Summary
The brain is organized on multiple levels. The lowest meaningful one pertains to the molecular realm, followed by subcellular structures like the synapses, by cells like the neurons, and by microcircuits, mesocircuits and large-scale circuit assemblies. This stratified structure has so far hampered the interpretation of brain functions in terms of elementary electrochemical events occurring in the membranes of neurons and synapses. Each organization level is governed by emerging rules that do not simply account for the summation of events at the lower levels but require the understanding of highly non-linear interactions occurring in complex feed-forward and feed-back loops. Moreover, various forms of plasticity can persistently modify the neural circuits and their connections depending on the interactions of the organism with the environment. The brain appears thus to operate as a complex adaptive dynamical system and interpreting its function requires understanding the time-dependent evolution of multiple local activities and their rewiring during behaviour. While experimental evidence is instrumental to any further consideration on how the brain might operate, interpreting its multiscale organization in mechanistic terms requires the development of appropriate models. In this work we will illustrate how low-level representations of neuronal activity, intermediate level large-field networks and high-level connectomics can be used to explain how ensemble brain functions might emerge from elementary neuronal components.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Yufik Y. M. and Friston K., Front. Syst. Neurosci., 10 (2016) 98.
Markram H., Nat. Rev. Neurosci., 7 (2006) 153.
Markram H., Sci. Am. Mag., 306 (2012) 50.
Markram H., Funct. Neurol., 28 (2013) 145.
Amunts K., Ebell C, Muller J., Telefont M., Knoll A. and Lippert T., Neuron, 92 (2016) 574.
Tononi G., Boly M., Massimini M. and Koch C., Nat. Rev. Neurosci., 17 (2016) 450.
D’Angelo E. and Peres A. (Editors), Fisiologia (Edi-Ermes, Milano) 2011.
Eccles J. C. (Editor), The neurophysiological basis of mind: the principles of neurophysiology (Oxford University Press, London) 1953.
Sperry R. W., Am. Sci., 40 (1952) 291.
Churchland P. S. (Editor), Neurophilosophy: toward a unified science of the mind-brain (Bradford Book, MIT Press, Cambridge) 1989.
Churchland P. S. (Editor), Brain-wise: Studies in Neurophilosophy (Bradford Books, MIT Press, Cambridge) 2002.
Kandel E. R. (Editor), in In search of memory: the emergence of a new science of mind (W. W. Norton and Company, New York) 2007, p. 382.
Koch C. (Editor), The quest for consciousness: a neurobiological approach (Roberts and Company Publishers, Pittsburgh) 2004.
De Schutter E., Ekeberg O., Kotaleski J. H., Achard P. and Lansner A., Trends Neurosci., 28 (2005) 562.
Bouteiller J. M., Allam S. L., Hu E. Y., Greget R., Ambert N., Keller A. F., Pernot F., Bischoff S., Baudry M. and Berger T. W., Conf. Proc. IEEE Eng. Med. Biol. Soc., 2011 (2011) 445.
Grillner S., Kozlov A. and Kotaleski J. H., Curr. Opin. Neurobiol., 15 (2005) 614.
Kotaleski J.H. and Blackwell K. T., Nat. Rev. Neurosci., 11 (2010) 239.
Chen W. and De Schutter E., Front. Neuroinform., 11 (2017) 13.
Koch C. and Segev I. (Editors), Methods in Neuronal Modeling, Second Edition (MIT Press, Cambridge) 1998.
De Schutter E. and Steuber V., in Computational neuroscience: realistic modeling for experimentalists, edited by De Schutter E. (CRC Press, Boca Raton) 2000, pp. 233–257.
D’Angelo E., Antonietti A., Casali S., Casellato C, Garrido J. A., Luque N. R., Mapelli L., Masoli S., Pedrocchi A., Prestori F. and Rizza M. F., Front. Cell. Neurosci., 10 (2016) 176.
D’Angelo E. and Casali S., Front. Neural Circuits, 6 (2013) 116.
Deco G., Jirsa V. K., Robinson P. A., Breakspear M. and Friston K., PLoS Comput. Biol., 4 (2008) e1000092.
Deco G., Jirsa V. K. and Friston K. J., in Principles of Brain Dynamics, edited by Rabinovich M. I., Friston K. J. and Varona P. (MIT Press, Cambridge) 2012, chapter 1.
