Abstract
The relationship between agriculture and nature is a central issue in the current agricultural debate. Organic Farming has ambitions and a special potential in relation to nature. Consideration for nature is part of the guiding principals of organic farming and many organic farmers are committed to protecting natural qualities. However, the issue of nature, landscape, and land use is not straightforward. Nature is an ambiguous concept that involves multiple interests and actors reaching far beyond farmers. The Danish research project Nature Quality in Organic Farming has investigated the relationship between nature and organic farming. This article will focus on an expert workshop held in connection with the project that investigates the way different actors conceptualize nature. Farmers, scientists, and non-governmental organizations came together to discuss their experiences of nature and expectations of organic agriculture. From this interaction, it was clear that nature is a contested notion. Different understandings of nature exist within the three groups and there is disagreement as to whether emphasis should be given to biological qualities, production values, or experiential and aesthetic perspectives. This complexity provides a challenge to organic farming as well as to the implementation of nature considerations in general. It illustrates an underlying battle for the right to define nature and nature quality and essentially decide what organic farmers should work towards. We argue that successful implementation requires organic farmers to carefully consider what expectations they wish to meet. Optimally it is dependent on a dialog between stakeholder interest groups that allows for multivocality and pluralism.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Danish Plant Directorate (2004), Statistik over økologiske jordbrugsbedrifter 2003 (Statistics for Organic Farms 2003) [Online at www.pdir.dk/Files/Filer/Oekologi/Statistik/03/Statistik_2003.pdf] Accessed February 17, 2005
DARCOF, Nature Quality in Organic Farming [Online at www.darcof.dk/research/darcofii/iii5.html] Accessed February 25, 2005
European Commission, CAP reform – a long-term perspective for sustainable agriculture, [Online at http://europa.eu.int/comm/agriculture/capreform/index_en.htm] Accessed February 17, 2005
M. Foucault (1971) L’Ordre du discours (Orders of Discourse) Gallimard Paris
L. Hansen (2004) ArticleTitle“Hvordan står det til med arbejdsmiljøet på de økologiske landbrug?” (How is the Working Environment on Organic Farms?)” Forskningsnytt om økologisk landbruk i Norden 1 19–21
Hansen L., E. Noe, and K. Højring (2004a), “Landscape and Nature Quality in the Development and Profiling of Organic Farming,” DARCOFenews 4. Newsletter from Danish Research Centre for Organic Farming [Online at www.darcof.dk/enews/dec04/index.html] Accessed February 17, 2005
Hansen, L., E. Noe, V. Langer, R. Ejrnæs, K. Tybirk, and M. B. Pedersen, Landmænds opfattelser af natur og aktuel naturkvalitet på bedriften. Cross cutting rapport for CC3 (Farmers’ Perceptions of Nature and Actual Nature Quality on the Farm. Cross Cutting Report for CC3) [Online at www.orgprints.org/00003921/] Accessed February 18, 2005
D. Heede (2002) Det tomme menneske, Introduktion til Michel Foucault (The Empty Individual. Introduction to Michel Foucault) Museum Tusculanums Forlag Copenhagen
J. A. Holstein J. F. Gubrium (1995) The Active Interview Sage Publications London
Højring, K. (2004), Æstetisk sansning og naturvidenskabelig naturforståelse – Et eksplorativt eksperiment (Aesthetic Sensation and Natural Scientific Perception of Nature—An Explorative Experiment) Working report 4, Danish Centre for Forest, Landscape and Planning, Hørsholm
Højring, K., L. Hansen, and E. Noe, “Organic Farming – Nature Conceptions, Management and Cross Compliance,” DARCOFenews 2 (2004). Newsletter from Danish Research Centre for Organic Farming [Online at www.darcof.dk/enews/june04/index.html] Accessed February 17, 2005
Højring K. and E. Noe (2004). “Communicative Approaches to Involving Farmers in Protecting Aesthetic and Biological Landscape Quality,” Proceeding at IRSA XI World Congress of Rural Sociology, Trondheim, Norway.
IFOAM, The Principals of Organic Agriculture [Online at www.ifoam.org] Accessed February 17, 2005
Ilsøe, D. (2004), “Organic Foods in Denmark – Between Conventionalisation and Change in Food Culture,” Proceeding at IRSA XI World Congress of Rural Sociology, Trondheim, Norway
Jensen, K. O’Doherty, H. N. Larsen, J. P. Mølgaard, J. Andersen, A. Tingstad, P. Marckmann, and A. Astrup (2001) Økologiske fødevarer og menneskets sundhed (Organic Food and Human Health). DARCOF report 14, Danish Research Centre for Organic Farming
Jessel, B. (2001), Ökologischer Landbau als Ausgleichsmaßnahme (Organic Farming as an Equilisation Measure). Garten+Landschaft, 8, pp. 12--15
Kaltoft, P. and M. Risgaard (2004), “Has Organic Farming Modernised Itself out of Business? An analysis of Reverting Organic Farmers,” Proceeding at IRSA XI World Congress of Rural Sociology, Trondheim, Norway
K. Milton (2002) Loving Nature. Towards an Ecology of Emotion Routledge London and New York
K. Milton (1996) Environmentalism and Cultural Theory. Exploring the Role of Anthropology in Environmental Discourse Routledge London and New York
Noe, E., N. Halberg, and J. Reddersen (2005), “Indicators of Biodiversity and Conservational Wildlife Quality on Danish Organic Farms for Use in Farm Management. A Multidisciplinary Approach to Indicator Development and Testing,” Journal of Agriculture and Environmental Ethics 18.
H. Siipi (2004) ArticleTitle“Naturalness in Biological Conservation” Journal of Agriculture and Environmental Ethics 17 457–477
Tybirk, K. and R. Ejrnæs (2001), “Økologisk jordbrugs bidrag til naturbevarelse” (The Contribution of Organic Farming to Nature Conservation), in K. Tybirk and H. F. Alrøe (eds.), Naturkvalitet i økologisk jordbrug (Nature Quality in Organic Farming). DARCOF report 9, Danish Research Centre for Organic Farming, pp. 37–54
K. Tybirk H. F. Alrøe P. Frederiksen (2004) ArticleTitle“Nature Quality in Organic Farming: A Conceptual Analysis of Considerations and Criteria in a European Context” Journal of Agriculture and Environmental Ethics 17 249–274
H. Verhoog M. Matze E. Lammerts Van Bueren T. Baars (2003) ArticleTitle“The Role of the Concept of the Natural (Naturalness) in Organic Farming” Journal of Agriculture and Environmental Ethics 16 29–49
G. A. Wilson (2001) ArticleTitle“From Productivism to Post-productivism... and Back Again? Exploring the (un)changed natural and mental landscapes of European Agriculture” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 26 IssueID1 77–102 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1475-5661.00007
Økologisk Landsforening (2002). Værdigrundlag for økologisk Jordbrug (Principles for Organic Farming). [Online at http://www.okoland.dk] Accessed February 17, 2005
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hansen, L., Noe, E. & Højring, K. Nature and Nature Values in Organic Agriculture. An Analysis of Contested Concepts and Values Among Different Actors in Organic Farming. J Agric Environ Ethics 19, 147–168 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-005-1804-y
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-005-1804-y