Abstract
Even though respect for integrity is hailed in several authoritative legal and ethical documents, and is typically presented as a complement to respect for autonomy, it is largely neglected in many leading works in ethics. Is such neglect warranted, or does it express a prejudice? This article argues that the latter is the case, and that this is due to misplaced conceptual concerns. It offers some proposals as regards the conceptualization of integrity in social ethics in general and in biomedical ethics in particular. Five main directions of interpretation of “integrity” are discerned and shown to be relevant for different areas of biomedical ethics. The defense of respect for integrity is served by a softening of principlism and by greater attention to context among the initial critics of this principle.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
M. Andersson (1994) Integritet som begrepp och princip Åbo Akademis förlag Åbo
T.L. Beauchamp J.F. Childress (2001) Principles of Biomedical Ethics EditionNumber5 Oxford UP Oxford
T.L. Beauchamp L.B. McCullough (1984) Medical Ethics: The Moral Responsibilities of Physicians Prentice Hall Englewood Cliffs, New York
T.L. Beauchamp (1994) ‘The “Four-principles” Approach’ R. Gillon (Eds) Principles of Health Care Ethics John Wiley & Sons NY
E. Bischofberger (1990a) ‘Människosyn, integritet och autonomi’ S.-O Andersson (Eds) Lidandet och makten Gothia Stockholm
E. Bischofberger (1990b) ‘The Ideas of Integrity and Autonomy: Discussion’ P. Allebeck B. Jansson (Eds) Ethics in Medicine – Individual Integrity Versus Demands of Society Raven Press NY
C. Blomquist (1971) Medicinsk etik Natur och Kultur Stockholm
J. Blustein (1991) Care and Commitment: Taking the Personal Point of View Oxford University Press New York
C. Boorse (1977) ArticleTitle‘Health as a Theoretical Concept’ Philosophy of Science 44 542–573 Occurrence Handle10.1086/288768
C. Calhoun (1995) ArticleTitle‘Standing for Something’ Journal of Philosophy 92 235–260
D. Cox M La Caze M.P. Levine (2003) Integrity and the Fragile Self Ashgate Aldershot
L. Curtin M.J. Flaherty (1982) Nursing Ethics: Theories and Pragmatics Prentice-Hall Bowie Maryland
G. Dworkin (1988) The Theory and Practice of Autonomy Cambridge UP New York
H.T. Engelhardt SuffixJr. (1986) The Foundations of Bioethics Oxford UP Oxford
H.T. Engelhardt SuffixJr. (1991) Bioethics and Secular Humanism: The Search for a Common Morality SCM Press London
R.R. Faden T.L. Beauchamp (1986) A History and Theory of Informed Consent Oxford UP New York
R. Fjellström (2004) ArticleTitle‘ Varför människor har lika Värde’ Filosofisk tidskrift 68 5–20
H.G. Frankfurt (1971) ArticleTitle‘Freedom of the Will and the Concept of a Person’ Journal of Philosophy 68 5–20
R. Gaita (2000) Common humanity Routledge London
J. Glover (1990) Causing Death and Saving Lives Penguin Books London
Hermerén G. (1996) Forskningens pris, forskningsetiska problem och principer i humaniora och samhällsvetenskap Humanistisk-samhällsvetenskapliga forskningsrådet Stockholm
H. Kelman (1977) ArticleTitle‘Privacy and Research with Human Beings’ Journal of Social Issues 33 169–195 Occurrence Handle11661565
Kemp P. et al. ed. (2000). Basic Ethical Principles in European Bioethics and Biolaw, Vol. I: Autonomy, Dignity, Integrity and Vulnerability. Centre for Ethics and Law, Copenhagen, Denmark, and Institut Borja de Bioética, Barcelona, Spain
M.E. Levine (1971) ArticleTitle‘Holistic Nursing’ Nursing Clinics of North America 6 253–264 Occurrence Handle5207059
B.L. Miller (1981) ArticleTitle‘Autonomy and the Refusal of Lifesaving Treatment’ Hastings Center Report. 11 IssueID4 22–28 Occurrence Handle7298320
L. Nordenfelt (1995) On the Notion of Health: An Action Theoretic Approach (2nd rev. ed) Kluwer Dordrecht
R. Noggle (1999) ArticleTitle‘Integrity, the Self, and Desire-Based Accounts of the Good’ Philosophical Studies 96 303–331 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1004387711585
E.D. Pellegrino (1990) ‘The Relationships of Autonomy and Integrity in Medical Ethics’ P. Allebeck B. Jansson (Eds) Ethics in Medicine Raven Press New York
E.D. Pellegrino (1994) ‘The Four Principles and the Doctor–Patient Relationship: the Need for a Better Linkage’ R. Gillon (Eds) Principles of Health Care Ethics John Wiley & Sons NY
E.D. Pellegrino D.C. Thomasma (1988) For the Patient’s Good: The Restoration of Beneficience in Health Care Oxford University Press Oxford/NY
M.E. Rogers (1970) An introduction to the theoretical basis of nursing A. Davis Philadelphia
J. Savulescu (1999) ‘Rational Desires and the Limitation of Life-Sustaining Treatment’ H. Kuhse P. Singer (Eds) Bioethics Blackwell Oxford
N. Schauber (1996) ArticleTitle‘Integrity, Commitment and the Concept of a Person’ American Philosophical Quarterly 33 119–129
P. Sundström (1996) Sjukvårdens etiska grunder Daidalos Göteborg
Taylor J.S. (1999). ‘The Theory of Autonomy’. Humane Studies Review. 12(3):
T. Torbjön (1998) Vårdetik Thales Sthlm
K.E. Tranøy (1993) Medicinsk etik i vår tid Studentlitteratur Lund
R. Young (1998) ‘Informed Consent and Patient Autonomy’ H. Kuhse P. Singer (Eds) A Companion to Bioethics. Blackwell Oxford
Encyclopedia of Bioethics. (Vol. 3) (1995). Simon & Schuster, Macmillan, NY
Svensk ordbok. (1986). Göteborg: Språkdata & Esselte studium
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Fjellstrom, R. Respect for persons, respect for integrity. Med Health Care Philos 8, 231–242 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-004-7694-3
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-004-7694-3