Abstract
We further develop a recent new proof (by Greenberger, Horne, and Zeilinger—GHZ) that local deterministic hidden-variable theories are inconsistent with certain strict correlations predicted by quantum mechanics. First, we generalize GHZ's proof so that it applies to factorable stochastic theories, theories in which apparatus hidden variables are causally relevant to measurement results, and theories in which the hidden variables evolve indeterministically prior to the particle-apparatus interactions. Then we adopt a more general measure-theoretic approach which requires that GHZ's argument be modified in order to produce a valid proof. Finally, we motivate our more general proof's assumptions in a somewhat different way from previous authors in order to strengthen the implications of our proof as much as possible. After developing GHZ's proof along these lines, we then consider the analogue, for our proof, of Bohr's reply to the EPR argument, and conclude (pace GHZ) that in at least one respect (viz. that of most concern to Bohr) the proof is no more powerful than Bell's. Nevertheless, we point out some new advantages of our proof over Bell's, and over other algebraic proofs of nonlocality. And we conclude by giving a modified version of our proof that, like Bell's, does not rely on experimentally unrealizable strict correlations, but still leads to a testable “quasi-algebraic” locality inequality.
“... to admit things not visible to the gross creatures that we are is, in my opinion, to show a decent humility, and not just a lamentable addiction to metaphysics.”
J. S. Bell
Similar content being viewed by others
References
J. S. Bell,Speakable and Unspeakable in Quantum Mechanics (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1987).
D. M. Greenberger, M. Horne, and A. Zeilinger, inBell's Theorem, Quantum Theory, and Conceptions of the Universe, M. Kafatos, ed. (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, 1989), p. 69.
N. F. Mott and H. S. W. Massey,The Theory of Atomic Collisions (Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1965), p. 214.
N. D. Mermin, “What's wrong with these elements of reality?”Phys. Today June, 1990; “Quantum mysteries revisited,”Am. J. Phys., forthcoming (1990).
D. M. Greenberger, M. A. Horne, A. Shimony, and A. Zeilinger, “Bell's theorem without inequalities,”Am. J. Phys., forthcoming (1990).
R. von Mises,Mathematical Theory of Probability and Statistics (Academic Press, London, 1964), p. 599.
A. Einstein, B. Podolsky, and N. Rosen,Phys. Rev. 47, 777 (1935).
P. Suppes and M. Zanotti, inLogic and Probability in Quantum Mechanics, P. Suppes, ed. (Reidel, Dordrecht, 1976), p. 445.
L. Wessels,Philos. Stud. 40, 3 (1981).
B. Skyrms,Philos. Sci. 49, 43 (1982).
M. L. G. Redhead,Incompleteness, NonLocality, and Realism (Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1987), Chap. 3.
G. Hellman,Philos. Sci. 54, 558 (1987).
J. N. Butterfield, inPSA 1990, Vol. I, A. Fine, M. Forbes, and L. Wessels, eds. (Philosophy of Science Association, East Lansing, 1990), p. 213.
D. Murdoch,Niels Bohr's Philosophy of Physics (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1987).
H. J. Folse, inPhilosophical Consequences of Quantum Theory, J. T. Cushing and E. McMullin, eds. (Notre Dame University Press, Notre Dame, 1989), p. 254.
A. Shimony,Dialectica 39, 107 (1985).
J. Earman, inKelvin's Baltimore Lectures and Modern Theoretical Physics, R. W. Kargon and P. Achinstein, eds. (MIT press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1987), p. 464.
Cf. A. I. Miller (ed.),Sixty-Two Years of Uncertainty (Proceedings of the Erice 1989 Summer School) (Plenum, New York, 1990), and references therein.
B. S. DeWitt and N. Graham, eds.The Many-Worlds Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics (Princeton University Press, Princeton, 1973).
J. T. Cushing and E. McMullin, eds.Philosophical Consequences of Quantum Theory—Reflections on Bell's Theorem (Notre Dame University Press, Notre Dame, 1989).
F. J. Belinfante,A Survey of Hidden-Variables Theories (Pergamon, Oxford, 1973), Pt. II, Chap. 2; C. Dewdney, P. R. Holland, A. Kyprianidis, and J. P. Vigier,Nature (London)336, 536 (1988).
D. Howard, inPhilosophical Consequences of Quantum Theory, J. T. Cushing and E. McMullin, eds. (Notre Dame University Press, Notre Dame, 1989), p. 224.
J. P. Jarrett,Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 480, 428 (1986).
B. d'Espagnat,Phys. Rep. 110, 201 (1984).
J. P. Jarrett,Noûs 18, 569 (1984).
B. C. van Fraassen,The Scientific Image (Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1980), p. 26.
W. Salmon,Scientific Explanation and the Causal Structure of the World (Princeton University Press, Princeton, 1984), p. 168.
J. N. Butterfield, inPhilosophical Consequences of Quantum Theory, J. T. Cushing and E. McMullin, eds. (Notre Dame University Press, Notre Dame, 1989), p. 114.
