Abstract
This article provides an overview of long-term changes in the relative conditions of the rich in preindustrial Europe. It covers four pre-unification Italian states (Sabaudian State, Florentine State, Kingdom of Naples and Republic of Venice) as well as other areas of Europe (Low Countries, Catalonia) during the period 1300–1800. Three different kinds of indicators are measured systematically and combined in the analysis: headcount indexes, the share of the top rich, and richness indexes. Taken together, they suggest that overall, during the entirety of the early modern period the rich tended to become both more prevalent and more distanced from the other strata of society. The only period during which the opposite process took place was the late Middle Ages, following the Black Death epidemic of the mid-fourteenth century. In the period from ca. 1500 to 1800, the prevalence of the rich doubled. In the Sabaudian State, the Florentine State and the Kingdom of Naples, for which reconstructions of regional wealth distributions exist, in about the same period the share of the top 10 % grew from 45–55 to 70–80 %—reaching almost exactly the same level which has recently been suggested as the European average at 1810. Consequently, the time series presented here might be used to add about five centuries of wealth inequality trends to current debates on very long-term changes in the relative position of the rich.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
The “modern” cadastres are characterized by a precise cartographic representation of all parcels of land, while the earlier estimi simply provide a description of goods and an assessment of their value. Generally speaking, the criteria used in compiling the modern cadastres were different from those that had been used for centuries for the estimi, so that they practically interrupt the series. Of the pre-unification Italian states considered here, the first to introduce a modern cadastre was the Sabaudian State, in 1731, although many communities in the area continued for a few decades to renew also their traditional estimi.
Venice, whose citizens paid the “redecima” tribute, is a partial exception.
The Appendix can be downloaded from http://didattica.unibocconi.eu/Alfani_database.
In particular: 1. The fact that the entire distributions were almost never published and often only synthetic tables organized per class were published; 2. The fact that, in Italy but not only there, the method of the “data collection for totality” (rilevazione per totalità) was used, which was later widely criticized due to the practical impossibility of actually achieving it to a satisfactory degree. For a discussion of the issue raised by the methods used by the Italian Marxist school of economic history, see Alfani 2014, 63-4. For similar criticism raised against the French grand théses in rural history of the 1950s-1970s, see Boudjaaba 2010, 375-6.
Other Tuscan rural communities (Antella and Santa Maria Impruneta) for which pre-Black Death data are included in the EINITE database are too small to calculate the measures needed in this article – although the impact of the plague on their distribution can be analysed by other methods, and in particular by comparison of Gini indexes and Lorenz curves: see Alfani and Ammannati 2016.
Notice that increasing the wealth of those who are already above the richness line – which is, by definition, set at a higher level than the median – does not affect the median value and consequently does not alter the richness line.
These figures probably under-estimate slightly the real situation, as the capital cities (Turin, Naples and Florence) are not included due to the lack of sources (see Sect. 1, as well a detailed discussion for the Sabaudian State in Alfani 2015 and for the Florentine State in Alfani and Ammannati 2016).
References
Alfani G (2009) Prima della curva di Kuznets: stabilità e mutamento nella concentrazione di ricchezza e proprietà in età moderna. In: Alfani G, Barbot M (eds) Ricchezza, valore, proprietà in Età Preindustriale. 1400–1850. Marsilio, Venice, pp 143–168
Alfani G (2010a) Wealth inequalities and population dynamics in northern Italy during the early modern period. J Interdiscip Hist 40(4):513–549
Alfani G (2010b) The effects of plague on the distribution of property: Ivrea, Northern Italy 1630. Popul Stud 64(1):61–75
