Abstract
Much has been written about how effective nature of science instruction must have a significant explicit and reflective character. However, while explicitly drawing students’ attention to NOS issues is crucial, learning and teaching the NOS are essentially matters of conceptual change. In this article, how people learn and learners’ responses to the demands of conceptual change are used to explain how students may exit from instruction with fundamental NOS misconceptions left intact or only slightly altered, despite being explicitly and reflectively attended to more accurate ideas. The purpose of this concept paper is to set within a theoretical framework of learning, and bring some coherence to, what has rapidly become a large body of empirical research regarding effective NOS instruction. Toward these two ends, this article: (1) illustrates how a conceptual change framework can be used to account for learners’ responses to NOS instruction and what teachers might do to promote understanding NOS and transferring it to new contexts; (2) characterizes popularly advocated NOS instructional approaches along a continuum marked by increasing connection to the workings of science, and decreased ability to dismiss NOS lessons as extraneous to authentic science; and (3) proposes that NOS instruction would likely be more effective if teachers deliberately scaffolded classroom experiences and students’ developing NOS understanding back and forth along the continuum.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
F. Abd-El-Khalick (1999) ArticleTitle‘Teaching Science With History’ The Science Teacher 66 IssueID9 18–22
F. Abd-El-Khalick (2001) ArticleTitle‘Embedding Nature of Science Instruction in Preservice Elementary Science Courses: Abandoning Scientism, but ...’ Journal of Science Teacher Education 12 IssueID3 215–233 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1016720417219
F. Abd-El-Khalick R.L. Bell N.G. Lederman (1998) ArticleTitle‘The Nature of Science and Instructional Practice: Making the Unnatural Natural’ Science Education 82 IssueID4 417–436 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1098-237X(199807)82:4<417::AID-SCE1>3.0.CO;2-E
F. Abd-El-Khalick N.G. Lederman (2000a) ArticleTitle‘Improving Science Teachers’ Conceptions of Nature of Science: A Critical Review of the Literature’ International Journal of Science Education 22 IssueID7 665–701
F. Abd-El-Khalick N.G. Lederman (2000b) ArticleTitle‘The Influence of History of Science Courses on Students’ Views of Nature of Science’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 37 IssueID10 1057–1095 Occurrence Handle10.1002/1098-2736(200012)37:10<1057::AID-TEA3>3.0.CO;2-C
V.L. Akerson F. Abd-El-Khalick N.G. Lederman (2000) ArticleTitle‘Influence of a Reflective Explicit Activity- Based Approach on Elementary Teachers’ Conceptions of Nature of Science’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 37 IssueID4 295–317
F. Akindehin (1988) ArticleTitle‘Effect of an Instructional Package on Preservice Science Teachers’ Understanding of the Nature of Science and Acquisition of Science-Related Attitudes’ Science Education 72 IssueID1 73–82
D. Allchin E. Anthony J. Bristol A. Dean D. Hall C. Lieb (1999) ArticleTitle‘History of Science With Labs’ Science & Education 8 IssueID6 619–632
InstitutionalAuthorNameAmerican Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) (1989) Project 2061: Science for All Americans AAAS Washington, DC
InstitutionalAuthorNameAnnenberg/CPB (1997) Minds of Our Own: Can We Believe Our Eyes Math and Science Videotape Collection P.O. Box 2345, South Burlington
K. Appleton (1993) ArticleTitle‘Using Theory to Guide Practice: Teaching Science From a Constructivist Perspective’ School Science and Mathematics 93 IssueID5 269–274
K. Appleton (1997) ArticleTitle‘Analysis and Description of Students’ Learning During Science Classes Using a Constructivist-Based Model’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 34 IssueID3 303–318 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1098-2736(199703)34:3<303::AID-TEA6>3.0.CO;2-W
G. Basalla (1976) ‘Pop Science: The Depiction of Science in Popular Culture’ G. Holton W.A. Blanpied (Eds) Science and its Public: The Changing Relationship Reidel Boston 261–278
Bednarek, D.I.: 1993, ‘Friction: Heat-Loving Bacterium Roils Two Worlds. Business, Academia Spar When Product of Basic Research Proves Practical’, The Milwaukee Journal, May 9.
