Abstract
In many experimental sciences, like particle physics or molecular biology, the proper place for establishing facts is the laboratory. In the sciences of population biology, however, the laboratory is often seen as a poor approximation of what occurs in nature. Results obtained in the field are usually more convincing. This raises special problems: it is much more difficult to obtain stable, repeatable results in the field, where environmental conditions vary out of the experimenter’s control, than in the laboratory. We examine here how this problem affected an influential experimental research tradition in community ecology, the study of the ecology of the rocky seashores. In the 1960s, a handful of North-American ecologists, most notably Joseph Connell, Robert Paine and Paul Dayton, made the rocky seashores a model study system for experimenting in the field. Their experiments were deceptively simple: they removed species living on the seashore and described the resulting effects on the local ecology. These experiments exerted a deep influence on community ecology. They provided evidence for speculative developments concerning the theory of interspecific competition, the factors responsible for species richness and the ecology of food webs. They also stimulated novel conceptual developments. In particular, Paine developed the predation hypothesis, which states that the presence of predators can favour species richness, before introducing the keystone species concept, according to which some species exert disproportionate effects on ecological systems. More broadly, these experiments gave support to a methodological trend in favour of field experimentation. Only controlled perturbations in the field, it seemed, provided a reliable method to get insights into the structure of ecological communities. However, as experiments were continued in time and repeated in different sites, divergent results appeared. We analyse here how intertidal researchers coped with the variability of environmental conditions and tried to stabilize their results. In the process, they reconsidered not only their early conclusions, but also the exclusive status given to field experiments. Expanding on this case study, we discuss some significant differences between laboratory and field experiments.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Andrewartha, H. G., & Birch, L. C. (1954). The distribution and abundance of animals. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Benson, K. R. (2002). The study of vertical zonation on rocky intertidal shores—A historical perspective. Integrative and Comparative Biology, 42(4), 776–779.
Benson, K. R. (2015). Marine biology, intertidal ecology, and a new place for biology. History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences, 36(3), 312–320.
Brandon, R. N. (1994). Theory and experiment in evolutionary biology. Synthese, 99(1), 59–73.
Connell, J. H. (1954). Home range and mobility of brush rabbits in California chaparral. Journal of Mammalogy, 35(3), 392–405.
Connell, J. H. (1961a). Effect of competition, predation by Thais lapillus, and other factors on natural populations of the barnacle Balanus balanoides. Ecological Monographs, 31, 61–104.
Connell, J. H. (1961b). The influence of interspecific competition and other factors on the distribution of the barnacle Chthamalus stellatus. Ecology, 42, 710–723.
Connell, J.H. (1963). Final Report to the Office of Naval Research, 6 February 1963, ‘Studies on the population dynamics of barnacles and their associates’. Defense Technical Information Center. http://www.dtic.mil/docs/citations/AD0401697). Accessed 27 July 2018.
Connell, J. H. (1970). A predator-prey system in the marine intertidal region. I. Balanus glandula and several predatory species of Thais. Ecological Monographs, 40(1), 49–78.
Connell, J. H. (1972). Community interactions on marine rocky intertidal shores. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 3, 169–192.
Connell, J. H. (1974). Field experiments in marine ecology. In R. N. Mariscal (Ed.), Experimental marine biology (pp. 21–54). New York: Academic Press.
Connell, J. H. (1975). Some mechanisms producing structure in natural communities: A model and evidence from field experiments. In M. L. Cody & J. M. Diamond (Eds.), Ecology and evolution of communities (pp. 460–490). Cambridge, MS: Harvard University Press.
Connell, J. H. (1980). Diversity and the coevolution of competitors, or the ghost of competition past. Oikos, 35(2), 131–138.
Connell, J. H. (1981). This week’s citation classic. Current Contents, 21, 149.
Connell, J. H. (1983). On the prevalence and relative importance of interspecific competition: evidence from field experiments. American Naturalist, 122(5), 661–696.
Connell, J. H. (1992). The profound effect of a pioneer French ecologist. Current Contents, 15, 8.
Connell, J. H., & Orias, E. (1964). The ecological regulation of species diversity. The American Naturalist, 98(903), 399–414.
Cooper, G. (1993). The competition controversy in community ecology. Biology and Philosophy, 8(4), 359–384.
