Abstract
Starting from the familiar observation that no straightforward treatment of pure quotation can be compositional in the standard (homomorphism) sense, we introduce general compositionality, which can be described as compositionality that takes linguistic context into account. A formal notion of linguistic context type is developed, allowing the context type of a complex expression to be distinct from those of its constituents. We formulate natural conditions under which an ordinary meaning assignment can be non-trivially extended to one that is sensitive to context types and satisfies general compositionality. As our main example we work out a Fregean treatment of pure quotation, but we also indicate that the method applies to other kinds of context, e.g. intensional contexts.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Barker C., Jacobson P. (2007) Direct compositionality. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Cappelen H., LePore E. (2007) Language turned on itself. The semantics and pragmatics of metalinguistic discourse. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Cappelen, H., & LePore, E. (2008). Quotation. In E. N. Zalta (Ed.), The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Winter 2008.
Clark H., Gerrig R. (1990) Quotations as demonstrations. Language, 66(4): 764–805
Davidson, D. (1979). Quotation. Theory and Decision, 11, 27–40. (Reprinted in Davidson, D. (1984). Inquiries into truth and interpretation (pp. 79–92). Oxford: Clarendon Press).
Dowty D. (2007) Compositionality as an empirical problem. In: Barker C., Jacobson P. (eds) Direct compositionality. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 23–101
Frege, G. (1892). Uber Sinn und Bedeutung. In P. Geach & M. Black (Eds.), Translations from the philosophical writings of Gottlob Frege (pp. 56–78). Oxford: Blackwell; 1952.
Frege, G. (1902). Letter to Russell 28.12 1902. In G. Gabriel (Ed.), Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel (pp. 234–237). Hamburg: Felix Meiner Verlag; 1976.
Geach P. (1957) Mental acts. Routledge Kegan Paul, London
Glüer K., Pagin P. (2006) Proper names and relational modality. Linguistics & Philosophy 29: 507–535
Glüer K., Pagin P. (2008) Relational modality. Journal of Logic, Language and Information 17: 307–322
Glüer, K., & Pagin, P. (2011). General terms and relational modality. Nous (forthcoming).
Hodges W. (2001) Formal features of compositionality. Journal of Logic, Language and Information 10: 7–28
Kaplan D. (1989) Demonstratives: An essay on the semantics, logic, metaphysics, and epistemology of demonstratives and other indexicals. In: Almog J., Perry J., Wettstein H. (eds) Themes from Kaplan. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 481–566
Kennedy C. (2007) Vagueness and grammar: The semantics of relative and absolute gradable adjectives. Linguistics & Philosophy 30: 1–45
Lewis, D. (1980). Index, context, and content. In S. Kanger & S. Öhman (Eds.), Philosophy and grammar. Dordrecht: D. Reidel.
Pagin P. (2005) Compositionality and context. In: Preyer G., Peter G. (eds) Contextualism in philosophy. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 303–348
Pagin, P. (2010). General compositionality and belief sentences. Talk given at SPE 3, Paris, May 2010.
Pagin, P. (unpublished). Compositionality, computability, and complexity. Manuscript, unpublished.
Pagin, P. (to appear). Communication and the complexity of semantics. In W. Hinzen, E. Machery, & M. Werning (Eds.), The Oxford handbook of compositionality. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Pagin P., Westerståhl D. (2010a) Compositionality I: Definitions and variants. Philosophy Compass 5(3): 250–264
Pagin P., Westerståhl D. (2010b) Compositionality II: Arguments and problems. Philosophy Compass 5(3): 265–282
Parsons T. (1982) What do quotation marks name? Frege’s theory of quotations and that clauses. Philosophical Studies 42(3): 315–328
Partee, B. H. (1984). Compositionality. In F. Landman & F. Veltman (Eds.), Varieties of formal semantics (pp. 281–311). Dordrecht: Foris. (Reprinted in Partee, B. H. (2004). Compositionality in formal semantics (pp. 153–181). Oxford: Blackwell).
Potts C. (2007) The dimensions of quotation. In: Barker C., Jacobson P. (eds) Direct compositionality. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 405–431
Predelli S. (2008) The demonstrative theory of quotation. Linguistics & Philosophy 31(5): 555–572
Quine W. V. O. (1940) Mathematical logic. Harvard University Press, Boston, MA
Quine W. V. O. (1960) Word and object. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Recanati F. (2001) Open quotation. Mind, 110: 637–687
Recanati F. (2008) Open quotation revisited. Philosophical Perspectives 22: 443–471
Recanati, F. (to appear). Compositionality, flexibility and context-dependence. In W. Hinzen, E. Machery, & M. Werning (Eds.), The Oxford handbook of compositionality. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Saka P. (1998) Quotation and the use-mention distinction. Mind 107: 113–136
Searle J. (1969) Speech acts: An essay in the philosophy of language. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Shan, C.-c. (2011). The character of quotation. Linguistics and Philosophy (this volume).
Tarski A. (1952) The semantic conception of truth. In: Linsky L. (ed.) Semantics and the philosophy of language. University of Illinois Press, Urbana, pp 13–47
Tarski, A. (1983). The concept of truth in formalized languages. In Logic, semantics, metamathematics (2nd ed., pp. 152–278). Indianapolis: Hackett; 1983.
Washington C. (1992) The identity theory of quotation. The Journal of Philosophy 89: 582–605
Werning, M. (2005). Right and wrong reasons for compositionality. In E. Machery, M. Werning, & G. Schurz (Eds.), The compositionality of meaning and content: Foundational issues (Vol. I, pp. 285–309). Frankfurt: Ontos.
Westerståhl D. (1998) On mathematical proofs of the vacuity of compositionality. Linguistics & Philosophy 21: 635–643
Westerståhl D. (2002) On the compositionality of idioms; an abstract approach. In: Barker-Plummer D. et al (eds) Words, proofs, and diagrams. CSLI Publications, Stanford, pp 241–271
Westerståhl D. (2004) On the compositional extension problem. Journal of Philosophical Logic 33: 549–582
Westerståhl, D. (to appear). Compositionality in Kaplan style semantics. In W. Hinzen, E. Machery, & M. Werning (Eds.), The Oxford handbook of compositionality. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Pagin, P., Westerståhl, D. Pure quotation and general compositionality. Linguist and Philos 33, 381–415 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10988-011-9083-8
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10988-011-9083-8