Abstract
The article reevaluates the reception of Mendelism in France, and more generally considers the complex relationship between Mendelism and plant breeding in the first half on the 20th century. It shows on the one side that agricultural research and higher education institutions have played a key role in the development and institutionalization of genetics in France, whereas university biologists remained reluctant to accept this approach on heredity. But on the other side, plant breeders, and agricultural researchers, despite an interest in Mendelism, never came to see it as the breeders’ panacea, and regarded it instead as of only limited value for plant breeding. I account for this judgment in showing that the plant breeders and Mendelism designed two contrasting kinds of experimental systems and inhabited distinct experimental cultures. While Mendelian geneticists designed experimental systems that allowed the production of definite ratios of different forms that varied in relation to a few characters, plant breeders’ experimental systems produced a wide range of variation, featuring combinations between hundreds of traits. Rather than breaking this multiple variation down into simple elements, breeders designed and monitored a genetic lottery. The gene was a unit in a Mendelian experimental culture, an “epistemic thing” as Rheinberger put it, that could be grasped by means of statistical regularities, but it remained of secondary importance for French plant breeders, for whom the strain or the variety – not the gene – was the fundamental unit of analysis and manipulation.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
InstitutionalAuthorNameIVe Conférence internationale de Génétique – Paris (1911) Comptes-rendus et Rapport édités Par Philippe de Vilmorin. 1913 Masson Paris
Berlan Jean-Pierre. 1987. Recherches sur l’économie Politique d’un Changement Technique: les Mythes du maïs Hybride. Thèse d’Etat, University d’Aix-Marseille II
Berlan Jean-Pierre 2005. “Brève histoire de la Sélection des Origines aux Biotechnologies.” Catalogue Semences de Kokopelli. Nimes: Premiere Impression, pp. 4–11
Louis Blaringhem (1913) Le Perfectionnement des Plantes Flammarion Paris
Félicien Bœuf (1913) “Culture Expérimentale de sortes Pures de Céréales” in IVe Conférence internationale de Gsénétique – Paris 1911. Comptes-rendus et rapport édités par Philippe de Vilmorin Masson Paris 319–327
Bœuf Félicien 1927. L’amélioration des Plantes Cultivées. Cours Professé à l’Ecole Coloniale d’agriculture de Tunis. Tunis
Félicien Bœuf (1936) Les Bases Scientifiques de l’Amélioration des Plantes Lechevalier Paris
Christophe Bonneuil Frédéric Thomas (2006) Du maïs hybride aux OGM, une histoire de la génétique végétale à l’INRA INRA Paris
Bormans, Paul 1927. “Le Rôle de la Génétique Appliquée à la Production Végétale.” La Grande revue agricole (1): 37–45.
Denis Buican (1984) Histoire de la Génétique et de l’Evolutionnisme en France PUF Paris
Richard M. Burian J. Gayon D.T. Zallen (1988) ArticleTitleThe Singular Fate of Genetics in the History of French Biology, 1900–1940 Journal of the History of Biology 21 357–402 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00144087
Jean Bustarret (1944) ArticleTitleVariétés et Variations Annales Agronomiques 14 336–362
Bustarret Jean 1961. “La Protection des Obtenteurs de Nouvelles Variétés”, Congrès National Des Semences, Rapports, Paris, 12–14 juin 1961. Paris: pp. 187–190
Maurice Caullery (1935) Les Conceptions Modernes de l’Hérédité Flammarion Paris
Eugène Coquidé (1920) Amélioration des Plantes Cultivées et du Bétail Baillière and fils Paris