R.L. Bell N.G. Lederman F. Abd-El-Khalick (2000) ArticleTitle‘Developing and Acting Upon One’s Conception of Science: A Follow-Up Study’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 37 IssueID6 563–581 Occurrence Handle10.1002/1098-2736(200008)37:6<563::AID-TEA4>3.0.CO;2-N
R.L. Bell N.G. Lederman F. Abd-El-Khalick (1998) ArticleTitle‘Implicit Versus Explicit Nature of Science Instruction: An Explicit Response to Palmquist and Finley’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 35 IssueID9 1057–1061 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1098-2736(199811)35:9<1057::AID-TEA6>3.0.CO;2-C
Benson, G.D.: 1984, ‘Teachers’ and Students’ Understandings of Biology’, Doctoral dissertation, University of Alberta, ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED280683.
N.W. Brickhouse Z.R. Dagher W.J. Letts H.L. Shipman (2000) ArticleTitle‘Diversity of Students’ Views About Evidence, Theory, and the Interface Between Science and Religion in an Astronomy Course’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 37 IssueID4 340–362 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1098-2736(200004)37:4<340::AID-TEA4>3.0.CO;2-D
S.G. Brush (1989) ArticleTitle‘History of Science and Science Education’ Interchange 20 IssueID1 60–71
R.W. Bybee J.C. Powell J.D. Ellis J.R. Giese L. Parisi L. Singleton (1991) ArticleTitle‘Integrating the History and Nature of Science and Technology in Science and Social Studies Curriculum’ Science Education 75 IssueID1 143–155
D. Cassidy G. Holton J. Rutherford (2002) Understanding Physics Springer-Verlag New York
M.P. Clough (1997) ArticleTitle‘Strategies and Activities for Initiating and Maintaining Pressure on Students’ Naive Views Concerning the Nature of Science’ Interchange 28 IssueID2–3 191–204
M.P. Clough (1998) ‘Integrating the Nature of Science with Student Teaching: Rationales and Strategies’ W.F. McComas (Eds) The Nature of Science in Science Education: Rationales and Strategies Kluwer Academic Publishers Dordrecht, The Netherlands 197–208
M.P. Clough (2004) ‘The Nature of Science: Understanding How the “Game” of Science is Played’ Weld Jeff (Eds) The Game of Science Education Allyn and Bacon Boston, MA 198–227
Clough, M.P. & Olson, J.K.: 2001, ‘Structure of a Course Promoting Contextualized and Decontextualized Nature of Science Instruction’, Paper presented at the 6th International History, Philosophy & Science Teaching Conference, November 7–11, Denver, CO.
M.P. Clough J.K. Olson (2004) ArticleTitle‘The Nature of Science: Always Part of the Science Story’ The Science Teacher 71 IssueID9 28–31
A. Colburn M.P. Clough (1997) ArticleTitle‘Implementing the Learning Cycle’ The Science Teacher 64 IssueID5 30–33
J.B. Conant (1957) Harvard Case Histories in Experimental Science Harvard University Press Cambridge
Z.R. Dagher (1994) ArticleTitle‘Does the Use of Anaolgies Contribute to Conceptual Change?’ Science Education 78 IssueID6 601–614
G. Boer ParticleDe (1991) A History of Ideas in Science Education: Implications for Practice Teachers College Press New York, NY
S.S. Demastes R.G. Good P. Peebles (1995) ArticleTitle‘Students’ Conceptual Ecologies and the Process of Conceptual Change in Evolution’ Science Education 79 IssueID6 637–666
D.R. Dibbs (1982) An Investigation into the Nature and Consequences of Teachers’ Implicit Philosophies of Science University of Aston Birmingham, UK
R. Driver (1997) In Annenberg/CPB Minds of Our Own Videotape Program One: Can We Believe Our Eyes Math and Science Collection P.O. Box 2345, South Burlington
R. Driver J. Leach R. Millar P. Scott (1996) Young People’s Images of Science Open University Press Buckingham
R.A. Duschl (1985) ArticleTitle‘Science Education and Philosophy of Science: Twenty-five years of Mutually Exclusive Development’ School Science and Mathematics 85 IssueID7 541–555
