Abstract
This paper identifies the different normative ethical arguments stated and suggested by Arjuna and Krishna in the Gītā, analyzes those arguments, examines the interrelations between those arguments, and demonstrates that, contrary to a common view, both Arjuna and Krishna advance ethical theories of a broad consequentialist nature. It is shown that Krishna’s ethical theory, in particular, is a distinctive kind of rule-consequentialism that takes as intrinsically valuable the twin consequences of mokṣa and lokasaṃgraha. It is also argued that Krishna’s teachings in the Gītā gain in depth, coherence, and critical relevance what they lose in simplicity when the ethical theory underlying those teachings is understood as a consequentialism of this kind rather than as a deontology.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Agrawal M.M. (1992) Arjuna’s moral predicament. In: Matilal B.K. (ed) Moral dilemmas in the Mahabharata. Indian Institute of Advanced Study, Shimla, pp 129–142
Apte V.S. (2000) A practical Sanskrit-English dictionary. Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi
Aurobindo. (1997) The complete works of Sri Aurobindo, Vol. 19: Essays on the Gita. Sri Aurobindo Ashram Press, Pondicherry
Bowles A. (2007) Dharma, disorder, and the political in Ancient India: The Āpaddharmaparvan of the Mahābhārata. Brill, Leiden
Brink D.O. (2006) Some forms and limits of consequentialism. In: Copp D. (ed) The Oxford handbook of ethical theory. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 380–423
Brodbeck S. (2004) Calling Krsna’s Bluff: Nonattached action in the Bhagavadgita. Journal of Indian Philosophy 32: 81–103
Chakravarti, S. S. (2002). Consequentialism and the Gita. Evam 3(1&2). http://www.svabhinava.org/HinduCivilization/SitansuChakravarti/ConsequentialismGita.pdf.
Chakravarti S.S. (2006) Ethics in the Mahabharata: A philosophical inquiry for today. Munshiram Manoharlal, New Delhi
Chatterjea T. (2002) Knowledge and freedom in Indian Philosophy. Lexington Books, Lanham, MD
Das G. (2009) The difficulty of being good: On the subtle art of Dharma. Penguin, New Delhi
Dasgupta S. (2006) A history of Indian Philosophy (Vol. II). Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi
Doniger O’Flaherty W. (1988) The origins of evil in Hindu Mythology. Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi
Dowd, J. (2011). Maximizing Dharma: Krsna’s consequentialism in the Mahabharata. Praxis, 3(1). http://www.castela.net/praxis/vol3issue1/Praxis3.128final29.pdf.
Fitzgerald, J. (2003). The Mahābhārata, Vol. 7: 11. The Book of the Women, 12. The Book of Peace, Part One. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Framarin C. (2004) Niṣkāmakarma: How desireless need one be?. Asian Philosophy 14(3): 239–254
Framarin C. (2006) The desire you are required to get rid of: A functionalist analysis of desire in the Bhagavadgītā. Philosophy East and West 56(4): 604–617
Framarin C. (2007) Good and bad desires: Implications of the dialogue between Kṛṣṇa and Arjuna. International Journal of Hindu Studies 11(2): 147–170
Gandhi M.K. (2009) The Bhagavad Gita according to Gandhi. North Atlantic Books, Berkeley
Gauchhwal B.S. (1958) A comparative study of the ethical teachings of Kant and the Bhagavadgītā. Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi
Hegel G.W.F. (2005) On the episode of the Mahabharata known by the name Bhagavad-Gita. Munshiram Manoharlal, New Delhi
Hopkins E.W. (1895) The religions of India. Ginn & Co., Boston
Kant I. (1981) Grounding for the metaphysics of morals (J. W. Ellington, Trans.). Hackett, Indianapolis
Katz R.C. (1989) Arjuna in the Mahabharata: Where Krishna is, there is victory. University of South Carolina Press, Columbia, SC
Kosambi D.D. (1962) Social and economic aspects of the Bhagavad-Gita. In: Kosambi D.D. (ed) Myth and reality: Studies in the formation of Indian culture. Popular Prakashan, Bombay, pp 12–41
Kosambi D.D. (2005) The Avatāra syncretism and possible sources of the Bhagavad Gītā. In: Chattopadhyaya B. (ed) D. D. Kosambi: Combined methods in Indology and other writings. Oxford University Press, New Delhi, pp 373–389
Malinar A. (2007) The Bhagavadgītā: Doctrines and contexts. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Matilal, B. K. (2002a). Krsna: In defence of a devious divinity. In J. Ganeri (Ed.), The collected essays of Bimal Krishna Matilal, Vol. II: Ethics and epics (pp. 91–108). New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Matilal, B. K. (2002b). Caste, Karma, and the Gītā. In J. Ganeri (Ed.), The collected essays of Bimal Krishna Matilal, Vol. II: Ethics and epics (pp. 136–144). New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