Roger Cooter S. Pumfrey (1994) ArticleTitleSeparate Spheres and Public Places: Reflections on the History of Science Popularization and Science in Popular Culture History of Science 32 237–267
Giovanni Dosi (1982) ArticleTitleTechnological Paradigms and Technological Trajectories: A Suggested Interpretation of the Determinants and Directions of Technological Change Research Policy 11 IssueID3 147–162 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0048-7333(82)90016-6
Jean-Louis Fischer (1990) Contribution à l’Histoire de la Génétique en France (1900–1915) J.-L. Fischer W.H. Schneider (Eds) Histoire de la Génétique. Pratiques, Techniques et Théories ARPEM Paris 43–64
Deborah K Fitzgerald (1990) The Business of Breeding: Hybrid Corn in Illinois, 1890–1940 Cornell University Press Ithaca
Evelyn Fox-Keller (2000) The Century of the Gene Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA
Jean Gayon R.M Burian (2000) ArticleTitleFrance in the Era of Mendelism, 1900–1930 Compte-Rendus de l’Académie des Sciences de Paris, Sciences de la vie / Life Sciences 323 1097–1106 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0764-4469(00)01251-8
Jean Gayon D.T Zallen (1998) ArticleTitleThe Role of the Vilmorin Company in Promotion and Diffusion of The Experimental Science of Heredity in France, 1840–1920 Journal of the History of Biology 3 241–262 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1004335619901
M. Gervais M. Jollivet Y Tavernier (1976) La fin de la France Paysanne de 1914 à Nos Jours G. Duby A. Wallon (Eds) Histoire de la France Rurale. vol. IV Seuil Paris
Jonathan Harwood (2005) Technology’s Dilemma: Agricultural Colleges Between Science and Practice in Germany, 1860–1934 Peter Lang Bern
Jonathan Harwood (1997) ArticleTitleThe Reception of Genetic Theory Among Academic Plant-breeders in Germany, 1900–1930 Sveriges Utsädesförenings Tidskrift 107 IssueID4 187–195
Marie-Angèle Hermitte (2004) Les Ressources Biologiques et le Droit Bruylant Bruxelles
Nathalie Jas (2002) Au Carrefour de la Chimie et de l’Agriculture, les Sciences Agronomiques en France et en Allemagne 1840–1914 Edition des Archives contemporaines Paris
Wilhelm Johannsen (1903) Über Erblichkeit in Populationen und reinen Linien Jena, Germany Fischer
Pierre-Benoît Joly C. Ducos (1993) Les Artifices du Vivant, Stratégie d’Innovation dans l’Industrie des Semences INRA-Economica Paris
Daniel J Kevles (1980) ArticleTitleGenetics in the United States and Great Britain, 1890–1930: A Review with Speculations Isis 71 IssueID258 441–455 Occurrence Handle10.1086/352543
Jack. Kloppenburg (1988) First the Seed: The Political Economy of Plant Biotechnology Cambridge University Press Cambridge
Michel Maylin (1926) Manuel Pratique et Technique de l’Hybridation des Céréales Maison Rustique Paris
Auguste Meunissier (1910) La Loi de Mendel et ses Applications Aubert et Cie Versailles
Auguste Meunissier (1918) ArticleTitleExpériences Génétiques Faites à Verrières Bulletin de la Société Nationale d’Acclimatation de France 65 43–55
Auguste Meunissier (1928) ArticleTitleLa Génétique au Congrès International de Berlin Bulletin de la Société Nationale d’Horticulture 5e série 1 209
Staffan Mueller-Wille (2005) ArticleTitleEarly Mendelism and the Subversion of Taxonomy: Epistemological Obstacles as Institutions Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 36/3 465–487 Occurrence Handle10.1016/j.shpsc.2005.07.001
Muller, Pierre 2000. “La Politique Agricole Française, l’Etat et les Organisations Professionnelles.” Economie Rurale (255–256): 33–39.
