Four characters in a trade-off: dissecting their phenotypic and genetic relations

Abstract

Phenotypic characters may covary negatively because they are in a trade-off or positively because they contribute to a single function. Genetic correlations can be used to test the validity and generality of these functional relationships by indicating the level of genetic integration and checking the conditions under which they are expressed. Phenotypic correlations indicate that there is a widespread trade-off between flight capability and early fecundity in insects. Different wing morphs (long and short wing) are thought to have a suite of reproductive and flight capability traits. In a half-sib mating experiment, we estimated phenotypic relationships between two flight-capability-related characters (flight muscle condition, wing morph) and two components of early fecundity (number of eggs in the ovaries, number of eggs laid), as well as genetic correlations relating wing morph and both components of fecundity in the wing-dimorphic cricket, Gryllus firmus. The number of eggs in the ovaries and the number of eggs laid were negatively correlated phenotypically and genetically with wing length morph (i.e., long wings associated with low fecundity). Both fecundity characters differed between wing morphs, but only if flight muscle was present and not histolyzed. The phenotypic and genetic correlations between fecundity characters were not significant. This suggests that the phenotypic relationship between ovary development and eggs laid is complex, they are not genetically integrated, and they may evolve independently. However, both early fecundity characters are functionally and genetically integrated within the trade-off to a similar degree. Finally, the trade-off affects early fecundity of both wing morphs suggesting that the functional relationship depends on flight muscle size.