Cramer, N. F., & May, R. M. (1972). Interspecific competition, predation and species diversity: A comment. Journal of Theoretical Biology, 34(2), 289–293.
Dayton, P. K. (1971). Competition, disturbance, and community organization: The provision and subsequent utilization of space in a rocky intertidal community. Ecological Monographs, 41, 351–389.
Dayton, P. K. (1973). Two cases of resource partitioning in an intertidal community: Making the right prediction for the wrong reason. The American Naturalist, 107(957), 662–670.
Dayton, P. K. (1979). Ecology: A science and a religion. In R. J. Livingston (Ed.), Ecological processes in coastal and marine systems (pp. 3–11). New York: Plenum Press.
Dayton, P. K. (2013). Interview with Peter Brueggeman, 18 January 2013. Scripps Institution of Oceanography Archives. http://libraries.ucsd.edu/speccoll/siooralhistories/2013-17-PaulDayton.pdf. Accessed 27 July 2018.
Demerec, M. (Ed.). (1957). Cold Spring Harbor Symposium on quantitative biology (Vol. 22). The Biological Laboratories: Cold Spring Harbor.
Deevey, E. S. (1947). Life tables for natural populations of animals. The Quarterly Review of Biology, 22(4), 283–314.
Dritschilo, W. (2008). Bringing statistical methods to community and evolutionary ecology: Daniel S. Simberloff. In O. Harman & M. Dietrich (Eds.), Rebels, mavericks, and heretics in biology (p. 356). New Haven: Yale University Press.
Elton, C. (1966). The pattern of animal communities. London: Methuen, Chapman and Hall.
Elton, C. S. (1927). Animal Ecology. London: Sidgwick & Jackson.
Elton, C. S. (1946). Competition and the structure of ecological communities. The Journal of Animal Ecology, 15(1), 54–68.
Fogg, G. E., & Southward, A. J. (1992). Dennis John Crisp. 29 April 1916–18 January 1990. Biographical memoirs of fellows of the Royal Society, 38, 113-129.
Gibb, J. (1954). Feeding ecology of tits, with notes on treecreeper and goldcrest. Ibis, 96, 513–543.
Hurlbert, S. H. (1984). Pseudoreplication and the design of ecological field experiments. Ecological Monographs, 54(2), 187–211.
Hutchinson, G. E. (1957). Concluding remarks. In M. Demerec (Ed.), Cold Spring Harbor symposium on quantitative biology (pp. 415–427). The Biological Laboratories: Cold Spring Harbor.
Hutchinson, G. E. (1959). Homage to Santa Rosalia or why are there so many kinds of animals? The American Naturalist, 93(870), 145–159.
Janzen, D. H. (1966). Coevolution of mutualism between ants and acacias in Central America. Evolution, 20(3), 249–275.
Kingsland, S. E. (1995). Modeling nature. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Kingsland, S. (2009). Frits Went’s atomic age greenhouse: The changing landscape on the lab-field border. Journal of the History of Biology, 42, 289–324.
Klopfer, P. H., & MacArthur, R. H. (1961). On the causes of tropical species diversity: Niche overlap. The American Naturalist, 95(883), 223–226.
Kohler, R. E. (2002). Landscapes and labscapes—Exploring the lab-field border in biology. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Lack, D. (1946). Competition for food by birds of prey. The Journal of Animal Ecology, 15(2), 123–129.
Levin, S. A., & Paine, R. T. (1974). Disturbance, patch formation, and community structure. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 71(7), 2744–2747.
MacArthur, R. (1955). Fluctuations of animal populations and a measure of community stability. Ecology, 36(3), 533–536.
MacArthur, R. H., & Connell, J. H. (1966). The biology of populations. New York: Wiley.
MacArthur, R. H., & Levins, R. (1964). Competition, habitat selection, and character displacement in a patchy environment. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 51(6), 1207–1210.
MacArthur, R. H., & Levins, R. (1967). The limiting similarity, convergence, and divergence of coexisting species. The American Naturalist, 101(921), 377–385.
MacArthur, R. H., & Wilson, E. O. (1967). The Theory of Island Biogeography. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Miller, R. S. (1964). Ecology and distribution of pocket gophers (Geomyidae) in Colorado. Ecology, 45(2), 256–272.