R.A. Duschl E. Wright (1989) ArticleTitle‘A Case Study of High School Teachers’ Decision Making Models for Planning and Teaching Science’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 26 IssueID6 67–501
J.T. Eflin S. Glennan G. Reisch (1999) ArticleTitle‘The Nature of Science: A Perspective from the Philosophy of Science’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 36 IssueID1 107–117 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1098-2736(199901)36:1<107::AID-TEA7>3.0.CO;2-3
P. Eichman (1996) ArticleTitle‘Using History to Teach Biology’ The American Biology Teacher 58 IssueID4 200–204
Y. Elkana (1970) ArticleTitle‘Science, Philosophy of Science and Science Teaching’ Educational Philosophy and Theory 2 15–35
T. Folger (2003) ArticleTitle‘Nailing Down Gravity: New Ideas About the Most Mysterious Power in the Universe’ Discover 24 IssueID10 34–41
I. Galili V. Bar (1992) ArticleTitle‘Motion Implies Force: Where to Expect Vestiges of the Misconceptions?’ International Journal of Science Education 14 IssueID1 63–81
J. Hagen D. Allchin F. Singer (1996) Doing Biology HarperCollins New York, NY
J.L. Heilbron (2002) ArticleTitle‘History in Science Education, with Cautionary Tales About the Agreement of Measurement and Theory’ Science & Education 11 IssueID4 321–331
E. Howe (2003) Using the History of Research on Sickle-Cell Anemia to Affect Preservice Teachers’ Conceptions of the Nature of Science Western Michigan University Kalamazoo, MI
A.R. Irwin (2000) ArticleTitle‘Historical Case Studies: Teaching the Nature of Science in Context’ Science Education 84 IssueID1 5–26 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1098-237X(200001)84:1<5::AID-SCE2>3.0.CO;2-0
Y.B. Kafai A.J. Gilliland-Swetland (2001) ArticleTitle‘The Use of Historical Materials in Elementary Science Classrooms’ Science Education 85 IssueID4 349–367 Occurrence Handle10.1002/sce.1014
R. Khishfe F. Abd-El-Khalick (2002) ArticleTitle‘Influence of Explicit and Reflective Versus Implicit Inquiry- Oriented Instruction on Sixth Graders’ Views of Nature of Science’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 39 IssueID7 551–578 Occurrence Handle10.1002/tea.10036
B. King (1991) ArticleTitle‘Beginning Teachers’ Knowledge of and Attitude Toward History and Philosophy of Science’ Science Education 75 IssueID1 135–141
L.E. Klopfer (1969) ArticleTitle‘The Teaching of Science and the History of Science’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 6 IssueID1 87–95
L.E. Klopfer W.W. Cooley (1963) ArticleTitle‘The History of Science Cases for High Schools in the Development of Student Understanding of Science and Scientists’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 1 IssueID1 33–47
S. Lakin J. Wellington (1994) ArticleTitle‘Who Will Teach the ‘Nature of Science’?: Teachers’ Views of Science and Their Implications for Science Education’ International Journal of Science Education 16 IssueID2 175–190
B. Latour (1987) Science in Action Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA
J. Leach A. Hind J. Ryder (2003) ArticleTitle‘Designing and Evaluating Short Teaching Interventions About the Epistemology of Science in High School Classrooms’ Science Education 87 IssueID6 831–848 Occurrence Handle10.1002/sce.10072
N.G. Lederman (1986a) ArticleTitle‘Students’ and Teachers’ Understanding of the Nature of Science: A Reassessment’ School Science and Mathematics 86 IssueID2 91–99
N.G. Lederman (1986b) ArticleTitle‘Relating Teaching Behavior and Classroom Climate to Changes in Students’ Conceptions of the Nature of Science’ Science Education 70 IssueID1 3–19
N.G. Lederman (1992) ArticleTitle‘Students’ and Teachers’ Conceptions of the Nature of Science: A Review of the Research’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 29 IssueID4 331–359
Lederman, N.G.: 1998, ‘The State of Science Education: Subject Matter Without Context’, Electronic Journal of Science Education 3(2), [WWW Document]. http://unr.edu/homepage/jcannon/ejse/lederman.html..
