with increasing maturity. Both cricondentherm and cricondenbar partly increase with maturity. Some samples show at least a “crossover area” in which critical points move first to higher temperatures before decreasing to lower ones while they steadily increase in pressure. Maturation of a type I kerogen proceeds within a very limited temperature interval in which the OM (here mainly remains of B. braunii) is converted into petroleum at a very fast rate, that is, within a temperature interval of 20 °C for samples 2–4 and within a temperature interval of 32 °C for sample 1 (Table S2, Fig. 3). Thus, the gas composition as well as the GOR does not change significantly throughout maturation as it does for more heterogeneous kerogen types II and III (Kuhn et al. 2010). Consequently, the evolution of the shape of phase envelopes for sample 1 is entirely consistent with its purported lacustrine origin.

Phase behaviour prediction

Phase behaviour of generated petroleum fluids for four early mature Wealden Shale samples from four depth intervals of well Ex-A (Table 1) was calculated for temperatures corresponding to transformation ratios of 10, 30, 50, 70 and 90 % (see Table S3). Secondary cracking of generated products at high temperatures was only considered theoretically in the scope of this work as the fate of migrating primary fluids was of prime importance. To predict the phase state of generated products within the sedimentary column, PhaseKinetic results are compared to the provided 1D basin model for well Ex-B which includes an average standard linear geopressure gradient of 100 bar/km and, in the case of the LSB, an average linear geothermal gradient of up to 34.4 °C/km (as extracted from the provided model of Bruns et al. 2013a, b). As the lithostratigraphic column of the Berriasian Wealden formation is dominated by organic matter deposition in a lacustrine freshwater environment with intercalations of only short-lived marine transgressions (Elstner and Mutterlose 1996; Mutterlose and Bornemann 2000), we applied kinetic parameters of samples comprising lacustrine type I organic matter of either heterogeneous character, represented by sample 1 (Fig. 7a), or homogeneous character, represented by sample 4 (Fig. 7b).

Fig. 7

Transformation ratios of the primary petroleum generation obtained from the bulk kinetic descriptions (Fig. 3) of sample 1 (a) and sample 4 (b) applied to the burial history of the LSB at well location Ex-B (Fig. 1). The geological temperatures and vitrinite reflectances of the distinct stages of petroleum formation are denoted in Table 3 (supplementary)

Even though increased amounts of vitrinite and inertinite were found in samples of well Ex-B, locally indicating input of terrestrial higher land-plant-derived organic matter (Rippen et al. 2013) or sedimentological differences in the facies of the organic-rich interval, the major part of the petroleum-generating organic matter fraction can be assumed to have also consisted of the remains of the lacustrine, algal material found in well Ex-A. In addition, high amounts of pyrobitumen found in samples of well Ex-B rather represent migrated than in situ petroleum residues and therefore impregnated adjacent rather than initial source intervals of the Wealden succession (discussed in the following; “second scenario”). Thus, kinetics of petroleum generation and evolution of physical properties of the generated fluids from representative intervals of well Ex-B most likely were largely similar to those predicted for samples from well Ex-A and can be used in the 1D basin model.

The Wealden Shale was deposited during the earliest Cretaceous (Berriasian) from 145 to 137 Mya and instantly underwent a rapid burial to 4,800 m within 56 Ma (until 89 Mya) in the area of well Ex-B (Figs. 1, 7). During subsidence to the maximum burial depth, the deposited organic matter passed through the oil and gas generation window. The onset of primary hydrocarbon generation from shales comprising stable, homogeneous type I organic matter as found in sample 4 occurred later, ca. 115 Mya at a depth of ≈2,670 m, whereas the generation from less stable, heterogeneous type I organic matter as found in sample 1 occurred earlier, ca. 122 Mya at ≈2,100 m depth. This corresponds to subsurface (hydrostatic) pressures of ≈267 and ≈210 bar, respectively. With ongoing burial maximum petroleum generation rates (T _max) were reached at 110 Mya for sample 4 and at 117 Mya for sample 1, whereas the offset of primary petroleum generation (TR = 90 %) was reached at 105 Mya (3,313 m) for sample 4 and at 111 Mya (2,950 m) for sample 1. Thus and in accordance with the bulk kinetic predictions (Table S2), the petroleum generation from stable, homogeneous lacustrine organic matter starts at greater depth (570 m deeper) and higher temperatures than petroleum generation from less stable, heterogeneous lacustrine organic matter. The generation window for the former one (sample 4) extends over a smaller depth interval (650 m) and time span (9.5 Ma) in comparison with the latter one (sample 1), where the generation window extends over 11 Ma and a depth interval of 850 m. According to the phase envelopes (Fig. 5), all hydrocarbons generated between 10 and 90 % TR, independently of organic matter origin or heterogeneity, occur in a single-phase state as undersaturated liquid petroleum at depth of generation because hydrostatic subsurface pressures of 268–332 bar for sample 4 and 210–293 bar for sample 1 are higher than geologically realistic bubble-point pressures which range from 70 to 95 bar for sample 4 and from 90 to 135 bar for sample 1. The given bubble-point pressure can be deduced from the intersection of the hydrostatic pressure gradient with the phase envelopes in Fig. 5.

