Abstract
Background
From September 1999 through January 2004 during the second Intifada (al-Aqsa), there were frequent terror attacks in Jerusalem. We assessed the effects on case fatality of introducing a specialized, intensified approach to trauma care at the Hebrew University-Hadassah Hospital Shock Trauma Unit (HHSTU) and other level I Israeli trauma units. This approach included close senior supervision of prehospital triage, transport, and all surgical procedures and longer hospital stays despite high patient-staff ratios and low hospital budgets. Care for lower income patients also was subsidized.
Methods
We tracked case fatality rates (CFRs) initially during a period of terror attacks (1999–2003) in 8,127 patients (190 deaths) at HHSTU in subgroups categorized by age, injury circumstances, and injury severity scores (ISSs). Our comparisons were four other Israeli level I trauma centers (n = 2,000 patients), and 51 level I U.S. trauma centers (n = 265,902 patients; 15,237 deaths). Detailed HHSTU follow-up continued to 2010.
Results
Five-year HHSTU CFR (2.62 %) was less than half that in 51 U.S. centers (5.73 %). CFR progressively decreased; in contrast to a rising trend in the US for all age groups, injury types, and ISS groupings, including gunshot wounds (GSW). Patients with ISS > 25 accounted for 170 (89 %) of the 190 deaths in HHSTU. Forty-one lives were saved notionally based on U.S. CFRs within this group. However, far more lives were saved from reductions in low CFRs in large numbers of patients with ISS < 25. CFRs in HHSTU and other Israeli trauma units decreased more through the decade to 1.9 % up to 2010.
Conclusions
Sustained reductions in trauma unit CFRs followed introduction of a specialized, intensified approach to trauma care.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Johnston WR (2012) Johnston’s archive—terrorism, counterterrorism and unconventional warfare—chronology of terrorist attacks in Israel. 15th Jan 2012. Available at: http://www.johnstonsarchive.net/terrorism/terrisraelsum.html
Statistical Report Summary regarding the Arab-Israeli conflict. Herzliya Interdisciplinary Center. Available at: http://www.ict.org.il
Bogen KT, Jones ED (2006) Risks of mortality and morbidity from worldwide terrorism: 1968–2004. Risk Anal 26(1):45–49
Krug EG, Mercy JA, Dahlberg LL, Zwi AB (2002) The world report on violence and health. World Health Organization. Lancet 360:1083–1088
Mackenzie EJ, Rivara FP, Gurkovich GJ, Nathens AB, Frey KP, Egleston BL, Salkever DS, Scharfstein DO (2006) A national evaluation of the effect of trauma-center care on mortality. N Eng J Med 354(4):366–378
Nathens A, Shafi S, Xiong W (2008) Ranking of trauma center performance: the bare essentials. J Trauma 65(3):628–635
Richter ED (2008) Israeli approvals for medical entry in the shadow of terror attacks at the Erez Crossing. Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs. Oct. 1, 2008. Available at: http://www.jcpa.org/JCPA/Templates/ShowPage.asp?DBID=1&LNGID=1&TMID=111&FID=283&PID=0&IID=2649. Accessed 5 Mar 2012
Almogy G, Luria T, Richter E, Pizov R, Bdolah-Abram T, Mintz Y, Zamir G, Rivkind A (2005) Can external signs of trauma guide management? Lessons learned from suicide bombing attacks in Israel. Arch Surg 140(4):390–393
Franklin J, Doelp A (1980) Shock trauma. Fawcett Crest, New York
Krumer R (2006) Director. External Relations Department, Hadassah Medical Center, Jerusalem
Seidman GI (2010) Is a flat-line a good thing? On the privatization of Israel’s healthcare system. Am J Law Med 36(2–3):452–481
Health care in the United States. Wikipedia. Available at: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_care_in_the_United_States. Accessed 15 Jan 2012
From World Health Organization (May 2009). “World Health Statistics 2009”. http://www.who.int/whosis/whostat/2009/en/index.html. Accessed 2 Aug 2009
Siegel-Izkovich J. Israel near bottom of list in OECD hospital bed rates. The Jerusalem Post. Available at: http://www.jpost.com/Home/Article.aspx?id=166612. Accessed 25 Jan 2010
Health Care Resources: Hospital Beds. From Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) Health Data 2011. OECD STATExtracts. Available at: http://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=HEALTH_REAC. Accessed 5 Mar 2012
A Comparison of National Trauma Data Bank (with Trauma Level I) of the American College of Surgeons Committee on Trauma 1999-2003. Israel National Center for Research on Trauma and Emergency Medicine. Tel-HaShomer-Sheba: Gertner Institute for Epidemiology and Health Policy. March 2005. PowerPoint presentation (Hebrew)
Almogy G, Rivkind AI (2007) Terror in the 21st century: milestones and prospects–part I [review]. Curr Probl Surg 44(8):496–554. See section “Mechanism of Injury.” pp 515–517
Peleg K, Aharonson-Daniel L, Stein M, Michaelson M, Kluger Y, Simon D, Noji EK, Israeli Trauma Group (ITG) (2004) Gunshot and explosion injuries: characteristics, outcomes, and implications for care of terror-related injuries in Israel. Ann Surg 239(3):311–318
Shafi S, Nathens AB, Parks J, Cryer HM, Fildes JJ, Gentilello LM, Shafi S, Parks J, Nathens AB, Gentilello LM (2008) Trauma quality improvement using risk-adjusted outcomes. J Trauma 64(3):599–604 discussion 604–606