Paine, R. T. (1963a). Ecology of the brachiopod Glottidia pyramidata. Ecological Monographs, 33(3), 187–213.
Paine, R. T. (1963b). Trophic relationships of 8 sympatric predatory gastropods. Ecology, 44(1), 63–73.
Paine, R. T. (1966). Food web complexity and species diversity. The American Naturalist, 100(910), 65–75.
Paine, R. T. (1969). A note on trophic complexity and community stability. The American Naturalist, 103(929), 91–93.
Paine, R. T. (1971). A short-term experimental investigation of resource partitioning in a New Zealand rocky intertidal habitat. Ecology, 52(6), 1096–1106.
Paine, R. T. (1974). Intertidal comm1977unity structure. Experimental Studies on the Relationship between a Dominant Competitor and Its Principal Predator. Oecologia, 15(2), 93–120.
Paine, R. T. (1977). Controlled manipulations in the marine intertidal zone, and their contributions to ecological theory. In C. E. Goulden (Ed.), The changing scenes in natural science 1776–1976 (pp. 245–270). Philadelphia: Academy of Natural Sciences.
Paine, R. T. (1984). Ecological determinism in the competition for space: The Robert H. MacArthur Award Lecture. Ecology, 65(5), 1339–1348.
Paine, R. T. (1989). Complex interactions in lake communities: Book review. Limnology and Oceanography, 34(2), 486–487.
Paine, R. T. (2010). Macroecology: Does it ignore or can it encourage further ecological syntheses based on spatially local experimental manipulations? (American Society of Naturalists Address). The American Naturalist, 176(4), 385–393.
Paine, R. T. (2012). Robert Paine Interview by Douglas Sprugel, 30 July 2012. Ecological Society of America Oral History Collection, Richard B. Russell Library for Political Research and Studies, University of Georgia Libraries, Athens, Georgia, 30602–1641.
Paine, R. T., & Levin, S. A. (1981). Intertidal landscapes: Disturbance and the dynamics of pattern. Ecological Monographs, 51(2), 145–178.
Paine, R. T., & Vadas, R. L. (1969). The effects of grazing by sea urchins, Strongylocentrotus spp., on benthic algal populations. Limnology and Oceanography, 14(5), 710–719.
Paine, R. T., Wootton, J. T., & Pfister, C. A. (2010). A sense of place—Tatoosh. In I. Billick & M. V. Price (Eds.), The ecology of place: contributions of place-based research to ecological understanding (pp. 229–250). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Parrish, J. D., & Saila, S. B. (1970). Interspecific competition, predation and species diversity. Journal of Theoretical Biology, 27(2), 207–220.
Platt, J. R. (1964). Strong inference. Science, 146(3642), 347–353.
Sapp, J. (2003). What is natural?: Coral reef crisis. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Simberloff, D. S., & Wilson, E. O. (1969). Experimental zoogeography of islands: the colonization of empty islands. Ecology, 50(2), 278–296.
Underwood, A. J., & Denley, E. J. (1984). Paradigms, explanations and generalizations in models for the structure of intertidal communities on rocky shores. In D. R. Strong, D. Simberloff, L. G. Abele, & A. Thistle (Eds.), Ecological communities: Conceptual issues and the evidence (pp. 151–180). New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
Vetter, J. (2012). Labs in the field? Rocky Mountain biological stations in the early twentieth century. Journal of the History of Biology, 45(4), 1–25.
Yong, E. (2013). Dynasty—Bob Paine fathered an idea—And an academic family—That changed ecology. Nature, 493, 286–289.
Acknowledgements
For communicating documents having helped us in this research, we thank Keith Benson, Peter G. Fairweather, Kyle Harms, Dennis H. Knight, P. G. Moore and Doug Sprugel. We are particularly grateful to Paul Dayton and Anne Paine for sharing and allowing us to quote archival materials. Chloe Ashley, Paul Dayton, P. G. Moore, Staffan Müller-Wille, Dan Reed and three anonymous reviewers made very helpful comments on the manuscript.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Grodwohl, JB., Porto, F. & El-Hani, C.N. The instability of field experiments: building an experimental research tradition on the rocky seashores (1950–1985). HPLS 40, 45 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40656-018-0209-y
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40656-018-0209-y