As can be revealed from the burial history of the LSB (Fig. 1), the organic and inorganic matter of the Wealden Shale experienced a relatively simple structural evolution of burial to maximum depth and subsequent geological uplift to more or less present-day depth. In the following, we discuss the fate of generated petroleum fluids, that is, their phase behaviour within the sediment column, in the light of two “end-member” scenarios. In the first one, termed “unconventional setting”, zero expulsion of generated hydrocarbon products is assumed, whereas in the second, more realistic one, expulsion of the major part of generated hydrocarbons is assumed.

During geological uplift in the Upper Cretaceous (Figs. 1, 7), subsurface pressure and temperature decreased. For retained hydrocarbons in an “unconventional setting”, phase separation might have occurred during the uplift phase once the bubble-point pressures and temperatures of the generated hydrocarbon fluids from samples 1 and 4 were reached. As described previously, phase envelopes of sample 1 exhibit elevated bubble-point pressures (see Table S3 for a hypothetical reservoir temperature of 100 °C) in comparison with those of the homogeneous sample 4. Petroleum fluids generated from homogeneous Wealden Shale samples 2–4 show bubble-point pressures of around 95 bar at 90 % TR which corresponds to a theoretical (hydrostatic pressure) depth for phase separation of around 950 m. On the other hand, petroleum fluids generated from the more heterogeneous sample 1 possess a bubble point of 135 bar at 90 % TR which corresponds to a depth of around 1,350 m. As can be revealed from well data and the 1D basin model, the Wealden Shale formation at the well location of Ex-B is buried to a present-day depth between 932 and 1,740 m. Nevertheless, at the Cretaceous-Tertiary border (67–63 Mya), the Wealden formation was further uplifted to a minimum depth of 717 m at its top and 1,525 m at its bottom. Thus and assuming zero secondary cracking (unlikely), retained fluids within the upper depth interval of well Ex-B, derived from both homogeneously and heterogeneously type I organic matter, would have reached their bubble-point pressure at hydrostatic pressures of approximately 70–90 bar and would have dissolved into a two-phase state of coexisting oil and gas. In contrast, petroleum fluids generated from homogeneous lacustrine organic matter and trapped within older Wealden horizons in times of maximum uplift were all positioned at depth levels below ≈950 m and therefore experienced hydrostatic pressures exceeding their bubble points at 95 bar. They could have only occurred as a single undersaturated oil phase. The latter is only true for the 4th depth interval of the here investigated sample set assuming composition of retained fluids derived from organic matter resembling that of the more heterogeneous sample 1. In the 2nd and 3rd depth interval, those fluids (bubble-point pressures of ≈135 bar) would have undergone phase separation.

