Abstract
As moral panic over immigrants spreadduring the early 1990s, immigrationpolicies became increasingly criminalized in the wake of the bombingsof the World Trade Center in 1993 and ofthe Murrah Federal Building in OklahomaCity in 1995. In response to the threat ofterrorism at home, Congress enacted theIllegal Immigration Reform andImmigration Responsibility Act along withthe Anti-Terrorism and Effective DeathPenalty Act in 1996. Since then severalkey provisions of those statutes haveproduced numerous violations of civilliberties and immigrants' rights. Drawingon a conceptual framework developed bysociologist Gary T. Marx (1981), thisarticle examines critically thecontradictions and ironies of immigrationcontrol, specifically the mostcontroversial aspects of the 1996 laws:court-stripping provisions, use of secretevidence, and growing register ofdeportable crimes. In light of theterrorist attacks on September 11th, 2001,the article expresses concerns over thegovernment's current campaign to fightterrorism, especially the use of racialprofiling and mass detention shrouded insecrecy.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
American Civil Liberties Union, ACLU Joins Fix '96 Campaign For Justice For Immigrants, 2000a, www.aclu.org
American Civil Liberties Union, Miami Federal Court to Consider Government's Use of “Secret Evidence” in Detention of Academic, Press Release, April 17 (Washington, D.C: ACLU Media Relations Office, 2000b).
American Civil Liberties Union, Stop the Use of Secret Evidence, 2000c, www.aclu.org
American Civil Liberties Union, ACLU Urges Congress to End Use of Secret Evidence Press Release, May 23 (Washington, D.C: ACLU Media Relations Office, 2000d).
American Civil Liberties Union, “New Immigrant Law Threatens People and Principles: An Interview with Lucas Guttentag, Director of the ACLU Immigrants' Rights Project,” (Reposted from, and with the permission of, TexLaw), 1999, www.aclu.org
American Civil Liberties Union, The Rights of Immigrants, 1997, www.aclu.org
Amnesty International, Questions and Answers About Amnesty International and Refugees, 2000, www.amnestyusa.org
Associated Press, “Palestinian Jailed on Secret Evidence Released,” December 15, 2000: EV1.
Bacon, D., “INS Declares War on Labor: Ethnic Cleansing Hits Immigrant Workers, In Midwest Meatpacking,” Nation October 25, 1999, 18–23.
Bacon, D., “INS Enforcers,” Nation January 4, 1999, 8, 24.
Becker, H., Outsiders: Studies in the Sociology of Deviance (New York: Free Press, 1963).
Benjamin, J.A., “INS eases Removal Guidelines,” Fort-Lauderdale Sun Sentinel, November 24, 2000a, EV1–3.
Brownstein, H., The Rise and Fall of a Violent Crime Wave: Crack Cocaine and the Social Construction of a Crime Problem (New York: Harrow and Heston, 1996).
Canedy, D., “Professor to Be Deported After Secret Evidence Case,” Associated Press November 27, 2001, EV1–2.
Catholic Legal Immigration Network (CLINIC), Project for the Indefinitely Detained (formerly the Coalition to Support Cuban Detainees), 2001, www.cscd.org
Cheng, M.M., “New INS Guidelines Soften '96 Laws,” New York Newsday November 26, 2000, EV1–3.
Christensen, K., R. Read, J. Sullivan and B. Walth, “Unchecked Power of the INS Shatters American Dream,” The Oregonian December 9, 2000, EV1–8.
Christensen, K., J. Sullivan and B. Walth, “Immigration Law Splinters Families,” The Oregonian December 12, 2000, EV1–9.
Clendenning, A., “U.S. Supreme Court to Take Up Detainee Issue,” The Associate Press December 3, 2000, EV1–3.
Cohen, S., Folk Devils and Moral Panics (London: Macgibbon and Kee, 1972).
Cole, D., “Terrorist Scare: The Government Uses Secret Evidence to Find Aliens Guilty By Association,” Nation April 19, 1999, 26–28.
Dow, M., “We Know What INS is Hiding,” Miami Herald November 11, 2001, EV1–3.
Eggen, D., “Meissner Ends Embattled Tenure as Head of INS,” Washington Post November 20, 2000, EV1–3.
Gearan, A., “High Court To Rule On Deportation,” Associated Press February 21, 2001, EV1–2.
Goode, E. and N. Ben-Yehuda, Moral Panics: The Social Construction of Deviance (Cambridge, MA: Blackwell, 1994).
Greenhouse, L., “Supreme Court Will Decide On Deporting Of Immigrants,” New York Times January 13, 2001a, A10.