Provonost PJ, Angus DC, Dorman T et al (2002) Physician staffing patterns and clinical outcomes in critically ill patients: a systematic review. JAMA 288:2151–2161
Richter ED, Blum R, Rivkind A (2006) Access to emergency care in Palestinian West Bank: interpretation of results is flawed. BMJ 332:1276; Comment on Rytter et al. Effects of armed conflict on access to emergency health care in Palestinian West Bank. BMJ 332(7550):1122–1124
Stein Y (2004) Effect of waiting in the Emergency Department on various parameters of patients and on their medical outcome [MD thesis]. Hebrew University, Jerusalem, Israel
Committee on Trauma, American College of Surgeons (2006) Performance improvement and patient safety. In: American College of Surgeons, eds. Resources for optimal care of the injured patient 2006. Chicago, IL, p 108
Nathens AB, Gurkovich GJ, MacKenzie EJ, Rivara FP (2004) A resource-based assessment of trauma care in the United States. J Trauma 56(1):173–178 discussion 178
Demetriades D, Martin M, Salim A, Rhee P, Brown C, Doucet J, Chan L (2006) Relationship between American college of Surgeons Trauma Center designation and mortality in patients with severe trauma (ISS > 15). J Am Coll Surg 202(2):212–215
Nathens AB, Maier RV, Jurovich GJ, Monary D, Rivara FP, MacKenzie E (2005) The Delivery of Critical Care Services in US Trauma Centers: is the standard being met? J Trauma Injury Infect Crit Care 60(4):773–784
Committee on Trauma, American College of Surgeons (2006) Descriptions of trauma center levels and their roles in a trauma system. In: American College of Surgeons (eds) Resources for Optimal Care of the Injured Patient 2006. Chicago, IL, pp 17–20
Broha K, Joseph T (2007) Email: Nov 24 2007. trauma-list-request@trauma.org discussing “Trauma: Who Cares?” by the National Confidential Enquiry into Patient Outcome and Death
Rytter MJ, Kjaeldgaard AL, Brønnum-Hansen H et al (2006) Effects of armed conflict on access to emergency health care in Palestinian West Bank: systematic collection of data in emergency departments. BMJ 332(7550):1122–1124
Champion HR, Mabee MS, Meredith JW (2006) The state of US trauma systems: public perceptions versus reality–implications for US response to terrorism and mass casualty events. J Am Coll Surg 203(6):951–961
Soffer D, Zmora O, Klausner JB, Szold O, Givon A, Halpern P, Schulman CI, Peleg K (2006) Alcohol use among trauma victims admitted to a level I trauma center in Israel. Isr Med Assoc J 8(2):98–102
Degenhardt L, Chiu WT, Sampson N et al (2008) Toward a global view of alcohol, tobacco, cannabis, and cocaine use: findings from the WHO World Mental Health Surveys. PLoS Med 5(7):e141
Richter ED, Friedman LS, Berman T, Rivkind A (2005) Death and injury from motor vehicle crashes: a tale of two countries. Am J Prev Med 29(5):440–449
Spira RM, Reissman P, Goldberg S, Hersch M, Einav S (2006) Evacuation of trauma patients solely to level I centers: is the question patient or trauma center survival? Debate IMAJ 8:113–131
Sosna J, Sella T, Shaham D, Shapira SC, Rivkind A, Bloom AI, Libson E (2005) Facing the new threats of terrorism: radiologists’ perspectives based on experience in Israel. Radiology 237(1):28–36
Bala M, Rivkind AI, Zamir G, Hadar T, Gertsenshtein I, Mintz Y, Pikarsky AJ, Amar D, Shussman N, Abu Gazala M, Almogy G (2008) Abdominal trauma after terrorist bombing attacks exhibits a unique pattern of injury. Ann Surg 248(2):303–309
Kmietowicz Z (2007) Hospitals without appropriate expertise should not offer trauma care. BMJ 335(7629):1067
Nathens AB, Rivara FP, MacKenzie EJ, Maier RV, Wang J, Egleson B, Sharfstein DO, Jurkovich GJ (2006) The impact of an intensivist-model ICU on trauma-related mortality. Ann Surg 244(4):545–554
Melanie Neal, Manager, NTDB, ACS, Chicago. February 23, 2007. Email: MNeal@facs.org
Sandra Goble, Statistician. NTDB American College of Surgeons. May 1, 2007
Acknowledgments
All authors disclose no potential conflicts of interest, including specific financial interests and relationships and affiliations (other than those affiliations listed in the title page of the manuscript) relevant to the subject of their manuscript. The principal investigator had full access to all of the data in the study and takes responsibility for the integrity of the data and the accuracy of the data analysis. We thank Dr Lee Friedman of the University of Illinois for consultation on data analysis, Sandra Goble and Melanie Neal of the American College of Surgeons for helpful clarifications on the workings of its National Trauma Data Base, and Kobi Peleg of the Center for Research on Trauma and Emergency Medicine, Gertner Institute for Epidemiology and Health Policy, Tel-HaShomer Hospital, for his contribution.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Appendix
Appendix
See Table 4.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rivkind, A.I., Blum, R., Gershenstein, I. et al. Trauma Care and Case Fatality during a Period of Frequent, Violent Terror Attacks and Thereafter. World J Surg 36, 2108–2118 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00268-012-1637-6
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00268-012-1637-6