Secondary cracking processes affecting the petroleum composition of primarily generated fluids are completely neglected in this scenario. Nevertheless, it is very likely that “near complete” secondary cracking of retained hydrocarbons took place by exposure to higher temperatures during times of maximum burial to maturity levels around 2.2–2.4 % VR_r (Rippen et al. 2013). It should be noted here that for the two lacustrine Wealden Shale samples compositional secondary cracking kinetics were determined using MSSV pyrolysis at three different heating rates and the GOR_FIT model (Mahlstedt et al. 2013). Presentation of those results is outside the scope of this paper, but it can be stated here that the end of the secondary conversion of primary petroleum to gas was calculated to occur at ~2.2 % easy R ₀ for products of sample 1 and ~2.3 % easy R ₀ for products of sample 4 (3 °C/Ma heating rate). Furthermore, it is well known that in-source secondary cracking proceeds much faster than in-reservoir secondary cracking and can be generally assumed to be completed before 2.0 % VR (Schenk et al. 1997a, b; Dieckmann et al. 1998; Hill et al. 2007; Horsfield et al. 1992). Generation of secondary gas from primary petroleum products within the Wealden sequence would therefore leave behind a pyrobitumen and, still assuming zero expulsion, fluids characterised by much higher GORs and therefore phase envelopes with much higher cricondenbars and lower cricondentherms (Fig. 8, compare to Fig. 17 in di Primio et al. (1998)). Consequently, retained fluids in all depth intervals of well Ex-B should occur at maximum burial depth as an undersaturated gas or condensate phase, which, depending on its GOR or gas dryness, might not be able to reach its dew point and consequently two-phase state even during uplift to surface pT-conditions. Looking into the profile of thermovaporisation gas chromatographic fingerprints of samples from well Ex-B (Fig. 10 in Rippen et al. 2013), it becomes clear that, in concordance with the above discussed, low overall amounts of free compounds within the lower three depth intervals can be described as gas condensates. Nevertheless, in the upper interval, at 2.2 % VR_r, paraffinic hydrocarbons dominated by intermediate chain length (n-C_13–15) and essentially no gas are encountered which are therefore unlikely to reflect originally retained petroleum compounds, at least when following the here presented thermal burial and uplift history. In this context, impregnation of rocks within this interval by migrated oil of for now unknown origin is more likely, whereas timing of migration and emplacement is as well unknown. Impregnating oils probably originate from another source rock horizon within the LSB (Wealden, Posidonia Shale or Carboniferous strata) that generated more recently.

Fig. 8

Phase envelope of a dry gas (after di Primio et al. 1998). Note that no phase separation can occur under natural pressure–temperature conditions

An additional scenario for phase separation, that is, phase separation during migration of expelled hydrocarbons into lower pressurised depth regions, is thinkable and more realistic than the previously described scenario. Wealden Shales can be described as a type I source rock if not oil shale characterised by HI values exceeding 600 mg HC/g TOC. According to Pepper and Corvi (1995), the major amount of the TOC of those kinds of rocks is reactive kerogen and can be converted into expellable petroleum because their sorptive capacity, defined by the amount of inert kerogen (which is low as the HI is high), is low. Usually up to 90 % of the total organic matter of oil shales such as the Green River Shale is converted to oil and is expelled. Due to the very narrow maturity range over which petroleum formation is predicted to proceed for the investigated lacustrine samples, a rapid pressure built-up can be expected to occur in course of the quick volume expansion of the reaction kerogen to oil and gas. This might induce primary migration rather via natural fracturing of the rock than via the pore network (Düppenbecker et al. 1991) as pressure built-up within the pores quickly exceeds rock integrity. A micro-fracture system predominantly parallel to the bedding plane is often observed in high-quality oil-generating source rocks which allowed an outward flow of oil through the spontaneously generated fracture system leading to pressure release. Formation of such a fracture system in the case of the Wealden Shale is indicated by bitumen (pyrobitumen) accumulation within the matrix, pore spaces as well as natural fractures of samples from overmature well Ex-B (compare Rippen et al. 2013). One known conventional oil accumulation believed to have been sourced already during Lower Cretaceous times, prior to inversion, by the Wealden Shale is the Bramberge oil field in Northern Germany (Grassmann et al. 2006); hence, migration is documented as having taken place.

For phase separation to occur during upwards migration, large distances would have had to be overcome: for fluids derived from less homogeneous and less stable lacustrine type I organic matter (resembling sample 1) vertical distances of approximately 1 km (generation at 210–293 bar for 10–90 % TR, bubble-point pressure ≈135 bar) and for fluid derived from homogeneous, stable lacustrine type I organic matter (resembling samples 2–4) vertical distances of approximately 2 km (generation at 259–333 bar for 10–90 % TR, bubble-point pressure ≈95 bar). Phase separation during vertical migration is very hard to model and beyond the scope of the work described here. Nevertheless, there might be indication of phase separation during long distance, lateral migration upwards within the source bed or adjacent strata. This indication can be inferred from the discussed bitumen filled natural fractures observed in samples of well Ex-B in connection with the still very high TOC contents of those samples compared with equivalent immature samples from well Ex-A (compare Rippen et al. 2013). If high contents of the original TOC were indeed expelled, as it is usually the case for type I source rocks, TOC contents at higher maturities should be significantly lower. Thus, it could be argued that organic matter within high maturity samples is largely derived from upwards migrated petroleum which reached bubble-point pressures and experienced phase separation, with the exsolving gas phase being lost and the oil phase, enriched in high molecular weight paraffinic compounds, being left behind as immobile bitumen plugging the pore space. Evidence for such a process might be derived from methane fluid inclusions within calcite fracture fillings of horizontal veins found in close association with the here investigated organic matter-rich horizons in the four depth intervals of well Ex-B (Lüders and Plessen 2012; unpublished results). Those horizontal veins are usually the result of mineralisation of hydraulic expulsion fractures, which developed, in close relation to the previous discussed natural fracturing during petroleum generation, in the course of exsolution of gas from a saturated oil phase, a process causing volume expansion and overpressure.