N.G. Lederman F.S. Abd-El-Khalick (1998) ‘Avoiding De-Natured Science: Activities That Promote Understandings of the Nature of Science’ W.F. McComas (Eds) The Nature of Science in Science Education: Rationales and Strategies Kluwer Academic Publishers Dordrecht, The Netherlands 83–126
N.G. Lederman R.S. Schwartz F. Abd-El-Khalick R.L. Bell (2001) ArticleTitle‘Pre-service Teachers’ Understanding and Teaching of Nature of Science: An Intervention Study’ Canadian Journal of Science, Mathematics and Technology Education 1 IssueID2 135–160
M. Limon L. Mason (2002) Reconsidering Conceptual Change: Issues in Theory and Practice Kluwer Norwell MA
H.S. Lin C.C. Chen (2002) ArticleTitle‘Promoting Preservice Chemistry Teachers’ Understanding About the Nature of Science Through History’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 39 IssueID9 773–792 Occurrence Handle10.1002/tea.10045
D. MacDonald (1996) ArticleTitle‘Making Both the Nature of Science and Science Subject Matter Explicit Intents of Science Teaching’ Journal of Science Teacher Education 7 IssueID3 183–196 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00117034
M. Matthews (1994a) ‘History and Philosophy in the Classroom: The Case of Pendulum Motion’ M. Matthews (Eds) Science Teaching: The Role of History and Philosophy of Science Routledge New York, NY 109–135
M. Matthews (1994b) Science Teaching: The Role of History and Philosophy of Science Routledge New York, NY
M. Matthews (1997) ArticleTitle‘Editorial’ Science & Education 6 IssueID4 323–329
W.F. McComas (Eds) (1998) The Nature of Science in Science Education: Rationales and Strategies Kluwer Academic Publishers Dordrecht, The Netherlands
W.F. McComas M.P. Clough H. Almazroa (1998) ArticleTitle‘The Role and Character of the Nature of Science in Science Education’ Science & Education 7 IssueID6 511–532 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1008642510402
W.F. McComas J.K. Olson (1998) ‘The Nature of Science in International Standards Documents’ W.F. McComas (Eds) The Nature of Science in Science Education: Rationales and Strategies Kluwer Academic Publishers Dordrecht, The Netherlands 41–52
P.B. Medawar (1963) ‘Is the Scientific Paper a Fraud?’ P.B. Medawar (Eds) The Threat and the Glory: Reflections on Science and Scientists HarperCollins New York, NY 228–233
K.E. Metz (1995) ArticleTitle‘Reassessment of Developmental Constraints on Children’s Science Instruction’ Review of Educational Research 65 IssueID2 93–127
H. Meyling (1997) ArticleTitle‘How to Change Students’ Conceptions of the Epistemology of Science’ Science & Education 6 IssueID4 397–416 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1017908916810
E.F. Mortimer (1995) ArticleTitle‘Conceptual Change or Conceptual Profile Change?’ Science & Education 4 IssueID3 267–285 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00486624
M. Monk J. Osborne (1997) ArticleTitle‘Placing the History and Philosophy of Science on the Curriculum: A Model for the Development of Pedagogy’ Science Education 81 IssueID4 405–424 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1098-237X(199707)81:4<405::AID-SCE3>3.0.CO;2-G
D.M. Moss E.D. Abrams J. Robb (2001) ArticleTitle‘Examining Student Conceptions of the Nature of Science’ International Journal of Science Education 23 IssueID8 771–790
H. Munby (1976) ArticleTitle‘Some Implications of Language in Science Education’ Science Education 60 IssueID1 115–124
InstitutionalAuthorNameNational Research Council (NRC) (1996) National Science Education Standards National Academy Press Washington, DC
Olson, J.K. & Clough, M.P.: 2001, ‘Secondary Science Teachers’ Implementation Practices Following a Course Emphasizing Contextualized & Decontextualized Nature of Science Instruction’ Paper presented at the 6th International History, Philosophy & Science Teaching Conference, November 7–11, Denver, CO.
Olson, J.K., Clough, M.P., Vanderlinden, D. & Bruxvoort, C.N.: 2003, ‘Methodological Issues in Assessing Nature of Science Understandings Through the Use of Writing Tasks’, Paper Presented at the Association for the Education of Teachers in Science (AETS) National Conference, St. Louis, MO, January 29–February 2.