Rabinovich M. I., Friston K. J. and Varona P. (Editors), Principles of Brain Dynamics (MIT Press, Cambridge) 2012.
Forti L., Cesana E., Mapelli J. and D’Angelo E., J. Physiol., 574 (2006) 711.
Gandolfi D., Pozzi P., Tognolina M., Chirico G., Mapelli J. and D’Angelo E., Front. Cell. Neurosci., 8 (2014) 92.
Palesi F., Tournier D. J., Calamante F., Muhlert N., Castellazzi G., Chard D., d’Angelo E. and Wheeler-Kingshott C. A. M., Brain Struct. Funct., 220 (2015) 3369.
Castellazzi G., Palesi F., Casali S., Vitali P., Sinforiani E., Wheeler-Kingshott C. A. M. and D’Angelo E., Front. Neurosci., 8 (2014) 223.
Arbib M., Érdi P. and Szentagothai J., Behav. Brain Sci., 23 (1997) 513.
Ferrea E., Maccione A., Medrihan L., Nieus T., Ghezzi D., Baldelli P., Benfenati F. and Berdondini L., Front. Neural Circuits, 6 (2012) 80.
Maccione A., Gandolfo M., Zordan S., Amin H., Di Marco S., Nieus T., Angotzi G. N. and Berdondini L., Brain Res. Bull., 119 (2015) 118.
Rieke F., Warland D., de Ruytervan Steveninck R. and Bialek W. (Editors), Spikes: Exploring the Neural Code (Computational Neuroscience) (MIT Press, Cambridge) 1999.
Palmer T. N. and O’Shea M., Front. Comput. Neurosci., 9 (2015) 124.
Hodges A. (Editor), Alan Turing: the enigma (Burnett Books, London) 1983, p. 111.
Lynch P. (Editor), The Emergence of Numerical Weather Prediction (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) 2006, pp. 1–27.
D’Angelo E., Solinas S., Garrido J., Casellato C., Pedrocchi A., Mapelli J., Gandolfi D. and Prestori F., Funct. Neurol., 28 (2013) 153.
Markram H., Muller E., Ramaswamy S., Reimann M. W., Abdellah M., Sanchez C. A., Ailamaki A., Alonso-Nanclares L., Antille N., Arsever S., Kahou G. A., Berger T. K., Bilgili A., Buncic N., Chalimourda A., Chindemi G., Courcol J. D., Delalondre F., Delattre V., Druckmann S., Dumusc R., Dynes J., Eilemann S., Gal E., Gevaert M. E., Ghobril J. P., Gidon A., Graham J. W., Gupta A., Haenel V., Hay E., Heinis T., Hernando J. B., Hines M., Kanari L., Keller D., Kenyon J., Khazen G., Kim Y., King J. G., Kisvarday Z., Kumbhar P., Lasserre S., Le Bé J. V., Magalhães B. R., Merchán-Pérez A., Meystre J., Morrice B. R., Muller J., Muñoz-Céspedes A., Muralidhar S., Muthurasa K., Nachbaur D., Newton T. H., Nolte M., Ovcharenko A., Palacios J., Pastor L., Perin R., Ranjan R., Riachi I., Rodríguez J. R., Riquelme J. L., Rössert C, Sfyrakis K., Shi Y., Shillcock J. C, Silberberg G., Silva R., Tauheed F., Telefont M., Toledo-Rodriguez M., Tränkler T., Van Geit W., Díaz J. V., Walker R., Wang Y., Zaninetta S. M., DeFelipe J., Hill S. L., Segev I. and Schürmann F., Cell, 163 (2015) 456.
Chung J. R., Sung C, Mayerich D., Kwon J., Miller D. E., Huffman T., Keyser J., Abbott L. C. and Choe Y., Front. Neuroinform., 5 (2011) 29.
Stix G., in Scientific American Blog - February 25, 2013, Big Neuroscience: Billions and Billions (Maybe) to Unravel Mysteries of the Brain.
Underwood E., Science, 339 (2013) 1022.
Wadman M., in Nature News Blog - 02 Apr 2013, Obama launches multibillion-dollar brainmap project.
Pozzorini C., Mensi S., Hagens O., Naud R., Koch C. and Gerstner W., PLoS Comput. Biol., 11 (2015) e1004275.
Wang Z., Guo L. and Adjouadi M., Int. J. Neural Syst., 24 (2014) 1440004.
