Abstract
This is a study to measure the efficiency of the rural Health Centres (HCs) and their Regional Surgeries (RSs) of the 6th Health Prefecture (HP) of Greece, which covers Southern and Western Greece. Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) was applied under Constant and Variable Returns to Scale, using a weight-restricted, output-oriented model, to calculate pure technical efficiency (PΤΕ), scale efficiency (SE) and total technical efficiency (TE). The selection of inputs, outputs and their relative weights in the model was based on two consecutive consensus panels of experts on Primary Health Care (PHC). Medical personnel, nursing personnel and technological equipment were chosen as inputs and were attributed appropriate weight restrictions. Acute, chronic and preventive consultations where chosen as outputs; each output was constructed by smaller subcategories of different relative importance. Data were collected through a questionnaire sent to all HCs of the covered area. From the 42 HCs which provided complete data, the study identified 9 as technical efficient, 5 as scale efficient and 2 as total efficient. The mean TE, PTE and SE scores of the HCs of the 6th Health Prefecture were 0.57, 0.67 and 0.87, respectively. The results demonstrate noteworthy variation in efficiency in the productive process of the HCs of Southern and Western Greece. The dominant form of inefficiency was technical inefficiency. The HCs of the 6th HP can theoretically produce 33 % more output on average, using their current production factors. These results indicated potential for considerable efficiency improvement in most rural health care units. Emphasis on prevention and chronic disease management, as well as wider structural and organisational reforms, are discussed from the viewpoint of how to increase efficiency.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Pan American Health Organization and World Health Organization (2007) Renewing primary health care in the Americas: a position paper of the Pan american health organization/world health organization (PAHO/WHO). PAHO, Washington
AAFP. American Academy of Family Physicians. Definition of primary care (2014) Available at: http://www.aafp.org/about/policies/all/primary-care.html
Kahn NB, Ostergaard DJ, Graham R (1994) AAFP constructs definitions related to primary care. Am Fam Physic 50:1211–15
Donaldson M, Yordy K & Vanselow N (eds) (1994) Institute of Medicine. Defining primary care: an interim report. National Academy Press, Washington, DC
Ministry of Health (1983) Law 1397/1983. (FEK 143Α) ‘National Health System’
Lionis C, Symvoulakis EK, Markaki A, Vardavas C, Papadakaki M, Daniilidou N, Souliotis K, Kyriopoulos I (2009) Integrated primary health care in Greece, a missing issue in the current health policy agenda: a systematic review. Int J Integr Care 9:e88
Economou C. (2010) Health systems in transition: Greece. Health system review. WHO/EURO, European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies, Copenhagen
Law 3918/2011 (2011) Structural reforms in Health System, FEK Α’ 31
Law 4238 / 2014 (2014) Primary national health network (PEDI), FEK 18
Oikonomou N, Tountas Y (2011) Insufficient primary care services to the rural population of Greece. Rural Remote Health 11(1):1661
Mossialos E, Allin S, Davaki K (2005) Analysing the Greek health system: a tale of fragmentation and inertia. Health Econ 14(Suppl 1):S151–S168
Pierrakos G, Yfantopoulos J (2007) Factors that influence the evaluation of primary health care services. Arch Hellen Med 24(6):578–582
Economou C. & Giorno C (2009) Improving the Performance of the Public Health Care System in Greece”, OECD Economics Department Working Papers, No. 722, OECD Publishing
Worthington AC (2004) Frontier efficiency measurement in health care: a review of empirical techniques and selected applications. Med Care Res Rev 61(2):135–170
Oikonomou N, Tountas Y (2011) The Greek economic crisis: a primary health-care perspective. Lancet 377(9759):28–9
Kousoulis A, Angelopoulou K, Lionis C (2013) Exploring health care reform in a changing Europe: lessons from Greece. Eur J Gen Pract 19(3):194–9
Oikonomou N, Tountas Y, Niakas D (2007) Greek studies of economic evaluation and efficiency in health. Archives of Hellenique Med 24(1):48–57 [In Greek]
Oikonomou N, Tountas Y (2009) Greek measurements of efficiency in health. Health Inspect 20(116):17–22 [In Greek]
