Abstract
This paper investigates the way that linguistic expressions influence vagueness, focusing on the interpretation of the positive (unmarked) form of gradable adjectives. I begin by developing a semantic analysis of the positive form of ‘relative’ gradable adjectives, expanding on previous proposals by further motivating a semantic basis for vagueness and by precisely identifying and characterizing the division of labor between the compositional and contextual aspects of its interpretation. I then introduce a challenge to the analysis from the class of ‘absolute’ gradable adjectives: adjectives that are demonstrably gradable, but which have positive forms that relate objects to maximal or minimal degrees, and do not give rise to vagueness. I argue that the truth conditional difference between relative and absolute adjectives in the positive form stems from the interaction of lexical semantic properties of gradable adjectives—the structure of the scales they use—and a general constraint on interpretive economy that requires truth conditions to be computed on the basis of conventional meaning to the extent possible, allowing for context dependent truth conditions only as a last resort.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abney, S. P. (1987). The English noun phrase in its sentential aspect. Ph.D. thesis. Cambridge, Mass: Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Austin J.L. (1961). The meaning of a word. In: Urmson J.O., Warnock G.J. (eds) Philosophical papers. Oxford, Oxford University Press, pp 55–75
Barker C. (2002) The dynamics of vagueness. Linguistics and Philosophy 25(1):1-36
Bartsch R., Vennemann T. (1972). The grammar of relative adjectives and comparison. Linguistische Berichte 20, 19-32
Bartsch R., Vennemann T. (1973). Semantic structures: A study in the relation between syntax and semantics. Frankfurt, Athäenum Verlag
Bhatt R., Pancheva R. (2004). Late merger of degree clauses. Linguistic Inquiry 35: 1-46
Bierwisch M. (1989). The Semantics of gradation. In: Bierwisch M., Lang E. (eds) Dimensional adjectives. Berlin, Springer-Verlag, pp 71–261
Boguslawski A. (1975). Measures are Measures: In Defence of the Diversity of Comparatives and Positives. Linguistiche Berichte 36: 1-9
Bosch P. (1983). “Vagueness” is context-dependence. A solution to the sorites paradox. In: Ballmer T., Pinkal M. (eds) Approaching vagueness. Amsterdam, North Holland, pp 189–210
Cappelen H., Lepore E. (2005). A tall tale: In Defence of Semantic Minimalism and Speech Act Pluralism. In: Preyer G., Peter G. (eds) Contextualism in philosophy: Knowledge, meaning and truth. Oxford, Oxford University Press
Corver, N. (1990). The syntax of left branch extractions. Ph.D. thesis, Tilburg University.
Cresswell M.J. (1977). The semantics of degree. In: Partee B. (ed) Montague grammar. New York, Academic Press, pp 261–292
Cruse D.A. (1986). Lexical semantics. Cambridge. Cambridge University Press, UK
Dalrymple M., Kanazawa M., Kim Y., Mchombo S., Peters S. (1998). Reciprocal expressions and the concept of reciprocity. Linguistics and Philosophy 21(2): 159-210
Dowty D.R. (1991). Thematic proto-roles and argument selection. Language 67: 547–619
Fine K. (1975). Vagueness, truth and logic. Synthese 30: 265-300
Giannakidou A. (2004). Domain restriction and the arguments of quantificational determiners. In: Young R. (ed) Proceedings of SALT 14. Ithaca, NY, pp 110–128
Graff D. (2000). Shifting sands: An interest-relative theory of vagueness. Philosophical Topics 20: 45-81
Grimshaw, J. (1991). Extended projection. Unpublished ms., Brandeis University.
Hackl, M. (2000). Comparative quantifiers. Ph.D. thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Hankamer J. (1973). Why there are two ‘than’s in English. In: Corum C., Smith-Stark T.C., Weiser A. (eds) Proceedings of the 9th Annual Meeting of the Chicago Linguistics Society. Chicago, IL
Heim, I. (1985). Notes on comparatives and related matters. Ms., University of Texas.
Heim I. (2000). Degree operators and scope. In: Jackson B., Matthews T.(eds) Semantics and Linguistic Theory 10. CLC Publication Ithaca, NY, pp 40–64
Heim I., Kratzer A. (1998). Semantics in generative grammar. Oxford, Blackwell
Hellan, L. (1981). Towards an integrated analysis of comparatives.Tübingen: Narr.
