Abstract
This paper elaborates on the following correspondence theorem (which has been defended and formally proved elsewhere): if theory T has been empirically successful in a domain of applications A, but was superseded later on by a different theory T* which was likewise successful in A, then under natural conditions T contains theoretical expressions \({\varphi}\) which were responsible for T’s success and correspond (in A) to certain theoretical expressions \({\varphi}^{*}\) of T*. I illustrate this theorem at hand of the phlogiston versus oxygen theories of combustion, and the classical versus relativistic theories of mass. The ontological consequences of the theorem are worked out in terms of the indirect reference and partial truth. The final section explains how the correspondence theorem may justify a weak version of scientific realism without presupposing the no-miracles argument.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Boyd R. (1984) The current ctatus of scientific realism. In: Leplin J. (eds) Scientific realism. University of California Press, Berkeley, pp 41–82
Carrier M. (2004) Experimental success and the revelation of reality: The miracle argument for scientific realism. In: Carrier M. et al (eds) Knowledge and the world: Challenges beyond the science wars. Springer, Heidelberg, pp 137–161
Carrier M. (2006) Antoine L. Lavoisier und die Chemische Revolution. In: Leich P. (eds) Leitlinien naturwissenschaftlichen Denkens. Duisburg, Königshausen & Neumann
Field H. (1973) Theory change and the indeterminacy of reference. Journal of Philosophy 70: 462–481
Earman J. (1977) Against indeterminacy. Journal of Philosophy 74: 535–538
Hacking I. (1983) Representing and intervening. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Ladyman J. (1998) What is structural realism?. Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science, 29(3): 409–424
Laudan, L. (1981). A confutation of convergent realism (Reprinted in The philosophy of science, pp. 107–138, by D. Papineau, Ed., Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Oxtoby D. et al (1999) Principles of modern chemistry. Saunders College Publishing, Orlando
McCann H.G. (1978) Chemistry transformed: The paradigm shift from phlogiston to oxygen. Ablex Publ. Corporation, Norwood, NJ
Psillos S. (1995) Is structural realism the best of both worlds?. Dialectica, 49(1): 15–46
Putnam, H. (Ed.). (1975). What is mathematical truth? In Mathematics, matter and method (pp. 60–78). Cambridge University Press: Cambriddge.
Schurz G. (2008) Patterns of abduction. Synthese, 164: 201–234
Schurz G. (2009) When empirical success implies theoretical reference: A structural correspondence theorem. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 60(1): 101–133
Worrall J. (1989) Structural realism: The best of both worlds. Dialectica 43(1–2): 99–124
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Schurz, G. Structural correspondence, indirect reference, and partial truth: phlogiston theory and Newtonian mechanics. Synthese 180, 103–120 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-009-9608-7
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-009-9608-7