Sissouras A, Mitropoulos I & Gounaris C (2000) Evaluating the efficiency of health care units: the case of the Greek primary care centers. In: Javor A, van Eimeren E & Duru G (eds). Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on System Science in Health Care. Budapest
Zavras A, Tsakos G, Economou C, Kyriopoulos J (2002) Using DEA to evaluate efficiency and formulate policy within a Greek national primary health care network. J Med Syst 26(4):285–292
Kontodimopoulos N, Moschovakis G, Aletras VH, Niakas D (2007) The effect of environmental factors on technical and scale efficiency of primary health care providers in Greece. Cost Eff Resour Alloc 5:14
Huang Y, McLaughlin C (1989) Relative efficiency in rural primary health care: an application of data envelopment analysis. Health Serv Res 24(2):143–158
Amado C, Santos S (2009) Challenges for performance assessment and improvement in primary health care: the case of the Portuguese health centres. Health Policy 91:43–56
Oikonomou N, Tountas Y, Kyriopoulos J (2012) The need for measurement of efficiency in Greek primary healthcare: the case for rural Southern and Western Greece. Appl Health Econ Health Policy 10(2):143–4
Farrell MJ (1957) The measurement of productive efficiency. J Royal Stat Soc (Series A) 120(3):253–281
Murillo-Zamorano L (2004) Economic efficiency and frontier techniques. J Econ Survey 18(1):33–77
Ozcan Y. (2014) Health Care Benchmarking and Performance Evaluation. An Assessment using Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA), 2nd Edition. Springer, Newton, MA
Charnes A, Cooper W, Rhodes E (1978) Measuring the efficiency of decision making units. Eur J Oper Res 2:429–444
Jacobs R (2001) Alternative methods to examine hospital efficiency: data envelopment analysis and stochastic frontier analysis. Health Care Manag Scie 4:103–115
Fried H, Lovell C, Schmidt S (1993) The measurement of productive efficiency: techniques and applications. Oxford University Press, New York
Dyson R, Thanassoulis E (1988) Reducing weight flexibility in data envelopment analysis. J Op’ Res Soc 39:563–576
Cooper W, Seiford L, Zhu J. (Eds) (2011) Handbook on data envelopment analysis, 2nd Edition. International Series in Operations Research & Management Science, Springer, New York
Wong Y, Beasley J (1990) Restricting weight flexibility in data envelopment analysis. J Oper Res Soc 41:829–835
Oikonomou N, Tountas Y, Mariolis A, Athanasakis K, Kyriopoulos Y (2010) The choice of the necessary equipment for the Greek Health Centres. 6th PanHellenic Congress on Management, Economics and Health Policy, Athens, 15–18
Oikonomou N, Tountas Y, Mariolis A, Athanasakis K, Kyriopoulos Y (2010) The outputs of the Health Centres of the country. A Delphi Method Research. 6th PanHellenic Congress on Management, Economics and Health Policy, Athens, 15–18
Williams PL, Webb C (1994) The Delphi technique: a methodological discussion. J Adv Nurs 19:180–6
Oikonomou N, Tountas Y, Mariolis A, Athanasakis K, Androulakis E, Kyriopoulos Y (2011) The weights of inputs and outputs of the Greek Health Centres: results of two consensus panels. 7th PanHellenic Congress on Management, Economics and Health Policy, Athens, 14–17
Oikonomou N, Tountas Y, Mariolis A, Athanasakis K, Androulakis E, Kyriopoulos Y (2011) The inputs of the Greek Health Centres: Results from two consensus panels. 6th Panhellenic congress of Health Promotion and Health Education, Athens, 14–15
Thompson RG, Langemeier LN, Lee CT, Thrall RM (1990) The role of multiplier bounds in efficiency analysis with application to Kansas farming. J Econ 46(1/2):93–108
Cooper WM, Seiford LM, Tone K (2006) Introduction to data envelopment analysis and its uses: with DEA-solver software and references. Spring Science + Business Media, Inc, New York
Starfield B (1998) Primary care: balancing health needs, services, and technology. Oxford University Press, New York
Oikonomidou E, Anastasiou F, Dervas D, Patri F, Karaklidis D, Moustakas P, Andreadou N, Mantzanas E, Merkouris B (2010) Rural primary care in Greece: working under limited resources. Int J Qual Health Care 22(4):333–7
Allen R, Athanassopoulos A, Dyson RG, Thanassoulis E (1997) Weights restrictions and value judgments in data envelopment analysis: evolution development and future directions. Ann Oper Res 73:13–34
Rezai Balf F, Shahverdi R, Moienalsadat H (2011) Estimation of return to scale under weight restrictions in data envelopment analysis. J Applied Math Islamic Azad Univ Lahijan 7(4):55–63
