Abstract
Introduction
We examined the reproducibility and accuracy of high-field MRA in traumatic anterior shoulder instability under conditions resembling clinical practice and assessed the influence of observer experience.
Materials and methods
Two radiologists with different experience levels evaluated 61 MRAs. Assessment was independent, blinded and non-sequential. For 40 MRAs, surgical reports were available to assess diagnosis accuracy and influence of observer experience. The assessed lesions were cuff lesions, Hill–Sachs lesions, bony and classic Bankart lesions, greater humeral tuberosity fractures, SLAP lesions and joint capsule lesions. Reproducibility was quantified using kappa coefficients. Accuracy was evaluated with sensitivity and specificity rates, positive and negative predictive values. Differences in the percentage of correctly diagnosed MRAs between the radiologists were tested using McNemar’s test for paired proportions.
Results
Inter-observer k-values ranged from 0.03 for joint capsule lesions to 0.45 for humeral head lesions. The overall kappa was 0.21 (95% CI; 0.12–0.30). We also observed markedly lower sensitivity and specificity rates than those reported in the literature for most lesions. The more experienced radiologist correctly diagnosed 78.9% of all lesions compared to 65.4% for the less experienced radiologist (P < 0.001; McNemar’s test).
Conclusion
MRA-interpretations of traumatic anterior shoulder instability should be regarded with caution in clinical practice. The experience level of radiologists can affect reproducibility and accuracy.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Altman DG (1991) Practical statistics for medical research. Chapman & Hall, London
Bachmann G, Bauer T, Jürgensen I, Schwab J, Weimar B, Rau WS (1998) Diagnostische Sicherheit und therapeutische Relevanz von CT-Arthrographie und MR-Arthrographie der Schulter. Fortschr Röntgenstr 168(2):149–156
Bencardino JT, Beltran J, Rosenberg ZS, Rokito A, Schmahmann S, Mota J, Mellado JM, Zuckerman J, Cuomo F, Rose D (2000) Superior labrum anterior–posterior lesions: diagnosis with MR arthrography of the shoulder. Radiology 214:267–271
Binkert CA, Zanetti M, Gerber C, Hodler J (2001) MR arthrography of the glenohumeral joint: two concentrations of Gadoteridol versus Ringer solution as the intraarticular contrast material. Radiology 220:219–224
Bitzer M, Nasko M, Krackhardt T, Schick F, Schöber W, Wiskirchen J, Morgalla M, Weise K, Claussen C (2004) Direkte CT-Arthrographie versus direkte MR-Arthrographie bei chronischer Schulterinstabilität: Ein Methodenvergleich nach Einführung der Multidetektor-CT-Technik. Fortschr Röntgenstr 176:1770–1775
Blum A, Coudane H, Molé D (2000) Gleno-humeral instabilities. Eur Radiol 10:63–82
Chandnani VP, Yeager TD, DeBerardino T, Christensen K, Gagliardi JA, Heitz DR, Baird DE, Hansen MF (1993) Glenoid labral tears: prospective evaluation with MR imaging, MR arthrography, and CT arthrography. AJR Am J Roentgenol 161:1229–1235
Chandnani VP, Gagliardi JA, Murnane TG, Bradley YC, DeBerardino TA, Spaeth J, Hansen MF (1995) Glenohumeral ligaments and shoulder capsular mechanism: evaluation with MR arthrography. Radiology 196:27–32
Cohen J (1960) A coefficient of agreement for nominal scales. Educ Psychol Meas 20:37–46
Cvitanic O, Tirman PFJ, Feller JF, Bost FW, Minter J, Carroll KW (1997) Using abduction and external rotation of the shoulder to increase the sensitivity of MR arthrography in revealing tears of the anterior glenoid labrum. AJR Am J Roentgenol 169:837–844
Drescher R, von Rothenburg T, Ludwig J, Köster O, Schmid G (2004) Direkte MR-Arthrographie des Schultergelenks mit maximaler Kapseldistension zur OP-Planung. Fortschr Röntgenstr 176:1469–1474
Ferrari FS, Governi S, Burresi F, Vigni F, Stefani P (2002) Supraspinatus tendon tears: comparison of US and MR arthrography with surgical correlation. Eur Radiol 12:1211–1217
Flannigan B, Kursunoglu-Brahme S, Snyder S, Karzel R, Del Pizzo W, Resnick D (1990) MR arthrography of the shoulder: comparison with conventional MR imaging. AJR Am J Roentgenol 155:829–832