Please keep in mind that the latter scenario is still speculative and complete fluid movement were not attempted to being modelled within the scope of this work. The discussion is rather motivated by showing possibilities of how PhaseKinetics data can be applied into geological systems.

Conclusion

Within the LSB, the Wealden Shale was deposited during the earliest Cretaceous (Berriasian) from 145 to 137 Mya and, according to the model of Bruns et al. (2013b) immediately underwent a rapid burial to 4,800 m within 56 Ma in the area of a pseudo-well situated at the location of well Ex-B leading to maximum temperatures of 226 °C. The subsequent basin history was strongly influenced by an inversion of the basin between 89 and 65 Mya removing nearly the entire Cretaceous sedimentary record at some locations. At present, the Wealden formation is covered by 932 m of Cretaceous and Cenozoic sediments at the well location Ex-B.

Bulk kinetic modelling revealed that the organic matter present in sample 1 is thermally more instable and shows a broader activation energy distribution resulting in a slower conversion to oil and gas at lower temperatures (T _max of 148.4 °C). The organic matter of the more homogeneous samples 2–4 is thermally more stable (T _max between 165.6 and 170.5 °C) and is converted faster. The fluids exhibit low GORs below 100 Sm³/Sm³ that do not significantly change throughout kerogen conversion which is a typical feature for homogeneously structured type I kerogens. Consequently, P _sat and B_O do also range within a limited area. All of the samples possess high generation potentials for heavy components (C₇₊), that is, paraffinic high-wax oils, whereas fluids from samples 2–4 are more enriched in very heavy fractions (C_14–45) compared with those from sample 1. This is also reflected in the phase envelopes which are “flatter” for homogeneous kerogen containing samples 2–4. Phase separation would proceed at lower depths than for fluids derived from sample 1.

This basin offers the benefit of having similar organofacies at different maturation stages, as well as having the overmature well Ex-B to act as reference to predict the possible pT-conditions of already generated oil and gas at the distinct present-day reservoir depths. Therefore, the bulk kinetic parameters of samples 1 and 4 were included in a 1D geologic basin model for the well Ex-B assuming that petroleum fluids generated from samples of this well contain the same compositions, and thus physical properties, as hydrocarbons from the samples of the immature well Ex-A. The onset of hydrocarbon generation using the bulk kinetics of the homogeneous organic matter-containing sample 4 was predicted to occur at a depth of 2,670 m (115 Mya) and the offset at 105 Mya at around 3,313 m depth. Applying the kinetic parameters of the more heterogeneous organic matter-containing sample 1 petroleum generation occurred within a quite broader depth as well as time interval ranging from 2,100 m (122 Mya) to 2,950 m (111 Mya). At these subsurface pT-conditions hydrocarbons are generated and expelled as a single liquid phase of oil undersaturated in dissolved gas. During geological uplift to a minimum depth of 717 (top) and 1,525 m (bottom) fluids derived from organic matter resembling that in sample 1 and trapped in the upper interval might have experienced a phase separation into a gas phase and a saturated fluid phase, whereas fluids in the lower intervals did at no time experience pT-conditions falling below their bubble-point pressures and therefore remain in an undersaturated single-phase state.

However, one can assume that severe secondary cracking of retained hydrocarbons took place leading to a strong increase in the GOR and a shift of phase envelopes to higher saturation pressures. Hence, phase separation could have occurred at much greater depths. Nevertheless and by comparison of free HC GC traces to the findings of bulk kinetics and phase behaviour, it becomes likely that migrated oil of unknown origin impregnated the upper horizon of well Ex-B. An alternative but speculative scenario is that severe natural fracturing due to pore pressure increase during rapid primary petroleum generation induces primary migration of products to lower situated Wealden horizons where phase separation can occur leaving behind waxy and immobile bitumen. Still very high TOC contents of the mature samples in comparison with immature samples as well as methane fluid inclusions within calcite fracture fillings could bear evidence for this process.