Banker R, Charnes A, Cooper W (1984) Some models for estimating technical and scale inefficiencies in data envelopment analysis. Manag Sci 30(9):1078–1092
Schmacker E, McKay N (2008) Factors affecting productive efficiency in primary care clinics. Health Serv Manag Res 21(1):60–70
Lionis 2011. Primary Care in Greece. European forum for primary care, 31 Jan 2011; Column 2011 – 1, accessible at http://www.euprimarycare.org/column/primary-care-greece
Oikonomou N, Tountas Y, Mariolis A, Athanasakis K, Kyriopoulos Y (2010) The factors affecting the use of services of the Health Centres of the country. 6th PanHellenic Congress on Management, Economics and Health Policy, Athens, 15–18
Linna M, Nordblad A, Koivu M (2003) Technical and cost efficiency of oral health care provision in Finnish health centres. Soc Sci Med 56(2):343–353
Marschall P, Flessa S (2011) Efficiency of primary care in rural Burkina Faso. A two-stage DEA analysis. Health. Econ Rev 1(1):5
Tountas Y, Karnaki P, Pavi E (2002) Reforming the reform: the Greek national health system in transition. Health Pol 62:15–29
Kirigia J, Sambo L, Scheel H (2001) Technical efficiency of public clinics in Kwazulu-Natal Province of South Africa. East Afr Med J 78(3Supp):S1–13
Hernández A, San SM (2014) Assessing the technical efficiency of health posts in rural Guatemala: a data envelopment analysis. Glob Health Action 7:23190. doi:10.3402/gha.v7.23190
Tountas Y, Oikonomou N, Pallikarona G, Dimitrakaki C, Tzavara C, Souliotis K, Mariolis A, Pappa E, Kontodimopoulos N, Niakas D (2011) Socio-demographic and socio-economic determinants of health services utilisation in Greece: the Hellas health I study. Health Serv Manag Res 24(1):8–18
Kyriopoulos JE, Tsalikis G (1993) Public and private imperatives of Greek health policies. Health Policy 26(2):105–117
Tountas Y, Karnaki P, Pavi E (2005) The “unexpected” growth of the private health sector in Greece. HealthPolicy 74(2):167–180
Oikonomou N, Mariolis A (2010) How is Greece conforming to alma-Ata’s principles in the middle of its biggest financial crisis? Br J Gen Pract 60(575):456–7
Souliotis K, Lionis C (2005) Creating an integrated health care system in Greece: a primary care perspective. J Med Syst 29:187–196
Theodorou M, Sarris Μ, Soulis S (2001) Health systems and Greek reality. Papazisi publications, Athens [In Greek]
Beaglehole R, Epping-Jordan J, Patel V, Chopra M, Ebrahim S, Kidd M, Haines A (2008) Improving the prevention and management of chronic disease in low-income and middle-income countries: a priority for primary health care. Lancet 372(9642):940–9
Moraitis E., Georgousi E., Zilides C., Theodorou M., Polyzos N., (1995). Study on the Organization and function of a Primary health care system, Athens, Ministry of Health & Pharmetrica [in Greek]
Theodorakis P, Lionis C (2003) Quality in primary health care: is general practice effective in the early detection of diseases and improvement of quality of life? In: Kyriopoulos C, Lionis C, Souliotis K, Tsakos G (eds) The quality of health services. Publications Themelio, Athens [In Greek]
Rogers W, Veale B. (2000). Primary Health Care and General Practice: A Scoping Report, Primary Health Care Research & Information Service, Adelaide
Zilidis X (1995) The health centres in northern Greece problems and potential development of primary health care. University Studio Press, Thessaloniki [In Greek]
Kontodimopoulos N, Nanos P, Niakas D(a) (2006) Balancing efficiency of health services and equity of access in remote areas in Greece. Health policy 76:49–57
Arguriadou S, Melissaropoulou H, Krania E, Karagiannidou A, Vlachonikolis J, Lionis C (2001) Dementia and depression: two frequent disorders of the aged in primary health care in Greece. Fam Pract 18:87–91
Lionis C, Tzagournissakis M, Iatraki E, Kozyraki M, Antonakis N, Plaitakis A (2001) Are primary care physicians able to assess dementia? an estimation of their capacity after a short-term training program in rural Crete. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry 9:3
Lionis C, Chatziarsenis M, Antonakis N, Gianoulis Y, Fioretos M (1998) Assessment of vaccine coverage of school children in three primary health care areas in rural Crete. Greece Fam Pract 15:443–448
Chatziarsenis M, Miyakis S, Faresj¨o T, Fioretos M, Vlachonicolis J, Trell E, Lionis C (1999) Is there room for general practice in penitentiary institutions: screening and vaccinating high risk groups against hepatitis. Fam Pract 16:366–368
