Abstract
In this paper, the author reconsiders “motherhood” in Japan. This reconsideration is based on Japanese psychoanalytic knowledge and a case study of a woman. As a child she was physically abused by her father, and struggled throughout her life with conflicts with her mother. The Japanese have historically idealized the concept of “motherhood” and maintained that it was possible for women to become the ideal mother for their children. The author maintains that “motherhood” is not dependent only on mothers, but is created and shared by fathers, children and all of society. In psychotherapy, the therapist provides a “motherly” energy to the client and shares the “motherhood” fantasy with the client to a certain extent. The therapist assists the client in the gradual process of abandoning the desire to be loved by the ideal mother and accept “motherhood” from other sources.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Doi, L. T. (1971). Amae no Kozo. Tokyo: Kobundo (in Japanese) (translated by Bester, J. (1973). The anatomy of dependence. Tokyo: Kodansha International Ltd.).
C. Fukatsu (2001) The conflicts of “Idaike” seen in the mothers with child raring difficulties K. Okonogi O. Kitayama (Eds) The ajase complex Sogensya Osaka 250–267
S. Fukuto (1991) Mothers and children in heian era Chuo-Koronsha Tokyo
Y. Hashimoto (2000) Psychotherapy for mothers Nippon Hyoronsya Tokyo
T. Kataoka (1993) The women in yotsuya kaidan Syogakkann Tokyo
H. Kawai (1975) “Puer aeternus”in Japan as a motherly community H. Kawai (Eds) Psychopathology in Japan as a motherly community Chuo-Koronsya Tokyo 8–34
H. Kawai (1982) The folk tales and the Japanese psychology Iwanami-syoten Tokyo
Kida, K. (1977). On “two kinds of guilty feelings” by Heisaku Kosawa. In A. Yoda & K. Ogawa (Eds.), Mothers: A flood and loss of motherhood. L’Esprit D’Aujourd’Hui, No. 115. pp. 107--117 (Was this published in French? Please give info) Tokyo: Shibundo, 1997 (in Japanese).
H. Kosawa (1953) On the Story of Ajase K. Okonogi (Eds) Psychoanalysis: After freud L’Esprit D’Aujourd’Hui, No. 148 Shibundo Tokyo 174–175
H. Kosawa (1954) Two kinds of guilt feelings K. Okonogi (Eds) Psychoanalysis: After freud L’Esprit D’Aujourd’Hui, No. 148 Shibundo Tokyo 166–173
S. Maeda (1985) Charts on clinical psychoanalysis Seishin-syobo Tokyo
T. Oda (1993) The falk tales and dream analysis Sogensya Osaka
M. Ohinata (1988) Studies on motherhood Kawashima-Shoten Tokyo
M. Ohinata (1990) Changes in Japanese society and motherhood H. Koshima M. Ohinata (Eds) Motherhood. Human mind, No. 30 Nippon Hyoronsya. Tokyo 85–91
M. Ohinata K. Okonogi O. Kitayama (2001) Ajase and modern motherhood K. Okonogi O. Kitayama (Eds) The ajase complex Sogensya Osaka 383–428
Okonogi, K. (1979a). The original resources and the processes of reconstruction in the Story of Ajase by Kosawa. In K. Okonogi (Ed.), Psychoanalysis after Freud. L’Esprit D’Aujourd’Hui, No.148. pp. (176–182). 1979 (in Japanese).
K. Okonogi (1979b) Ajase and Orestes K. Okonogi (Eds) Psychoanalysis after freud. L’Esprit D’Aujourd’Hui, No.148 Shibundo Tokyo 206–227
K. Okonogi (1979c) Japanese-type Object Relations from the viewpoint of the Ajase complex K. Okonogi (Eds) Psychoanalysis after freud. L’Esprit D’Aujourd’Hui, No.148 Shibundo Tokyo 228–247
K. Okonogi (1978) ArticleTitleThe Ajase complex of the Japanese(1); The depth psychology of the moratorium people. Japan Echo 5 IssueID4 88–105
K. Okonogi (1995) The heritage from Heisaku Kosawa K. Okonogi H. Myogi (Eds) Psychoanalysis Today. L’Esprit D’Aujourd’Hui Shibundo Tokyo 325–342
K. Otsuki (1936) Motherhood and Voluptuousness A. Yoda K. Ogawa (Eds) Mothers: A flood and loss of motherhood L’Esprit D’Aujourd’Hui, No.115 Shibundo Tokyo 187–193
S. Suga (1996) The daughters of “Puer aeternus” Seiwa-shoten Tokyo
K. Takaishi (1997) The daughters who take care of their mothers Nippon Hyoronsya Tokyo
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Kiyoko Kamibeppu, R.N., Ph.D., Associate Professor, The University of Tokyo, Clinical Psychologist, Japanese Association for Clinical Psychology.
Address correspondence to Kiyoko Kamibeppu, Department of Family Nursing, Faculty of Medicine, Graduate School of Health and Nursing, The University of Tokyo, 7-3-1, Hongo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, Japan; e-mail: kkamibeppu-tky@umin.ac.jp.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kamibeppu, K. Reconsideration of “Motherhood” in Contemporary Japan. Am J Psychoanal 65, 13–29 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11231-004-1815-x
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11231-004-1815-x