Alfani G (2013) Fiscality and territory. Ivrea and Piedmont between the Fifteenth and Seventeenth Centuries. In: Vester M (ed) Sabaudian Studies. Political Culture, Dynasty, & Territory 1400–1700. Truman State University Press, Kirksville, pp 213–239
Alfani G (2014) Back to the peasants: new insights into the economic, social, and demographic history of northern Italian rural populations during the Early Modern period. Hist Compass 12(1):62–71
Alfani G (2015) Economic inequality in northwestern Italy: a long-term view (fourteenth to eighteenth centuries). J Econ Hist 75(4):1058–1096
Alfani G, Ammannati F (2016) Economic inequality and poverty in the very long run: the case of the florentine state (late Thirteenth-Early Nineteenth Centuries). Econ History Rev (forthcoming)
Alfani G, Caracausi A (2009) Struttura della proprietà e concentrazione della ricchezza in ambiente urbano: Ivrea e Padova, secoli XV–XVII. In: Alfani G, Barbot M (eds) Ricchezza, valore, proprietà in Età Preindustriale. 1400–1850. Marsilio, Venice, pp 185–209
Alfani G, De Franco D (2015) Economic and social inequality in a preindustrial society: building a social table for northern Italy (Sabaudian State, 1613). In: Paper given at the European historical economics society conference, Pisa, 4–5 Sept 2015
Alfani G, Di Tullio M (2015) Dinamiche di lungo periodo della disuguaglianza in Italia settentrionale: una nota di ricerca. Dondena Working Paper No. 71
Alfani G, Ryckbosch W (2016) Growing apart in early modern Europe? A comparison of inequality trends in Italy and the Low Countries, 1500–1800. Explor Econ Hist. doi:10.1016/j.eeh.2016.07.003
Alfani G, Sardone S (2015) Long-term trends in economic inequality in southern Italy. The Kingdoms of Naples and Sicily, 16th–18th centuries: First results. In: Paper given at the economic history association conference, Nashville, 11–13 Sept 2015
Alvaredo F, Atkinson AB, Picketty T, Saez E (2013) The top 1 percent in international and historical perspective. J Econ Perspect 27(3):3–20
Ammannati F (2015) La Peste Nera e la distribuzione della proprietà nella Lucchesia del tardo Medioevo. Popolazione e Storia 2(2015):21–45
Ammannati F, De Franco D, Di Tullio M (2015) Misurare la diseguaglianza economica nell’età preindustriale: un confronto fra realtà dell’Italia centro-settentrionale. Rivista di Storia Economica 31(3):309–340
Atkinson AB, Picketty T, Saez E (2011) Top incomes in the long run of history. J Econ Lit 49(1):3–71
Berengo M (1970) A proposito di proprietà fondiaria. Rivista Storica Italiana 82:121–147
Bose A, Chakravarty SR, D’Ambrosio C (2014) Richness orderings. J Econ Inequal 12(1):5–22
Boudjaaba F (2010). La distribuzione delle fortune fondiarie in Francia alla fine dell’ ancien régime: un approccio dinamico a partire dal caso della Normandia. In: Alfani G, Barbot M (eds) Ricchezza, valore, proprietà in Età Preindustriale. 1400–1850. Marsilio, Venice, pp 371–390
Canbakal J (2013) Wealth and inequality in Ottoman Bursa, 1500-1840. In: Paper given at the economic history society annual conference, York, 5–7 Sept 2013
Fornasin A (2002) La proprietà della terra, i percettori dei prodotti e della rendita. In: Pinto G, Poni C, Tucci U (eds.) L’Italia agricola dalle origini ad oggi, vol II, Il Medioevo e l’età moderna. Polistampa, Firenze, pp. 357–380
García‐Montero, H (2015) Long‐term trends in wealth inequality in catalonia, 1400–1800: initial results. Dondena working paper no. 79
Hanus J (2013) Real inequality in the early modern Low Countries: the city of ‘s-Hertogenbosch, 1500–1660. Econ Hist Rev 66(3):733–756
Herlihy D (1967) Medieval and Renaissance Pistoia. Yale University Press, New Haven
Herlihy D (1978) The distribution of wealth in a Renaissance Community: Florence 1427. In: Abrams P, Wrigley EA (eds) Towns in societies. Essays in economic history and historical sociology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 131–157
Herlihy D, Klapisch-Zuber C (1985) Tuscans and their families. Yale University Press, New Haven
Hoffman PT, Jacks D, Levin PA, Lindert PH (2002) Real inequality in Europe since 1500. J Econ Hist 62(2):322–355
Lindert PH (1991) Toward a comparative history of income and wealth inequality. In: Brenner YS, Kaelble H, Thomas M (eds) Income distribution in historical perspective. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 212–231
Lindert PH (2014) Making the most of Capital in the 21st century. NBER Working paper no. 20232
Lindert PH and Williamson JG (2015) American colonial incomes, 1650–1774. Econ Hist Rev, online-first version