Hoeksema J. (1984). Negative polarity and the comparative. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 1: 403–434
Jacobson P. (1999). Towards a variable-free semantics. Linguistics and Philosophy 22: 117-184
Jacobson, P. (2005). Variable free semantics: The case of quantifier domain restrictions. Lecture at the Institut Jean Nicod, June 10, 2005.
Jacobson, P. (2006). Direct compositionality and variable free semantics: Taking the surprise out of “complex variables”. Lecture at the 30th Penn Linguistics Colloquium, University of Pennsylvania, February 25, 2006.
Kamp H. (1975). Two theories of adjectives. In: Keenan E. (ed) Formal semantics of natural language. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, pp 123–155
Kamp H. (1981). The paradox of the heap. In: Mö nnich U. (ed) Aspects of philosophical logic. Dordrecht, Reidel
Kennedy, C. (1999). Projecting the adjective: The syntax and semantics of gradability and comparison. New York: Garland. (1997 UCSC Ph.D thesis).
Kennedy C. (2001). Polar opposition and the ontology of ‘degrees’. Linguistics and philosophy 24: 33-70
Kennedy C., McNally L. (1999). From event structure to scale structure: Degree modification in deverbal adjectives. In: Matthews T., Strolovitch D. (eds) Semantics and linguistic theory 9. Ithaca, NY, pp 163–180
Kennedy C., McNally L. (2005). Scale structure and the semantic typology of gradable predicates. Language 81(2): 345-381
Klein E. (1980). A semantics for positive and comparative adjectives. Linguistics and philosophy 4: 1-45
Klein E. (1991). Comparatives. In: von Stechow A., Wunderlich D. (eds) Semantik: Ein Internationales Handbuch der Zeitgenössischen Forschung. Berlin, Walter de Gruyter, pp 673–691
Kyburg A., Morreau M. (2000). Fitting words: Vague language in context. Linguistics and philosophy 23(6): 577-597
Larson R.K. (1988). Scope and comparatives. Linguistics and philosophy 11: 1–26
Lasersohn P. (1999). Pragmatic Halos. Language 75(3): 522-551
Lewis D.K. (1970). General semantics. Synthese 22: 18-67
Lewis, D. K. (1979). Attitudes de dicto and de se. The Philosophical Review, 88(4), 513-543. Reprinted with postscripts in lewis (1983).
Lewis, D. K. (1983). Philosophical papers, Vol. I. Oxford, Great Britain: Oxford University Press.
Ludlow P. (1989). Implicit comparison classes. Linguistics and philosophy 12: 519-533
Martí, M. L. (2002). Contextual variables. Ph.D. thesis, University of Connecticut.
McConnell-Ginet, S. (1973). Comparative constructions in English: A syntactic and semantic analysis. Ph.D. thesis, University of Rochester.
Meier, C. (2003). The meaning of Too, Enough, and So ... That. Natural language semantics, 11(1), 69-107.
Montague, R. (1974). English as a formal language. In R. Thomason (Ed.), Formal philosophy: Selected papers (pp. 188-221). New Haven: Yale University Press.
Neeleman A., Van de Koot H., Doetjes J. (2004). Degree expressions. The linguistic review 21(21): 1-66
Paradis C. (2001). Adjectives and boundedness. Cognitive linguistics 12(1): 47-65
Pinkal, M. (1979). Semantics from different points of view. In R. Bäurle, U. Egli, & A. von Stechow (Eds.), How to refer with vague descriptions (pp. 32-50). Berlin: Springer-Verlag.
Pinkal M. (1995). Logic and lexicon. Dordrecht, Kluwer
Raffman D. (1994) Vagueness without paradox. The Philosophical review 103: 41-74
Raffman D. (1996). Vagueness and context relativity. Philosophical studies 81: 175-192
Rotstein C., Winter Y. (2004). Total adjectives vs. partial adjectives: Scale structure and higher order modifiers. Natural Language Semantics 12: 259-288
Rusiecki J. (1985). On adjectives and comparison in English. New York, Longman Linguistics Library
Sapir E. (1944). Grading: A study in semantics. Philosophy of Science 11: 93-116
Sawada, O. (2005). The possible semantic diversity of the comparative constructions in English and Japanese: A construction based approach. Paper presented at the 9th International Cognitive Linguistics Conference, Yonsei University, Korea, July 19, 2005.