McNaughton D., Rawling P. (1992) Honoring and promoting values. Ethics 102(4): 835–843
Minor R. (1982) Bhagavadgita: An exegetical commentary. Asia Books, Columbia, MO
Minor, R. (ed) (1986) Modern Interpreters of the Bhagavadgita. SUNY Press, Albany
Minor R. (2007) Krishna in the Bhagavad Gita. In: Bryant E.F. (ed) Krishna: A sourcebook. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 77–94
Monier-Williams M. (2005) A Sanskrit-English dictionary etymologically and philologically arranged with special reference to cognate Indo-European languages. Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi
Moore C.A. (1992) Metaphysics and ethics in Radhakrishnan’s philosophy. In: Schilpp P.A. (ed) The philosophy of Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan. Motilal Banarsidass, New Delhi, pp 279–312
Mulgan T. (2001) The demands of consequentialism. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Nagel T. (1986) The view from nowhere. Oxford University Press, New York
Nozick R. (1981) Philosophical explanations. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Nussbaum M.C. (2000) The costs of tragedy: Some moral limits of cost-benefit analysis. The Journal of Legal Studies 29(S2): 1005–1036
Olson R.G. (1972) Deontological ethics. In: Edwards P. (ed) The encyclopedia of Philosophy (Vol. 2). Macmillan and Free Press, New York, p 343
Pal J. (2004) Karma, Dharma, and Moksha: Conceptual essays on Indian ethics. Abhijeet, New Delhi
Perrett R. (1998) Hindu ethics: A philosophical study. University of Hawaii Press, Honolulu
Pettit P. (1991) Consequentialism. In: Singer P. (ed) A companion to ethics. Blackwell, Oxford, pp 230–240
Radhakrishnan S. (1911) The ethics of the Bhagavadgita and Kant. International Journal of Ethics 21(4): 465–475
Radhakrishnan S. (1914) The ethics of the Vedanta. International Journal of Ethics 24(2): 168–183
Radhakrishnan S. (1974) The Bhagavadgītā. Blackie, New Delhi
Rawls J. (1971) A theory of justice. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Ross W.D. (2007) The right and the Good (Philip Stratton-Lake, Ed.). Clarendon Press, Oxford
Roy S.C. (1941) The Bhagavadgītā and modern scholarship. Luzac, London
Sargeant W. (2009) The Bhagavad Gītā: 25th anniversary edition. SUNY Press, Albany, NY
Śastri, A. M. (1901). The Bhagavad-Gītā with the commentary of Śrī Śankarāchārya. Mysore: G. T. A. Printing Works.
Scanlon T.M. (1998) What we owe to each other. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Scheffler S. (1982) The rejection of consequentialism. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Schneewind J.B. (1992) Autonomy, obligation, and virtue: An overview of Kant’s moral philosophy. In: Guyer P. (ed) The Cambridge companion to Kant. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 319–341
Sen A. (2000) Consequential evaluation and practical reason. The Journal of Philosophy 97(9): 477–502
Sen A. (2005) The argumentative Indian. Picador USA, New York
Sen A. (2009) The idea of justice. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Sharma A. (1986) The Hindu Gītā: Ancient and classical interpretations of the Bhagavadgītā. Duckworth, London
Skorupski J. (1995) Agent-neutrality, consequentialism, utilitarianism...A terminological note. Utilitas 7: 49–54
Smart J.J.C. (1956) Extreme and restricted utilitarianism. Philosophical Quarterly 6(25): 344–354
Stevenson R.W. (1986) Tilak and the Bhagavadgita’s Doctrine of Karmayoga. In: Minor R. (ed) Modern interpreters of the Bhagavad Gita. SUNY Press, Albany, NY, pp 44–60
Telang, K. T. (1882). The sacred books of the East, Vol. VIII: The Bhagavadgîtâ with the Sanatsugâtîyâ and the Anugîtâ. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
van Buitenen, J. A. B. (1981a). The Bhagavadgītā in the Mahābhārata. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
van Buitenen, J. A. B. (1981b). The Mahābhārata, Vol. 2: 2. The Book of the Assembly Hall, 3. The Book of the Forest. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Walzer M. (1977) Just and unjust wars: A moral argument with historical illustrations. Basic Books, New York
Woods J.F. (2001) Destiny and human initiative in the Mahābhārata. SUNY Press, Albany, NY
Zaehner R.C. (1979) The Bhagavad-Gītā with a commentary based on the original sources. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sreekumar, S. An Analysis of Consequentialism and Deontology in the Normative Ethics of the Bhagavadgītā . J Indian Philos 40, 277–315 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10781-012-9154-3
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10781-012-9154-3