Izhikevich E. M. and Edelman G. M., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 105 (2008) 3593.
Falotico E., Vannucci L., Ambrosano A., Albanese U., Ulbrich S., Vasquez Tieck J. C, Hinkel G., Kaiser J., Peric I., Denninger O., Cauli N., Kirtay M., Roennau A., Klinker G., Von Arnim A., Guyot L., Peppicelli D., Martínez-Cañada P., Ros E., Maier P., Weber S., Huber M., Plecher D., Röhrbein F., Deser S., Roitberg A., vander Smagt P., Dillman R., Levi P., Laschi C, Knoll A. C. and Gewaltig M. O., Front. Neurorobot., 11 (2017) 2.
Carrillo R. R., Ros E., Boucheny C. and Coenen O. J., Biosystems, 94 (2008) 18.
Brüderle D., Petrovici M. A., Vogginger B., Ehrlich M., Pfeil T., Millner S., Grübl A., Wendt K., Müller E., Schwartz M. O., de Oliveira D. H., Jeltsch S., Fieres J., Schilling M., Müller P., Breitwieser O., Petkov V., Muller L., Davison A. P., Krishnamurthy P., Kremkow J., Lundqvist M., Muller E., Partzsch J., Scholze S., Zühl L., Mayr C, Destexhe A., Diesmann M., Potjans T. C., Lansner A., Schüffny R., Schemmel J. ¨. and Meier K., Biol. Cybern., 104 (2011) 263.
Pfeil T., Grübl A., Jeltsch S., Müller E., Müller P., Petrovici M. A., Schmuker M., Brüderle D., Schemmel J. and Meier K., Front. Neurosci., 7 (2013) 11.
Gerstner W., Sprekeler H. and Deco G., Science, 338 (2012) 60.
Moran R., Pinotsis D. A. and Friston K., Front. Comput. Neurosci., 7 (2013) 57.
Spiegler A. and Jirsa V. K., Neuroimage, 83 (2013) 704.
Jirsa V. K. and Stefanescu R. A., Bull. Math. Biol., 73 (2011) 325.
Ogawa S., Tank D. W., Menon R., Ellermann J. M., Kim S. G., Merkle H. and Ugurbil K., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 89 (1992) 5951.
Pauli R., Bowring A., Reynolds R., Chen G., Nichols T. E. and Maumet C., Front. Neuroinform., 10 (2016) 24.
Eklund A., Nichols T. E. and Knutsson H., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 113 (2016) 7900.
Woo C. W., Krishnan A. and Wager T. D., Neuroimage, 91 (2014) 412.
Tournier J. D., Yeh C. H., Calamante F., Cho K. H., Connelly A. and Lin C. P., Neuroimage, 42 (2008) 617.
Parker G. J., Stephan K. E., Barker G. J., Rowe J. B., MacManus D. G., Wheeler-Kingshott C. A., Ciccarelli O., Passingham R. E., Spinks R. L., Lemon R. N. and Turner R., Neuroimage, 15 (2002) 797.
Thomas C., Ye F. Q., Irfanoglu M. O., Modi P., Saleem K. S., Leopold D. A. and Pierpaoli C., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 111 (2014) 16574.
Daducci A., Dal Palú A., Descoteaux M. and Thiran J. P., Front. Neurosci., 10 (2016) 247.
Bassett D. S. and Bullmore E. T., Neuroscientist, (2016) pii:1073858416667720.
Buzsaki G. (Editor), Rhythms of the Brain (Oxford University Press, Oxford) 2006.
Beckmann C. F., DeLuca M., Devlin J. T. and Smith S. M., Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. Biol. Sci., 360 (2005) 1001.
Menon V., in Principles of Brain Dynamics, edited by Rabinovich M. I., Friston K. J. and Varona P. (MIT Press, Cambridge) 2012.
Sanz Leon P., Knock S. A., Woodman M. M., Domide L., Mersmann J., McIntosh A. R. and Jirsa V. K., Front. Neuroinform., 7 (2013) 10.
Friston K. J., Mechelli A., Turner R. and Price C. J., Neuroimage, 4 (2000) 466.
Brunel N. and Wang X. J., J. Comput. Neurosci., 1 (2001) 63; 37 (2014) 593(E).