A. Shimony, M. A. Horne, and J. F. Clauser,Dialectica 39, 98 (1985).
J. S. Bell,Dialectica 39, 103 (1985).
G. Hellman,Synthese 53, 461 (1982).
F. M. Kronz, “Hidden locality, conspiracy, and superluminal signals,”Philos. Sci. 57, 420 (1990).
A. Shimony, inProceedings of the International Symposium: Foundations of Quantum Mechanics in the Light of New Technology, S. Kamefuchiet al., eds. (Physical Society of Japan, Tokyo, 1984), p. 225.
A. Shimony, inQuantum Concepts in Space and Time, R. Penrose and C. J. Isham, eds. (Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1986), p. 182; inPhilosophical Consequences of Quantum Theory, J. T. Cushing and E. McMullin, eds. (Notre Dame University Press, Notre Dame, 1989), p. 25; “Physical and philosophical issues in the Bohr-Einstein debate,” preprint (1989).
A. Fine and P. Teller,Found. Phys. 8, 629 (1977); M. L. G. Redhead,Philos. Sci. 48, 50 (1981).
S. Kochen and E. Specker,J. Math. Mech. 17, 59 (1967).
P. Heywood and M. L. G. Redhead,Found. Phys. 13, 481 (1983).
H. Krips,The Metaphysics of Quantum Theory (Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1987), Chap. 9.
M. J. Maczynski,Rep. Math. Phys. 2, 135 (1971); J. Bub,Found. Phys. 6, 511 (1976); and the articles of Demopoulos, Bub, and Humphreys, inStudies in the Foundations of Quantum Mechanics (Philosophy of Science Association, East Lansing, MI, 1980).
B. C. van Fraassen, inContemporary Research in the Foundations and Philosophy of Quantum Theory, C. A. Hooker, ed. (D. Reidel, Dordrecht, 1973), p. 80.
A. Elby,Found. Phys. Lett. 3, 239 (1990).
A. Stairs,Philos. Sci. 50, 578 (1983).
H. Brown and G. Svetlichny, “The quasi-algebraic proof of nonlocality in quantum mechanics, Part I: Nonstochastic theories,”Found. Phys. 20, 1379 (1990).
A. Elby, “The quasi-algebraic proof of nonlocality in quantum mechanics, Part II: Stochastic theories,”Found. Phys. 20, 1389 (1990).
N. Bohr,Phys. Rev. 48, 696 (1935).
N. Bohr,Nature (London) 136, 65 (1935).
P. Roussel,Microphysical Reality and Quantum Formalism, Vol. II, A. van der Merwe, F. Selleri, and G. Tarozzi, eds. (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, 1988), p. 421.
J. F. Clauser and A. Shimony,Rep. Prog. Phys. 41, 1881 (1978).
I. Pitowsky,Quantum Probability-Quantum Logic (Springer, Berlin, 1989), Chap. 2.
S. L. Braunstein and C. M. Caves,Nucl. Phys. 6B, 211 (1989).
M. Jammer,The Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics (Wiley, New York, 1974), p. 324. (The proof is due to R. Friedberg.)
I. Pitowsky,Philos. Sci. 49, 380 (1982).
E. de Obaldia, A. Shimony, and F. Wittel,Found. Phys. 18, 1013 (1988).
A. Peres and A. Ron, inMicrophysical Reality and Quantum Formalism, Vol. II, A. van der Merwe, F. Selleri, and G. Tarozzi, eds. (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, 1988), p. 115.
R. W. Latzer,Synthese 29, 331 (1974).
A. Elby, “A Kochen-Specker proof that stochastic, local realistic theories violate rotational invariance,” submitted toSynthese (1990).
R. K. Clifton, “Strengthening Elby's dilemma,” submitted toSynthese (1990).
J. F. Clauser and M. A. Horne,Phys. Rev. D 10, 526 (1974).
F. Selleri, ed.,Quantum Mechanics versus Local Realism: The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Paradox (Plenum, New York, 1988).
H. P. Stapp,Found. Phys. 10, 767 (1980).
A. Fine,J. Math. Phys. 23, 1306 (1982).
J. N. Butterfield, “Bell's Theorem: What It Takes,”Br. J. Philos. Sci., forthcoming (1990).
A. Fine,The Shaky Game: Einstein, Realism, and the Quantum Theory (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1986), Chap. 4.
G. Svetlichny, M. L. G. Redhead, H. Brown, and J. N. Butterfield,Philos. Sci. 55, 387 (1988).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
This paper is dedicated to the memory of John Bell whose brilliant work has done so much to clarify the foundations of quantum mechanics.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Clifton, R.K., Redhead, M.L.G. & Butterfield, J.N. Generalization of the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger algebraic proof of nonlocality. Found Phys 21, 149–184 (1991). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01889530
Received:
Revised:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01889530