Abstract
This study presents a method for characterizing entrainment using Lagrangian data. Specifically, the method exploits the temporal evolution of enstrophy along pathlines to determine if pathlines undergo entrainment. The method only recently became feasible with the development of four-dimensional particle tracking velocimetry [4D-PTV; see Schanz et al. (Exp Fluids 57(5):7, 2016)], which produces pathlines of temporal length and spatial density that was previously unattainable. The proposed entrainment method was tested on experimentally acquired 4D-PTV data of a turbulent starting vortex forming behind a linearly accelerating circular plate. The method is shown to be insensitive to its control parameters. The first control parameter is an enstrophy threshold used to identify pathlines that always exhibit low enstrophy. The second control parameter is the size of an “enstrophy-source region”, which is placed within the measurement domain to identify pathlines that gain enstrophy through interactions with an enstrophy source. In the case of the starting vortex, the method reveals topological features significant to the entrainment process, such as the roll-up of irrotational fluid between the shear layer and vortex core, and pockets of entrainment that exist within undulations on the shear layer’s outboard side. Whereas the method proposed here measures the entrainment ratio directly, the use of Lagrangian coherent structures (LCSs) to quantify entrainment is shown to be infeasible for turbulent flows due to the presence of complex material manifolds for such flows. Furthermore, unlike results from Rosi and Rival (J Fluid Mech 811:3750, 2017), which analyzed the spreading of enstrophy isocontours to characterize entrainment into a starting vortex, the proposed method produces an entrainment rate that is insensitive to the enstrophy threshold, and clearly reveals mechanisms of entrainment. Using the starting vortex data, the proposed technique measured an entrainment ratio range similar to that for laminar vortex rings. The result suggests that, for this particular class of flows, turbulence does not play a significant role with respect to entrainment. The proposed method is seen as an effective tool, given its ability to quantify the entrainment, reveal its salient topological features, and potentially be easily adapted to other classes of flows.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Brown GL, Roshko A (1974) On density effects and large structure in turbulent mixing layers. J Fluid Mech 64(4):775–816
Brunton SL, Rowley CW (2010) Fast computation of FTLE fields for unsteady flows: a comparison of methods. Chaos 20:1–12
Caflisch R (1989) Mathematical aspects of vortex dynamics. In: Proceedings in applied mathematics series, Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics
Chauhan K, Philip J, de Silva CM, Hutchins N, Marusic I (2014) The turbulent/non-turbulent interface and entrainment in a boundary layer. J Fluid Mech 742:119–151
Corrsin S, Kistler AL (1955) Free-stream boundaries of turbulent flows. Tech. Rep, NACA
Dabiri JO, Gharib M (2004) Fluid entrainment in isolated vortex rings. J Fluid Mech 511:311–331
Didden N (1977) Untersuchung laminarer, instabiler ringwirbel mittels laser doppler anemometrie. Technical Report 67
Dimotakis PE, Brown GL (1976) The mixing layer at high reynolds number: large-structure dynamics and entrainment. J Fluid Mech 78:535–560
Fernando JN, Rival DE (2016a) On vortex evolution in the wake of axisymmetric and non-axisymmetric low-aspect-ratio accelerating plates. Phys Fluids 28(1):017,102
Fernando JN, Rival DE (2016b) Reynolds-number scaling of vortex pinch-off on low-aspect-ratio propulsors. J Fluid Mech 799
Green MA, Rowley CW, Haller G (2007) Detection of Lagrangian coherent structures in three-dimensional turbulence. J Fluid Mech 572:111–120
Head MR, Bandyopadhay PR (1981) New aspects of turbulent boundary-layer structure. J Fluid Mech 107:297–338
Holzner M, Lüthi B (2011) Laminar superlayer at the turbulence boundary. Phys Rev Lett 106(134):503
