Abstract
Advance directives are propagated as instruments to maintain patients’ autonomy in case they can no longer decide for themselves. It has been never been examined whether patients’ and healthy persons themselves are inclined to adhere to these documents. Patients’ and healthy persons’ views on whether instructions laid down in advance directives should be followed because that is (or is not) “the right thing to do”, not because one is legally obliged to do so, were studied and compared with that of medical staff. Method: Vignette study presenting five cases. Cancer patients, healthy persons, nursing staff and physicians (n = 100 in each group) were interviewed. An adherence score was calculated (maximum value 5). The adherence score is found to be low in all groups, yet lowest in patients (1.55; standard deviation 1.13) and healthy controls (1.60; 1.37). The scores are significantly different between nursing staff on the one hand and patients and healthy controls on the other (p < 0.005 and p < 0.05, respectively), and between doctors and patients (p < 0.05). Interviewees who want these documents to be followed tend to live alone and to have already written an advance directive. Conclusions: Cancer patients and healthy persons widely disregard instructions laid down in advance directives and consider them less binding than physicians and nursing staff do. Only a minority tends to adhere more to advance directives. To improve decision-making at the end of life when patients are no longer able to decide for themselves alternative concepts, such as advanced care planning, should be considered.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
H.M. Chan (2004) ArticleTitle‘Sharing Death and Dying: Advance Directives, Autonomy and the Family’ Bioethics 18 87–103 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1467-8519.2004.00383.x Occurrence Handle15146852
InstitutionalAuthorNameCouncil of Ethical and Judicial Affairs of the American Medical Association (1989) ‘Current opinions of the Council of Ethical and Judicial Affairs of the American Medical Association American Medical Association Chicago
R.S. Downie K.C. Calman (1994) Healthy respect Oxford University Press Oxford 51
C. Dyer (2004a) ArticleTitle‘Living Wills will have to Specify Treatments that Patient is Refusing’ British Medical Journal 328 1035
C. Dyer (2004b) ArticleTitle‘Bill Clarifies Gap in Law Over Living Wills’ British Medical Journal 328 1516
L.L. Emanuel M.J. Barry J.D. Stoeckle L.M. Ettelson E.J. Emanuel (1991) ArticleTitle‘Advance Directives for Medical Care-a case for Greater use’ New England Journal of Medicine 324 889–895 Occurrence Handle2000111 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK3M7lsF2qsA%3D%3D Occurrence Handle10.1056/NEJM199103283241305
Fagerlin, A. and C.E. Schneider: 2004, ‘Enough. The Failure of the Living Will’, Hastings Center Report 30–42.
InstitutionalAuthorNameGerman Medical Council (2004) ArticleTitle‘Principles for Medical Care of the Terminally Ill’ Deutsches Aerzteblatt 101 A1298–A1299
S. Ikonomidis P.A. Singer (1999) ArticleTitle‘Autonomy, Liberalism and Advance Care Planning’ Journal Medical Ethics 25 522–527 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DC%2BD3c7gtFChtA%3D%3D
S. Luttrell A. Sommerville (1996) ArticleTitle‘Limiting Risks by Curtailing Rights: A Response to Dr Ryan’ Journal of Medical Ethics 22 100–104 Occurrence Handle8731536 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK28zgtFCkuw%3D%3D
J. Lynn N.E. Goldstein (2003) ArticleTitle‘Advance Care Planning for Fatal Chronic Illness: Avoiding Commonplace Errors and Unwarranted Suffering’ Annals of Internal Medicine 138 812–818 Occurrence Handle12755553
B. Oorschot ParticleVan C. Hausmann N. Köhler K. Leppert S. Schweitzer K. Steinbach R. Anselm (2004) ArticleTitle‘Perspectives of Patients on Advanced Directives Results of a Survey of Palliative Umour Patients’ Ethik in der Medizin 6 112–122
S.J. Perry (2002) ArticleTitle‘Legal Implications for Failure to Comply with Advance Directives: An Examination of the Incompetent Individual’s Right to Refuse Life-sustaining Medical Treatment’ Behavioural Sciences and Law 20 253–269
B.M. Reilly C.R. Magnussen J. Ross J. Ash L. Papa M. Wagner (1994) ArticleTitle‘Can We Talk? Inpatient Discussions About Advance Directives in a Community Hospital Attending Physicians Attitudes, their Inpatients Wishes, and Reported Experience’ Archives of Internal Medicine 154 2299–2308 Occurrence Handle10.1001/archinte.154.20.2299 Occurrence Handle7944852 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK2M%2FjtFGnuw%3D%3D
J.A. Robertson (1991) ArticleTitle‘Second Thoughts on Living Wills’ Hastings Cenert Report 21 6–9 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK387ht1Cqsw%3D%3D
C.J. Ryan (1996) ArticleTitle‘Betting your Life: An Argument Against Certain Advance Directives’ Journal Medical Ethics 22 95–99 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK28zgtFCkug%3D%3D
S.W. Sahm (2000) ArticleTitle‘Palliative Care Versus Euthanasia. The German Position: The German General Medical Council’s Principles for Medical Care of the Terminally Ill’ Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 25 195–219 Occurrence Handle10833136 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DC%2BD3c3ptVOgsQ%3D%3D Occurrence Handle10.1076/0360-5310(200004)25:2;1-O;FT195
Sahm, S., R. Will and G. Hommel: in press. ‘Attitudes Towards and Barriers to Write Advance Directives Amongst Tumour Patients, Healthy Controls and Medical Staff’, Journal Medical Ethics, in press.