Greenhouse, L., “Justices Permit Immigrants To Challenge Deportations: 5–4 Ruling May Lead to Judicial Scrutiny of Other Actions by Executive Branch,” New York Times June 26, 2001b, A1, A15.
Hall, S., Critcher, T. Jefferson, J. Clarke and B. Roberts, Policing the Crisis: Mugging, the State and Law and Order (New York: Holmes and Meiser, 1978).
Hawkins, R. and G. Tiedeman, The Creation of Deviance (Columbus, Ohio: C.Merrill, 1975).
Hegstrom, E., “Immigrants Taught to Sue for Unpaid Wages,” The Houston Chronicle November 30, 2000, EV1–2.
Hirschi, T., Causes of Delinquency (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1969).
Indefinite Detention Project of the Catholic Legal Immigration Network Inc., Quarterly Report for the Indefinite Detention Project: October-December, 2000, www.cscd.org
Jansen, B., “Deal Sought on Illegal Farm Labor,” Associated Press December 4, 2000.
Lawyers Committee For Human Rights, Testimony delivered by Daniel Shanfield, Staff Attorney, Lawyers Committee for Human Rights: Before the United States House of Representatives Committee on the Judiciary Subcommittee on International Operations and Human Rights. April 13, 2000a: www.lchr.org
Lemert, E., Human Deviance, Social Problems, and Social Control (Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1972).
Lewin, T., “Curbs in Immigrants' and Inmates' Rights, Too,” New York Times December 26, 2000, EV 1–3.
Margasak, L., “Court Rules Against Open-Ended Jail,” Associated Press June 28, 2001, EV1.
Martinez, D., “New INS Guidelines Soften Edge of '96 Laws,” Miami Herald January 2, 2001, EV1–3.
Marx, G.T., “Ironies of Social Control: Authorities as Contributors to Deviance Through Escalation, Nonenforcement, and Covert Facilitation,” Social Problems 1981 (28), 221–246.
Osborn, K., “DUI gets Aliens a Free Trip Home,” Fox News January 24, 2001.
Parenti, C., Lockdown America: Police and Prisons in the Age of Crisis (New York: Verso, 1999).
Reinarman, C. and H. Levine, Crack in America: Demon Drugs and Social Justice (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1997).
Reiss, A., “Delinquency as the Failure of Personal and Social Control,” American Sociological Review 1951 (16), 196–207.
Reimers, D.M., Unwelcome Strangers: American Identity and the Turn Against Immigration (New York: Columbia University Press, 1998).
Robertson, J.E., “Prison Reform, A Faustian Bargain: Commentary on Prospective Relief Before and After French v. Miller,” Criminal Law Bulletin March–April, 2001, 194–208.
Robertson, J.E., “Psychological Injury and the Prison Litigation Reform Act: A 'Not Exactly' Equal Protection Analysis,” Harvard Journal on Legislation 2000 (37:1), 105–158.
Rodriguez, C., “Law Puts Immigrants in Jeopardy of Deportation for Minor Crimes,” Boston Globe December 28, 2000, EV1–2.
Sack, K., “Judge Finds Labor Law Broken at Meat-Packing Plant,” New York Times January 4, 2001, A18.
Schneider, L., “Ironic Perspective and Sociological Thought,” in L. Coser (ed.), The Idea of Social Structure (New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1975) pp. 323–339.
Shapiro, B., “All in the Name of Security: The Administration is Using September 11 to Curtail Our Civil Liberties,” The Nation October 22, 2001, 20–22.
Sullivan, J. and B. Walth, “Ex-lawmaker Watches Reforms Exceed Intent,” The Oregonian December 9, 2000, EV 1–3.
Tagami, T., “INS Arrests 14 Hispanics in Sting Operation at Courthouse,” Herald-Leader November 21, 2000a, EV1–3.
Tagami, T., “Roadblock Revelas Problem for Courts,” Herald-Leader November 26, 2000b, EV1–6.
Tebo, M.G., “Locked Up Tight,” ABA Journal November, 2000, EV 1–9.
Uchitelle, L., “I.N.S. Is Looking the Other Way As Illegal Immigrants Fill Jobs: Enforcement Changes in Face of Labor Shortage,” New York Times March 9, 2000, A1, C16.
Ufford, L., “ACLU Pushes Against 'Secret Evidence',” ACLU-Civil Liberties Reporter 2000 (34:3), 1, 4.
Welch, M., Detained: Immigration Laws and the Expanding I.N.S. Jail Complex. (Philadelphia: Temple University Press 2001).
Welch, M., Punishment in America: Social Control and the Ironies of Imprisonment. (Thousand oaks, California: Sage 1999).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Welch, M. Ironies of social control and the criminalization of immigrants. Crime, Law and Social Change 39, 319–337 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1024068321783
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1024068321783