Robert C Olby (2000) ArticleTitleMendelism : From Hybrids and Trade to a Science Compte-Rendus de l’Académie des Sciences de Paris, Sciences de la Vie / Life Sciences 323 1043–1051 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0764-4469(00)01253-1
Robert C Olby (1987) ArticleTitleWilliam Bateson’s Introduction of Mendelism to England: A Reassessment British Journal for the History of Science 20 399–420 Occurrence Handle10.1017/S0007087400024201
Paolo Palladino (1993) ArticleTitleBetween Craft and Science: Plant Breeding, Mendelian Genetics, and British Universities, 1900–1920 Technology and Culture 34 IssueID2 300–323 Occurrence Handle10.2307/3106538
Paolo Palladino (1994) ArticleTitleWizards and Devotees: On the Mendelian Theory of Inheritance and the Professionalization of Agricultural Sciences in Great Britain and the United States, 1880–1930 History of Science xxxii 409–444
Paul Diane B. and Kimmelman Barbara A. 1988. “Mendel in America: Theory and Practice, 1900–1919.“ Rainger et al. (eds), American Development of Biology. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, pp. 281–310
Dwijen Rangnekar (2000) Innovative Appropriation: The Role of Law, Economics and Science in Transforming Plants into Products – A Case Study of Wheat Breeding in the UK Ph. D. Thesis, School of Economics, Kingston University UK
Rheinberger, Hans-Jörg. 1997. Towards a History of Epistemic Things. Synthetizing Proteins in the Test Tube. Stanford University Press.
Nils Roll-Hansen (1997) ArticleTitleThe Role of Genetic Theory in the Success of the Svalöf Plant Breeding Program Journal of the Swedish Seed Association 4 196–207
Jan Sapp (1983) ArticleTitleThe Struggle for Authority in the Field of Heredity, 1900–1932: New Perspectives on the Rise of Genetics Journal of the History of Biology 16 311–342 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00582405
Emile Schribaux (1908) ArticleTitleL’Amélioration des Espèces Végétales de Grandes Cultures Bulletin de la Société d’encouragement pour l’industrie Nationale 110 613–654
Emile Schribaux J. Nanot (1906) La Botanique Agricole Baillière et fils Paris
George F. Sprague L.A. Tatum (1942) ArticleTitleGeneral and Specific Combining Ability in Single Crosses of Corn Journal of the American Society of Agronomy 34 923–932
Marion Thomas (2004) ArticleTitleDe nouveaux Territoires d’Introduction du Mendélisme en France: Louis Blaringhem (1878–1958), un Généticien Néolamarckien sur le Terrain Agricole Revue d’Histoire des Sciences 57 65–100 Occurrence Handle10.3406/rhs.2004.2204
Stéphane. Tirard (2003) ArticleTitleGaston Bonnier (1853–1922): Un Botaniste Lamarckien Bulletin d’histoire et d’épistémologie des sciences de la vie 10 IssueID2 157–186
Walter G. Vincenti (1990) What Engineers Know and how they Know it: Analytical Studies from Aeronautical History John Hopkins University Press Baltimore
Philippe de Vilmorin (1910) La Génétique et la Quatrième Conférence Internationale de Génétique Duruy Paris
Vilmorin, Philippe de.1913. “Fixité des Races de Froments.” IVe Conférence Internationale de Génétique – Paris 1911. Comptes-rendus et Rapport Edités par Philippe de Vilmorin. Paris: Masson pp. 312–316
Vilmorin Philippe de and Meunissier, A. 1913. Quelle a été jusqu’à présent l’influence des nouvelles méthodes de sélection sur la stabilité des variétés de plantes cultivées. 1913 (reprint from the Actes du Congrès International d’Agriculture de Gand)
Thomas Wieland (2004) “Wir beherrschen den pflanzlichen Organismus besser, ...” – Wissenschaftliche Pflanzenzüchtung in Deutschland, 1889–1945 Deutsches Museum München
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bonneuil, C. Mendelism, Plant Breeding and Experimental Cultures: Agriculture and the Development of Genetics in France. J Hist Biol 39, 281–308 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-006-0005-5
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-006-0005-5