Lionis C, Frangoulis E, Skliros S, Alexandrakis G, Kouroumalis E (1999) HowGreekGPs manage hepatitis C infected patients: experiences gained from a primary health care district in rural Crete. Aust J Fam Physicians 28:207
Christodoulou E, Oikonomou N, Mariolis A, Papageorgiou E, Aivaliotis (2009) Accomplishment of pain management in primary health care. 15th Wonca Europe Conference, 16–19, Basel, Switzerland
Oikonomou N, Papathanasiou M, Marayiannis K, Aivaliotis I, Papageorgiou E, Mariolis A (2009) Diagnosing Type 2 diabetes in asymptomatic patients — clinical opportunistic screening in the first urban health centre in Greece. 15th Wonca Europe Conference, 16–19 Basel, Switzerland
Oikonomou N, Mariolis A (2009) Three trends that undermine the Greek health system: is there a way out? Eur J Gen Pract 15(2):67–68
Kounalakis D, Lionis C, Okkes I et al (2003) Developing an appropriate EPR system for the Greek primary care setting. J Med Syst 27(3):239–245
Kazley A, Ozcan Y (2009) Electronic medical record (EMR) Use and efficiency: a data envelopment analysis of hospitals. Socio Econ Plan Sci 43(3):209–216
Furukawa M (2011) Electronic medical records and efficiency and productivity during office visits. Am J Manag Care 17(4):296–303
Deidda M, Lupiáñez-Villanueva F, Codagnone C, Maghiros I (2014) Using data envelopment analysis to analyse the efficiency of primary care units. J Med Syst 38:122
Lionis X, Merkouris P (2000) Views on the current situation in primary health care and suggestions for its improvement. Primary Health Care 12:7–9 [In Greek]
Kringos DS, Boerma WG, Bourgueil Y, Cartier T, Hasvold T, Hutchinson A, Lember M, Oleszczyk M, Pavlic DR, Svab I, Tedeschi P, Wilson A, Windak A, Dedeu T, Wilm S (2010) The european primary care monitor: structure, process and outcome indicators. BMC Fam Pract 11:81
Groenewegen P, Jurgutis A (2013) A future for primary care for the Greek population. Qual Prim Care 21(6):369–78
Skroumbelos A, Oikonomou N, Thireos E, Economidou E, Kyriopoulos J (2012) Transition to a model of perspective financing of primary health care : the case of primary health care visit groups. Department of Health Economics, National School of Public Health, Athens, [In Greek] (Available at : http://www.esdy.edu.gr/default.aspx?page=toy_meletes_toy)
Kavoura M, Zavras D, Kyriopoulos J (2003) Quantitative and qualitative definition of essential nursing personnel in Greece. Nosileftiki 42(4):457–68
Adamakidou T, Kalokerinou A (2010) New health policies on primary health care in Greece. Health Sci J 4(1):15–23
McGlynn E, Shekelle P, Chen S, Goldman D, Romley J, Hussey P et al. (2008) Identifying, Categorizing, and Evaluating Health Care Efficiency Measures. Final Report. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (4): Publication No. 08–0030
Roll Y & Golany B. (1993) Alternate Methods of Treating Factor Weights in DEA. Omega: International Journal of Management science, 21:99–109. Research Society of Japan, 1996, 39:604–613
Pedraja-Chaparo F, Salinas-Jiminez J, Smith P (1997) On the role of weight restrictions in data envelopment analysis. J Prod Anal 8:215–230
Podinovski V. (2000) Research Papers No 330: Weight restrictions and production trade-offs in DEA models. Warwick Business School, The University of Warwick, Coventry
Hollingsworth B (2008) The measurement of efficiency and productivity of health care delivery. Health Econ 17:1107–1128
Amado C, Dyson R (2008) On comparing the performance of primary care providers. Eur J Oper Res 185:915–32
Cordero J, Alonso-Morán E, Nuño-Solinis R, Orueta J, Sauto AR (2015) Efficiency assessment of primary care providers: a conditional nonparametric approach. Eur J Oper Res 240(1):235–244
Acknowledgment
We are grateful to the members of the Delphi panel for providing their expertise on the inputs and outputs of Greek PHC, the former head of the 6th Health Prefecture professor Panagiotis Goumas for facilitating data collection and the administrations of the Health Centres of the 6th Health Prefecture for kindly providing the necessary information.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Oikonomou, N., Tountas, Y., Mariolis, A. et al. Measuring the efficiency of the Greek rural primary health care using a restricted DEA model; the case of southern and western Greece. Health Care Manag Sci 19, 313–325 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10729-015-9324-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10729-015-9324-4