Agriculture and Human Values

, Volume 30, Issue 3, pp 325–335

Confronting coexistence in the United States: organic agriculture, genetic engineering, and the case of Roundup Ready® alfalfa

Authors

  • Kristina Hubbard
    • Organic Seed Alliance
    • Environmental Studies ProgramUniversity of Montana
Article

DOI: 10.1007/s10460-012-9394-6

Cite this article as:
Hubbard, K. & Hassanein, N. Agric Hum Values (2013) 30: 325. doi:10.1007/s10460-012-9394-6

Abstract

In agriculture, the principle of coexistence refers to a condition where different primary production systems can exist in the vicinity of each other, and can be managed in such a way that they affect each other as little as possible. Coexistence policies aim to ensure that farmers are able to freely grow the crops they choose—be they genetically engineered (GE), non-GE conventional, or organic. In the United States (US), the issue of coexistence has very recently come into sharp relief with the introduction of Roundup Ready® (RR) alfalfa, a landmark court decision in 2007 (Geertson v. Johanns), and subsequent governmental actions, including the first Environmental Impact Statement on a GE crop. By contrast, in 2003 the European Union (EU) created a policy to manage coexistence and to address economic harms that may be caused by contamination. We briefly review the EU framework as an instructive resource. This policy analysis then looks at the US organic industry and its standards with respect to GE before turning to the case of RR alfalfa. With a focus on the field trial stage and on environmental assessments prior to market approval, the case reveals numerous problems in the existing regulatory framework as it pertains to coexistence and prevention of contamination of organic products with GE material. The paper concludes with specific policy recommendations for creating a more robust coexistence policy in the US.

Keywords

Agricultural biotechnology Coexistence Genetic engineering Organic agriculture Coordinated Framework for Biotechnology Roundup Ready® alfalfa

Abbreviations

AC21

Advisory Committee on Biotechnology and 21st Century Agriculture

APHIS

Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service

CFS

Center for Food Safety

EA

Environmental assessment

EFSA

European Food Safety Authority

EIS

Environmental impact statement

EU

European Union

FONSI

Finding of No Significant Impact

GE

Genetically engineered

GMO

Genetically modified organism

NEPA

National Environmental Policy Act

NGO

Non-governmental organization

NOP

National Organic Program

NRC

National Research Council

rBGH

Recombinant Bovine Growth Hormone

RR

Roundup Ready®

USDA

United States Department of Agriculture

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2012