Huang Z, Kawall JG, Keffer JF, Ferre JA (1995) On the entrainment process in plane turbulent wakes. Phys Fluids 7(5):1130–1141
Knisely CW (1990) Strouhal numbers of rectangular cylinders at incidence: a review and new data. J Fluids Struct 4(4):371–393
Krug D, Holzner M, Lüthi B, Wolf M, Kinzelbach W, Tsinober A (2013) Experimental study of entrainment and interface dynamics in a gravity current. Exp Fluids 54(1530):1–13
Lüthi B, Tsinobar A, Kinzelbach W (2005) Lagrangian measurement of vorticity dynamics in turbulent flow. J Fluid Mech 528:87118
Mathew J, Basu AJ (2002) Some characteristics of entrainment at a cylindrical turbulence boundary. Phys Fluids 14(7):2065–2072
Mistry D, Philip J, Dawson JR, Marusic I (2016) Entrainment at multi-scales across the turbulent/non-turbulent interface in an axisymmetric jet. J Fluid Mech 802:690–725
Mohebi M (2016) Influence of thickness and angle of attack on the dynamics of rectangular cylinder wake
Nakamura Y, Hirata K (1989) Critical geometry of oscillating bluff bodies. J Fluid Mech 208:375393
Olcay AB, Krueger PS (2008) Measurement of ambient fluid entrainment during laminar vortex ring formation. Exp Fluids 44(2):235–247
Olcay AB, Krueger PS (2010) Momentum evolution of ejected and entrained fluid during laminar vortex ring formation. Theoret Comput Fluid Dyn 24(5):465–482
Phillip J, Marusic I (2012) Large-scale eddies and their roles in entrainment in turbulent jets and wakes. Phys Fluids 48(055108)
Raben SG, Ross SD, Vlachos PP (2014) Computation of finite time Lyapunov exponents from time resolved particle image velocimetry data. Exp Fluids
Raffel M, Willert CE, Wereley ST, Kompenhans J (2007) Particle image velocimetry: a practical guide, 2nd edn. Springer, Berlin
Rival DE, Kriegseis J, Schaub P, Widmann A, Tropea C (2014) Characteristic length scales for vortex detachment on plunging profiles with varying leading-edge geometry. Exp Fluids 55(1):1660
Rosi GA, Rival DE (2017) Entrainment and topology of accelerating shear layers. J Fluid Mech 811:3750. https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2016.716
Rosi GA, Walker AM, Rival DE (2015) Lagrangian coherent structure identification using a Voronoi tesselation-based networking algorithm. Exp Fluids 56(10):1–14
Schanz D, Gesemann S, Schröder A (2016) Shake-the-box: Lagrangian particle tracking at high particle image densities. Exp Fluids 57(5):7
Shadden SC, Lekien F, Marsden JE (2005) Definition and properties of Lagrangian coherent structures from finite-time Lyapunov exponents in two-dimensional aperiodic flows. Phys D 212:271–304
Shadden SC, Dabiri JO, Marsden JE (2006) Lagrangian analysis of fluid transport in empirical vortex ring flows. Phys Fluids 18(047105):1–11
Shadden SC, Katija K, Rosenfeld M, Marsden JE, Dabiri JO (2007) Transport and stirring induced by vortex formation. J Fluid Mech 593:315–331
Wang M, Tao J, Wang C (2013) Flowvisual: Design and evaluation of a visualization tool for teaching 2D flow field concepts. 120th ASEE annual conference and exposition
Westerweel J, Hofmann T, C F, J H (2009) Momentum and scalar transport at the turbulent/non-turbulent interface of a jet. J Fluid Mech 631:199–230
Wolf M, Lüthi B, Holzner M, Krug D, Kinzelbach W, Tsinober A (2012) Investigations on the local entrainment velocity in a turbulent jet. Phys Fluids 24(10):105,110
Wolf M, Holzner M, Krug D, Lüthi B, Kinzelbach W, Tsinober A (2013) Effects of mean shear on the local turbulent entrainment process. J Fluid Mech 731:95–116
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to thank the Natural Sciences and Engineering Council of Canada (NSERC) for their financial backing. The authors also wish to acknowledge contributions made by John N. Fernando and Jaime Wong to the development and characterization of the experiment.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rosi, G.A., Rival, D.E. A Lagrangian perspective towards studying entrainment. Exp Fluids 59, 19 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00348-017-2465-0
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00348-017-2465-0