Friston K. J., Harrison L. and Penny W., Neuroimage, 19 (2003) 1273.
Lee L., Friston K. and Horwitz B., Neuroimage, 30 (2006) 1243.
Galliano E., Mazzarello P. and D’Angelo E., J. Physiol., 588 (2010) 3639.
Marr D., J. Physiol., 202 (1969) 437.
D’Angelo E., in Computational theories and their implementation in the brain — The legacy of David Marr, edited by Vaina L. M. and Passingham R. E. (Oxford University Press, Oxford) 2016, pp. 62–78.
Honda T. and Ito M., in Computational theories and their implementation in the brain — The legacy of David Marr, edited by Vaina L. M. and Passingham R. E. (Oxford University Press, Oxford) 2016, pp. 29–61.
Ito M. (Editor), Cerebellum and Neural Control (Raven Publishing, New York) 1984.
Davison A.P., Hines M. and Muller E., Front. Neurosci., 3 (2009) 374.
D’Angelo E., Mapelli L., Casellato C., Garrido J. A., Luque N., Monaco J., Prestori F., Pedrocchi A. and Ros E., Cerebellum, 15 (2016) 139.
D’Angelo E., De Filippi G., Rossi P. and Taglietti V., J. Neurophysiol., 80 (1998) 493.
D’Angelo E., Nieus T., Maffei A., Armano S., Rossi P., Taglietti V., Fontana A. and Naldi G., J. Neurosci., 21 (2001) 759.
Diwakar S., Magistretti J., Goldfarb M., Naldi G. and D’Angelo E., J. Neurophysiol., 101 (2009) 519.
Magistretti J., Castelli L., Forti L. and D’Angelo E., J. Physiol., 573 (2006) 83.
Goldfarb M., Schoorlemmer J., Williams A., Diwakar S., Wang Q., Huang X., Giza J., Tchetchik D., Kelley K., Vega A., Matthews G., Rossi P., Ornitz D. M. and D’Angelo E., Neuron, 55 (2007) 449.
Dover K., Marra C., Solinas S., Popovic M., Subramaniyam S., Zecevic D., D’Angelo E. and Goldfarb M., Nat. Commun., 7 (2016) 12895.
Hodgkin A. L. and Huxley A. F., J. Physiol., 117 (1952) 500.
Solinas S., Forti L., Cesana E., Mapelli J., De Schutter E. and D’Angelo E., Front. Cell. Neurosci., 1 (2007) 4.
Solinas S., Forti L., Cesana E., Mapelli J., De Schutter E. and D’Angelo E., Front. Cell. Neurosci., 1 (2007) 2.
Vervaeke K., Lorincz A., Gleeson P., Farinella M., Nusser Z. and Silver R. A., Neuron, 67 (2010) 435.
Vervaeke K., Lorincz A., Nusser Z. and Silver R. A., Science, 335 (2012) 1624.
Szoboszlay M., Lőrincz A., Lanore F., Vervaeke K., Silver R. A. and Nusser Z., Neuron, 90 (2016) 1043.
Nieus T., Sola E., Mapelli J., Saftenku E., Rossi P. and D’Angelo E., J. Neurophysiol., 95 (2006) 686.
Nieus T. R., Mapelli L. and D’Angelo E., Front. Cell. Neurosci., 8 (2014) 246; 10 (2016) 30(E).
Solinas S., Nieus T. and D’Angelo E., Front. Cell. Neurosci., 4 (2010) 12.
Diwakar S., Lombardo P., Solinas S., Naldi G. and D’Angelo E., PLoS One, 6 (2011) e21928.
Parasuram H., Nair B., D’Angelo E., Hines M., Naldi G. and Diwakar S., Front. Comput. Neurosci., 10 (2016) 65.
Masoli S., Solinas S. and D’Angelo E., Front. Cell. Neurosci., 9 (2015) 47.
D’Angelo E. and De Zeeuw C. I., Trends Neurosci., 32 (2009) 30.
D’Angelo E., Prog Brain Res., 210 (2014) 31.
Sgritta M., Locatelli F., Soda T., Prestori F. and D’Angelo E., J. Neurosci., 37 (2017) 2809.
Sola E., Prestori F., Rossi P., Taglietti V. and D’Angelo E., J. Physiol., 557 (2004) 843.
Mapelli L., Gagliano G., Soda T., Laforenza U., Moccia F. and D’Angelo E., J. Neurosci., 37 (2017) 1340.