Funke M, Kopka L, Vosshenrich R, Oestmann W, Grabbe E (1996) MR arthrography in the diagnosis of rotator cuff tears. Standard spin-echo alone or with fat suppression. Acta Radiologica 37:627–632
Guntern DV, Pfirrmann CWA, Schmid MR, Zanetti M, Binkert CA, Schneeberger AG, Hodler J (2003) Articular cartilage lesions of the glenohumeral joint: diagnostic effectiveness of MR arthrography and prevalence in patients with subacromial impingement syndrome. Radiology 226:165–170
Hodler J, Kursunoglu-Brahme S, Snyder SJ, Cervilla V, Karzel R, Schweitzer ME, Flannigan BD, Resnick D (1992) Rotator cuff disease: assessment with MR arthrography versus standard MR imaging in 36 patients with arthroscopic confirmation. Radiology 182:431–436
Jee W, McCauley TR, Katz LD, Matheny JM, Ruwe PA, Daigneault JP (2001) Superior labral anterior posterior (SLAP) lesions of the glenoid labrum: reliability and accuracy of MR arthrography for diagnosis. Radiology 218:127–132
Loew R, Kreitner KF, Runkel M, Zoellner J, Thelen M (2000) MR arthrography of the shoulder: comparison of low-field (0.2 T) vs high-field (1.5 T) imaging. Eur Radiol 10:989–996
Magee T, Williams D, Mani N (2004) Shoulder MR arthrography: which patient group benefits most. AJR Am J Roentgenol 183:969–974
Matsen FA, Rockwood CA (1998) Glenohumeral instability. In: Rockwood and Matsen (eds) The shoulder. WB Saunder Company, Philadelphia, pp 611–745
Meister K, Thesing J, Montgomery WJ, Indelicato PA, Walczak S, Fontenot W (2004) MR arthrography of partial thickness tears of the undersurface of the rotator cuff: an arthroscopic correlation. Skeletal Radiol 33:136–141
Palmer WE, Brown JH, Rosenthal DI (1993) Rotator cuff: evaluation with fat-suppressed MR arthrography. Radiology 188:683–687
Palmer WE, Brown JH, Rosenthal DI (1994) Labral–ligamentous complex of the shoulder: evaluation with MR arthrography. Radiology 190:645–651
Palmer WE, Caslowitz PL (1995) Anterior shoulder instability: diagnostic criteria determined from prospective analysis of 121 MR arthrograms. Radiology 197:819–825
Parmar H, Jhankaria B, Maheshwari M, Singrakhia M, Shanbag S, Chawia A, Deshpande S (2002) Magnetic resonance arthrography in recurrent anterior shoulder instability as compared to arthroscopy: a prospective comparative study. J Postgrad Med 48:270–273
Roger B, Skaf A, Hooper AW, Lektrakul N, Yeh L, Resnick D (1999) Imaging findings in the dominant shoulder of throwing athletes: comparison of radiography, arthrography, CT arthrography, and MR arthrography with arthroscopic correlation. AJR Am J Roentgenol 172:1371–1380
Sailer J, Imhof H (2004) Schultergelenkinstabilität. Radiologe 44:578–590
Sanders TG, Morisson WB, Miller MD (2000) Imaging techniques for the evaluation of glenohumeral instability. Am J Sports Med 28:414–434
Sano H, Kato Y, Haga K, Itoi E, Tabata S (1996) Magnetic resonance arthrography in the assessment of anterior instability of the shoulder: comparison with double-contrast computed tomography arthrography. J Shoulder Elbow Surg 5:280–285
Sasaki T, Saito Y, Yodono H, Prado GLM, Miura H, Itabashi Y, Ishibashi Y (2003) Technical note. Labral–ligamentous complex of the shoulder. Evaluation with double oblique axial MR arthrography. Acta Radiol 44:435–439
Waldt S, Burkart A, Lange P, Imhoff AB, Rummeny EJ, Woertler K (2004) Diagnostic performance of MR arthrography in the assessment of superior labral anteroposterior lesions of the shoulder. AJR Am J Roentgenol 182:1271–1278
Zlatkin MB (2003) Rotator cuff disease. In: MRI of the shoulder. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Wolters Kluwer Company, Philadelphia, pp 117–175
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
van Grinsven, S., Kesselring, F.O.H.W., van Wassenaer-van Hall, H.N. et al. MR arthrography of traumatic anterior shoulder lesions showed modest reproducibility and accuracy when evaluated under clinical circumstances. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 127, 11–17 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00402-006-0205-7
Received:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00402-006-0205-7