P.R. Pintrich R.W. Marx R.A. Boyle (1993) ArticleTitle‘Beyond Cold Conceptual Change: The Role of Motivational Beliefs and Classroom Contextual Factors in the Process of Conceptual Change’ Review of Educational Research 63 IssueID2 167–199
G.J. Posner K.A. Strike P.W. Hewson W.A. Gertzog (1982) ArticleTitle‘Accommodation of a Scientific Conception: Toward a Theory of Conceptual Change’ Science Education 66 IssueID2 211–227
L.B. Resnick (1987) ArticleTitle‘Learning in School and Out: The 1987 Presidential Address’ Educational Researcher 16 IssueID9 13–20
D.W. Rudge (2000) ArticleTitle‘Does Being Wrong Make Kettlewell Wrong for Science Teaching?’ Journal of Biological Education 35 IssueID1 5–11
J.L. Rudolph J. Stewart (1998) ArticleTitle‘Evolution and the Nature of Science: On the Historical Discord and its Implications for Education’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 35 IssueID10 1069–1089 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1098-2736(199812)35:10<1069::AID-TEA2>3.0.CO;2-A
T.L. Russell (1981) ArticleTitle‘What History of Science, How Much, and Why?’ Science Education 65 IssueID1 51–64
F.J. Rutherford G. Holton F.G. Watson (1970) The Project Physics Course Holt, Rinehart and Winston New York, NY
J. Ryder J. Leach R. Driver (1999) ArticleTitle‘Undergraduate Science Students’ Images of Science’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 36 IssueID2 201–220 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1098-2736(199902)36:2<201::AID-TEA6>3.0.CO;2-H
I.A. Shibley SuffixJr. (2003) ArticleTitle‘Using Newspapers to Examine the Nature of Science’ Science & Education 12 IssueID7 691–702
M.U. Smith N.G. Lederman R.L. Bell R.L. McComas M.P. Clough (1997) ArticleTitle‘How Great is the Disagreement about the Nature of Science? A Response to Alters’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 34 IssueID10 1101–1103 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1098-2736(199712)34:10<1101::AID-TEA8>3.0.CO;2-V
J. Solomon J. Duveen L. Scot (1992) ArticleTitle‘Teaching About the Nature of Science Through History: Action Research in the Classroom’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 29 IssueID4 409–421
A. Stinner B.A. McMillan D. Metz J.M. Jilek S. Klassen (2003) ArticleTitle‘The Renewal of Case Studies in Science Education’ Science & Education 12 IssueID7 617–643
K.A. Strike G.J. Posner (1983) ArticleTitle‘On Rationality and Learning: A Reply to West and Pines’ Science Education 67 IssueID1 41–43
K.A. Strike G.J. Posner (1992) ‘A Revisionist Theory of Conceptual Change’ R. Duschl R. Hamilton (Eds) Philosophy of Science, Cognitive Psychology, and Educational Theory and Practice SUNY New York 147–176
P.K. Tao (2003) ArticleTitle‘Eliciting and Developing Junior Secondary Students’ Understanding of the Nature of Science Through a Peer Collaboration Instruction in Science Stories’ International Journal of Science Education 25 IssueID2 147–171 Occurrence Handle10.1080/09500690210126748
K. Tobin P. Garnett (1988) ArticleTitle‘Exemplary Practice in Science Classrooms’ Science Education 72 IssueID2 197–208
L.M. Tyson G.J. Venville A.G. Harrison D.F. Treagust (1997) ArticleTitle‘A Multidimensional Framework for Interpreting Conceptual Change Events in the Classroom’ Science Education 81 IssueID4 387–404 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1098-237X(199707)81:4<387::AID-SCE2>3.0.CO;2-8
L.S. Vygotsky (1978) NoChapterTitle M. Cole V. John-Steiner S. Scribner E. Souberman (Eds) Mind in Society: The Development of Higher Psychological Processes Harvard University Press Cambridge MA
L.S. Vygotsky (1986) NoChapterTitle A. Kozulin (Eds) Thought and Language MIT Press Cambridge, MA
J.H. Wandersee (1992) ArticleTitle‘The Historicality of Cognition: Implications for Science Education Research’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 29 IssueID4 423–434
L.H.T. West A.L. Pines (1983) ArticleTitle‘How “Rational” is Rationality?’ Science Education 67 IssueID1 37–39
M. Windschitl (2002) ArticleTitle‘Framing Constructivism in Practice as the Negotiation of Dilemmas: An Analysis of the Conceptual, Pedagogical, Cultural, and Political Challenges Facing Teachers’ Review of Educational Research 72 IssueID2 131–175
D.L. Zeidler N.G. Lederman (1989) ArticleTitle‘The Effects of Teachers’ Language on Students’ Conceptions of the Nature of Science’ Journal of Research in Science Teaching 26 IssueID9 771–783
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Clough, M.P. Learners’ Responses to the Demands of Conceptual Change: Considerations for Effective Nature of Science Instruction. Sci Educ 15, 463–494 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11191-005-4846-7
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11191-005-4846-7