Garrido J. A., Ros E. and D’Angelo E., Front. Comput. Neurosci., 7 (2013) 64.
Garrido J. A., Luque N. R. and D’Angelo E., Front. Neural Circuits, 7 (2013) 159.
Luque N. R., Garrido J. A., Carrillo R. R., D’Angelo E. and Ros E., Front. Comput. Neurosci., 8 (2014) 97.
Casellato C., Antonietti A., Garrido J. A., Carrillo R. R., Luque N. R., Ros E., Pedrocchi A. and D’Angelo E., Plos One, 9 (2014) e112265.
Casellato C., Antonietti A., Garrido J. A., Ferrigno G., D’Angelo E. and Pedrocchi A., Front. Comput. Neurosci., 9 (2015) 24.
Antonietti A., Casellato C., D’Angelo E. and Pedrocchi A., IEEE Trans. Neural Netw. Learn. Syst., PP (2017) 99.
Kawato M., Kuroda S. and Schweighofer N., Curr. Opin. Neurobiol., 21 (2011) 791.
Lang E. J., Apps R., Bengtsson F., Cerminara N. L., De Zeeuw C. I., Ebner T. J., Heck D. H., Jaeger D., Jörntell H., Kawato M., Otis T. S., Ozyildirim O., Popa L. S., Reeves A. M., Schweighofer N., Sugihara I. and Xiao J., Cerebellum, 16 (2017) 230.
Eyal G., Verhoog M. B., Testa-Silva G., Deitcher Y., Lodder J. C., Benavides-Piccione R., Morales J., DeFelipe J., de Kock C. P., Mansvelder H. D. and Segev I., Elife, 5 (2016) e16553.
Cazemier J. L., Clascá F. and Tiesinga P. H., Front. Neuroanat., 10 (2016) 110.
Bader A. A., Sherif G., Noah O., Christopher O., Georgios P., John O. and Kai Z., J. Theor. Biol., 422 (2017) 18.
Alahmadi A. A., Pardini M., Samson R. S., D’Angelo E., Friston K., Toosy A. T. and Gandini Wheeler-Kingshott C. A., Hum. Brain Mapp., 36 (2015) 5079.
Grillner S. and Robertson B., Curr. Biology, 26 (2016) R1088.
Monaco J., Casellato C., Koch G. and D’Angelo E., Eur. J. Neurosci., 40 (2014) 3363.
Shadmehr R., Smith M. A. and Krakauer J. W., Annu. Rev. Neurosci., 33 (2010) 89.
Renzi C., Vecchi T., D’Angelo E., Silvanto J. and Cattaneo Z., Clin. Neurophysiol., 125 (2014) 2132.
Cattaneo Z., Renzi C., Casali S., Silvanto J., Vecchi T., Papagno C. and D’Angelo E., Cortex, 58 (2014) 272.
De Vidovich G. Z., Muffatti R., Monaco J., Caramia N., Broglia D., Caverzasi E., Barale F. and D’Angelo E., Front. Hum. Neurosci., 10 (2016) 582.
Connor J. A. and Stevens C. F., J. Physiol., 213 (1971) 21.
Connor J. A. and Stevens C. F., J. Physiol., 213 (1971) 31.
Hines M. L. and Carnevale N. T., J. Neurosci. Methods, 169 (2008) 425.
McDougal R. A., Morse T. M., Carnevale T., Marenco L., Wang R., Migliore M., Miller P. L., Shepherd G. M. and Hines M. L., J. Comput. Neurosci., 42 (2017) 1.
Tsodyks M. V. and Markram H., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 94 (1997) 719. Correction in: Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 94 (1997) 5495.
Rubinov M. and Sporns O., Neuroimage, 52 (2010) 1059.
Tzourio-Mazoyer N., Landeau B., Papathanassiou D., Crivello F., Etard O., Delcroix N., Mazoyer B. and Joliot M., Neuroimage, 15 (2002) 273.
Clayden J. D., Funct. Neurol., 28 (2013) 197.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
D’Angelo, E., Wheeler-Kingshott, C.G. Modelling the brain: Elementary components to explain ensemble functions. Riv. Nuovo Cim. 40, 297–333 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1393/ncr/i2017-10137-5
Received:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1393/ncr/i2017-10137-5