Abstract
This paper analyses the impact of the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) on electricity prices, in particular on wholesale power markets across the EU. To study this impact, this paper discusses the major results of a bottom-up modelling analysis of the implications of emissions trading for the performance of the wholesale power market in 20 European countries. The analyses show that a significant part of the costs of (freely allocated) CO2 emission allowances is passed through to power prices, resulting in higher electricity prices for consumers and additional (‘windfall’) profits for power producers, even in cases of full auctioning. In addition, they show that the ETS-induced increases in power prices depend not only on the level of CO2 prices but also on the structure of the power market, i.e., the incidence of market power, and the price responsiveness of power demand. Finally, the analyses show that the internalization and pass-through of carbon costs are crucial elements in a policy regime to reduce CO2 emissions by both changing the mix of power generation technologies and lowering total electricity demand.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abrate G (2003) Regulating retail electricity prices: a review of theoretical and empirical issues, Hermes Working Paper 7, www.hermesricerche.it/elements/wp03-7.pdf
Allaz B, Vila J-L (1993) Cournot competition, futures markets and efficiency. J Econ Theor 59: 297–308
Bauer C, Zink J (2005) Korrelation zwischen Strompreisen und CO2-Zertifikatepreisen. Energiewirtschaftliche Tagesfragen 55(8): 574–577
Bunn D, Fezzi C (2007) Interaction of european carbon trading and energy prices. London Business School, London
Chen Y, Sijm J, Hobbs BF, Lise W (2008) Implications of CO2 emissions trading for short-run electricity market outcomes in Northwest Europe. J Regul Econ 34(3): 251–281
Chernyavs’ka L, Gulli F (2008) Marginal CO2 pass-through under imperfect competition in power markets. Ecol Econ 68(1–2): 408–421
Centeno E, Reneses J, Barquín J (2007) Strategic analysis of electricity markets under uncertainty: a conjectured-price-response approach. IEEE Trans Power Syst 22: 423–432
Frontier Economics (2006) CO2 trading and its influence on electricity markets. Final report to DTe, Frontier Economics Ltd, London
Green R (1999) The electricity contract market in England and Wales. J Ind Econ 47(1): 107–124
Hobbs BF (2001) Linear complementarity models of the Nash-Cournot competition in bilateral and POOLCO power markets. IEEE Trans Power Syst 16(2): 194–202
Hobbs BF, Drayton G, Fisher EB, Lise W (2008) Improved transmission representations in oligopolistic market models: quadratic losses, phase shifters, and DC lines. IEEE Trans Power Syst 23(3): 1018–1029
Hobbs BF, Rijkers FAM, Wals A (2004) Strategic generation with conjectured transmission price responses in a mixed transmission pricing system–Part I: formulation and Part II: application. IEEE Trans Power Syst 19(2):707–717, 872–879
Hobbs BF, Rijkers FAM, Boots MG (2005) The more cooperation, the more competition? A Cournot analysis of the benefits of electric market coupling. Energy J 26(4): 69–98
Honkatukia J, Malkonen V, Perrels A (2006) Impacts of the European emission trade system on Finnish wholesale electricity prices, VATT Discussion Paper 405, Government Institute for Economic Research, Helsinki
IPA (2005) Implications of the EU Emissions Trading Scheme for the UK Power Generation Sector, Final Report to the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI), IPA Energy Consulting, Edinburgh
Kara M, Syri S, Helynen S, Kekkonen V, Ruska M, Forsström J (2008) The impacts of EU CO2 emissions trading on electricity markets and electricity consumers in Finland. Energy Econ 30(2): 193–211
Levy C (2005) Impact of emission trading on power prices: a case study from the European emission trading scheme. University Paris Dauphine and DEA d’Economie Industrielle, Paris
Linares P, Javier Santos F, Ventosa M, Lapiedra L (2006) Impacts of the European emissions trading scheme and permit assignment methods on the Spanish electricity sector. Energy J 27(1): 79–98
Lise W, Hobbs BF, Hers S (2008) Market power in the European electricity market—the impacts of dry weather and additional transmission capacity. Energy Policy 36(4): 1331–1343
Neuhoff K, Barquin J, Boots MG, Ehrenmann A, Hobbs BF, Rijkers FAM, Vázquez M (2005) Network-constrained Cournot models of liberalized electricity markets: the devil is in the details. Energy Econ 27: 495–525
Oranen A (2006) The impact of emissions trading on the price of electricity in Nord Pool—market power and price determination in the Nordic electricity market, Master’s thesis, Environmental Economics, Department of Economics and Management, University of Helsinki
Özdemir Ö, Scheepers M, Seebregts A (2008) Future electricity prices, wholesale market prices in and exchanges between Northwest European electricity markets, ECN-E–08-044, Petten, The Netherlands
Scheepers MJJ, Rijkers FAM, Wals AF, Boots MG (2003) Verticale concentratie op de Nederlandse elektriciteitsmarkt, ECN-CX–03-066, Petten, The Netherlands (in Dutch)
Sijm J, Bakker S, Chen Y, Harmsen H, Lise W (2005) CO2 Price dynamics. The implications of EU emissions trading for the price of electricity, ECN-C–05-081, Petten, The Netherlands
Sijm J, Neuhoff K, Chen Y (2006) CO2 cost pass through and windfall profits in the power sector. Clim Policy 6(1): 49–72
Sijm J, Hers S, Lise W (2008a) The implications of free allocation versus auctioning of EU ETS allowances for the power sector in the Netherlands, ECN-E-08-056, Petten, The Netherlands
Sijm J, Hers S, Lise W, Wetzelaer B (2008b) The impact of the EU ETS on electricity prices, Final report to DG Environment, ECN-E–08-007, Petten, Petten, The Netherlands
Sijm JS, Chen Y, Hobbs BF (2009) The impact of power market structure on the pass-through of CO2 emissions trading costs to electricity prices—a theoretical approach. In: Paper presented at the EAERE2009 conference, 24–27 June, Amsterdam
Ventosa M, Baíllo Á, Ramos A, Rivier M (2005) Electricity market modeling trends. Energy Policy 33(7): 897–913
Zhang J, Hobbs BF, Pang JS (2009) Long-run equilibrium modeling of alternative emissions allowance allocation systems in electric power markets. Operations Res, accepted for publication
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lise, W., Sijm, J. & Hobbs, B.F. The Impact of the EU ETS on Prices, Profits and Emissions in the Power Sector: Simulation Results with the COMPETES EU20 Model. Environ Resource Econ 47, 23–44 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10640-010-9362-9
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10640-010-9362-9
Keywords
- Electricity market
- Carbon cost pass-through
- Power sector modelling
- Europe, EU ETS
- Windfall profits
- CO2 reduction
- Cournot competition