Schwarzschild R. (2005). Measure phrases as modifiers of adjectives. Recherches Linguistiques de Vincennes 35: 207-228
Sedivy J., Tanenhaus M., Chambers C., Carlson G. (1999). Achieving incremental semantic interpretation through contextual representations. Cognition 71: 109-147
Seuren, P. A. (1973). The comparative. In F. Kiefer, & N. Ruwet (Eds.), Generative grammar in Europe. (pp. 528-564), Dordrecht: Riedel.
Soames S. (1999). Understanding truth. Oxford, Oxford University Press
Stanley J. (2000). Context and logical form. Linguistics and philosophy 23(4): 391-434
Stanley J. (2002). Nominal restriction. In: Peter G., Preyer G. (eds) Logical form and language. Oxford, Oxford University Press, pp 365–368
Stanley J. (2003). Context, interest relativity, and the sorites. Analysis 4(63): 269-280
Stanley J., Szabó Z. (2000). On quantifier domain restriction. Mind and Language 15: 219-261
Steedman M. (2000). The syntactic process. Cambridge, Mass, MIT Press
Svenonious, P., & Kennedy, C. (2005). Northern norwegian degree questions and the grammar of measurement. paper presented at the 31st Incontro di Grammatica Generativa, Universita’ Roma 3, 25 February, 2005.
Syrett, K., Bradley, E., Kennedy, C. & Lidz, J. (2005). Shifting standards: Children’s understanding of gradable adjectives. Paper presented at the 2005 Annual Meeting of the Linguistics Society of America, San Francisco, CA.
Syrett, K., Lidz, J., & Kennedy, C. (2006a). Scalar structures and the semantic representations of adjectives in child language. Paper presented at the 42nd Annual Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society.
Syrett, K., Lidz, J., & Kennedy, C. (2006b). The semantic typology of gradable adjectives: experimental evidence from adult and child language. Poster presented at the 2006 Annual Meeting of the CUNY Conference on Human Sentence Processing.
Tappenden J. (1993). The liar and Sorites Paradoxes: Toward a unified treatment. Journal of Philosophy 90: 551-577
Travis C. (1996). Meaning’s role in truth. Mind 105: 451-466
Unger P. (1975). Ignorance. Oxford, Clarendon Press
von Fintel, K. (1994). Restrictions on quantifier domains. Ph.D. thesis, University of Massachusetts, Amherst.
von Stechow A. (1984). Comparing semantic theories of comparison. Journal of semantics 3, 1-77
Wheeler S. (1972). Attributives and their modifiers. Noûs 6(4): 310-334
Williamson T. (1992). Vagueness and ignorance. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 66: 145-162
Williamson T. (1994). Vagueness. London, Routledge
Yoon Y. (1996). Total and partial predicates and the weak and strong interpretations. Natural Language semantics 4: 217-236
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
This paper grew out of joint work with Louise McNally, and owes a great debt to this collaboration. I am also grateful to Chris Barker, Gennaro Chierchia, Delia Graff, Irene Heim, Ed Keenan, Jeffrey King, Sally McConnell-Ginet, Jason Stanley, and audiences at MIT, Princeton, Northwestern, the University of British Columbia, the University of Chicago, the University Amherst, the University of Michigan, the University of Milan-Bicocca, Pennsylvania, the University of Stuttgart, Yale University and the Sprachwissenschaft, Berlin, for very helpful comments and feedback on earlier versions of this work. I would like to express particular gratitude to John MacFarlane and Michael Glanzburg for their thoughtful and insightful reviews of the manuscript, to Mark Richard for two challenging and extremely helpful commentaries on earlier versions of the paper, and to the Associate Editor Kent Bach for probing suggestions, questions, and comments both before and during the L&P review process. Any remaining shortcomings, incoherence, or vagueness are (definitely) my responsibility. This paper is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant No. 0094263 and 0618917 and by the American Council of Learned Societies under a Charles Ryskamp Research Fellowship.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kennedy, C. Vagueness and grammar: the semantics of relative and absolute gradable adjectives. Linguistics & Philosophy 30, 1–45 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10988-006-9008-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10988-006-9008-0