Abstract
The vegan ideal is entailed by arguments for ethical veganism based on traditional moral theory (rights and/or utilitarianism) extended to animals. The most ideal lifestyle would abjure the use of animals or their products for food since animals suffer and have rights not to be killed. The ideal is discriminatory because the arguments presuppose a “male physiological norm” that gives a privileged position to adult, middle-class males living in industrialized countries. Women, children, the aged, and others have substantially different nutritional requirements and would bear a greater burden on vegetarian and vegan diets with respect to health and economic risks, than do these males. The poor and many persons in Third World nations live in circumstances that make the obligatory adoption of such diets, where they are not already a matter of sheer necessity, even more risky.
Traditional moral theorists (such as Evelyn Pluhar and Gary Varner whose essays appear in this issue) argue that those who are at risk would beexcused from a duty to attain the virtue associated with ethical vegan lifestyles. The routine excuse of nearly everyone in the world besides adult, middle-class males in industrialized countries suggests bias in the perspective from which traditional arguments for animal rights and (utilitarian) animal welfare are formulated.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allen, Lindsay H. 1986. Calcium and osteoporosis.Nutrition Today 21: 6–10.
Bothwell, T. H., R. D. Baynes, B. J. MacFarlane, and A. P. MacPhail. 1989. Nutritional Iron Requirements and Food Iron Absorption.Journal of Internal Medicine 226: 357–365 (review of 72 sources).
Dallman, P. R. 1989. Iron Deficiency: Does It Matter?Journal of Internal Medicine 226: 367–372 (review of 31 sources).
Dawson-Hughes, Bess. 1991. Calcium Supplementation and Bone Loss: A Review of Controlled Clinical Trials.American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 54 (Suppl.): 274S-280S (review of 66 studies).
Dwyer, Johanna T. 1991. Nutritional Consequences of Vegetarianism.Annual Reviews in Nutrition 11: 61–91 (review of 135 studies).
George, Kathryn Paxton. 1990. So Animal a Human,.. Or the Moral Relevance of Being an Omnivore.Journal of Agricultural Ethics 1: 175–192.
—. 1992. The Use and Abuse of Scienctific Studies.Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 5: 217–233.
—. 1994. Should Feminists Be Vegetarians?Signs: Journal of Women and Culture 19: 405–434.
Herbert, Victor. 1980.Nutrition Cultism. Philadelphia, PA: George F. Stickley Co.
—. 1984. Vitamin B-12. InNutrition Reviews' Present Knowledge in Nutrition, 5th ed. Washington, DC: The Nutrition Foundation, Inc. (76 sources). pp. 347–364.
—. 1988. Vitamin B-12: Plant Sources, Requirements, Assay.American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 48: 852–858.
Hercberg, S., and P. Galan. 1989. Biochemical Effects of Iron Deprivation.Acta Paediatrica Scandinavica 361 (Suppl.): 63–70 (review of 45 sources).
Kozol, Jonathan. 1988.Rachel and Her Children: Homeless Families in America. New York, NY: Grown.
Matkovic, Velimir K., K. Kostial, I. Simonovic, R. Buzina, A. Broderac, and B. E. C. Nordin. 1979. Bone Status and Fracture Rates in Two Regions of Yugoslavia.American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 32: 540–549.
McDonald, Janet T. 1986. Vitamin and Mineral Supplement Use in the United States.Clinical Nutrition 5: 27–33 (review of 57 studies).
Munro, Hamish N., Paulo M. Suter, and Robert M. Russell. 1987. Nutritional Requirements of the Elderly.Annual Reviews in Nutrition 7: 23–49 (review of 171 sources).
Parks, Y. A., and B. A. Wharton. 1989. Iron Deficiency and the Brain.Acta Paediatrica Scandinavica 361 (Suppl.): 71–77 (review of 25 sources).
Peacock, Munro. 1991. Calcium Absorption Efficiency and Calcium Requirements in Children and Adolescents.American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 54 (Suppl.): 261S-265S (review of 40 studies).
Pluhar, Evelyn. 1992. Who Can Be Morally Obligated to Be a Vegetarian?”Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 5: 189–216.
Pollitzer, William S., and John J. B. Anderson. 1989. Ethnic and Genetic Differences in Bone Mass: A Review with a Hereditary vs. Environmental Perspective.American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 50: 1244–1259 (review of 90 sources).
Rawls, John. 1971.A Theory of Justice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Regan, Tom. 1983.The Case for Animal Rights. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Robertson, Laurel, Carol Flinders, and Brian Ruppenthal. 1986.The New Laurel's Kitchen. Berkeley, CA: Ten Speed Press.
Rodysill, Kirk J. 1987. Postmenopausal Osteoporosis—Intervention and Prophylaxis. A Review.Journal of Chronic Diseases 40(8):743–760 (review of 178 sources).
Sandler, Rivka Black, Charles W. Slemenda, Ronald E. LaPorte, Jane A. Cauley, Margaret M. Schramm, Mary Lynn Barresi, and Andrea M. Kriska. 1985. Postmenopausal Bone Density and Milk Consumption in Childhood and Adolescence.American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 42: 270–274.
Scrimshaw, Nevin S. 1991. Iron Deficiency.Scientific American (October): 46–52.
Sharma, D. C., V. Pendse, K. Sahay, and B. L. Soni. 1991. The Changing Pattern of Maternal and Neonatal Anaemia at Udaipur during Two Decades in Relation to Poverty, Parity, Prematurity, and Vegetarianism.Asia Oceania Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 17: 13–17.
Singer, Peter. 1975.Animal Liberation. New York, NY: Avon.
Soysa, Priyani. 1987. Women and Nutrition.World Review of Nutrition and Dietetics 52: 1–70 (review of 54 sources).
United Nations. 1991.1990 Demographic Yearbook (Annuaire Demographique). New York, NY: United Nations, Department of International Economic and Social Affairs, Statistical Office.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
George, K.P. Discrimination and bias in the vegan ideal. J Agric Environ Ethics 7, 19–28 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01997221
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01997221