Medeiros M (2006) The rich and the poor: the construction of an affluence line from the poverty line. Soc Indic Res 78:1–18
Medeiros M, Ferreira de Souza PHG (2014) The Rich, the affluent and the top incomes: a literature review. IRLE Working Paper No. 105-14
Mocarelli L (2009) The attitude of Milanese society to work and commercial activities. The case of the porters and the case of the elites. In: Ehmer J, Lis C (eds) The idea of work in Europe from Antiquity to Modern Times. Ashgate, Farnham, pp 101–121
Nicolini EA, Ramos Palencia (2015) Decomposing Income Inequality in a Backward Pre-Industrial Economy: Old Castile (Spain) in the Middle of the 18th Century. Econ History Rev (online-first version)
Nicolini EA, Ramos Palencia F (2013) Comparing income and wealth inequality in pre-industrial economies. Lessons from Spain in the 18th century. In: Paper given at the 10th Swedish Economic History Meeting, Lund, 4–5 Oct 2013
Pamuk S (2007) The Black Death and the origins of the ‘Great Divergence’ across Europe, 1300–1600. Eur Rev Econ Hist 11(3):289–317
Peichl A, Schaefer T, Scheicher T (2010) Measuring richness and poverty: a micro data application to Europe and Germany. Rev Income Wealth 56(3):597–619
Piketty T (2014) Capital in the twenty-first century. Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Piketty T, Postel-Vinay G, Rosenthal J-L (2006) Wealth concentration in a developing economy: Paris and France, 1807–1994. Am Econ Rev 96(1):236–256
Piketty T, Postel-Vinay G, Rosenthal J-L (2014) Inherited vs Self-Made Wealth: theory and Evidence from a Rentier Society (Paris 1872–1937). Explor Econ Hist 51:21–40
Porisini G (1963) La proprietà terriera nel Comune di Ravenna dalla metà del secolo XVI ai giorni nostri. Giuffré, Milano
Prados De La Escosura L (2007) Inequality and poverty in Latin America: a long-run exploration. In: Hatton TJ, O’Rourke KH, Taylor AM (eds) The new comparative economic history. MIT Press, Cambridge MA, pp 291–315
Prados De La Escosura L (2008) Inequality, poverty and the Kuznets curve in Spain, 1850–2000. Eur Rev Econ Hist 12:287–324
Pullan B (1978) Poveri, mendicanti e vagabondi. Storia d’Italia, Annali, vol 1. Einaudi, Turin, pp 981–1047
Reis J, Martins A (2012) Inequality in Early Modern Europe: The “Strange” Case of Portugal, 1550–1770. In: Paper given at the conference Wellbeing and Inequality in the Long Run, Madrid, 1 June 2012
Roine J, Waldenström D (2015) Long run trends in the distribution of income and wealth. In: Atkinson A, Bourguignon F (eds) Handbook of income distribution, vol 2A. North-Holland, Amsterdam
Rossi N, Toniolo G, Vecchi G (2001) Is the kuznets curve still alive? evidence from italian household budgets, 1881–1961. Journal of Economic History 61(4):904–925
Rotelli C (1966) La distribuzione della proprietà terriera e delle colture a Imola nel XVII e XVIII secolo. Giuffré, Milan
Ryckbosch W (2012). A consumer revolution under strain? Consumption, wealth and status in eighteenth-century Aalst. Unpublished PhD Dissertation, University of Antwerp
Ryckbosch W (2015) Economic inequality and growth before the industrial revolution: the case of the Low Countries (fourteenth to nineteenth centuries). Eur Rev Econ Hist (online-first version)
Santiago-Caballero C (2011) Income inequality in central Spain, 1690-1800. Explor Econ Hist 48(1):83–96
Santiago-Caballero C, Fernández E (2013) Income inequality in Madrid, 1500–1850. In: Paper given at the economic history society annual conference, York, 5–7 Sept 2013
Soltow L, Van Zanden JL (1998) Income and wealth inequality in the Netherlands, 16th-20th centuries. Het Spinhuis, Amsterdam
Van Zanden JL (1995) Tracing the beginning of the Kuznets curve: Western Europe during the early modern period. Econ Hist Rev 48(4):643–664
Williamson JG (1985) Did British capitalism breed inequality?. Allen & Unwin, Boston
Williamson JG, Lindert PH (1980) American inequality: a macro economic history. Academic Press, New York
Woolf SJ (1988) Porca miseria. Poveri e assistenza nell’Età moderna, Laterza, Bari
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Alfani, G. The rich in historical perspective: evidence for preindustrial Europe (ca. 1300–1800). Cliometrica 11, 321–348 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11698-016-0151-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11698-016-0151-8
Keywords
- Economic inequality
- Wealth concentration
- Richness
- Top wealthy
- Middle ages
- Early modern period
- Italy
- Low Countries
- Catalonia
- Black Death
- Property structures