J. Savulescu (1994) ArticleTitle‘Rational Desires and the Limitation of Life Sustaining Treatment’ Bioethics 8 191–222 Occurrence Handle11652346
A. Sehgal A. Galbraith M. Chesney P. Schoenfeld G. Charles B. Lo (1992) ArticleTitle‘How Strictly do Dialysis Patients Want their Advance Directives Followed?’ Journal of the American Medical Association 267 59–63 Occurrence Handle10.1001/jama.267.1.59 Occurrence Handle1489360 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK38%2FnvFeksw%3D%3D
M.L. Slevin L. Stubbs H.J. Plant P. Wilson W.M. Gregory P.J. Armes S.M. Downer (1990) ArticleTitle‘Attitudes to Chemotherapy: Comparing Views of Patients with Cancer with those of Doctors, Nurses, and General Public’ British Medical Journal 300 1458–1460 Occurrence Handle2379006 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK3czjsFGjtg%3D%3D Occurrence Handle10.1136/bmj.300.6737.1458
Task force of the German Federal Ministry of Justice on patients’ autonomy at the end of life.: 2004, Final Report. online: www.bmj.bund.de, last seen 29th of July 2004.
J.M. Teno S. Licks J. Lynn N. Wenger A.F. Connors SuffixJr R.S. Phillips M.A. O’Connor D.P. Murphy W.J. Fulkerson N. Desbiens W.A. Knaus (1997) ArticleTitle‘Do Advance Directives Provide Instructions that Direct Care? SUPPORT Investigators. Study to Understand Prognoses and Preferences for Outcomes and Risks of Treatment’ Journal of the American Geriatric Society 45 508–512 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK2s3lsFektw%3D%3D
J. Teno J. Lynn N. Wenger R.S. Phillips D.P. Murphy A.F. Connors SuffixJr. N. Desbiens W. Fulkerson P. Bellamy W.A. Knaus (1997) ArticleTitle‘Advance Directives for Seriously Ill Hospitalized Patients: Effectiveness With the Patient Self-Determination Act and the SUPPORT Intervention. SUPPORT Investigators. Study to Understand Prognoses and Preferences for Outcomes and Risks of Treatment’ Journal of the American Geriatric Society 45 500–507 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK2s3lsFektg%3D%3D
T. Thompson R. Barbour L. Schwartz (2003) ArticleTitle‘Adherence to Advance Directives in Critical care Decision Making: Vignette Study’ British Medical Journal 327 1011 Occurrence Handle14593032
M.R. Tonelli (1996) ArticleTitle‘Pulling the Plug on Living Wills. A Critical Analysis of Advance Directives’ Chest 110 816–822 Occurrence Handle8797430 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK28zptVCntg%3D%3D
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sahm, S., Will, R. & Hommel, G. Would They Follow What has been Laid Down? Cancer Patients' and Healthy Controls' Views on Adherence to Advance Directives Compared to Medical Staff. Med Health Care Philos 8, 297–305 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-005-2108-8
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-005-2108-8